[M][N] Medic Mafia - Page 3

On March 08 2018 07:19 rsoultin wrote:


Yeah that was the one point. I don't think that you ever mentioned your reasons for tubesock, though I was filtering by mobile so take that with a grain of salt.

On March 08 2018 07:23 Vivax wrote:


That'd be my issue with tube too. Reactive and self-centered filter, but you're also somewhere in that category for me.

I'd feel a lot better about lynching you if HF wasn't trying so hard to keep you on the block as I'm not sure what he is yet.

On March 08 2018 08:06 Holyflare wrote:
I'm healing df.

On March 09 2018 03:43 Vivax wrote:
And df needs to get in here cause I want to know what his action is going to be.

I don't see a better play he could think of where he doesn't tell town who he's doccing. He needs to play with open cards now or explain why not.

On March 08 2018 19:21 Holyflare wrote:
Other medic(s) just heal prplhz. I either get df killed and he's town or nothing happens and we go from there. Maybe that will actually help you come to some kind of consensus.

On March 09 2018 04:19 n00bKing wrote:

lol, IF THAT'S TRUE, then I wish someone had actually said so, when I asked someone (ANYone) in the thread to back that notion.

How is that a question that doesn't want an answer? Man, if I don't want an answer to that question, I can just NOT ask it. That would be REAL easy. Or I could have waited to post it until much later, and allowed less time for people to see and comment on it. I didn't. There was plenty of time for people to see and comment on it, and then for us to decide how/whether it should influence the notion of a DF lynch.

It wasn't a question that doesn't want an answer. It was a question that didn't GET an answer.

If DF ever turns out to be scum, and you and I are both still alive, we can have a conversation about me forcing a townread on him against your alleged "majority" (which was actually like 3 people). If DF ever turns out to be town, I think that conversation is over. I can't really see any way to scumread me for: abandoning my original lynch target with 1 hour to go (who was Town) and defending the counterwagon (also town, in this hypothetical) and then leaving, and just crossing my fingers and hoping the noose doesn't fall onto one of my teammates. Working to keep DF out of the noose in that scenario couldn't possibly make less sense, especially once DF claims medic, which would've made it trivially easy to just go "oh, you're claiming medic? That makes you mathematically more likely to be scum now. Die." Boom, dead Town medic, and a BULLETPROOF alibi for me sticking him in the noose.

The kills I like are prpl and Kelsier.

I maintain that I do not like the idea of having DF go off and heal a secret target of his choosing. I maintain that HF is actively damaging the Town's best interests, if he refuses to follow thread sentiment regarding his target.

On March 07 2018 04:04 Damdred wrote:


He does sound defeated and what not, but the DF i've played with doesn't mind rolling scum. He generally fights hard as scum and is excellent at keeping his tone somewhere in the realm of his town game.

I just think its a weird opening for him regardless of his alignment and i'd much rather not even think about lynching him for it just because its so outside meta for him it doesn't register for either side.

On March 09 2018 04:21 darthfoley wrote:
Lol townmedic!HF ensuring he kills another townmedic N1 would surely be superb.

Mafia will probably shoot HF (if he's actually town and/or townmedic) and medic me, potentially killing 2/3 town medics in one night. Really really stellar idea for a game that's supposedly heavily townsided.

On March 09 2018 04:32 Vivax wrote:
My pessimism driven gut tells me that prplhz is going to flip town though.
What's the alternative though.

On March 09 2018 04:40 n00bKing wrote:

THANKS, buddy! Wish you'd posted this during D1 instead (or that ANYone else had answered, when I asked for confirmation of the theory).

Then yes, HF is right. You should have been the Day 1 lynch. Glad we got that cleared up.

On March 09 2018 04:57 Holyflare wrote:


Yeah, great play when you're just mafia though.

On March 09 2018 05:07 n00bKing wrote:

smh

It appears that you don't even know how I ended up asking the question in the first place. You keep talking about what HF said, like as if that's not exactly the "theory" I was trying to get "confirmation" of from absolutely anyone else (and didn't get).

Vivax's listed reasons for voting against you have nothing to do with your meta. In skimming his D1 posts about you just now, I don't notice anything that even indicates he has EVER seen you play before, as either allegiance. rsoul's comments about the weirdness of your entry to the thread do not speak to my question at all. I didn't remember that post from Damdred, having not ever seen it a 2nd time, given that I didn't re-read his filter, since he hasn't been here to talk to, nor has he really been discussed as a lynch target. Apparently everyone else either forgot about it too, or thought it didn't answer the question, since he only mentions your town play in regard to "tone." But anyway, like I said, I'm convinced now. Yes, you should have been the Day 1 lynch. But hopefully you're Town anyway, and will start to play like the guy you think matches your reputation. *wink, WINK*

On March 09 2018 06:07 MoosyDoosy wrote:

then who would you vig in this scenario?