A normal game just for JAT <3 - Page 67

On April 20 2016 03:19 justanothertownie wrote:
The more you do this the more I think you are just trying to rile me up and to undermine my standing in this town.

On April 20 2016 03:37 Rels wrote:

BTW since you were arguing about basic mafia play, if you were town and I was scum, I wouldn't go against the hardest player to go against for no reason. There is no point in doing that.

On April 20 2016 03:26 Superbia wrote:
About to head to movies. I'm town doc boys. =/

Lynch someone else (TW/maybe SL).

He really doesn't, but what else can we do?
The best I can suggest is a GB/ possibly SL wagon but those are shots in the dark.

On April 20 2016 03:41 justanothertownie wrote:

There are only 2 options:

1) You are doing exactly this.
2) You are misrepresenting me and calling me mafia for things that don't make anyone mafia as town. Forgive me for having my doubts about that.

On April 20 2016 03:44 Rels wrote:

3) You are scum and you're angry I caught you over something so simple

On April 20 2016 03:41 justanothertownie wrote:

There are only 2 options:

1) You are doing exactly this.
2) You are misrepresenting me and calling me mafia for things that don't make anyone mafia as town. Forgive me for having my doubts about that.

On April 20 2016 03:46 justanothertownie wrote:

Even if I was mafia 2) would still apply.

On April 20 2016 03:48 Rels wrote:

Case in point ^^
Now let's shut it down unless I reread your interactions after Superbia's flip.

On April 20 2016 03:44 Rels wrote:

3) You are scum and you're angry I caught you over something so simple

Ok, I assume the vig shot fazers. Everything else would make me quite mad.
Superbia claims with his first post today.

On April 20 2016 03:53 gumshoe wrote:


yous a derp rels, a big ol / : derp.

I'll ask you the same question I asked tumble (I will be assuming super is scum for this question, as this whole argument is predicated on that and you insist on having it before the flip so there ya go)

If jat is scum, then he must have okd the shot on palmer in order to give supers vig claim weight.

if so, why did he immediatly shoot that possibility down?



better yet, why did he go through with it in the first place? If he was scum, wouldn't he realize that shooting the same guy that super claimed he would kill would make no sense and would hurt his position far more than just a flat doc claim at the start of the day? Did he not realize fazzers had a good shot of dying?

It's ether a terrible oversight, or a flat out terrible play. Something I dont think ether of you would let go through.

On April 20 2016 03:57 justanothertownie wrote:

There is also the possibility that mafia just accepted that superbia was going down today and killed Palmar because a) he is a good player and their attempt to mislynch him while he was away failed b) he was an unlikely medic save.
Palmar dying is not a reason to read me anything.

On April 20 2016 04:00 gumshoe wrote:


wrong, palmer dying throws suspicion onto super. as why would scum shoot the guy super claimed he was going to kill? unless they knew he was never going to kill him. Ie, scum knows supers not vig, how, cause supers scum. Hence why scum shot palmer without fear.

it outright makes no sense unless they were trying to pass it off as a vig shot. It was so very derp and I dont see a player like your rels letting that slip

On April 20 2016 03:58 Rels wrote:
Sry gumshoe but I don't think your "vig kill" theory is likely. Palmar is a strong player and he got shot, maybe it was because of your plan which would mean the scumteam are complete idiots, and maybe he was shot because he is a strong player and nothing can be assumed about the scum team.

On April 20 2016 04:03 gumshoe wrote:


I am asserting the scum team are complete idiots.

ok. follow along I am going to make this really fucking simple

super claims. Scum has no idea what he is if super is town.

Super says hes going to shoot palmer

if super is not scum, why would scum shoot plamer thereby risking 2 kp on one target considering palmer was going to possibly die anyway?

the only explanation is scum knew that super wouldnt vig shoot palmer. They only way they could know that is if super is scum.

therefore, shot onto palmer=completely outing super.

is that so very complicated?