EPTOUTLAW MINI MAFIA - Page 2
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
| ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
| ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
On December 30 2015 18:09 ritoky wrote: Can you post some reads you feel strongly about? Even if they are TRs. I would like something that isn't maybe this, maybe that. Why would you prefer an afk be shot instead of someone who you scum read? And why moosy over BF/slam/ness anything in particular distinguish 1 of the unengaged over the other? slam is prob town koshi is prob town gb feels different from how he was in haunted mansion mini (where he was town) but not necessarily in a scum way, and i like his war with HF which makes me think town ness prob town moosy SHOULD be considered mafia for his behavior which is why he should be shot. we don't waste a lynch where we get no real information and the game gets more solvable no idea how to read hf, too much post not gonna bother unless its absolutely necessary ows filter feels like it's full of air, so much oneliner stuff, striking me as someone who is providing commentary rather than content. need to reread after a few more flips. | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
un pequeño chupacabra sueño en la biblioteca | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
ows vivax one of sl or slam one of noon or palmar maybe gb could prob eliminate one more name if i was caffeinated enough but i doubt it. thought about comparing this list to the dead guys filters from n1 maybe when i wake up tonight. from memory palmar was suspect but the rest i dont remember off the top of my empty skull | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
rsoul obviously killed because confirmed town and capable of playing as opposed to coag who is mostly reliable for deciding at the last possible moment who to lynch at lylo, making him a low priority kill based on artanis rayn and vivax, palmar is suspect as they were the largest proponents of his lynch. also they were probably the most obvious town so it's hard to decide if they were killed for being obviously town or if they were being killed for their scum reads. i don't want to lynch onegu yet because im pretty sure he's town and pulled of a highly retarded ego-related move to try to get a scum read lynched and that is so bad that i would rather ignore him completely than dedicate any more brain cells to thinking about it. also the people voting for him at this point, yikes. no idea what i was thinking about since i didnt write it down when writing my last scum team list, poked through various filters and there was a confluence of ideas that make it a thing that happened. mostly how people talk to / treat eachother and their scum reads, but it was nebulous and in my head so i have no idea if it's good or not. maybe not. i am apparently the black sheep when it comes to scum reads this game which probably means i'm 90% wrong or more. i remember last time that happened in a game hosted by bh, wasn't a good time after i died and found out how retarded i was. could be that all over again. maybe there's some hidden nuggets in the way the rels vote went. honestly i don't see/remember how come rels was lynched for sheeping rayn or what his major offense was. haven't given a single thought to nocturne but there's been some discussion about him relating to replacement meta that could be a good start. it's entirely possible that ness quit not because he was a pissed off townie but because he didn't want to deal with mafia [the game] elitist hotheads. i could see that. i had that kind of thought in my first newbie game with someone a lot less outrageous. it's hindering me thinking about things in terms of potential teams with this many players and i'm at a loss when it comes to trying process of elimination so... yeah. gonna sheep damdred today. | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
On January 03 2016 22:49 nooniansoong wrote: Blah blah blah Super long post Conclusion: I'm gonna sheep Damdred the analyst stuns again with his analysis | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
On January 03 2016 23:23 sicklucker wrote: The only hidden nugget in the rels vote is that towns were more likely to switch. Palmar ritoky sicklucker Trfel, The Shining Damdred Small Town points for them but its not that important super unlikely there all town. When I play mafia I do actively try to switch votes to draw out claims. But I dont do it at the last second when they dont even have time to claim it could potentially make yourself look bad on the flip my recent thoughts about the shining is that he seems perfectly happy with how things are going and that strikes me as bothersome compared to how involved he seemed early-game. do you concur? | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
On January 03 2016 23:30 Damdred wrote: Why are you so happy to sheep and tr me oo when you thought I was super scum before the claim? bc my scum read of you hinged on you defending shining for no reason when i have no idea about the history of you and shining and that makes it weak as f, and nobody else seemed to care about that point so i let it go | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
any why you take issue with my opinion that there is more likely only one mafia (if any) between the two of palmar and noon based on your interactions | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
The longer a double bus goes on the less likely it is to be one especially in this game where it's potentially a near-perfect game. Ofc I would call it a double bus when I felt you were both scummy in my mind | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
On January 04 2016 19:53 Palmar wrote: This one is specifically not true, in fact your entire post was DEFENDING me instead of showing how I was scummy. The only caveat you left is that somehow it could be a double bus, without specifically talking about how or why I could be mafia. i didnt talk about how or why you could be mafia because up to this point the only real evidence i really have that you could be mafia is how poorly the night kills reflect on you, and i think you'd agree that's not concrete on its own. it's a downside of playing by how things feel instead of citing specific evidence. its not like i have a history of people looking to me as a town leader or having stunning analysis. im sure that makes people hate reading or playing with me. | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
On January 04 2016 20:18 Palmar wrote: and stop bashing yourself, you're a fine player who actually tries shit. It's literally the easiest job in the world to be likable in tl mafia you have to do two things a) don't be a complete dick b) at least try to do something both of which you do fine enough. Let's assume for a second you're not mafia, who do you think we should lynch today and why. Also, what do you think of the people I've written about so far? kush feels very diplomatic and rigid and i obviously agree he could be scum. the post you quoted where he explains his questioning exo's scumread of you has a tone of being apprehensive about explaining it which is out of character for his robotic analytical approach this game. exo scumreading you in that scenario could be a way to get you to explain how you reached your conclusion but actually now that i'm looking at that period of the game it feels a similar to his reaction to the mason claim -- very hot headed and needlessly aggressive. could you look at exo? i've been townreading him for his doggedness towards rsoul/coag and have ignored him since, but it's probably time to look more closely and your point brings up what may be a pattern that could be out of the norm for his town behavior. the last two games i've played with sl he's had what i could describe as a sort of shifting gears into business mode that has happened within the first day or two of the game. the first one he saved me from a mislynch and the game was won handily (student mini) and the second he again took much more personal responsibility for the direction of the game (haunted mini), which while his activity this game is quite high i don't get the same sense of taking the reigns this game that i did in those two. it's not a concrete thing but i could see him potentially being scum in this game but again nothing concrete. the posts regarding nocturnemage are kinda curious On January 03 2016 17:31 sicklucker wrote: oh ness was replaced by that fucker sort of implies he knows nocturnemage On January 04 2016 02:00 sicklucker wrote: But I never played with nocturne before so dandred I wanna give him a chance he seems to be trying... Can we kill slam plzpl mister dandred mister? but this post says he hasn't. i find this weird. his issue with noct knowing the setup of the game is kind of silly since he himself didn't read the OP in the game we were in haunted mini, so it's a stupid point to fuss about when he himself is underinformed. if sl should have any issues with noct i would imagine it would be more with how noct is pushing your lynch but without taking any of the responsibility for it which i imagine you'd have a problem with. onegu thoughts are already in my filter | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
i don't think he's the slam dunk lynch [dat pun doe] we're looking for and i'd rather lynch gb. that said i don't want to lynch palmar today at all so i will protect with a vote on slam until that discussion can happen ##vote: alakaslam | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
On January 04 2016 23:46 NocturneMage wrote: EBWOP to 3750 actually wait, you replaced in after day 1.....meh, fuck. Well if you can, great. what specifically about it? stylistically its classic palmar. starting late was normal for palmar too. something specific if youre curious would be great as im typing with 1 hand right now while icing my wrist to see if it makes my finger numbnes abate | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
so hes ok calling noct a fucker for no reason? to me itimplied a familiarity like ribbing a friend but then they d ont know eachother it just stands out as weird like i said | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
On January 05 2016 00:02 nooniansoong wrote: So it's just weird and has zero bearing on either player's alignment? If it has some bearing, please explain why. maybe it reflects on a negative state of mind from sl, what reason would he have for being upset about something at that point of the game and is it related? On January 03 2016 17:28 sicklucker wrote: i mean if noct is a stranger then the comment is definitely weird. if he's upset that the slot wasnt modkilled why take it out on the gracious replacement?so i came back expecting some good discussion but it was mostly people trying to figure out ness whos going to be mod killed... used your time better boys like i said its weird but its not alignment indicative unless it's pointing to potentially town for frustration with inactives or potentially scum for frustration that a townslot wasnt modkilled so weird is the best descriptor right now and its worth noting later whether or not the noct slot is mafia or not | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
| ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
On January 05 2016 04:26 Damdred wrote: Though oo being here worries me a small bit but idk what do you mean me being here worries you a small bit? on the lynch? present at my computer [are you watching me watch Sherlock?]? alive on this planet? | ||
|
ObviousOne
United States3704 Posts
gb flips mafia and we finally get a feel for the larger composition of the scum team based on interactions and reads or we're completely wrong and whatever, scum team are gods, god bless em | ||
| ||
