Student Mafia V

On January 18 2015 03:46 Damdred wrote:
I've read everyones filter besides DP just procrastinating on his

On January 18 2015 06:39 Damdred wrote:
So basically if LM comes back and does stuff you might rescend that scum read/suspicion.

And then when we drop to your next uspicion it isn't even the person you then pointed to (dp) it is instead two lurkers?

Also sure that's true about that previous post...but what about how you came flying out of the blue in the last student tmafia against bats with a huge case, even in the past newbie game you were halfway inactive and you still had pretty strong scum reads 24-36 hours into the game?

On January 19 2015 01:34 Damdred wrote:
Rs top town for parroting me. Lm probable mafia and is a great ads tvoe

On January 19 2015 11:49 Damdred wrote:
I have to cover all of my basis though, and we actually need to analysis the claim.

Firstly, there are two possible scenerios that involve a tracker. One is Cop tracker and one is tracker doctor. I thought about it as JarJar softing, but he cannot possibly know still that a medic exists in this setup as we are down to a 50/50 if he is the tracker. If we see a doc/cop flip obviously hes mafia, there might be something there and its still possibly a scum slip instead of a soft. I know it sounds tin foil, but its something we have to consider down the line and JarJar isn't confirmed if he isn't shot obviously. And if cop flips and doc flips.outs we at least have one mafia already there. So just figured I would talk it out before moving down.

Trfel should be the lynch tomorrow, maybe LM, and we still have to evaluate a couple more people. I'm going to heal Dp tonight obviously, hes the most towny person in the game.

I"m not sure if we should kill breshke tomorrow I like some of his posts but we need to pressure him a bit more, and talk me through your EoD rsoultin.

On January 19 2015 11:58 Damdred wrote:
whoa whoa whoa, firstly i'm not claiming doctor. That sentence must of been autocorrected or something, the gist is correct as I think dp is the most towny and should be healed. But i'm not the doc.

On January 19 2015 12:09 Damdred wrote:



Obviously jarjar will be alive tomorrow more than likely just for wifom if hes tracker and more than likely he will be blocked if he is the true tracker. I'm not going to give scum strategy so we shouldn't talk about it to much in depth, but until we start seeing some flips of another power role we need to just ignore it for now more than likely. I don't have much to substantiate with but the "softing/scum slip" earlier makes me a bit weary to believe the claim.

We have little inactives, I think we can eliminate shining from lynch tomorrow. Breshke needs a good day, LM needs a decent day. Those to me are our really only inactives and they aren't spammy but are here if we have a cop I would check one of them and hope to get lucky.

Trfel has been the least interested in the days activity I think, and has really changed the play from all of the other games I played with him in. Even in the last newbie it seemed very similar to carol/last student mafia. Was pretty strong even if he wasn't as inactive, and as blue in carol he was really strong. This just seems like a weird mirror like performance, playing down his ability no real scum reads sheeping instead of pushing. Being wrong is good in mafia it helps you get more information instead of laying back

On January 20 2015 01:49 Damdred wrote:
I noticed that you said dps reasoning's were weak. What do you make of that?

On January 20 2015 02:39 Damdred wrote:


Yea I don't see how LM is really re-evaluating reads or votes from that, he got caught in a mistake/lie/not reading and had to back peddle from it. Nothing really towny about that.

His other posts were really disjoined and really weren't flowing with the game in most spots so not sure why they were so good?

On January 20 2015 13:13 Damdred wrote:
Shining did a decent amount of work post flip and had some decent thoughts. Its generally a townie trait to jump straight in and get thoughts in during the night to me, some of his other things had a nice push to it as well.

Its one of my weaker town reads but I doubt I lynch him tomorrow.

On January 20 2015 13:34 Breshke wrote:


No you are right they are different. What LS was doing was actually pushing the game forward to scumhunt. So yeah you are right about me just arguing semantics I guess i just never really thought of it out of the context of creating discussion vs creating discussion.

Here is where i say i still don't understand how he was reading LS as his one and only town because i still think his reasons were weak because I think LS could easily ask questions as scum. That being said the read as right and LS is town the same as Jarjar so it could easily be me who has to think about stuff differently

On January 20 2015 13:41 Damdred wrote:


Most sure of Rsoultin and Geript at this point, least sure of Breshke and Dp. Shining is somewhere inbetween the two sets.

On January 20 2015 13:52 Damdred wrote:


Right now I have five town reads and its all the unconfirmed people in the game I am 100% wrong on someone.

If tre and LM flip scum DP looks the worst but doesn't necessarily make him scum.

your posts look ok tonight so I have to re look at you. Shining could be scum and rs could be bussing. So yea its not a fun spot to be in

On January 21 2015 08:53 geript wrote:
I will say that Damdred's filter looks exceptionally worse in skimming it. Shining is town; then mafia then town then mafia. LS is in the same boat. Las is mafia for trying to get a meta read on Damdred. Then it's the reason he's obviously town. I really don't get it.

On January 18 2015 12:16 Damdred wrote:
Well geript I'm sure I will miss something talking with you here.

I think your post on dp had good direction, had clear thought patterns and pulled from past experiences in context for that part. It looks really towny from you and so its a really good post I don't think it proves one way or another about dp. But I'm procrastinating because of things diving him because dp has a way of being meh when I read his post.

I think shining is telling the truth about having limited net and drunk which isn't alignment indicative. but his post shows that he read what little of the thread there was to read and he had thoughts about it and was able to articulate them into reasonable points about people.

I hate list posts but his weren't overly bad this time.

I'm actually moving tr down my townlist and sinking. I had the huge post and the reasoning for not having scum reads is pretty bad band didn't sound genuine to me. And the interactions with GB just feel weird at points.

On January 19 2015 05:56 Damdred wrote:
I'm glad you asked me dp, I am lazy and think your obvious town. I don't see you being Scum nor a lynch so I'm ignoring your filter because I read you in thread as town.

On January 21 2015 09:44 Damdred wrote:


No offense DP, but you have a really egotistical writing style at points especially when talking about vets and newbs and it makes me feel meh about you.

But your postings in the thread were towny in context so no need for me to read your filter at that point.

On January 21 2015 09:41 Damdred wrote:


This is dumb the bolded especially. LS asked for a meta on me early in the game which caused me to doubt him and put him in mafia pile as evidenced in my filter if you looked. I put him down in the reaction test to see how people reacted and then I said that he was town and haven't moved from that since then.

I've played like one decent game with trfel and I town read and then later in the game it became a scum read before they were checked not sure.

That's just how me and GB are, gb goes damdred is town, scum, town, town town town. Just how we are when we play.

I'm just going to ignore the stupid going on though its ok

On January 21 2015 09:48 Damdred wrote:


No DP that's not alignment indicative I just hate reading you, quite honestly you drive me insane.

You were obv town though at that point so meh. Your posts make me feel meh they still make me feel meh.

On January 21 2015 13:36 Damdred wrote:
You can't, someone has claimed a red check on you.

We are killing you off unless you claim come up with an amazing defense.

On January 22 2015 11:15 Damdred wrote:
In day one I really didn't care if I got lynched or not, at that point I thought GB was town. And at that point it was either gb or me and GB had been playing better due to putting in work than me obviously.

I thought JJB had been playing scummy so tried to get a wagon moved there instead of on gb which happened and he turned out to be blue and we moved the wagon onto your lynch.

Afterwards I just went to work to try to figure the game out.

On January 23 2015 08:14 geript wrote:
Actually, I'm just going to sheep Breshke. He's obviously reading far more carefully than I am right now.

##vote Lonemeow

On January 18 2015 06:15 Damdred wrote:
He really hasn't posted any reads quite yet so he hasn't answered my question at this point so not much to garner yet.

Geript has some good thoughts in his posts. I can't really tell his alignment yet

On January 19 2015 05:56 Damdred wrote:
I'm glad you asked me dp, I am lazy and think your obvious town. I don't see you being Scum nor a lynch so I'm ignoring your filter because I read you in thread as town.

Geript is pretty town, if he's alive after d2 and no roles claim he's pulling a Russian mafia but he looks super towny

LS is town based on hi a addiction to meta as town.

Jjb is mafia I think

On January 20 2015 09:22 Damdred wrote:
Lol, Geript might actually be Scum after those posts.

On January 20 2015 11:54 Damdred wrote:
Geript, lets say I calmed down and have taken a step back and gazed over your filters in Russian mafia and here. Im comfortable saying the anger here isn't like what happens in Russian where you are just 100% cool until you get caught by what you deem to be an imbalanced game.

I don't see you throwing doubts on people as mafia in this case, you would roll with it and bus your team mate without questioning claims I think.

I think you are towny this game, and shouldn't let my paranoia get the better of me probably.

So that leaves me with staring at (minus town reads)

Breshke
LM

geript talk to me about DP. How sure are you that hes town right here? I know you were pretty sure earlier?

On January 23 2015 23:22 Damdred wrote:
DP seems to be involved and connected to the game and giving thoughts, I think even though I have some doubts about him I don't think he would connect himself with the scum team like this if LM is scum which is a real possibility.

Breshke looks the best coming into today really putting in the effort to try to solve the game and answer questions about him

Rsoultin looks great as well, questioning everything and seems paranoid enough to be towny plus actions before.

Jarjar: Un cc'd blue

Town:
Breshke
Rsoultin
DP
JarJar

I think, that Geript feels really disconnected from the game and he sometimes really lacks followup and can't really tell what hes doing anymore. Really seems like yesterday he was disparaging the claim of LS and JarJar trying to put doubts setting up trfels counter claim which trfel totally fell through with. But that's wifom, besides that. The question about the day 1 lynch will bother people because why would mafia want to pull off a town? Perhaps to stop town from lynching LM as a last second lynch, as GB myself both lost ton of traction and GB my main pusher stopped and jarjar was claiming blue so getting people from looking at LM would be good.

LM is the other mafia I think, not trying to solve the game.

I think tis geript and LM at this point. But we will see and geript will give me tons of flack for this post I know hehe

##Vote LM

On January 25 2015 03:49 Damdred wrote:


To the first question, Geript would normally be a high priority night kill. Obviously with both of our blues coming out early he would be shuffled down the list but if he was alive with no blues claimed then it would be possible hes scum at that point.

That point it was all so random posting and made it seem like Geript was questioning whether LS actually had a red check on trfel and was throwing a bit of shadow in my mind on the claim. Was just a weird series of posts by geript at that point.

Russian mafia geript played one of the best games of scum I ever saw him play, really town sided a lot of the time did just enough to get mislynches, ended up getting caught by a tracker/watcher though. Was a fun game though.

On January 25 2015 03:52 rsoultin wrote:


So then am I right in interpreting your referencing Russian as a reason to be paranoid of geript even when his posts seem townie?

On January 25 2015 06:08 Damdred wrote:
As far as I can tell, LM isn't even voting me is he?

On January 26 2015 10:06 Damdred wrote:
If you are town rs why aren't you worried about bresh coming so hard alongside you?