Catastrophe Mafia

Catastrophe Mafia Notes: (4-8-14 at 9:30am PDT)

Format = [name] - [intial gut read] - (reasons that make me lean town, scum, or null) - [final read]

2. Djodref(replaced by geript) - Gut Null - (modkill soon?) (checked to be town by VisceraEyes > town) (claims to be town, but have an anti-town role > null) (being uncooperative and saying a lot of things that don't like up > null) (based on meta this looks like geript town play > town) - Town read

3. Holyflare - Gut Scum - (his day 1 start is weak. he is asking a lot of questions, but it doesn't seem to have a town
agenda behind it. > scum) (middle of day 1. he seems to be trying to figure out things more > null) (end of day 1. seems
to be a bit more carefree in his posting. trying to fish out a lot of peoples roles that are on the chopping block.
doesn't feel very invested in actually killing scum > scum) (asking tons of stupid questions and saying pointless things
> scum) (Sandroba is saying he is town > town) (recents posts look a lot better for being town > town) - Town read

5. Koshi - Gut Town - (somewhat forthcoming about his "cult" > null) (seemed to be carefree about the lynches during day 1, didn't mind sheeping "town heroes" > null) (staying active and generally good vibes > town) - Leaning Town read

8. Dandel Ion - Gut Null - (i dont know how to read this guy. most posts dont strike me as either scum or town, was
all about sheeping sandroba, which is cool with me > null) - Null read

12. Oatsmaster - Gut Scum - (intial scum read based off him being abrasive and asking too many useless questions > scum) (him tunneling on me makes it harder to read > null) (just don't like his style of play so far this game, don't see any
scum hunting or towny mindset > scum) - Leaning Scum read

13. strongandbig - Gut Town - (claims to have one shot docced Sandroba > town) (overall I just like his filter, generally
pro town posts, provides good analysis behind his reads > town) - Town read

14. VisceraEyes - Gut Town - (has been in the background most of the game > null) (a lot of friendly bro posts and sticking up for others, white knighting > null) (claims to have checked Djo as town > town) (good vibes from PMing with him > town) - Leaning town

15. austinmcc - Gut Null - (mostly trolly/filler posts > null) (seems like he doesn't really care about the game, this
makes me think he is 3p or apathetic town > null) - Null read

16. Amiko - Gut Scum - (claims he is 3rd party > null) - Leaning 3rd party

17. Hopeless1der - Gut Null - (just sheeped votes and went with majority lynches, didn't put any effort scum hunting > null) - Null read

18. justanothertownie - Gut Town - (baaaahhhhhhhhhhhh > null) (probably town, doesn't seem to be pushing a mafia agenda > town) (people I think are town like JAT as town, so I defer to them for the moment > town) (claims his win con is to kill Sandroba, if this doesn't happen he will help town > scum) (some sort of 3rd party lyncher role??) - Leaning 3rd party

19. WaveofShadow - Gut Town - (His "soon-to-receive item list" seems a bit contrived to do as 3rd party or scum > town) (decent reads and analysis behind them > town) - Leaning Town read

20. LSB - Gut Scum - (complete lack of actual scum hunting > scum) (there is no real interest in the game from him, his posts seem to be there just to skate by > scum) - Leaning Scum read

22. Killing - Gut Town - (I agree with his reads, sort of in his pocket for defending me, but this aligns more with his town meta than scum > town) (he has claimed his role to me, I think he is telling the truth about it > town) (some hesitations about whether his role could be mafia or 3p after further discussion > null) (used his ability to reduce chaos to zero > town)
(Pmed a bunch with Killing, feel good about him > town) - Town read

24. VayneAuthority - Gut Null - (lurker city > null) (people saying that his lack of trying is his town meta? > null)
- Leaning Scum read

25. Palmar - Gut Null - (was checked* to be a creature of this world > null) *(implications behind this speak to fantasy creature roles could be bad, possibly these creatures will have flavour text when they kill like in Apeture mafia) (a lot of people I am beginning to trust think he is town > town) (Palmar's lack of trying to control the game doesn't line up with mafia meta > town) - Leaning Town read

27. IAmRobik - Gut Town - (little kid screaming his head off with profanity galore > town) (reprimanding us for lynching
but doing nothing to prevent it > null) - Leaning Town read

28. sandroba - Gut Town - (in this guys pocket, the way he posts just feel right. his analysis is spot on in my opinion.
doesn't seem to be pushing any mafia agenda > town) (have PMed a bunch with sandroba and get good vibes > town) - Town read

Day 1 Deaths
29. gumshoe - Dead(town) - Gut Town

6. raynpelikoneet - Dead(town, modkilled) - Gut Null

Night 1 Deaths
23. Foolishness - Dead(town) - Gut Town

1. Keirathi - Dead(town) - Gut Town

11. kitaman27 - Dead(town) - Gut Town

7. marvellosity - Dead(town) - Gut Town

Day 2 Deaths
30. Blazinghand - Dead(town) - Gut Scum - (claims he is going to explode in 24 hours, i really hope this happens haha) (his play is all over the place, i don't believe his role claim > scum) (his play strikes me as not caring, so
possible 3rd party?) - Scum read

9. syllogism - Dead(scum) - Gut Null - (not sure what to think of his posting so far, strikes me as trying to be town, but can't tell if genuine or not > null) (claimed mafia > scum) - Scum read

10. iamperfection - Dead(scum) - Gut Scum - (So we have Foolishness calling iamp scum and marv swearing he is town > null) (his beginning of day 1 is filled with a lot of filler > scum) (he lightly pushes and pokes at some of the scummier players in the thread, but doesn't really back anything up or pursue actual scum reads > scum) (just seems to be sliding under the radar and not trying to acutally scum hunt > scum) - Scum read

26. yamato77 - Dead(town) - Gut Town - (seems to actually care about who is getting lynched and finding scum > town) (seems to be putting pieces together and asking the right questions > town) - Leaning Town read

4. Tehpoofter - Dead(town) - Gut Scum - (quirky and sarcastic remarks > scum) (implied he is town with VE in an indirect way > scum) (asking a ton of questions, but not really trying to get mafia lynched > scum) (case against Robik was very nit picky and grasping at straws > scum) (went from not trusting marv to agreeing with him in a very short time, seemed unnatural > scum) (claims to have red check on Syllo, Syllo has claimed scum at this point > town) - Town read