It's clear that Palmar felt BC was unreadable, as he was reluctant to call him mafia day 1 based on the fact that BC is always bad day 1. And the whole "list of cobblers" thing.

This is true, but Palmar was completely set on VE on D1 and D2. I would think he'd want confirmation on that check given how it was the only thing he talked about. I agree with you that you don't necessarily need to check your scumspects, but Palmar was pretty one-track minded for the first two days so it wouldn't make sense in his case. I'd like to hear his explanation, in any case, as well as his reasoning of why he suddenly thought VE was town.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

April 30 2013 15:05 GMT

#3620

On May 01 2013 00:04 yamato77 wrote:
With ShaioPi being confirmed scum, I think our best plan of action is to lynch Ace tomorrow.

Details at 11.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

April 30 2013 15:31 GMT

#3625

I went over Kush's and GiggleS' filter and have a likely town read on Kush and a weak town read on GrapeS. Kush for saying a few things that are too dumb to be scum and GrimeS would've had to bus half his team to be scum, which is still possible given how inactive they were but eh.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

April 30 2013 19:44 GMT

#3659

I would like to see Yamato and Ace as well as Palmar and BC engaged in Mortal Kombat.
I would also like to hear more from Stutters, on anything really.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

April 30 2013 20:22 GMT

#3681

On May 01 2013 04:48 TheRavensName wrote:

Show nested quote +

You there! Substitute scate on through to the other side boy. What are your thoughts on these people and cases against them and why?

I think Yamato is town and he suspects Ace whom I'm pretty null on after Shiao flipped scum JK, since his foremost claim to towniness is gone.
I've already suspected the cobbler, but I don't think the cobbler and palmar can be in the same scumteam given their interactions. I don't think I need to explain to you that Palmar's claim has been fairly fishy, and his VE tunnel poorly reasoned. I find it likely that one of the two is scum after getting townier reads on other players.
As for Stutters, there hasn't been much content to judge him on. I can follow his thought process but there's not enough of it to judge on, ergo I would like to hear more from him.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

April 30 2013 20:25 GMT

#3683

It's not so much convenient as much as it is opening filters.
I don't want to open up the vet filters though, it'll be too much effort

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

April 30 2013 20:36 GMT

#3690

On May 01 2013 05:31 Palmar wrote:
guys I'm town.

Will you fight the cobbler in Mortal Kombat?

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

April 30 2013 20:46 GMT

#3694

On May 01 2013 05:44 VisceraEyes wrote:
OH PALMAR WHO'S YORU SCUMBUDDY? IS IT ARTANIS?

Make it real small so that only I can see it! Everyone will promise not to look right guys?

That'd be sick, we could have a sick back and forth going on where he calls you scum and I call you town and we derail the entire thread like that. I wish I was on a QT with Palmar now.

TRN, can you mason me next? I want to banter with him

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

April 30 2013 20:50 GMT

#3697

I already filtered a bunch of people today! Stop being so demanding

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

April 30 2013 21:08 GMT

#3701

On May 01 2013 06:03 TheRavensName wrote:

Show nested quote +

You do realize if I mason you its just me and you right? Games with the always expanding mason list with everyone otgether is done with host controling who gets masoned/rnging it.

Oh.
Well that's boring. Nevermind then

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

May 01 2013 08:15 GMT

#4003

His situation does seem pretty hopeless. I had him down as wants to be scum but his mom won't let him, but I guess his mom let him after all.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

May 01 2013 08:42 GMT

#4006

On May 01 2013 17:32 yamato77 wrote:
I'm glad everyone seems to be able to recognize good analysis when they see it.

Artanis, who do you think the last mafia is and why?

Right now I'm inclined to believe it's you.

I dunno yet. Probably between BC and Palmar.
Have you filtered me yet?

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

May 01 2013 08:49 GMT

#4008

On May 01 2013 17:44 ObviousOne wrote:
I took a step back and thought about it. How did I do?

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

May 01 2013 09:33 GMT

#4010

On May 01 2013 18:30 ObviousOne wrote:
ITT: artanis happy it wasn't a case on him

Not really, it would be impossible to even fathom a case on the shining beacon of towniness that is my filter.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

May 01 2013 14:45 GMT

#4017

On May 01 2013 23:16 WaveofShadow wrote:
Oh wait a minute, OO. Is it the comparison between saying you're bad therefore mafia, and then saying townies are bad?

I just caught that. Hmmmm...that IS good. I dunno now...what do??

It is simple.
We lynch the cobbler.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

May 01 2013 14:59 GMT

#4019

Well, Yamato's case looks stronger so I suggest we lynch the hopeless one first then move on to deal with the cobbler.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

May 01 2013 15:42 GMT

#4028

On May 02 2013 00:24 VisceraEyes wrote:
That Artanis liked that case is pretty amazing, I'm left wondering what he liked about it.

I just wanted to applaud for that last sentence because it was beautiful. Overall, the storytelling was grand.
The case isn't particularly strong on actual evidence, it just provides a reasonable narrative for a scum BC. There's no hard evidence, it just makes sense given how BC has played. The case is far too short and lacking to be damning which is why as stated I'd want to see Hopeless flip first, but it gives a decent narrative.