pirate

yo ho ho a pirate ye be. at night you can target someone but you're so drunk it will fail. you may choose to walk the plank, be keelhauled or marooned.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

March 31 2013 22:19 GMT

#2354

yea i don't know if i killed palmar so i was looking for people who might know something. which is why i went crazy when cora said that palmar was killed by a vig (which he apparently didn't say anyway).

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

March 31 2013 22:20 GMT

#2355

i also considered claiming after d2 because i was pretty sure i could kill acro that night but then acro just died.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

March 31 2013 22:28 GMT

#2358

sinani first

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

March 31 2013 22:34 GMT

#2360

because we have a check on him

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

March 31 2013 22:37 GMT

#2364

marv rb

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

March 31 2013 22:51 GMT

#2368

On April 01 2013 07:37 strongandbig wrote:
Okay two things
First, prplhz if your role works as claimed then how were you "unsure" whether you killed palmar? After the flip you should have known that your power would've delivered a bullet to the head not a gun. At that point, I'm pretty sure the logical thing to say is not "maybe I killed him".
Second, I don't buy the explanation for choosing palmar. You're saying you chose someone who you had no read on, just to see what would happen? And that to do this you chose palmar? That makes much less sense to me than the alternative, scum explanation.
Third, if we hypothesize that marv's and my roles were phrased the way they are because of the interaction with prplhz's role, what seems more likely - that it was done to make a town prplhz more powerful or to make a scum prplhz less powerful?
Okay that was three things I guess.

i don't know what would have happened if i had not targetted palmar. still don't.

palmar seemed to be town but then he seemed to get more uninterested in the game. i thought a gun would give him more interest in the game and give me a better idea about him. if he's town and he has a gun, good. if he's scum then i give him another gun the next night and he shoots his own brains out, good. i never thought that he'd just die right there.

in hindsight i probably shouldn't have done that but i never considered that everybody was blue. i knew i was blue, grack was blue, kei and cora both blue, how many blues could there be?

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

March 31 2013 22:55 GMT

#2369

On April 01 2013 07:50 strongandbig wrote:
Okay wait idea brain

If we assume that five scum in this setup is unlikely, then that means oats and prp are likely to not be scum together. So we can test both their role claims at the same time by having prp target oats. If prp is lying and oats is telling the truth, oats won't get the gun.get the gun. If oats is lying and prp is telling the truth, then oats will die. If both are telling the truth, then we have oats with a gun and we can tell him who to shoot with it.

what did oats claim

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

March 31 2013 23:01 GMT

#2372

that's a dumb plan. i give the gun to sinani and if he's not dead tomorrow we lynch him.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

March 31 2013 23:22 GMT

#2377

On April 01 2013 08:16 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Show nested quote +

No it's not. This way we have no way of knowing if prplhz's claim is legit. Had he gunned sinani he could have proved his claim on N3 by regunning sinani -> kill him. Smurf hangs anyways today.

yes it is.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

March 31 2013 23:48 GMT

#2387

i don't know if it was suboptimal or whatever but giving a gun to palmar was obviously not a good idea in hindsight. guess you'll have to convince yourself that i thought it was a decent idea n1 but when palmar flipped d2 i freaked and decided to play safe. i already told you why i thought it was a decent idea, had a townish read on palmar and i didn't think he was blue. the kill-him-n2-if-he-messes-up wasn't why i did it at all, it was just a little extra.

anyway it sucked when i saw palmar flip blue because maybe i did that and killing one of the best townies on n1 isn't really what i was hoping to do this game so when the opportunity to play it safe came up, i did just that.

giving the gun to someone who is 100% getting lynched tomorrow is the best idea unless:
1) i'm really sure he's vanilla scum AND there's someone i am really sure is vanilla townie and is going to make it to tomorrow OR there's someone i am really sure is blue scum
2) i'm really sure he's vanilla townie AND there's someone i am really sure is vanilla townie and is going to make it to tomorrow OR there's someone i am really sure is blue scum

so playing it safe is giving it to smurf.

also, in response to marv "suboptimal" and rayn "really bad", what would you have done n1?