Normal Mini Mafia III - Page 2

On August 22 2012 18:36 Djagulingu wrote:

I'm a little bit familiar with how shady plays. He lurked to the death as scum in Newbie MM 23 (which was his first game as far as I know), was pretty active and attended the scumhunt pretty well in 24 up until he got lynched at the end of day1. Meta analysis suggests that this Shady we have seen up to now is more like the scum one in Newbie MM 23.

However (I don't know how big of a factor this is but) he could be a lot less easygoing in his first game of mafia, being a scum is another factor contributing to that, just like this being his first game against bigger dawgz (which I'm not one of) and not newbies might also cause him being less easygoing.

On the other hand though he might have taken lessons from NMM23 as well, which may help him adapt his scum play better into bigger dawgz. I don't know and can't estimate how well or poorly he adapted though.

Other than that, I'm not familiar with any of the players, except for the notorious troll Chezinu (from BH's explanations in this thread).

On August 22 2012 21:42 Kville wrote:
Lemmings will be lemmings and you just happend to be the one in front.

What i gathered is that you claim to 'sheep' and yet you yourself have done nothing else but provide one liners and start nothing but chaos.

If it makes you feel any better

#Vote marvellosity

On August 23 2012 01:02 Kville wrote:


The question of what i thought of talis and obvious?

Well i can't say much about talis but his posts do seem a little sketchy aslways as obvious. My top three suspects seem to be :
talis
obvious
shady

I'll post more about these three later when i get home from my classes.
Until then
##Unvote

On August 23 2012 01:20 Obvious.660 wrote:
Djagulingu, you're right and perhaps I should have cast my vote earlier in the game. I did, however, want to give the people who hadn't participated much a chance to show their initial scumminess before casting my first vote.

The first thing I want to bring up right now is BL (and others') suspicions of me for not voting Palmar based on being convinced that he truly intended to push for random lynch. Being my first game with Palmar, I wasn't certain that he was indeed serious about his claim there. My response to this line of inquiry about me was to, as VE put it, put the ball in Palmar's court to find out why exactly it was he proposed and endorsed a random lynch.
I never did get a satisfactory response from Palmar about this. Palmar, would you be so kind as to share why you have once again pushed for a random lynch?

On August 23 2012 01:20 Kville wrote:

You are correct. There should be a solid case, which is where my mistake was given such little time given at this moment i cannot post one right now which is why I provided much little information about what i gathered about my suspects Which is the sole reason why I withdrew my vote. Does not mean he is off my radar,

On August 22 2012 21:42 Kville wrote:
Lemmings will be lemmings and you just happend to be the one in front.

What i gathered is that you claim to 'sheep' and yet you yourself have done nothing else but provide one liners and start nothing but chaos.

If it makes you feel any better

#Vote marvellosity

On August 23 2012 01:32 Kville wrote:


No your still a scum and i plan to prove it.

On August 23 2012 01:32 Kville wrote:


No your still a scum and i plan to prove it.

On August 23 2012 02:37 VisceraEyes wrote:
Interesting. However, that aside, his actions since joining the game are damning. He stated upon returning that he wants to lynch lurkers because "they're bad for town later". However, as his recent play shows, lurkers was never really an issue for him...because there are still people who qualify as lurkers in the game (damaging, even) yet he's contented to ride this Kville wagon. Why? Doesn't he care about town? Didn't he want to remedy the lurker situation?

I'm disappointed with the level of activity here. I think that we're letting lurkers get off a little too easy. I'm especially suspicious of people who haven't posted, as it's already been a full 12 hours since the game started, more than enough time for players to post. Moreover, this playstyle is unfair to town, since town by default has to go off of evidence to scumhunt and if everyone is lurking scum gets a free ride in terms of not having to give up much evidence.

I'm going to go with a rando-vote on a lurker unless someone can claim me otherwise with a compelling case. I haven't yet seen a case that's good enough so far.

On August 23 2012 03:23 talismania wrote:
upcaught!

VE I was with you on shady until he started going after kville. I thought the reasoning behind going for lurkers smelled like bs but the way he went after kville was genuine. like picking up on the fact that marv was out of kville's list is a townie trait and it all fits with what people say about him being a tunneler.

On August 23 2012 02:05 Obvious.660 wrote:
Alllllrightythen.

I'll take a look at Kville, who apparently came into the thread to push some suspicion away from himself and cast wild accusations at others. Then to disappear. So that's cool I guess.

So his preliminary, opening "case" that is his list of people have "sketchy posts":
Followed up by adding Marv who has has already cast suspicion on AND voted for, after being called out for forgetting to add him to the list.
So there's no evidence exactly what those sketchy posts were, outside of the train of votes for Kville and somehow the interactions between those players being evidence of a scum team?This post above is making mountains from molehills. Implying connections this early in a mini game, where people working together (scums, masons) are likely to be far more careful of being linked by meta-factors such as post timing, is rather silly. It's a good bit of evidence to bring up when looking at other such coincidences and making further reads, but until those situations present themselves I just don't see any justification for making the call that it's linking them as scum partners.

---

I think I like this one the most, though:Marv has earned his FOS and Vote for what I see as OMGUS reasons, and Kville is now certain that he has found a second scum in Shady Sands. Oooookay. Next we're going to hear how if X flips Red then Y must be Red? Kville's entire train of though needs to be explained.

On August 23 2012 04:55 marvellosity wrote:
don't we have forever until deadline? game started early so i think it's tomorrow evening/night, no?