as mentioned this is basicly a game with multiple lifes. Mafia needs 3 turns to kill you with KP only instead of just one night and you probably won't be "lynched" within one cycle either.
It's basicly an incredible overkill that could never come into play anyways due to it's costs.

A "vig" would be more like something dealing 4 dmg, like the one gonzaw proposed.

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

June 19 2012 20:11 GMT

#85

@Toads the creature gets +1+0 each turn, so the Mafia KP gets incrementally increased.

Toadesstern

Germany16350 Posts

June 19 2012 20:12 GMT

#86

On June 20 2012 05:11 Artanis[Xp] wrote:
@Toads the creature gets +1+0 each turn, so the Mafia KP gets incrementally increased.

that's still only 9 dmg in the first 2 cycles :p

gonzaw

Uruguay4911 Posts

June 19 2012 20:15 GMT

#87

So....do you have the list of all the decks combinations/cards that have certain effects in the game?

Like what deck would make you a DT or a Day Vigilante or something?

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

June 19 2012 20:18 GMT

#88

I haven't even started on deck constructions yet since I've been busy with school. I'm not sure I'm going to be creating blue roles since this is experimental enough as is. Perhaps one or two board cards that people can tap mana to give someone an ability for that turn.

Barbiero

Brazil5259 Posts

June 20 2012 03:33 GMT

#89

GUYS I have to /out

I'm sorry, it's just that my lack of normal games is really hampering my play, so I'll join wbg's movie mafia instead. I apologize!

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

June 20 2012 21:19 GMT

#90

Too bad

What do you guys think about sideboards?

Poll: Sideboards?

Nah, unneccesary. (5)

63%

Sure, but only to change the deck before the game. (3)

38%

Yes, allow players to change their decks before the game and at the end of the second Attack Phase (0)

0%

8 total votes

Your vote: Sideboards?

(Vote): Nah, unneccesary.
(Vote): Sure, but only to change the deck before the game.
(Vote): Yes, allow players to change their decks before the game and at the end of the second Attack Phase

Second attack phase doesn't neccesarily need to be the case. I'm thinking of allowing players to sub cards in to their library so they can adapt to what they've seen. What is your guys' opinions on it? Or should I abandon sideboards altogether?

gonzaw

Uruguay4911 Posts

June 20 2012 21:33 GMT

#91

What are Sideboards?

>_> <_<

Artanis[Xp]

Netherlands12968 Posts

June 20 2012 21:51 GMT

#92

They're 15 cards that you can swap into your main deck for cards from your main deck.

EchelonTee

United States5256 Posts

June 20 2012 22:11 GMT

#93

They are usually used in tournament play to adjust your deck's layout depending on the opponent. Like for example if you have a Red Weenie deck (rush style kill kill). but this combo deck is about to crap all over you, you can sideboard in a few key cards that disrupt their combo.

Are the deck types of each player going to be revealed before start of the game, or no? I think that would affect whether sideboards are really necessary.

Toadesstern

Germany16350 Posts

June 20 2012 22:27 GMT

#94

revealing decks before the start of the game would suck really hard.

I don't really like the idea of sideboards now that I thought about it although I already voted "yeah want them". You could pimp it after getting your alignment to be more what you want it to be considering your alignment.
I'd say that's in general stronger for mafia than for town because mafia has ths 4/1 unblockable beast thingy town has to live with either way and they can't really adjust to that other than doing massive elven heals. Mafia on the other hand could do a couple of things that are really anti-town that you don't really want to play at all if you're town and therefore are totally useless unless you roll mafia.
Just picture the white armageddon or land destruction in general. Someone playing armageddon basicly screws everyone in the game, making them unable to play new monster or spells (which is this games version of lynches) which slows down the game (kind of a no-lynch) while mafias KP grow stronger every day and they can use that no matter of economy.

That's stuff that could be really strong for mafia but essentially useless for town and a sideboard means you don't have to think about something that is okayish for both alignments anymore. You just pimp your deck depending on your alignment. If you roll town get those land destructions out and get something different in there fot example.

Sooooo, long story short: I voted for yes but I don't want them.

MidnightGladius

China1214 Posts

June 21 2012 01:55 GMT

#95

Yeah, my first reaction to a potential sideboard was also to load it with stalling effects and mass discard/LD. When you have an awesome clock that the other team can't remove, there's no need to actually do anything else :D

marvellosity

United Kingdom36161 Posts

June 21 2012 11:52 GMT

#96

On June 21 2012 07:27 Toadesstern wrote:
revealing decks before the start of the game would suck really hard.

I don't really like the idea of sideboards now that I thought about it although I already voted "yeah want them". You could pimp it after getting your alignment to be more what you want it to be considering your alignment.
I'd say that's in general stronger for mafia than for town because mafia has ths 4/1 unblockable beast thingy town has to live with either way and they can't really adjust to that other than doing massive elven heals. Mafia on the other hand could do a couple of things that are really anti-town that you don't really want to play at all if you're town and therefore are totally useless unless you roll mafia.
Just picture the white armageddon or land destruction in general. Someone playing armageddon basicly screws everyone in the game, making them unable to play new monster or spells (which is this games version of lynches) which slows down the game (kind of a no-lynch) while mafias KP grow stronger every day and they can use that no matter of economy.

That's stuff that could be really strong for mafia but essentially useless for town and a sideboard means you don't have to think about something that is okayish for both alignments anymore. You just pimp your deck depending on your alignment. If you roll town get those land destructions out and get something different in there fot example.

Sooooo, long story short: I voted for yes but I don't want them.

Listen to this guy!