whysomuch is likely a villager too based on my experience with him and what I've seen from him so far in the thread
Surprisingly Normal Mini Mafia XI - Page 29
Forum Index > TL Mafia |
SexDoll
United States44 Posts
whysomuch is likely a villager too based on my experience with him and what I've seen from him so far in the thread | ||
marvellosity
United Kingdom36156 Posts
| ||
SexDoll
United States44 Posts
On April 28 2012 04:53 Lazermonkey wrote: Reading through the thread more closely this time. @AcesAnoka - His posts are just scummier and scummier. Something to add on the case against him are the last posts before he goes to bed. He first is very suspicious about yomi, but when both Golden and Splinter posts some good cases against him he quickly responds with: I understand that he needs to go to bed but basically what he does is fleeing from all the allegations by saying '' this case was bad, hope u forget about it till tomorrow''. @The_Zen_Man Must say that he is acting way to defensive atm. At least if he is in fact a towine. Up untill just an hour ago all he had posted was defensive posts in response to WhySoMuch. He then makes a summary posts which just made me even more puzzled. His conclusions just seem to be way off. The one I was most suprised about was: It's almost like you didn't read anything but the very first pages. Alot of people, me including, have been thinking that AcecAnoka's behavior was more then just strange. This is NOT only due to his first post but mostly due to the yomi-debate. And I don't understand what you mean with I think it was a good thing you put that pressure vote on yomi, after all it did give a response from him.. The only thing yomi said was what everyone was thinking: that he was just trying to start a discussion. Now this is alot WIFOM. But it IS possible that AcesAnoka were trying to go for a cheap bandwagon on yomi and when he realized that it all failed utterly he was quick to abandon the ship. His scumbro The_Zen_Man tries to to cover his teammate by giving him a relativelynice review in his summary post. Imo The_Zen_Man seems like a confused townie tho and not lynch worthy at all atm. AcecAnoka on the other hand seems quite a bit suspicious to me still. reread a little more of lazermonkey because of that other post I quoted earlier and cus I saw whysomuch voting him and think this post is interesting. Lazer post is a defence of zen_man with an attack on aces (who I think is a likely towno). It's interesting because both cases are very thin and he has fairly strong opinions in opposite directions on each of them. If Lazer is a scummo, he's very unlikely to take this position if aces and zenman are both towndawgs. It's too viable for ppl to go either way on both of these ppl for him to take such a hard stance on them if they were both townspeople. Scum will either back off on these ppl to let the townsos make a bad decision, or they will chose the line of reasoning that makes either of them more likely to be scum. SOOO given my initial reads on lazer and aces, if lazer flips scum, we can probably turbolynch thezenman the next day | ||
SexDoll
United States44 Posts
whysomuch, has anyone claimed or anything? are there any specific rules you think I might not know that I should? | ||
SexDoll
United States44 Posts
On May 04 2012 09:52 marvellosity wrote: Mmhmm. You're still scum though sup bro you should answer some of my generic questions about the mechanics of the game so far imo | ||
SexDoll
United States44 Posts
On May 04 2012 09:52 marvellosity wrote: Mmhmm. You're still scum though because im such a boss and an all around cool dude, i'll help you out a little more and tell you why this response is absurdly townistic this is a player comfortable in his role without worry about how others perceive him lock tounsman apparently im posting too fast and got a spam alert or something this would never happen on 2p2 | ||
marvellosity
United Kingdom36156 Posts
| ||
SexDoll
United States44 Posts
giving me info is probably a good idea though | ||
marvellosity
United Kingdom36156 Posts
| ||
SexDoll
United States44 Posts
On April 28 2012 03:05 The_Zen_Man wrote: If i have seemed inactive, i will try to make up for it now. Below i will give my opinions on a few players. WhySoMuch: I still find it strange that you were so aggresive towards me early in the game after i had only posted one post. I also find it strange that you barely mentioned Veriat who's first post was very similliar to mine. Said this before, but can you please explain you're actions here? Also, why didn't you aske yomi for further explination on his vote on you? Instead you voted on me and had some few posts where you conversed with yomi. This also seemed strange to me. Please explain. Yomi: Not 100% sure on you, but you seem to aggressive for being mafia. Maybe you should have given a better explanation than the one you gave when you voted. LazerMonkey: You seem to be very busy irl, but you could try to contribute a little. So far, i don't think you have contributed much at all. AcesAnoka: You seem suspicous to me. You're first comment was rather strange, but i know you shoulnd't judge someone too much based on what they first wrote. I think it was a good thing you put that pressure vote on yomi, after all it did give a response from him. Veriat: I find it strange that you posted a very similliar post just after mine. I do however like your post where you explain how we would gain information if nolynch. Try to contribute more. O.Golden_ne: I like your playing style. You encourage everyone to stay calm when they seem emotional and explain themselves when they seem suspicous. Pure-SC2: You have very good analytical posts, and you are one of the players that contribute the most. Keep it up! nreekay324 : Im not sure if you are lurking or just not able to post, but you seem really suspicious at the moment. Please explain yourself, and also your vote. ##Vote: The_Zen_Man this dude is nearly always a wolf skimmed all of his posts. super defensive and super concerned with how he's coming across. All his defences are him basically saying stuff like "why would I do that as a scum" when the answer to that is obviously so that you could say that when being pushed. as for the actual post I quoted, it's a common things scum do. They make a list with a bunch of ppl on it and say a sentence or 2 about each of them. The problem is that there aren't any reads there. They're all summaries or suggestions or questions. It's an excuse to post Marv being a tool but w/e, never vote him | ||
WhySoMuch
132 Posts
On May 04 2012 09:58 SexDoll wrote: I see there are a bunch of claimable roles whysomuch, has anyone claimed or anything? are there any specific rules you think I might not know that I should? No one has claimed anything yet. Angel protected the right person yesterday or the town has a veteran. 1) You have to get a Majority on someone in order for them to be lynched. This is insanely prowolf so I have no idea how town are suppose to win these things 2) They don't like lists. 3) They don't like short posts 4) You can talk during night 5) You don't have to f5 the thread, I assure nothing has happened. Could go 6 hours without a post. 6) WIFOM- Speculative things Lurkers = UTRs | ||
SexDoll
United States44 Posts
On April 28 2012 20:38 Veriat wrote: @ The_Zen_Man the things about you i find fishy is your opening post: And after lurker for some time, you posts this And from that point on you're on the defensive, not added to the discussion but simply defending your self in multiple posts. To me this just looks scummy, you open being pro "no lynch" because you're scared it might hit you our one of your fellow scum. And then you're playing defensive trying devirt the attention somewhere else, like just now that i vote for you, you panic vote me back, and try to divert the attention to me, now that i've called you out. And on a side note i know i shared your opinion on the whole D1 lynch discussion, but i my previous posts i note that from reading some of the arguments on the topic, and this being my first forum mafia, i change my mind slightly on the subject. And i apologize if my first post on why i found you scummy lacked content, upon prof reading it (after posting it ofc /facepalm) i do see SC2's point on it looking kinda scummy. ##unvote nvm | ||
marvellosity
United Kingdom36156 Posts
| ||
WhySoMuch
132 Posts
And oddly enough we reached the same conclusion on Marvelous. | ||
nreekay324
46 Posts
Where do we go now??? I still think the case Marvellosity made against Golden is the most solid case we have. But we can't really push Golden to answer for the case against him because, well, now it's sexdoll? And have zenman and mordanis checked out too ![]() | ||
WhySoMuch
132 Posts
| ||
Lazermonkey
Sweden2176 Posts
Because I'm scum or because I don't remember things. you choose! Was just a really something I wrote in panic-mode, trying to throw of the suspicion of me. I'm sorry for this! | ||
Mordanis
United States893 Posts
@ SexDoll Thanks for coming in, and welcome. Anyways, my thoughts: Lazer has only played one game on TL before, and that game he was (mis)lynched on the first day. IDK if that will excuse everything, but for me for this cycle, I see his previous excuse post as valid. There has been little talk of Nreekay. There has been little talk from Nreekay. I'm suspicious of him, but I'll still hold on to my reasoning about him. Definitely worth looking into if things don't work as we'd like them to. Golden/Sex Doll, I've felt some suspicion for you for quite a while. IDK, there was never really any response to Marv's case, and now its sort of hard to have one person defend another based on simply inheriting the same role. In short, with still two mafia and 6 town, I'll likely vote Golden because Marv had a pretty decent case and replacements make the game so much more annoying. Anyways, I've been trying to figure out the implications of mafia voting for/against Veriat, and what mafia would be trying to do right now. I haven't really checked out, I'm just re-evaluating. As I stated earlier (and no hate to the replacements), replacing players makes it nearly impossible to figure out the orientation of the combined player. This has temporarily discouraged me, but I should have a lot more time tomorrow to wade through things. | ||
The_Zen_Man
Sweden202 Posts
On May 04 2012 09:57 SexDoll wrote: reread a little more of lazermonkey because of that other post I quoted earlier and cus I saw whysomuch voting him and think this post is interesting. Lazer post is a defence of zen_man with an attack on aces (who I think is a likely towno). It's interesting because both cases are very thin and he has fairly strong opinions in opposite directions on each of them. If Lazer is a scummo, he's very unlikely to take this position if aces and zenman are both towndawgs. It's too viable for ppl to go either way on both of these ppl for him to take such a hard stance on them if they were both townspeople. Scum will either back off on these ppl to let the townsos make a bad decision, or they will chose the line of reasoning that makes either of them more likely to be scum. SOOO given my initial reads on lazer and aces, if lazer flips scum, we can probably turbolynch thezenman the next day Please make a better explanation to why i should be "turbolynched" if lazer flips scum? Also, try to read all of the thread before forming a opinion. | ||
The_Zen_Man
Sweden202 Posts
| ||
| ||