Werewolves Invade Teamliquid II

On February 13 2012 10:29 sinani206 wrote:
why do i always check tl an hour before the game starts and then not until 10 hours later...

On February 14 2012 09:56 Probulous wrote:
Because to me someone sending a PM to a guy who is playing his first game asking for his role without sending similar PM's to more experienced players is scummy as hell. It looks like he is trying to buddy up and influence the newbie.

A townie would send PM's to everyone or ask in the thread. Scum don't want to arose the suspicion of senior players so newbs are easy targets. That is why it bothers me. Now I know the evidence is thin at best which is why I am trying to find some more, no-one else is coming forward though so I have to keep believing he only sent one to SpiritClown. Well, why SpiritClown then? The only justification I can see is that he is a newb.

I am sure I am missing something but this is all I got. Help?

On February 15 2012 06:52 Lanaia wrote:


I just think it's silly that people think he's scum solely because of what he's done in regards to asking roles. It just seems a bit overboard, no?

On February 15 2012 08:00 Probulous wrote:
I don't know what to think about sinani so I am going to propose a different candidate for lynch

zeurg

He is actively lurking and refusing to contribute.

Note he was on IRC for just under half an hour before Mattchew mentioned his name. Then 23 seconds later he posts. He was reading the thread as he says but he was obviously reading IRC too. Anyway when pushed to contribute he says nothing.

Now it is nice to know he is apparently a townie but this is the last thing he says until

Nothing for 1.5 hrs and then he quits. This was in the middle of the prpl shitstorm and he says nothing.I even tried to get him to talk in a private channel. Unfortunately it isn't logged, sorry guys. But all I said was that he should start posting but I got no response.


Now I know this is his first game but he is actively trying to avoid posting. He doesn't want to contribute and doesn't like being questioned. A townie would post when pushed, they should not be scared of making mistakes. I make them, even the great and mighty palmar makes them (though he may dispute it). Only mafia have a reason to try to avoid the spotlight in this manner.

On February 16 2012 21:59 froggynoddy wrote:
2. [UoN]Sentinel

Claiming to be scum seems like a stupid move, both as scum and as townie. Its probably a slightly stupider move as scum as he was talking to someone who seems to be regarded as townier than most... thats a thin defence though.

On February 16 2012 08:19 Probulous wrote:


His first major contribution to the thread was in regards to my request for Prpl’s PMs. Here he writes

This rang scummy to me. This is basically stating you support fishing for information from newbs. I have made it clear that I don’t like it (others clearly disagree), but this caught my eye.

Then he goes and says this



This is really bad logic. Just because Lanaia defends Prpl’s actions does not mean they are on the same team. Sure it would make Lanaia look scummy if Prpl flipped red but here he says he would straight up vote for her. He would lynch her based off a prpl flip.

He takes up the argument in IRC


Prpl never defended Lanaia, when asked he says

The only thing that Prpl mentions about Lanaia is

Which is hardly defending given no-one was attacking Lanaia.

Sentinel has made a concerted effort to link Lanaia and prpl such that one’s alignment will confirm the other.

Then he goes and undermines my case against zeurg right after I posted it. A vote for someone is worth nothing if you give them an ready made excuse not to reply. This is what Sentinel writes

Sentinel supports fishing for information from newbs, tried really hard to link a Prpl flip with Lanaia and actively undermined my efforts to get zeurg to post.

##Vote [UoN]Sentinel

Sorry bro as much fun as you are, you rolled mafia this game.

PS: This is irrelevant to the case so it is in spoilers but I had a giggle
+ Show Spoiler +

On February 17 2012 11:59 Paperscraps wrote:
EBWOP: I think that either ghost_403 or prplhz is scum.*

On February 17 2012 11:58 Paperscraps wrote:
I think there either ghost_403 or prplhz is scum.

I am not sure what to make of the Probulous vs [UoN]Sentinel ordeal as of yet. Leaning towards Sentinel being scum and not joking this time.

There is scum somewhere in Lanaia, Bluelightz and Grackaroni.

On February 18 2012 09:04 Paperscraps wrote:
So today we are lynching

lanaia

and

[UoN]Sentinel

lanaia is filler and only opinionated when provoked. She is more curious about what other player's reads are, than providing content herself. She has been diplomatic this whole game and reactionary. Her vote on ghost_403 and the reasoning behind it is weak. The ensuing bandwagon on ghost_403 is too easy.

[UoN]Sentinel is obvious scum. He hasn't provided any content worthwhile. His filter is scummy and reaction to being called scum is bad. His last post is him pretty much giving up. Any real townie would fight.

On February 23 2012 22:00 froggynoddy wrote:
goddamn it, I said early on in the scum QT that Palmar was almost certainly scum..... grrrr. Well played.