BC's Arkham City

On February 06 2012 18:41 Kenpachi wrote:

This post is an atrocity.

RANDOM VOTING STAGE?
REALLY? fucking dumb. Its detrimental to blow any KP you get for mere information.[

Fun Fact: Town loses when i get lynched. (100% of the time)

Oh and im not hinting anytihng. i shouldn't give a vibe when i claim townie. Ive claimed townie when i was Mafia, Veteran, Vigilante, Doctor and etc.

From my standpoint, i have no opinion on Sheth, however im now deadset on this fool

On February 06 2012 22:51 -_-Quails wrote:

Did you read the rest of that post?
For your benefit:

Explicit reasons:
Objective: rgTheSchworz recycled an argument in order to attack KenPatchi. This is not a pro-town thing to do.

Subjective: rgTheSchworz reacted to the vanilla claim in a way that raised my hackles, as did Sheth but Sheth used his own reasoning rather than recycling and so is less suspicious.

Objective: That quote. player A knows -> mafia knows -> player A is mafia

If Kenpachi is scum how do they know his role? He could be really a green. He could really be a blue. HIS CLAIM SAYS NOTHING ABOUT WHAT HE IS.

Moving on to Cyber_Cheese:
Cyber_Cheese's points about Catwoman are wrong. Or maybe it was Tunkeg? Someone said "catwoman should just shoot the most pro-town people", that's not true either. Catwoman should DT until she finds her target then kill them. She doesn't win with scum. If scum win before two-face/penguin are dead then Catwoman loses. Shooting the most pro-town looking people will probably just result in red and green deaths. If you even broadcast that advice or assumption why would two-face and the penguin put themselves in the spotlight? Now Catwoman is in a WIFOM situation where she has to guess what her target is thinking and shooting randomly is unsafe, puts her at a higher risk of losing the game. With the combined full force KP of batman/catwoman/mafia all shooting into "town" (except batman/catwoman don't know who town is, although you guys seem pretty confident they will know implicitly) the game will likely end with scum winning and town with both third parties losing. I'm not going to crunch numbers because I can't do math but I'm guessing of at least one of each candidate surviving to endgame in this scenario are pretty high. I hope that clears things up. I think Cyber_Cheese is either mafia or, more obviously, Batman. I don't know why I didn't put it together before but the player trying to get the Joker offered up scot free with no clear pro-town motives seems like a pretty good bet for me. If he's not third party or scum I'd be pretty shocked. Can anyone link me to some games in which Cyber_Cheese was a town aligned player in memory?

After looking at that I might switch votes. I dislike voting for players who attack me because I am very defensive and often in mafia games I get tunnel vision when I'm attacked. But just as often as I've been wrong, I've been right and ever since letting Pandain slip through my grasp in Insane Mafia I've tried to be more confident.

She is also incredibly good at fooling people with her Allure and access to materials to make the perfect disguise. As such she can appear to be any role in the game. She wins when two face and penguin are eliminated.

For what its worth, I know exactly what role Toad is, what his special power was and why it was that way. Hence why I'm far more inclined to believe him and DocH, unless a counterclaim was to come forward.

I'd bet on your role right now.

It's not town to say "I don't care if I get lynched cause I can still win." So can scum

I am Two-Face

Guy doesnt claim a DT check tomorrow

Lynch ensues

On February 11 2012 02:23 RayzorFlash wrote:
I think the whole Schworz drama will likely clear itself out tonight, or at least give us more concrete information instead of like, 7 people throwing out either what they think, or random claims that don't make sense...

I was working on an analysis of Chaoser, and his actions on Day 1 don't seem that scummy to me, but the hard Day 2 push to set up a lynch after Sheth is lynched seems reallyyyyy scummy... I don't have a solid opinion on that yet, and I still think we lynch Sheth today to verify Radfield.

Oh and, I don't think anyone's mentioned this, but Palmar can't POSSIBLY be as crazy as he's posting with randomly not remembering stuff he did the previous day. Methinks he has some sort of role text restriction that gives him split personality disorder / lunacy... The characters that might work well with such a restriction (disregarding other peoples claims, and actual logic) are: Joker, Harley Quinn, Scarecrow (different night personality than day maybe?), Two-face, Calendar Man, and Clayface... None of the mafia power-roles seem to logically work with this restriction, so I'm inclined to lean very slightly towards Palmar being town (or i'm totally off-base with my logic... lol)

Oh wait of course you would because your not mentally retarded. And yes information if fucken great this game is all about information. If we can determine if Radfield alignment and nail scum why wouldn't we lynch Sheth.

I'm going to vote for Sheth because he would give us a good bit of info and give us some info on Radfield too

On February 11 2012 02:00 Toadesstern wrote:

you know what I was referring to.

Jackal shot DocH. DocH is the only one within the circle of people who are either dead or claimed a hit and at the same time are on the gay-phone-session. Jackal can only shoot people on his gay-phone-session. He called me a liar and maybe found out what was meant to be for docH. Anyways I'm pretty sury Jackal shot DocH.

On February 11 2012 19:05 DoctorHelvetica wrote:


You mean the thing Kurumi is saying would be impossible in order to defend you????

On February 11 2012 19:35 Palmar wrote:
I got hit last night.

If Palmar is batman he already knew I'm batman way before DocH told everyone.
And I am pretty sure Palmar knew I am joker before n1 deadline which again makes it more likely that he's not the badman. But maybe I misinterpreted something idk

On February 09 2012 03:32 kitaman27 wrote:


Why is there a decent chance the joker will die tonight? Seems just as likely as any other vig.

On February 12 2012 02:35 Toadesstern wrote:

me neither

He won't be killed by scum at any point though regardless of his alignment.

Also, lying about a DT check cannot be a town move, in any occasion. You should die for this.

You will have to be either VERY lucky, or both you and Chaoser have to be scum, for you to be able to fake a rolecheck.

Theoretically town gains not lynching Chaoser today, which is what we should be doing. However I have no faith that you are actually a dt, so I see no need to listen to your check.

Perhaps this is more WIFOM to confuse scum.

If he is scum then this act would deter town vigis from shooting at chaoser but could bait 3rd party in checking/shooting him.

i took a hit last night
my role would not allow me to survive said hit.

what i would then conclude:
i must have been medic protected (but i have not been told that directly)

On February 13 2012 03:56 Jayjay54 wrote:


rg, use your logic. Say BM thinks layana is good town, he protects him two times. What does that have to do with lanaya's real alignment.

Also why can't BM just lying about protecting him. Lanaya only gets notified when he was hit, he was alive so BM knew he wasn't killed. (I find that unlikely, but it's possible as well)

So no, everything is possible. Especially a scum lanaya and town BM should not be counted out.


[This has nothing to do with me seeing lanaya as scum, I just want to argue with that "Both town or both scum" idea]

im going to bed, will catch up tomorrow - i'm surprised im alive ... i must have a medic on me

On February 13 2012 04:51 Kurumi wrote:

The thing is not protect itself, but the TIMING.
If hosts forgot about a protect (mind, You're only informed of a save when You're actually hit) he would be..
DEAD.
Thanks to this, we know he's LYING.
Add that the hosts weren't even around him claiming he "just got the pm" and TADAAM.

On February 13 2012 05:00 Kurumi wrote:
Anyway, I am up for suggestions who should be checked by me next night.
I'll kill Bill Murray anyway.

That means that Rg is a Vet, and cant be a Detective. Why he is keeping up the bullshit about DT? I dont know pretty anti town in my opinion

But I think it makes the most sense. Given this information i think we should completely ignore his DT checks cause there bullshit. Kurimi had to agree with the Harley Quinn guess it was a guess.

So RG is a Vet not a DT and not two face if he was twoface he would be dead. I hope we can move foward as town and from now on
Ignore his DT checks because there complete bullshit.

This Does mean as well tho that he is town. : ( Given that i will have to reread the filters to find someone else i think is scummy D:

BTW RG i still think your anti town as fuck. Just not scum

On February 17 2012 00:44 risk.nuke wrote:

Well that's the clever part from his side. It's to fool scum, But I am 99% they won't fall for it so right now he's just confusing townies and spamming. I mean don't you think mafia finds it a bit odd that if he were freeze why he choose not to just say. Oh I'm the last medic and absorb bullets which is his job rather then shouting all over the thread how he is freeze. The bad part on his behalf is he just blew away any wifom.

I don't see how there can be any damn confusion. I am confirmed two-face if noone else claims. And if scum tries to claim, well I don't know what will happen.

schwors I'm not allowed to answer that question. It is pm-flavor.

Well that's the clever part from his side. It's to fool scum, But I am 99% they won't fall for it so right now he's just confusing townies and spamming. I mean don't you think mafia finds it a bit odd that if he were freeze why he choose not to just say. Oh I'm the last medic and absorb bullets which is his job rather then shouting all over the thread how he is freeze. The bad part on his behalf is he just blew away any wifom.

On February 17 2012 01:11 risk.nuke wrote:
None of rg, forumite and myself are scum. This is law from now untill either the game ends or someone else claims two-face. In which case it will ceace to be a law for the abruptly 15 seconds it will take to prove that the fake-claimer is scum and that I am the real two-face.