EPTOn April 13 2011 13:57 darmousseh wrote:
Analysis on me by chaoser
+ Show Spoiler +
I read kav and he is usually a good townie so at first he was helpful. After a while, his posts seemed forceful and intentional rather than his normal style of posting. Gmarshal is probably town, but DrH is definitely town based on games I've played with him in the past. We already determined that the pardoner is a bad role for town, so let's make prot pardoner and then lynch him. Simple plan easy to execute, guaranteed black dead.
Also, we will have plenty of time tomorrow to find out the scum. We have all sorts of detectives, trackers, watchers to help get town information and information is power. Suggesting to lynch someone 5 minutes before the next day even starts is terrible.
Analysis on me by chaoser
+ Show Spoiler +
On April 13 2011 13:41 chaoser wrote:
Read up to Page 83 and I want to look at someone
Darm:
He says this and yet when GM bounced around a bit he still voted him
Backtracks off Kav
Very much against Prot being in office, says he is probably mafia.
But then, even though this whole time he was against Prot being in office, all of a sudden he changes his stance and says DrH's plan was "the most pro-town of all" when previous he had said Prot was probably red. Why would you want Prot in office then, regardless of if he is red or black?
Again says he is weary prot...and kav
+ Show Spoiler +
lol...look at all this wishy washy posting
Lynch Darm or Lynch ON on Day 2.
Read up to Page 83 and I want to look at someone
Darm:
He says this and yet when GM bounced around a bit he still voted him
Backtracks off Kav
Very much against Prot being in office, says he is probably mafia.
But then, even though this whole time he was against Prot being in office, all of a sudden he changes his stance and says DrH's plan was "the most pro-town of all" when previous he had said Prot was probably red. Why would you want Prot in office then, regardless of if he is red or black?
Again says he is weary prot...and kav
+ Show Spoiler +
On April 12 2011 02:42 darmousseh wrote:
I usually don't answer stuff like this because it's just trying to get people to react in a certain manner etc, but day 1 is always speculative. The only things we can go off so far is prot claiming. The other million posts in the thread are just useless "Lynch all lairs, lynch/dont lynch inactices, lynch lurkers" fluff which ver already wrote a good thread about and trying to argue whether it's good or not for a non town-aligned player to have a town favorable role (mayor) which is obviously idiotic without having to even argue against it. There are 2 types of people on day 1, spammers and lurkers. If you aren't spamming then, "omg you are a lurker you scum". I find that this analysis is usually wrong. Good scum will play the same as they normally do when they are scum or town, but it's the little things (like the words themselves) which give an indication whether a person is trying to act intentionally or just aggressively. This is why I believe that Kav is black, his posts seem "forced", but not forced enough when he was scum and he is playing safe, which is why I think he is black.
I've been scum and town with kav before in the past and my read on him is based on those past games and while I think gmarshal is town, I think DrH is more town and is better suited for mayor at this point. I was a little weary of DrH only because he didn't believe me when I came up with a plan in mini-mafia (which ended up partially costing the game), but that is the past and I think he is a good person to lead town. Either him or gmarshal would be good candidates, going with DrH based on gut.
I usually don't answer stuff like this because it's just trying to get people to react in a certain manner etc, but day 1 is always speculative. The only things we can go off so far is prot claiming. The other million posts in the thread are just useless "Lynch all lairs, lynch/dont lynch inactices, lynch lurkers" fluff which ver already wrote a good thread about and trying to argue whether it's good or not for a non town-aligned player to have a town favorable role (mayor) which is obviously idiotic without having to even argue against it. There are 2 types of people on day 1, spammers and lurkers. If you aren't spamming then, "omg you are a lurker you scum". I find that this analysis is usually wrong. Good scum will play the same as they normally do when they are scum or town, but it's the little things (like the words themselves) which give an indication whether a person is trying to act intentionally or just aggressively. This is why I believe that Kav is black, his posts seem "forced", but not forced enough when he was scum and he is playing safe, which is why I think he is black.
I've been scum and town with kav before in the past and my read on him is based on those past games and while I think gmarshal is town, I think DrH is more town and is better suited for mayor at this point. I was a little weary of DrH only because he didn't believe me when I came up with a plan in mini-mafia (which ended up partially costing the game), but that is the past and I think he is a good person to lead town. Either him or gmarshal would be good candidates, going with DrH based on gut.
On April 12 2011 14:55 darmousseh wrote:
I'm mostly in agreement with this, but it's because I had a anti-town read on kav, and the way he went down was very anti-town. I was considering switching the vote for gmarshal towards the end, but kav just screwed town.
I'm mostly in agreement with this, but it's because I had a anti-town read on kav, and the way he went down was very anti-town. I was considering switching the vote for gmarshal towards the end, but kav just screwed town.
lol...look at all this wishy washy posting
Lynch Darm or Lynch ON on Day 2.
I read kav and he is usually a good townie so at first he was helpful. After a while, his posts seemed forceful and intentional rather than his normal style of posting. Gmarshal is probably town, but DrH is definitely town based on games I've played with him in the past. We already determined that the pardoner is a bad role for town, so let's make prot pardoner and then lynch him. Simple plan easy to execute, guaranteed black dead.
Also, we will have plenty of time tomorrow to find out the scum. We have all sorts of detectives, trackers, watchers to help get town information and information is power. Suggesting to lynch someone 5 minutes before the next day even starts is terrible.
Electing prot as pardoner is a good idea, wasting a lynch to kill a black is bad, that doesnt make sense.
Also, trying to make town feel comfortable with 'we have plenty of time to find scum' and encouraging reliance on power roles is scummy play. And wtf is with your last sentence? There's five minutes left in the night, it's definitely not too early to scumhunt.
