Harry Potter Mafia!

On December 12 2010 14:46 RebirthOfLeGenD wrote:

err EBWOP sorry
I said I would fully be accountable for who I killed btw. Its a burden I would be willing to take on. Look at my above post with my LSB analysis. In this current system if we voted for LSB he would be able to sherk off blame/responsibility because the masses made the decision even though hes the one pulling the trigger. It is really stupid to pretend that it is still a majority lynch, that is like saying America is a true democracy even though someone else is making the final decision. I was willing to take the burden of the MoM kill in deciding who I was going to put down and on top of that I was willing to take responsibility for that outcome. I would be lying if I said that I think a majority decision is always the best way to do it. The mafia is rightfully scared of one good player getting that first kill off and it not belonging to a townie. Its hard to mount a really strong case against someone day 1 and its much easier for the mafia to manipulate a mislynch which is why they would prefer to do exactly what LSB is doing and deferring the mislynch back into the towns hands and allowing us to fuck it up on our own volition, or so we would be led to believe.

On December 14 2010 09:10 Barundar wrote:

I'm sorry what?

On December 14 2010 09:13 LunarDestiny wrote:

Mr.zergling and I are in that group. We were planning to use his ability and if we catch something, we would reveal our group to town along with the information.

Mr.Zergling can confirm what I say when he gets on...

On December 14 2010 10:05 kitaman27 wrote:


Can you also confirm that you group has an alternate win condition?

On December 14 2010 10:24 why wrote:
1) Can Mr. Zergling and Lunar Destiny prove that they are mod-confirmed? Like by breadcrumb? Sorry if this has already been addressed.

2) My interpretation is that 3 death eater hits went out, 1 on Amber, 1 on RoL, and 1 on Beneather. RoL survived the hit, but got taken out by a 3rd-party (quite possibly town-aligned since he was garnering a lot of suspicion). I think RoL got hit by death eater because only 1 person has claimed to be hit and because RoL was playing more scummy than normal. A scum would interpret this as trying to make him a less attractive target (you don't NK scummy players) and NK'ed him anyway.

This makes LSB more likely to be scum as RoL was quite vocal in his denunciation.

3) Kenpachi and LSB = mod-confirmed patil sisters? The only thing I can think of that makes his defense make sense (other than them both being scum, of course). In this case your play is REALLY STUPID Kenpachi.

On December 14 2010 10:42 why wrote:
Can Mr. Zergling and LunarDestiny just both say that a mod confirmed to each of them that all of them are 100% town? There is always the possibility of a traitor Mason.

On December 14 2010 10:44 LunarDestiny wrote:

Confirm. Our role pms (annul say in the op there is no lie in them) say that we belong to a town-aligned group.

On December 14 2010 10:46 why wrote:
(ps breadcrumb is when you fill your old posts with hints as to your role so you can confirm role-claim later, this is especially useful for mod-confirmed Masons )

On December 14 2010 12:14 LSB wrote:
Right now I'm just observing what's going on. I left enough hints to lead you in the right direction.

I've already character claimed somewhere in this thread. It's very subtle, but important.

Btw, don't publically state it. Just PM me. (And No, I am not one of the Patils).

On December 14 2010 12:35 oddo123 wrote:
I thought all townies work together in mini-groups where a player knows of the other members in that group. Apparently, I might be wrong bleah =/

On December 14 2010 13:10 LSB wrote:
Me, Meapak and RoL were in a group.

On December 14 2010 13:30 LSB wrote:
I take it that you're okay with me revealing your role?

On December 14 2010 13:35 LSB wrote:

Last time I took out something I thought wouldn't benefit the town, everyone started harping on me x.x

On December 15 2010 06:14 deconduo wrote:


Its so obvious he's legit, town just sheeped mafia.

On December 15 2010 09:07 Jackal58 wrote:

Why?
From previous Annul post:
thegilaboy, deconduo, LSB = 3 on orgolove.

I think we have one or two better options right here.

On December 15 2010 09:09 Kenpachi wrote:
wait a second.. is he mafia? because his name is black ~_~

On December 15 2010 09:14 ilovejonn wrote:
now his name is red and black lol annul edit

On December 15 2010 09:15 Airbag wrote:
It says he was not aware of his power until Day 4. Seeing as it is now Night 2, it is completely retarded to go for orgolove at this point.




Because mafia prefer to distract/subvert votes rather than directly defend a fellow mafia? Doesn't it make sense that instead of connecting themselves to a mafia that might die, they present a new target and try to split up the town?

I find it weird that you are using the fact that we killed a death eater to try to get the people who got him lynched get lynched. That's bad play LunarDestiny, that makes you suspicious to me.

On December 15 2010 09:21 Kenpachi wrote:
okay so if he had contact with Mafia, i assume i will die next

On December 15 2010 09:27 Kenpachi wrote:
but thatll force a roleclaim and i dont want that

On December 15 2010 09:39 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:

And why would we do this? Orgolove called this from the start.

On December 15 2010 09:15 Airbag wrote:
It says he was not aware of his power until Day 4. Seeing as it is now Night 2, it is completely retarded to go for orgolove at this point.




Because mafia prefer to distract/subvert votes rather than directly defend a fellow mafia? Doesn't it make sense that instead of connecting themselves to a mafia that might die, they present a new target and try to split up the town?

I find it weird that you are using the fact that we killed a death eater to try to get the people who got him lynched get lynched. That's bad play LunarDestiny, that makes you suspicious to me.

On December 16 2010 11:23 Kenpachi wrote:
Lunar is.. Padma Patil

On December 16 2010 12:02 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:

Kenpachi is green. I can guarantee it.

On December 16 2010 11:44 LunarDestiny wrote:

I got annul's approval to claim. Yes, I am Padma Patil and my alternative winning condition I win if Parvati Patil wins.

On December 16 2010 12:48 kitaman27 wrote:


Your claim makes no sense.

Why would your alternate win condition be: "I win if another town wins"

The only way this makes sense if one of the two of you are scum. Am I missing something?

Are you aware of your twins identity?

I can confirm that Dr.H PMd me at the start of the game (as Airbag) posing as a noob. He was asking some questions, saying he wanted to team up with a veteran to stay alive. I am by no means a veteran, and he was trying to sweet talk me to get my trust. After watching him post, I had determined that he was most certainly a smurf. When I called him out on it, he eventually told me that he was DocH. He also made a claim early that he was able to protect people, so I figured he was Poppy. When talking to Kitaman, he said that he had a DT who had found the real Poppy, and it was not Airbag/Dr.H.

I can confirm that Dr.H PMd me at the start of the game (as Airbag) posing as a noob. He was asking some questions, saying he wanted to team up with a veteran to stay alive. I am by no means a veteran, and he was trying to sweet talk me to get my trust. After watching him post, I had determined that he was most certainly a smurf. When I called him out on it, he eventually told me that he was DocH. He also made a claim early that he was able to protect people, so I figured he was Poppy. When talking to Kitaman, he said that he had a DT who had found the real Poppy, and it was not Airbag/Dr.H.

On December 18 2010 07:02 Barundar wrote:

They kill DrH?

On December 18 2010 07:02 LunarDestiny wrote:
Kitaman, have your dt personally claim to me and I will prove that I am town to him also.

If my prove is flawed in that it is not enough to prove I am 100% town, then either one of you can tell town. If I am mafia, town also knows Mr.Zergling is mafia.

On December 18 2010 08:10 Pandain wrote:

You don't
But I'm telling you you're going to lynch a DT

On December 18 2010 08:21 Barundar wrote:
Is pandain the safest lynch at this point?

On December 18 2010 08:36 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:
Kenpachi needs to vote now. Even if it's for himself we cannot have him modkilled

On December 18 2010 08:50 DoctorHelvetica wrote:

He also said that if I were checked I would come back town and that is impossible that I returned a death-eater aligned result.

Whoever said that is lying.

On December 18 2010 08:47 LunarDestiny wrote:
I change my vote.

A town confirmed dt claim to me and say that he checked Dr.H and he is mafia.
Annul also say that mafia can not buss dt check and any means.
So the dt check is 100% legit.

Dr.H is a sure lynch.

On December 18 2010 07:13 annul wrote:
3 nonvoters: kenpachi, ilovejonn, node. less than 2 hours to go.

bedtime. if they do not vote by the deadline, they're all dead.

ill put up night post when i wake up. if its really significantly late then ill extend night or someting.

voting is extremely close today so if you are on a placeholder vote, remember to do something with it

On December 20 2010 07:07 orgolove wrote:
I don't get why DrH became a sudden target of everyone's investigations. I was afk for about half a day, and suddenly half the town wants him dead. Looking back, all I can see is that there's layers upon layers of lies.

One of you are claiming that one of your friends investigated someone else and he was doctor, and that friend said that that someone he investigated was not DrH, and that someone who knew his friend knew that DrH was not Poppy then told you kitaman.

By comparison, we saw that Amber was not a veteran as he had claimed, and thus he had to have been protected by a medic. Further Kenpachi was modkilled, not killed by a mafia. So we don't know for sure if DrH is actually lying. DrH was also one of the instrumental voices (as AirBag) in lynching LSB, who turned out to be 100% red.

This is MYLO. I am as suspicious of DrH (or any one of you) as anyone else. But I'm not going to vote to lynch anyone unless we get something 100% concrete. And that's especially considering how many LIES there were in this game - you might still be lying right now, and trying to start a bandwagon early in the day to seal the deal.

On December 20 2010 08:03 CubEdIn wrote:
Meh, my power is a bit odd.
I can't tell who checks my target, or what they do. But once I check someone, I can see actions against them for the rest of the game (or until I die).

If any of the other "watches" could be verified I would have said something. But the other watches were rather useless.

Night #1: LSB. He was visited by someone.
Night #2: Airbag. He was not visited by anyone.
Night #3: Airbag. He was visited by someone & zeks - he was also visited by someone, obviously.

I know it's convenient, but I checked LSB because he was scummy as hell. And I checked zeks because he seemed very pro-town, but in last night's debacle he chose not to vote, which I found very suspicious. So yeah.

I can check whoever you want me to check, and I'll still have my sights on Airbag.

On December 20 2010 08:51 Barundar wrote:
I think Kitaman is lying about extra DT and whatnot. Based on his dedication, Jcarl "confirmed" him. Obvious he is Voldemort or real Poppy, and at the moment it's down to a flip between him and DrH.

Kitaman said DrH and Pandain was scum. DrH said Pandain was not scum. Kitaman could have been lying about both. DrH could have been right about Pandain beceause he was scum.

Town would be safer to find scum elsewhere.

vote Coagulation

On December 20 2010 07:37 annul wrote:


if this is true, then he was cheating.

next time someone blatantly cheats in PM land, report it. they get modkilled.

On December 22 2010 06:29 CubEdIn wrote:
Does anyone else find it weird that nobody made a stand for DrH this turn?

I mean, it's not like there was an "Either Pandain or DrH" situation. They were tied in votes but the same points could be made against DrH's lynch whether Pandain was blue or red.

Anway good for town, bad for oddo. I practically begged for people to stop being afk.
Next stop for modkill, tube? Not because he voted for me, but it seems like the natural order of things.

On December 23 2010 05:38 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:
So did the mafia forget to PM the night hits? Or do we have a damn good town all of a sudden?