Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Mafia - Page 7

On July 03 2010 03:00 ~OpZ~ wrote:

Medic is the role people claim where they won't have to verify their actions. Dontcha know that?

-_-...

On July 03 2010 03:09 ~OpZ~ wrote:

Are you ignoring ME AND JEEJEE "killed" you?!

You are either voldemort, or the horcrux died.

one or the other. And if you're harry, then the horcrux died. That simple. Has to be...-_-
And you have to be Harry...so bleh...
-_-

On July 03 2010 03:47 ~OpZ~ wrote:

He checked Yink too...

Remember, we're thinking he's Naive, but haven't come across another mafia yet....

On July 07 2010 02:13 Roffles wrote:

Okay Jugan. Whatever you say. I like how you never mentioned my name or Radfield's as a DE. Alrighty.

On July 07 2010 02:27 YellowInk wrote:
BM, let me first say that it's fun to have a flavorful game even if it's not perfectly balanced or run. I appreciate that you did this for us and I can see that it took a lot of work to both put this together and to run it.

Now I'm going to vent for a moment. Or two. Hopefully the commentary in and discussion following from this post will lead to improved games run by anyone.

It's ok to have some roles disclosed and others not, but it should be clearly indicated in the rules. The 'spell triangle' should definitely have been in the OP since you apparantely told Amber[Light] about it at some point. It's ok to have hidden game information if you're stating in the OP that there is hidden information. I could see the game design being like a couple of the experienced wizards know about the triangle and all the kids don't. You could mix in the spell triangle flavor with the role PMs so it looks like you're just explaining it to the experienced wizards without making it seem like a big deal that they should tell everyone else. Then when someone comes out and tries to explain it (like Amber[Light] did), they suddenly realize they have to convince everyone the truth of it (and the mod does NOT step in). If it's a rule that the mod can verify, it needs to be in the OP.

Please don't post things that can possibly affect the game - even DTA got railed for wording something in his game that could possibly imply that a random person was receiving a blue role. It's important to be completely clear that any post you are making is not having an impact on gameplay. Most times mod responses need to any queries need to be kept very short and to the point - if even answered at all. This goes for PMs, too. The majority of the posts (and PMs) that you made that weren't day start/end info contained information that affected my knowledge - some dramatically so. I kept the info out of thread as best I could, but it definitely affected some of my decisions.


Was Amber[Light] or Radfield choosing the bans? I was really confused with our minister being Harry Potter but making bans that made it more difficult for us to communicate. I think the idea of posting restrictions is cool (and I have used them in games), but if this was just to suit your taste and wasn't something being implemented by someone's mechanic (seems MoM power most obviously), that's pretty arbitrary.

On July 07 2010 02:40 YellowInk wrote:
This appears to be a pretty strong community that you can just PM someone who is not involved in the game and just ask for advice. I havn't seen Qatol play, but clearly he's interested in the community and has familiarity with the game and maybe is a good resource for such things.

On July 07 2010 05:41 Bill Murray wrote:
after the abenson catastrophe, i was very impressed with radfield and roffles
of course i wanted the town to win, as that's how it happens in the books, and i wanted amber to use the day-expelliarmus he gained to block radfield (which would have ended the game!), but radfield played nearly perfectly, so what can you do


the play this game was by far better than my modding
i vow to take more time to become a better mod
hope you all give me a 2nd chance

On July 07 2010 05:08 Jugan wrote:
It was quite obvious when you take time to think about your actions roffles. And I posted earlier, I wanted the town to lose

also roffles, I never mentioned ANYONE as a death eater.

On July 07 2010 09:02 Radfield wrote:



Don't forget that I also had Jeejee under the imperius curse So he only could have casted what I wanted him to.

I Imperiused him after Jugan got lynched, since I wanted to make sure he investigated YI when he said he was going to. Because if he decided to investigate me or roffles, we would have been in serious trouble.

Gilaboy checks me, great even if he's not naive, because I'm a godfather, so I'll flip green.
Jeejee checks YI, great because it supports my previous claim of checking YI
I Imperius Jeejee to ensure his check, and then claim to have investigated Roffles.

That night worked out amazing. Particularly Thegilaboy switching from roffles to me at the last minute. The only people I could kill(since I figured YI and Amber would be protecting themselves) were Jspazz and Jayme. Jayme was basically confirmed by Jugan's death, so it had to be him.

Thanks a bunch for modding this Bill. I had a ton of fun as Voldemort. I wish I'd been a bit more creative with my spells though. After you told me I could pretty much cast anything I wanted, I was going to start brainstorming random spells to see if you would let me use them. Particularly 'finite incantatum' to wipe away any protective spells on someone, and 'crucio' just cause it would be fun.