Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Mafia - Page 6

On July 01 2010 10:21 johnnyspazz wrote:
lol what opz, if you come up innocent you're more likely to believe i'm innocent? don't you know if youre innocent or not already? also damn i just read 3 pages of jugan being a terrible townie if he is indeed ron.

On June 29 2010 13:50 AcrossFiveJulys wrote:
~OpZ~ has been posting confusingly, and seemed to be in contact with JeeJee through PM (he said he "agreed" with jeejee that lakris should be lynched before jeejee announced that lakris is nagini). This means that he has a role that can PM... besides death eaters, I have no idea who can PM, possibly masons? Maybe opz and jeejee are masons together.

Jayme has been awfully quiet lately. Don't have a specific read on him, but he does seem a bit off.

Radfield... where the hell has he been? I do get a slightly scummy vibe from him, but the fact that he didn't pardon lakris gives him a small amount of credit (though if he is a death eater, he could be waiting until later to pardon a death eater so he doesn't reveal himself).

Roffles has been posting pretty pro town and sensibly, and seems neutral for the most part... perhaps too much so.

My recommendation for rolecheck tonight is radfield. If he does turn out red, we can lynch him before he pardons a death eater. Of course, he could be godfather, but that's always a risk. If he managed to get himself pardoner as the godfather, then he's a better player than I give him credit for.

On June 29 2010 20:33 Radfield wrote:
Likely confirmed townies at this point:
Jeejee
Opz
Thegilaboy

Checked green by thegilaboy(who may be naive however)
Yellowink
Jspazz

Others
Myself
Roffles
Jugan
Jayme
Amber


Presumably Amber and YI will die today, sorting out our current mess. Even if both flipped green(moderately unlikely) it leaves us in a great spot. Mafia with a KP of 1, 3 confirmed townies who possibly all(?) have dt checks available to them, with 5 unknown players. Mafia roleblocker is dead. Either Jeejee or Opz will still have a daykill available to them. There is still a Tree Stump in the game. The survivors and traitors are all likely dead.

Give me a minute to come up with a game plan here, because I think we should be able to wrap this up.

On June 25 2010 04:05 Bill Murray wrote:


you can claim it only if you have to. for example: you are near being lynched, or someone else is claiming your name.

don't worry about the masons

On June 30 2010 04:42 ~OpZ~ wrote:

No

On July 03 2010 02:28 YellowInk wrote:
Similar to you/JeeJee, I know Radfield has some investigative property, but that doesn't confirm him to be town if Thegilaboy is naive or Radfield is godfather. I havn't been impressed with Roffles' play, but the only way Roffles is DE is if Radfield is DE. This may actually be a more likely situation if you and JeeJee role claim and that claim provides some evidence of your being town.

There is also the possibility that JeeJee isn't vouching for you - I don't recall and can't find any place where he defends you directly. Then I could see you and johnnyspazz or you and Thegilaboy being in it together. We do seem to have too many detectives, though an alignment checking DT is weaker in this setup due to only 3 death eaters being detectable by this.

So you can see why I have great interest in you revealing more about yourself. Since you have the ultimate defense, should I vote for you secure that the death eaters can't take you down? Or do you have more that you are now willing to share?

On July 03 2010 02:37 Amber[LighT] wrote:
To be honest I don't know why YI or I are being considered. First off lynching me is suicide and anyone that thinks so is ridiculous. I offered numerous times to be checked in this game. Since you get a clue back even someone who's read one book should be able to pick up on my character.

I think it's really suspicious that we have all of these detectives running about. Two of which are obtaining clues, the other is obtaining roles, and that just doesn't sit right. Want to confirm a list of townies? Take out the Detective that's making claims. No offense to our detectives, but it's been three days and you each have done a number of checks. Let's confirm our detective work. If someone flips red then they are obviously trying to manipulate checks, but it gives us a chance to focus on a list of players left in this game.

My target suggestion? TheGilaBoy

He's the odd-man out and has a "unique" role that needs confirmation. Think about it. If you lynch me what do you gain? Knowing that you now have to face an uphill battle in lynchings and no auto-kill for HWMNBN. Kill TheGilaBoy and you get to know if his checks are real or just his way of sending us off-course.

Also we know YI is a protector. Do you want to risk lynching the last medic in the game?

On July 03 2010 02:37 Amber[LighT] wrote:
To be honest I don't know why YI or I are being considered. First off lynching me is suicide and anyone that thinks so is ridiculous. I offered numerous times to be checked in this game. Since you get a clue back even someone who's read one book should be able to pick up on my character.

I think it's really suspicious that we have all of these detectives running about. Two of which are obtaining clues, the other is obtaining roles, and that just doesn't sit right. Want to confirm a list of townies? Take out the Detective that's making claims. No offense to our detectives, but it's been three days and you each have done a number of checks. Let's confirm our detective work. If someone flips red then they are obviously trying to manipulate checks, but it gives us a chance to focus on a list of players left in this game.

My target suggestion? TheGilaBoy

He's the odd-man out and has a "unique" role that needs confirmation. Think about it. If you lynch me what do you gain? Knowing that you now have to face an uphill battle in lynchings and no auto-kill for HWMNBN. Kill TheGilaBoy and you get to know if his checks are real or just his way of sending us off-course.

Also we know YI is a protector. Do you want to risk lynching the last medic in the game?

On July 03 2010 02:41 ~OpZ~ wrote:

Gilaboy is not DE...I've checked him and he wears cute lil miniature bow ties.

On July 03 2010 02:45 YellowInk wrote:
Amber[Light], what do you think of ~OpZ~'s ultimate defense being horcrux?

On July 03 2010 02:37 Amber[LighT] wrote:
Also we know YI is a protector. Do you want to risk lynching the last medic in the game?

On July 03 2010 03:04 Amber[LighT] wrote:


I wasn't targeted last night. I think that should throw up a few red flags. I'm not sure if BM would intentionally hide the 2nd horcrux within another character. It seems unlikely as the first horcrux was Nagini, unless Opz is a diary or a cup etc...

I just can't sit here and say I completely trust the Opz/JeeJee bandwagon lately as we still haven't been able to lynch a DE since Lakris. I don't want to go out and kill Opz or JeeJee though.... If Opz is in fact a horcrux we should kill him though. If I die then Opz needs to go. You can't kill VM without both horcrux's, but I am able to kill VM without the horcrux being eliminated. I would rather keep us both alive (if he's a horcrux) and try to win with the most town members alive as possible.

Opz should not be a suspect on the same level YI and I should not be suspects.

On July 03 2010 03:09 YellowInk wrote:
Logic fails you. You and JeeJee could be Bellatrix and Peter. Maybe johnnyspazz is HWMNBN. Since BM has refused us up to date numbers. We really don't know if there are 2 or 3 death eaters left.

If the flavor can be trusted, maybe it is as you say. You and JeeJee are HWMNBN and Peter. If you could kill Harry Potter then claim you thought it was HWMNBN, maybe you'd manage to weasel out of being hung because of 'how much you have helped the town with your investigating'. You've all but claimed mason, so if you got investigated by say Thegilaboy and came up clean, that could be enough to take the game. Or, again, Bellatrix could be hidden in our midst to take the game.

There are plenty of explanations for how you and JeeJee could be death eaters. Since you say you have the 'ultimate' defense and continue to refuse to claim, you're getting my vote now. If you really are town I hope you come to your senses before the lynch unlike Jugan.

On July 03 2010 03:36 JeeJee wrote:
oh yeah scrimmy and ginny were presumably checked by gila who's presumably townie
which only leaves 1 de which obviously isn't right
sooo

On July 03 2010 04:00 Radfield wrote:


This doesn't make sense to me Opz. You're claiming that shooting Amber somehow clears you of suspicion, because DEs would never do such a thing. I'd say that DEs with AK powers would be looking for a chance to take out townies when those townies are most suspicious looking, but haven't been given time to defend themselves. Which is kinda what happened. Not to mention that Amber is the juiciest target for the mafia to target. And how would you AKing someone mean BM made you do it? I don't understand what you're saying there.

Also, both you and Jeejee are forgetting the possibility that Thegilaboy is a godfather. If he was the godfather, then he would likely have a fake persona, since he'd need to come back as townie on all role/alignment checks. This fits well with my thought that BM provided a safe list to the DE's(he totally flip-flopped on his whole legal/illegal to name claim thing)

On July 03 2010 04:02 Radfield wrote:
But here's the real problem Opz. You're trying to kill, or just killed(with your spoilered AK), the person who Jeejee supposedly investigated last night. If you and Jeejee are tied at the hip like you say, then presumably he should have let you know his results, which would be the same as I got on Day 2, meaning YI is Neville Longbottom. Of all the people in this game, he would basically be our most confirmed townie, given that he's been role checked three times! And you just killed him? Either that or you're bullshitting up the thread with fake Avada Kadavras, which is super disruptive.

On July 03 2010 04:02 Radfield wrote:
But here's the real problem Opz. You're trying to kill, or just killed(with your spoilered AK), the person who Jeejee supposedly investigated last night. If you and Jeejee are tied at the hip like you say, then presumably he should have let you know his results, which would be the same as I got on Day 2, meaning YI is Neville Longbottom. Of all the people in this game, he would basically be our most confirmed townie, given that he's been role checked three times! And you just killed him? Either that or you're bullshitting up the thread with fake Avada Kadavras, which is super disruptive.