|
On May 30 2010 11:37 Korynne wrote:
DarthThienAn - Posted
Amber[LighT] - Hasn't posted yet after game started
tree.hugger - Has posted elsewhere after Ace PM'd
johnnyspazz - Has not posted yet after game started
L - Has not posted yet after game started
Iaaan - Posted
Radfield - Posted
BrownBear - Posted
Nikon - Has not posted yet after game started
Vivi57 - Has posted elsewhere after Ace PM'd
citi.zen - Has not posted yet after game started
~OpZ~ - Has not posted yet after game started
motbob - Has posted elsewhere after Ace PM'd
Korynne - Posted (lol forgot to put that there the first time xD)
LunarDestiny - Posted
ohN - Hasn't posted yet after game started
LuDwig- - Posted
TwoToneTerran - Posted
Xelin - Posted
Chezinu - Didn't post here to join, so must've PM'd Ace or something? No posts.
Should be correct I think... >.<;;
Is there an easier way to check when someone's last post was? xD I went through their posts and had to check all the threads that had new posts on May 30th.
i was banned until last night so I wouldn't be able to post until at least this morning... which I did.
|
Oh no worries. I'm just starting a list. Like I said I'll make a new one when day starts. It's not like everyone has no life like me and can be on mafia all the time even if they weren't banned. =P
|
L if we could PM then this game would be exceptionally simple.
Watcher claims, everyone PM's roles to him and we go from there. But we can't PM, or at least you only can if it is specified in your role.
|
L this game has no PM .___.
if we have to shoot my vote goes to Korynne
Reason: He is trying too hard to write everything..in my opinion he wants to appear as " a real motiveted town guy"..i don't believe this type of behaviour..however we have 24 hour to decide XD
|
LuDwig-, be specific.
Vote on who to be shot and who to do the shooting.
(Don't have to do both at the same time, but specify what you mean)
|
That's a she. And I'm always this active. You should be focusing on people who aren't contributing at all or saying stupid shit like L like omg guys let's all PM me rather than me, who is actually contributing to town. -.-
(If you have a valid reason for suspecting me then let's hear it).
Also no edits.
|
Ok in this game you can't have a real good reason to suspect someone (or at least at 99% this game is a "guess game").
I only find sospicious the way you act..in my opinion the mafia guys will try to take the center of the scene making us taking them as our leader(so they can kill us without problem).
I am not saying "go lynch korynne" i am only saying "hey guys..look at korynne..she looks sospicious to me"
|
Whew! Just now getting home from a wild night. Going to sort out night actions and put up the day post soon. Sorry for the delay ^_^
Also all roles were assigned randomly fyi.
|
Mafia doesn't want to take the center of attention... and I'm not even saying like hey guys you should let me shoot or hey guys you should listen to what I say. All I've been suggesting is generic things that doesn't apply to me. L should be way more suspicious of trying to use town like hogging medic protection or saying he'll do the shooting.
The general rule of thumb is that mafia tries to blend in and lurk, not that they jump into the center of attention at the first opportunity. In fact most of the time people are considered town when they are not afraid of jumping into the spotlight and stuff.
I'm not saying you should just think me and L are not mafia for "jumping into the spotlight," I'm just saying that's usually not a reason people are suspected of being mafia. Half the reason people go for the lynch a lurker/inactive the first day is because mafia are more likely to want to hide and not be in the spotlight. The more I post the more likely it is for me to slip up or for someone to build a case against me if I am mafia.
Also the problem with jumping into the spotlight this game is that the only way L can do that is to be the godfather, which would be kinda dumb in my opinion because it would make him quite likely to be under suspicion and get himself killed. I hope no one claimed to L through PM because #1 it's not allowed and #2 then if he's godfather he now could possibly know blue roles or at least eliminate some choices if he's looking to pick off blues.
If you think 99% of this game is just a guessing game then IMO you shouldn't be playing mafia. I mean seriously, who wants to be in a game where everyone flips a bunch of coins and rolls a bunch of dice to determine the outcome?
|
This is my 2nd mafia game, but I think luck is a huge factor in mafia. It is hard to judge people with almost no information. Lets hope the result of night 1 gives us something to work with.
|
I don't like the idea of privately claiming to L. He could be the GF, he could be mafia (although would be retarded), and we don't know anything yet.
I would vote to kill motbob (he hasn't said nothing I've noticed yet). To early for the cop to public claim, so dunno. Anyway, lets see how night one ends, yes?
|
Luck is a huge factor in terms of like, oh look Zona the mafia got modkilled, or like, first day lynch. But if you're going to think that mafia is just 99% luck then I see no point in playing. Also how much luck a game is also depends on the setup of the game.
OpZ, read what people said, no claiming to L, PMs are not allowed in this game unless your role says so. (I'm not disagreeing with you, I wouldn't claim to L if it was allowed, I'm just saying it's not something we need to have a discussion about)
I don't think any blue roles should claim unless they deem it useful to the town (i.e. they found a mafia or they're about to get shot).
|
Ok guys, I'm extending night to 12AM tonight. Everyone that could act hasn't sent me in abilities plus there was some confusion that I wasn't around to clear up. Night 0 ends 11 hours from now. Good luck!
|
On May 31 2010 01:48 Korynne wrote:
Mafia doesn't want to take the center of attention... and I'm not even saying like hey guys you should let me shoot or hey guys you should listen to what I say. All I've been suggesting is generic things that doesn't apply to me. L should be way more suspicious of trying to use town like hogging medic protection or saying he'll do the shooting.
The general rule of thumb is that mafia tries to blend in and lurk, not that they jump into the center of attention at the first opportunity. In fact most of the time people are considered town when they are not afraid of jumping into the spotlight and stuff.
I'm not saying you should just think me and L are not mafia for "jumping into the spotlight," I'm just saying that's usually not a reason people are suspected of being mafia. Half the reason people go for the lynch a lurker/inactive the first day is because mafia are more likely to want to hide and not be in the spotlight. The more I post the more likely it is for me to slip up or for someone to build a case against me if I am mafia.
Also the problem with jumping into the spotlight this game is that the only way L can do that is to be the godfather, which would be kinda dumb in my opinion because it would make him quite likely to be under suspicion and get himself killed. I hope no one claimed to L through PM because #1 it's not allowed and #2 then if he's godfather he now could possibly know blue roles or at least eliminate some choices if he's looking to pick off blues.
If you think 99% of this game is just a guessing game then IMO you shouldn't be playing mafia. I mean seriously, who wants to be in a game where everyone flips a bunch of coins and rolls a bunch of dice to determine the outcome?
From 3 pages we are saying that our best plan is to shoot to inactive player..do you really think that mafia will lurk now?
|
On May 31 2010 02:17 LuDwig- wrote:Show nested quote +On May 31 2010 01:48 Korynne wrote:
Mafia doesn't want to take the center of attention... and I'm not even saying like hey guys you should let me shoot or hey guys you should listen to what I say. All I've been suggesting is generic things that doesn't apply to me. L should be way more suspicious of trying to use town like hogging medic protection or saying he'll do the shooting.
The general rule of thumb is that mafia tries to blend in and lurk, not that they jump into the center of attention at the first opportunity. In fact most of the time people are considered town when they are not afraid of jumping into the spotlight and stuff.
I'm not saying you should just think me and L are not mafia for "jumping into the spotlight," I'm just saying that's usually not a reason people are suspected of being mafia. Half the reason people go for the lynch a lurker/inactive the first day is because mafia are more likely to want to hide and not be in the spotlight. The more I post the more likely it is for me to slip up or for someone to build a case against me if I am mafia.
Also the problem with jumping into the spotlight this game is that the only way L can do that is to be the godfather, which would be kinda dumb in my opinion because it would make him quite likely to be under suspicion and get himself killed. I hope no one claimed to L through PM because #1 it's not allowed and #2 then if he's godfather he now could possibly know blue roles or at least eliminate some choices if he's looking to pick off blues.
If you think 99% of this game is just a guessing game then IMO you shouldn't be playing mafia. I mean seriously, who wants to be in a game where everyone flips a bunch of coins and rolls a bunch of dice to determine the outcome? From 3 pages we are saying that our best plan is to shoot to inactive player..do you really think that mafia will lurk now?
Shooting an "inactive player" is pretty standard on TL. Forces activity in most games by letting people who don't post know they will be the first ones killed. Also, mafia usually try and hide by not posting.
We also don't want to send an inactive to do the job of killing someone. He'd be pretty useless at killing.
|
What I'm really worried about right now is that L could have gotten information from a couple people because they didn't realize PMs are not allowed and just did what L said because I have no idea why people just decide to listen to L.
I personally don't think he's all that good, I'm more of a Radfield fan, cuz he actually catches mafia legit and makes sense, and doesn't have the stupid I'm better than you vibe. Same with Ace, I'm reading the red army mafia thing right now and I'm definitely siding with Ace right now reading through it (don't know if Ace or L is mafia or whatever yet still on day 1 in the reading).
|
LuDwig-, this stuff is pretty standard (check out previous games here, or other mafia forums). Lurking gives town less information, so we want people to post, so by threatening to kill inactives/lurkers, we want to force people to post more. It's all about incentives, we want as much information as possible, and we want people to post so we get more information.
|
On May 31 2010 02:21 Korynne wrote:
What I'm really worried about right now is that L could have gotten information from a couple people because they didn't realize PMs are not allowed and just did what L said because I have no idea why people just decide to listen to L.
I personally don't think he's all that good, I'm more of a Radfield fan, cuz he actually catches mafia legit and makes sense, and doesn't have the stupid I'm better than you vibe. Same with Ace, I'm reading the red army mafia thing right now and I'm definitely siding with Ace right now reading through it (don't know if Ace or L is mafia or whatever yet still on day 1 in the reading).
Not in the game
lol Ace had his fair share of elitism in the past.
|
What do you mean had? 
|
xD iunno I'm not into L's style, or Foolishness, or OpZ, but that's just me and I'm not going to suspect any of them due to that.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
