|
On October 26 2009 12:13 Qatol wrote:Show nested quote +On October 26 2009 12:09 Ace wrote:
meh, you can go ahead and modkill me then. If people are going to complain about the way some random men/women on the internet are talking to them rather than read the posts I'd rather not be part of this. There is a difference between arguing for your plans/point of view and flaming the crap out of anyone who posts in the thread. I don't see why you can't make the same arguments without saying stuff like: "Every game I've got a fanclub of guys trying to ride my 9inch and Amber returned just for it this game. Gotta love it." Are you saying that you can't post civilly at all and need us to modkill you because you are incapable of showing a little common sense when posting? I mean, it isn't like you would get away with the kind of stuff you are saying anywhere else on the site. Why can't you use the same kind of restraint you use there when posting in the mafia game?
For the record I didn't complain 
|
On October 26 2009 16:12 Tricode wrote:Show nested quote +On October 26 2009 09:08 Amber[LighT] wrote:
You're coming up with this elaborate scheme that by day 3 might show us what path we need to take, yet you can't even come up with a lynch candidate for today. You seem pretty apathetic towards what we need to do tonight, as though the town can deal with the loss of one of us retards. You want to lynch me, ROL, Shikyo, Pyrr, L... but only because we disagree with you.
I don't recall Ace saying he wanted to really lynch you guys. But my memory is fuzzy on it...maybe ROL but i don't recall to much of Ace actually suggesting or saying we should lynch any of you. Only some suspicion or giving his opinion about your abilities.
He hasn't proposed a very strong lynch candidate tonight.
|
On October 27 2009 02:02 Tricode wrote:Show nested quote +On October 26 2009 22:25 Amber[LighT] wrote:On October 26 2009 16:12 Tricode wrote:On October 26 2009 09:08 Amber[LighT] wrote:
You're coming up with this elaborate scheme that by day 3 might show us what path we need to take, yet you can't even come up with a lynch candidate for today. You seem pretty apathetic towards what we need to do tonight, as though the town can deal with the loss of one of us retards. You want to lynch me, ROL, Shikyo, Pyrr, L... but only because we disagree with you.
I don't recall Ace saying he wanted to really lynch you guys. But my memory is fuzzy on it...maybe ROL but i don't recall to much of Ace actually suggesting or saying we should lynch any of you. Only some suspicion or giving his opinion about your abilities. He hasn't proposed a very strong lynch candidate tonight. That has nothing to do with what you said or claimed.
explain?
|
On October 27 2009 02:24 Tricode wrote:Show nested quote +On October 27 2009 02:08 Amber[LighT] wrote:On October 27 2009 02:02 Tricode wrote:On October 26 2009 22:25 Amber[LighT] wrote:On October 26 2009 16:12 Tricode wrote:On October 26 2009 09:08 Amber[LighT] wrote:
You're coming up with this elaborate scheme that by day 3 might show us what path we need to take, yet you can't even come up with a lynch candidate for today. You seem pretty apathetic towards what we need to do tonight, as though the town can deal with the loss of one of us retards. You want to lynch me, ROL, Shikyo, Pyrr, L... but only because we disagree with you.
I don't recall Ace saying he wanted to really lynch you guys. But my memory is fuzzy on it...maybe ROL but i don't recall to much of Ace actually suggesting or saying we should lynch any of you. Only some suspicion or giving his opinion about your abilities. He hasn't proposed a very strong lynch candidate tonight. That has nothing to do with what you said or claimed. explain? You said he wants to lynch ROL, Shikyo, Pyrr, L, but I pointed out that isn't true. Then you quote what i said. Why bother even quoting me calling you out on you making up stuff that Ace never said. Then except ignore it by saying he "never proposed a lynch candidate". What does that have to do with your previous statement about him wanting him to have you guys lynched? Nothing.
If you were ace on the previous page, who would you like the see lynched. It's obvious he wants to see all of us dead before he gets lynched.
|
On October 27 2009 08:09 Ace wrote:
and I find it funny Shikyo is so stupid to think I'd fake Dt, so we can lynch Judge who could be mafia so I could "trick the town". Yes, I'd kill 1 of only 4 people on my team for that. Brilliant Shikyo. Epic really.
Ace your plan is very elaborate on the mafia side. Trust me what you did was ingenious, thats all I need to say.
I will say this to the people abstaining:
If I die because of apathy because mafia sways votes over Ace... well seriously fuck you all for not listening sooner.
|
On October 27 2009 13:59 BloodyC0bbler wrote:Show nested quote +On October 27 2009 13:57 L wrote:On October 27 2009 12:56 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
with this last lynch, we are in a pinch
three analysists down, and with a noose we dropped a crown
with only a few analysists who still remain, the town will lean on them like a cane
With the mafia most likely in those few, we might as well bow our heads in a pew May I suggest you stop posting like this is some kindergarten rhyme time and do some of the aforementioned analysis then? You aren't a second rate player, why are you on the sidelines? because my specialty was removed from the game, so instead im opting to be lame I however have given insight, in how to win this fight yes its all in rhyme, but its not like being annoyings a crime
Oh man Ver/Qatol forgot the town idiot role what are we supposed to do now that BloodC0bbler can't play as his favorite role and has to be a boring townie.
womp womp wommmmmmmmmmmp
|
On October 28 2009 09:38 SugiuraMidori wrote:So for anyone, like L, that doesn't know why I place up those lists of colored folk is for the benefit of the entire town. Yes it can give away things to the mafia as well, but we can always remember that I'm not going to be 100% on the list (unless I get red again). The list is formed from my reading of how people talk in their posts, and how grammar is being used (hence the rhyme posts were a waste of time to analyze, same for flaming). What I try to do is gather a reasonable hint on who the town needs to lynch, not that, as we've clearly noticed, anyone follows me since I'm not some fancy "Vet" player. Following the clues as best I can I also make an effort to group people by how they act with each other as well, which I could have used the flaming posts to read, but that was lamesauce anyhow. That is why I can easily group a lot of the folk as either green or blue, and what I feel like are reds (as well as what others are saying if my analysis is incomplete). If you do notice my first one, I listed Foolish as non-red and Caller as red... so I made a mistake there, but at least I wasn't fool enough to lynch Ace when I could tell he wasn't lying his butt off to fake y'all out (as if he was red). However, those that voted for Ace are suspect in two ways, they knew what I knew (that Ace was truthful and was a DT and are red and wanted him gone) or they were bigots ... I'd say there were some that didn't want to read his shit anymore, but I didn't vote for him, so that's not as valid. ;P
To be honest that was probably the towns error and the mafia sat back and watched everything happen. That's exactly what we did in mafia VII when it was Ace/Ver vs. neMy and the moron-parade.
|
VII or VIII I forgot I'm thinking it was VIII sorry bout that ;O
|
incognito always dies silently 
NICE work DreamFlower. I already suspected the judge to be mafia but thanks for throwing a bomb on him and idk how you figured out Ace's sanity... if it was all luck thats cool too
|
On October 28 2009 18:10 Scamp wrote:
I have a question for Amber[Light]. What is your opinion of Motbob, Judge, Myself, and Pyrr?
If you looked back a few pages you could tell that I originally thought Judge and Motbob were mafia because they were working with Ace (whom I suspected). When Ace died I was unsure how to take his rolecheck for Judge and in my eyes it was highly probable that he was not actually a paramedic, but I honestly thought he was a townie.
Motbob is still suspicious to me, only because his inactivity did bother me a bit. I understand his grandfather died, but there's still something that's bothering me. Either he's a blue who Qatol needed a night action from or he was a red who had a really good excuse not to post. I really wish we knew more information about him and why Ace saved him. If anyone actually knew why he pardoned him please tell us.
Up until last night I would have said Pyrr is not mafia. I trust him a lot this game so I am not sure if I believe he's not mafia because of my insane amount of trust in him, or because he's been taking proper steps to help the town. Honestly the confirmation kill would have been to lynch Motbob to figure this out. They both can't be mafia if Pyrr wanted to lynch him on Day 1. It also seems unlikely that Pyrr wanted to lynch motbob and then told Ace to pardon him because they didn't seem to work together at all.
Scamp I can't gauge whether you're a townie or mafia. Everyone in this game is connected to another player depending on who they accuse, who they vote for, and how they post. It's not good if you have so few posts that are neutral. It doesn't give us any reading on you.
I voted for Vivi57 for the lynch simply because I'm going to allow someone else make the call today. I'll admit I fucked up pushing for Ace yesterday, but I took a path that the town had taken in the past with RCing Detectives.
|
I think the recent votes for L is pretty laughable. I think people tried to bandwagon thinking Qatol meant 10 KST this morning 
|
On October 29 2009 23:46 Scamp wrote:Show nested quote +On October 29 2009 23:21 Amber[LighT] wrote:I think the recent votes for L is pretty laughable. I think people tried to bandwagon thinking Qatol meant 10 KST this morning Out of respect of the organizers who have asked us to refrain from personal attacks, I will only say that this thought is exceptionally retarded. Also Ace thought you were mafia and Ace is never wrong.
With that logic L and I must be mafia.
|
And I must be retarded since the three of you decided it would be a good idea to go ahead and vote for L despite the lack of discussion. Last night when I went to sleep the vote seemed to be Vivi vs. Chez vs. Redtooth and now you want to throw in L too? One day at a time bro we'll get to everyone on the list don't worry.
|
On October 30 2009 00:07 Scamp wrote:Show nested quote +On October 29 2009 23:50 Amber[LighT] wrote:
And I must be retarded since the three of you decided it would be a good idea to go ahead and vote for L despite the lack of discussion. Last night when I went to sleep the vote seemed to be Vivi vs. Chez vs. Redtooth and now you want to throw in L too? One day at a time bro we'll get to everyone on the list don't worry. Hey I didn't call you retarded. Just the thought of a bandwagon of not enough people before a mistaken deadline even though that's been constant throughout the whole game. I don't know what you're trying to pull here but I posted up my reasoning quite clearly. Please point me to the excellent discussion on Vivi that prompted you to vote for him. Show nested quote +On October 28 2009 23:04 Amber[LighT] wrote:
I voted for Vivi57 for the lynch simply because I'm going to allow someone else make the call today. I'll admit I fucked up pushing for Ace yesterday, but I took a path that the town had taken in the past with RCing Detectives.
And that someone is, apparently, SugiuraMidori. So why does SugiuraMidori get to make the call for you?
Up until today she's put more effort into this game than you did. All of a sudden you want to analyze the town and actually take part in discussion. Voting for Vivi is more than just "I'm following sugiura," but when you think about it, let's take out of the people that aren't doing much to contribute. These people are worse than inactives, and sometimes mafia will have about 50% of their team play the inactive role so they stay under the radar. This is such a typical case especially when the mayor and pardoner are not red (which I believe is the case in this game).
I'm not saying because you didn't post in the past two day cycles that you're opinion is worthless to me, but let's try to take to take a logical approach and separate the town into groups..... ugh i was talking to my boss about something and completely lost my train of thought with this. Let me get back to this when it pops in my head again
|
On October 30 2009 00:53 Scamp wrote:Show nested quote +On October 30 2009 00:22 Amber[LighT] wrote:Up until today she's put more effort into this game than you did. All of a sudden you want to analyze the town and actually take part in discussion. Voting for Vivi is more than just "I'm following sugiura," but when you think about it, let's take out of the people that aren't doing much to contribute. These people are worse than inactives, and sometimes mafia will have about 50% of their team play the inactive role so they stay under the radar. This is such a typical case especially when the mayor and pardoner are not red (which I believe is the case in this game). I'm not saying because you didn't post in the past two day cycles that you're opinion is worthless to me, but let's try to take to take a logical approach and separate the town into groups..... ugh i was talking to my boss about something and completely lost my train of thought with this. Let me get back to this when it pops in my head again I like how effort = posting. You know who really put the most effort into this game? Ace. What happened to Ace? Oh right, he's dead. And you had a hand in that. And why are you comparing me to her? And why haven't you pointed me to the discussion that got you to vote for Vivi? But please, do try to separate the town into groups. I'd like to hear what you come up with.
Ace made the mistake that he himself scrutinizes other players for in other mafia games all the time.
His effort was counter-productive to the town. Did you read what he was posting? How useful was it to the town for him to insult all of us for not agreeing with his plan?
I'm comparing you to her because you two should be compared. Why can't I do that?
|
On October 30 2009 01:36 Scamp wrote:Show nested quote +On October 30 2009 01:26 Amber[LighT] wrote:
Ace made the mistake that he himself scrutinizes other players for in other mafia games all the time.
His effort was counter-productive to the town. Did you read what he was posting? How useful was it to the town for him to insult all of us for not agreeing with his plan?
I'm comparing you to her because you two should be compared. Why can't I do that? I read what Ace was posting. It wasn't counter-productive to the town. It was just alienating and annoying. But it certainly had it's uses. I said you can't compare us because I asked you why she got to call the shots for your vote. You voted long before I started talking. I guess you can compare us if you really want to, it just isn't viable for what I asked and merely serves as a distraction. I'd still like you to organize us into groups. I'd also like you to explain what information we got from Ace's lynch.
After the night post came out I wasn't exactly thinking "Hey I wonder what Scamp would do in this situation" because I didn't care. You didn't give me a reason to care up until maybe a page ago.
|
nice i was gonna switch my vote too I see I can't tell time in KST ^^
|
yah this should be a win at this point. I assume something big is going on behind the scenes and I hope whoevers orchestrating the actions of the town has the most information (though I trust the people who have led us to victory so far.
2x lynch is a-ok with me. I was going to suggest it today for tomorrow, but I felt that maybe we should see if we actually can lower the KP of the mafia before making such a tough choice.
|
btw I'm going to be semi-inactive from the game until Sunday. At my moms and I only have my work laptop and going to the parade in the city tomorrow
(if anyone here is going lemme know we can meet up and plan kills and drink to them )
EDIT: BTW if I get pictures I will show the ironic costume I have for Halloween, just thought of the connection now putting it on 
|
I think it should be Scamp and HeavenOnEarth. We all know that we need to be active to understand everybody in this game and in my opinion being quiet puts you in the hot seat. I've said this before and I'll say it again being inactive in this game especially is bad.
I'm on the fence about Scamp I just feel like he was providing mis-information, and once night hit he was nowhere to be found. (two days ago) He made one post and was gone again. I don't think this is the best reason to vote for someone to lynch but of the candidates to get lynched he is definitely part of my top 2.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
