|
NOTE: When providing a source, please provide a very brief summary on what it's about and what purpose it adds to the discussion. The supporting statement should clearly explain why the subject is relevant and needs to be discussed. Please follow this rule especially for tweets.
Your supporting statement should always come BEFORE you provide the source. |
On April 09 2022 00:51 warrior4093 wrote:Show nested quote +On April 09 2022 00:19 Mohdoo wrote:On April 08 2022 23:57 Gorsameth wrote:On April 08 2022 23:14 Biff The Understudy wrote: Looks like both sides are quite liberally executing prisonners and that on top of well documented russian war crimes, there are quite solid proofs that ukrainian soldiers have also murdered prisonners.
I guess it’s unsurprising, considering. Its wrong and soldiers shouldn't be doing it but it doesn't take much imagination to understand why Ukrainians might not be to kind when they capture Russian soldiers who have been shelling their women and children. We like to make up rules and pretend to make war more 'civilised' but if war came to our homes, we'd act the same. My ethics has an easy time allowing the people being invaded to do whatever they damn please with people they capture. Fundamentally none of this would be happening if Russian soldiers didn't make a conscious decision to step into sovereign territory and begin killing people. if you want to turn into a monster that your enemy is , then sure thats a great way, i will remind you that despite 500k murders and nearly 200k rapes in Bangladesh (happened over a few months) , the surrendered 93000 soldiers of Pakistani military were safely returned to their home in 1971 , Bangladeshis chose not to abandon their humanity , they did not want to satisfy their enemy by turning in to the same monsters they were fighting . being human in face of adversity and brutality is what makes us a better persona , a better human . once you commit murder and execution , the blood lust twists your mind and warps your sense of morality, there is a reason so many soldiers suffers from PTSD .
I'm not saying it is great and peachy to execute people. I am saying I am not going to get mad at someone for executing an invading army.
|
Russian Federation20 Posts
>>I find "but the Russians will use it for propaganda" kind of pointless when Russia has no problem lying and fabricating their own 'evidence' if they feel the need.
No, you underestimate them. All this insane shit is because russian secret services are extremely good at manipulating public views - and sometimmes they would kill hundreds of their own people just to frame their enemy. It is increadibly difficult to argue with people who say something like "so do you approve that Ukrainian nationalist killed our people in Odessa?" At the same time many of propaganda things are laughing stock here, like an interview with a Ukrainian fugitive who told that "our nazis crucified a 6-year old boy at a center square of Slavyansk"
|
Might be laughable, but it's proven to be highly effective. Most russians are already pro putin, and they aren't changing their mind as sanctions hit.
|
Besides the question of it being 'understandable' or not, these war crimes by the Ukranian forces are big strategic mistakes. Ukraine's effort depends on Western support. That support is sensitive to these questions. I'm sure that Ukrainian leadership understands this.
|
|
Russian Federation20 Posts
Putin's support was well below 30-40% before the war - and this is one of its main reasons btw. Now it is completely unclear what the real social opinion is; thousands of kremlin bots in every social media imitate a common viewpoint. I'd cautiosly say that around 60-70% in Moscow and St-Petersburg are against the war, and perhaps similar share is pro-war in small towns \ countryside
>>Considering the FSB will show up at your door if you post the wrong thing online and they were even arresting people for holding blank signs many of the anti Putin crowd are not saying it.
all true; I encountered with it, just for stating my position considering going to demonstrations in Telegram chat
|
On April 09 2022 02:43 warding wrote: Besides the question of it being 'understandable' or not, these war crimes by the Ukranian forces are big strategic mistakes. Ukraine's effort depends on Western support. That support is sensitive to these questions. I'm sure that Ukrainian leadership understands this.
I don't think that support is that sensitive. It should be fine as long as Ukrainians won't do anything crazy to civilians, like the stuff the Chechen separatists did before Russians wiped them out.
I guess I can imagine some countries dropping their support for Ukraine to resume trading with Russia while pretending it's because they don't want to support war criminals.
|
On April 09 2022 02:43 warding wrote: Besides the question of it being 'understandable' or not, these war crimes by the Ukranian forces are big strategic mistakes. Ukraine's effort depends on Western support. That support is sensitive to these questions. I'm sure that Ukrainian leadership understands this.
When that helicopter attacked a depot in russian territory, russians blamed ukraine, ukraine said it was not them, and it made me think that maybe the ukranian goverment might not be fully in control of their army. If you add the fact that volunteers joining the fight might not have the noblest of motivations (like protecting ukraine), it will be even harder to control these war crimes. One of the videos with supposed executions I saw had volunteers from Georgia. If those guys are there just to get revenge against Russia… urgh
I just hope it doesn’t get out of hand, with the west abandoning ukraine for these things.
|
|
|
My brain tells me she has a chance my guts tell me she doesn’t.
Le Pen is despised by a ton of people. The problem is that so is Macron and that french people are super vulnerable to populism because everyone here has an intellectual superiority complex and is certain he knows better than all those consensual sheeps.
I know many people who won’t vote in a Macron Le Pen second round. They should reaaaaally know better but we also like being rebels because don’t we look cool being all cynical and all.
I still don’t believe she can win. That would be a Trump magnitude disaster.
|
This huge news, not just soviet style heavy weaponry but NATO standard equipment.
Nato member states have agreed to supply new types of advanced weaponry to Ukraine, alliance representatives said, as Kyiv prepares for an offensive by Russia in the country’s east.
The pledge came after a plea from Ukraine’s foreign minister for western countries to move faster with supplies or risk seeing “many people die . . . because this help came too late”.
Six weeks since Vladimir Putin, Russia’s president, ordered the invasion of Ukraine, Moscow’s troops have largely withdrawn from territory north of Kyiv after failing to seize the capital but are regrouping and rearming ahead of an attempt to advance in the eastern Donbas region, Ukrainian and western officials said.
That has sparked demands from Kyiv for western countries to supply more heavy weapons, armour and more advanced systems. Ukraine’s foreign minister Dmytro Kuleba said he would use a Nato meeting in Brussels to ask for aircraft, missiles, armoured vehicles and heavy air defence systems, among others.
Liz Truss, UK foreign secretary, told reporters after the meeting that member states had backed giving more weapons.
“There was support for countries to supply new and heavier equipment to Ukraine, so that they can respond to these new threats from Russia,” she said. “And we agreed to help Ukrainian forces move from their Soviet-era equipment to Nato standard equipment, on a bilateral basis.”
Antony Blinken, US secretary of state, said Washington was looking at sending “new systems” to Ukraine.
“We are not going to let anything stand in the way of getting Ukrainians what they need,” he said. “We are looking across the board right now, not only at what we have provided . . . [but] whether there are additional systems that would make a difference.”
The promise of more military aid came as Dmitry Peskov, Putin’s spokesperson, admitted Russia had suffered “significant losses of troops” during its invasion of Ukraine, which he described as “a huge tragedy for us”.
Peskov said Russia had withdrawn from Kyiv and Chernihiv in central Ukraine last week as a “goodwill act to lift tension from those regions and show Russia is really ready to create comfortable conditions to continue negotiations”. But fighting would continue in the Donbas, he added.
Following the killing of hundreds of civilians in Bucha and other Kyiv suburbs, Volodymyr Zelensky, Ukraine’s president, warned that elsewhere in the country Russia would seek to portray people killed by its forces as victims of Ukrainian troops.
“To do this, the occupiers collect corpses on the streets, take them out and can use them elsewhere in accordance with the elaborated propaganda scenarios,” he said in a video address late on Thursday.
Nato member countries have supplied Ukraine with anti-tank missiles, drones and other defensive weaponry before and during the war. However, they have declined to supply other classes of weapons or impose a no-fly zone, as Kyiv has demanded, over the risk of engaging Russia in a wider war.
Kuleba said afterwards he was “cautiously optimistic” that alliance states would meet his demand but warned that delays would result in more deaths.
“Either you help us now, and I am speaking about days . . . or your help will come too late,” Kuleba said. “Many people will die . . . exactly because this help came too late.”
He added: “I was very specific about the requests and the timeline that they should be accommodated. I will be looking forward to the follow-up from allies.”
Ukraine has warned that Russia was preparing a renewed offensive in the Donbas aimed at seizing territory in the two administrative regions of Luhansk and Donetsk, which separatists have partially occupied since a Moscow-backed uprising in 2014.
Ukraine’s military authorities on Wednesday called on residents living in the regions to leave “while they still had the chance”.
Jens Stoltenberg, Nato’s secretary-general, said allies had agreed to “further strengthen” support for Ukraine immediately and in the “medium and long term”.
“It was a clear message from the meeting today that allies should do more and are ready to do more to supply more equipment. They realise and recognise the urgency,” he said.
Meanwhile, the UN General Assembly on Thursday voted to suspend Russia from the Geneva-based Human Rights Council, an international rebuke to Moscow over the invasion of Ukraine and alleged atrocities.
Ninety-three UN members approved Russia’s suspension — the first imposed on any permanent member of the UN Security Council.
However, 24 UN members, including China, Iran, Bolivia and Kazakhstan, voted against Russia’s suspension. Another 58 countries abstained, including India, Indonesia and Egypt, showing that a wide range of nations have sided with Moscow or sought to remain neutral in the conflict.
Source
|
On April 09 2022 02:16 Mirelle wrote: >>I find "but the Russians will use it for propaganda" kind of pointless when Russia has no problem lying and fabricating their own 'evidence' if they feel the need.
No, you underestimate them. All this insane shit is because russian secret services are extremely good at manipulating public views - and sometimmes they would kill hundreds of their own people just to frame their enemy. It is increadibly difficult to argue with people who say something like "so do you approve that Ukrainian nationalist killed our people in Odessa?" At the same time many of propaganda things are laughing stock here, like an interview with a Ukrainian fugitive who told that "our nazis crucified a 6-year old boy at a center square of Slavyansk"
Can confirm, russian special services historically had no problems killing own citizens, blowing them in masses in residential houses, many poisonings and killings of journalists + opposition leaders, hiding atrocities in Beslan/Nord-Ost for the sake of dehumanization and enforcement of the new laws in order to get more control over the population. As a result they control the whole state media by now, this process started in early 2000 by taking control over NTV (НТВ). It ended basically now as there are no alternative massmedia left in the whole country, everything was either censored or shut down. What's left is 50 shades of propaganda.
Although, I should point out that the narrative is targeted on the elder demographics mostly, alongside lower class citizens, those ones who got no access to alternative media and/or poorly educated with lower quality of life.
Also, it appears that younger generations (in city areas especially) and middle class in Russia are much more resistant to propaganda, as they are having this important critical thinking aspect involved, plus an access to the social media which is also a key. They are the future of Russia.
Feels bad for Macron at this point, he was trying to be the saviour and negotiator so many times until realised it was pointless and a waste of time at best ;(
P.S. To all my TL fellas: I haven't posted in a while, sorry for that, still have hard time accepting this reality to some degree. Overall my family and me are safe physically atm while my parents/relatives/friends in Kharkiv are also safe for now, and I hope their luck is limitless. The city is constantly shelled, it happens everyday, mostly the outskirts, but sometimes even the center is targeted. Mentally it's a bit hard to stay collected, that is a big challenge, but oddly enough i'm still trying to be somewhat optimistic, trying to do a daily routine, doing my job, working out and planning for the future.
With some of TLers i'm keeping in touch via Telegram, but will also try to post regularly in the topic as well!
|
On April 09 2022 02:43 warding wrote: Besides the question of it being 'understandable' or not, these war crimes by the Ukranian forces are big strategic mistakes. Ukraine's effort depends on Western support. That support is sensitive to these questions. I'm sure that Ukrainian leadership understands this. I don't know how sensitive Western support is but this has been a known issue for years (Azov and Aidar battalions being some of the better known examples). There was hardly a peep when the Ukrainian National Guard tweeted out a neo nazi Azov soldier smearing pig fat on bullets meant for Muslim fighters or when the Ukrainian newscaster was quoting Adolf Eichmann.
|
On April 09 2022 04:18 GreenHorizons wrote:Show nested quote +On April 09 2022 02:43 warding wrote: Besides the question of it being 'understandable' or not, these war crimes by the Ukranian forces are big strategic mistakes. Ukraine's effort depends on Western support. That support is sensitive to these questions. I'm sure that Ukrainian leadership understands this. I don't know how sensitive Western support is but this has been a known issue for years (Azov and Aidar battalions being some of the better known examples). There was hardly a peep when the Ukrainian National Guard tweeted out a neo nazi Azov soldier smearing pig fat on bullets meant for Muslim fighters or when the Ukrainian newscaster was quoting Adolf Eichmann.
Known issue for years? This was not an issue before 2014 at all, and we may guess why. You are clearly overestimating the whole impact and most importantly confusing "neo nazis" with "ethno nationalists".
Politically speaking all 3 nationaliastic parties had ~2% support combined during the last parliament elections. We are no saints, but stop trying to sell it's a serious issue in Ukraine, it's clearly not.
|
Don't mind him. It's his usual shtick.
|
On April 09 2022 02:16 Mirelle wrote: >>I find "but the Russians will use it for propaganda" kind of pointless when Russia has no problem lying and fabricating their own 'evidence' if they feel the need.
No, you underestimate them. All this insane shit is because russian secret services are extremely good at manipulating public views - and sometimmes they would kill hundreds of their own people just to frame their enemy. It is increadibly difficult to argue with people who say something like "so do you approve that Ukrainian nationalist killed our people in Odessa?" At the same time many of propaganda things are laughing stock here, like an interview with a Ukrainian fugitive who told that "our nazis crucified a 6-year old boy at a center square of Slavyansk" I am sorry if this sounds harsh but are people in Russia really that idiotic they believe whatever their great leader says and that this is still like 13th century?? I mean, i wouldn't think people at this time are that easily manipulated regardless of where they live but i guess i am just too naive..
|
The EU has added more sanctions against Russia, with France threatening to embargo all Russian oil. Though this may be due to the upcoming French elections. Germany says they may do the same "later this year"... So there's that.
April 8 (Reuters) - The European Union on Friday formally adopted new sweeping sanctions against Russia, including bans on the import of coal, wood, chemicals and other products which were estimated to slash at least 10% of total imports from Moscow.
The measures also prevent many Russian vessels and trucks from accessing the EU, further crippling trade, and will ban all transactions with four Russian banks, including VTB. (VTBR.MM)
The ban on coal, the first the EU has so far imposed on any energy import from Russia, will be fully effective from the second week of August. No new contracts can be signed from Friday.
Existing contracts will have to be terminated by the second week of August, meaning that Russia can continue to receive payments from the EU on coal exports until then. read more
"These latest sanctions were adopted following the atrocities committed by Russian armed forces in Bucha and other places under Russian occupation," EU's top diplomat, Josep Borrell, said in a statement.
The Kremlin has said that Western allegations Russian forces committed war crimes by executing civilians in the Ukrainian town of Bucha were a "monstrous forgery" aimed at denigrating the Russian army.
The coal ban alone is estimated by the Commission to be worth 8 billion euros a year in lost revenues for Russia. That is twice as big as the EU Commission's head Ursula von der Leyen had said on Tuesday read more .
Oil and gas imports from Russia, which remain so far untouched, are together worth about 100 billion euros a year.
In addition to coal, the new EU sanctions ban imports from Russia of many other commodities and products, including wood, rubber, cement, fertilisers, high-end seafood, such as caviar, and spirits, such as vodka, for a total additional value estimated in 5.5 billion euros ($5.9 billion) a year.
An EU official said that the combined import bans were worth at least 10% of what the EU buys from Russia in a year. That comes in addition to previous import bans that hit the steel and iron sectors. In total, up to a fifth of all imports from Russia by value are expected to be cut because of direct sanctions.
The EU also restricted export to Russia of a number of products, including jet fuel, quantum computers, advanced semiconductors, high-end electronics, software, sensitive machinery and transportation equipment, for a total value of 10 billion euros a year.
Adding previous export bans on other technology, the EU has blocked so far about a quarter of its total exports by value to Russia, one EU official said.
Source
|
Northern Ireland23843 Posts
On April 09 2022 04:18 GreenHorizons wrote:Show nested quote +On April 09 2022 02:43 warding wrote: Besides the question of it being 'understandable' or not, these war crimes by the Ukranian forces are big strategic mistakes. Ukraine's effort depends on Western support. That support is sensitive to these questions. I'm sure that Ukrainian leadership understands this. I don't know how sensitive Western support is but this has been a known issue for years (Azov and Aidar battalions being some of the better known examples). There was hardly a peep when the Ukrainian National Guard tweeted out a neo nazi Azov soldier smearing pig fat on bullets meant for Muslim fighters or when the Ukrainian newscaster was quoting Adolf Eichmann. What do we do with that information?
Best case Ukraine by and large isn’t latently Nazi, worst case let’s say they are.
In either scenario is Russia’s conduct acceptable? Should Ukraine be left without aid(
I usually agree with your points but, not really sure what you’re angling for here.
|
On April 09 2022 10:15 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On April 09 2022 02:16 Mirelle wrote: >>I find "but the Russians will use it for propaganda" kind of pointless when Russia has no problem lying and fabricating their own 'evidence' if they feel the need.
No, you underestimate them. All this insane shit is because russian secret services are extremely good at manipulating public views - and sometimmes they would kill hundreds of their own people just to frame their enemy. It is increadibly difficult to argue with people who say something like "so do you approve that Ukrainian nationalist killed our people in Odessa?" At the same time many of propaganda things are laughing stock here, like an interview with a Ukrainian fugitive who told that "our nazis crucified a 6-year old boy at a center square of Slavyansk" I am sorry if this sounds harsh but are people in Russia really that idiotic they believe whatever their great leader says and that this is still like 13th century?? I mean, i wouldn't think people at this time are that easily manipulated regardless of where they live but i guess i am just too naive..
People believe all sorts of stupid shit even in countries that are not as hard on propaganda as Russia or with better access to knowledge and information. I guess you give people too much credit (especially considering that quite a big chunk of human population is under 83 IQ if the numbers mean anything to you).
|
|
|
|