|
NOTE: When providing a source, please provide a very brief summary on what it's about and what purpose it adds to the discussion. The supporting statement should clearly explain why the subject is relevant and needs to be discussed. Please follow this rule especially for tweets.
Your supporting statement should always come BEFORE you provide the source. |
On March 31 2022 15:07 Simberto wrote:Show nested quote +On March 31 2022 10:40 iPlaY.NettleS wrote:On March 30 2022 16:16 midameko wrote:On March 30 2022 10:15 Mohdoo wrote:Now that Russia is tucking tail , let's do a recap: 1) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 2) Russia's military shown to be in complete shambles 3) Putin's inner circle shown to be incompetent and providing by info 4) Europe now on track to eliminate any and all need for Russian gas eventually 5) Russia's economy will take decades to recover 6) Zero benefit whatsoever 7) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 8) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 9) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 10) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" Europe needs at least five years to seriously reduce its dependence on Russian gas. Yes, I saw Russia is demanding payment in rubles for gas from 'unfriendly' countries.Germany is currently refusing to do that. Too bad Germany decommissioned the vast majority of their nuclear plants with the rest schedule to close this year.Interested to see who blinks first.Possibly Putin according to this article? See what happens. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/30/business/germany-gas-rationing.htmlHours later, the Kremlin appeared to defuse the standoff by detailing a plan that would allow Berlin or other European customers to keep paying in euros. The plan was relayed by Mr. Putin in a telephone call with Chancellor Olaf Scholz, according to statements released late Wednesday by the German government and by the Russian state news agency, Tass.
In the call, Mr. Putin said that a new Russian law requiring gas deliveries to be settled in rubles would go into effect April 1. But “payments would continue to be made exclusively in euros and transferred as usual to Gazprom Bank, which is not affected by the sanctions,” according to a statement from Mr. Scholz’s office summarizing the call. “The bank would then convert the money into rubles.” Okay, stupid question, but why does Putin want to be paid in rubles? Isn't getting outside currency far more valuable to russia than getting rubles, which they can print themselves? IIRC during the soviet era, the eastern block countries were always all about getting dollars and DM and stuff like that. Why does Putin now absolutely want to get rubles? It seems to be all about who gets the headache of having to convert Euros to Rubles. Russia wants to trade Euros for Rubles in order to prop up the Ruble, but sanctions block most banks, and especially the central bank, from doing so. Selling gas to Europe and getting paid in Rubles means Germany (mostly) would need to buy Rubles, effectively doing what the central bank wants to do but can't.
It seems like a seriously flawed plan for the long term (with the Ruble becoming increasingly worthless over time), but Putin still seems to be clutching onto the hope that the war will soon be over and with that sanctions will disappear and everything will be back to normal. It doesn't seem like a realistic outcome, but it appears to be what he is aiming at.
https://www.marketplace.org/2022/03/30/why-does-putin-want-europe-to-buy-natural-gas-with-rubles-instead-of-euros/
https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/explainer-paying-natural-gas-rubles-83735661
|
On March 31 2022 02:15 {CC}StealthBlue wrote: I thought voters had to decide NATO membership?
All existing members of NATO have to accept the new members.
As for Finland or any other possible NATO applicant, they need popular support for the application. There is no exclusive reference to a popular vote or referendum in the relevant NATO rules, so regular legislative process is likely to be enough. Funnily enough as support for NATO has gone up here the support for a referendum about NATO has gone down.
In the other news, there are reports of yet another certified Stalin classic, Siberian deportations: https://twitter.com/visegrad24/status/1508886270080172039?t=WeQWyGm6zgZpf4XMV_Dp0A&s=19
Or do these even count as Siberian deportations anymore when the camps are on the Pacific coast. It's not really possible for Russia to get Ukrainians further away from their homeland than this.
|
On March 31 2022 15:07 Simberto wrote:Show nested quote +On March 31 2022 10:40 iPlaY.NettleS wrote:On March 30 2022 16:16 midameko wrote:On March 30 2022 10:15 Mohdoo wrote:Now that Russia is tucking tail , let's do a recap: 1) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 2) Russia's military shown to be in complete shambles 3) Putin's inner circle shown to be incompetent and providing by info 4) Europe now on track to eliminate any and all need for Russian gas eventually 5) Russia's economy will take decades to recover 6) Zero benefit whatsoever 7) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 8) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 9) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 10) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" Europe needs at least five years to seriously reduce its dependence on Russian gas. Yes, I saw Russia is demanding payment in rubles for gas from 'unfriendly' countries.Germany is currently refusing to do that. Too bad Germany decommissioned the vast majority of their nuclear plants with the rest schedule to close this year.Interested to see who blinks first.Possibly Putin according to this article? See what happens. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/30/business/germany-gas-rationing.htmlHours later, the Kremlin appeared to defuse the standoff by detailing a plan that would allow Berlin or other European customers to keep paying in euros. The plan was relayed by Mr. Putin in a telephone call with Chancellor Olaf Scholz, according to statements released late Wednesday by the German government and by the Russian state news agency, Tass.
In the call, Mr. Putin said that a new Russian law requiring gas deliveries to be settled in rubles would go into effect April 1. But “payments would continue to be made exclusively in euros and transferred as usual to Gazprom Bank, which is not affected by the sanctions,” according to a statement from Mr. Scholz’s office summarizing the call. “The bank would then convert the money into rubles.” Okay, stupid question, but why does Putin want to be paid in rubles? Isn't getting outside currency far more valuable to russia than getting rubles, which they can print themselves? IIRC during the soviet era, the eastern block countries were always all about getting dollars and DM and stuff like that. Why does Putin now absolutely want to get rubles?
I'm not big in fincances but I thought the idea behind this was to stabilize the worth of Rubel. + Show Spoiler +Exchange rate: Jan 1st 85 Rubel -> 1 Euro March 27th 144 Rubel -> 1 Euro March 31th 92 Rubel -> 1 Euro. Seems to be working I guess?
The guys above have explained everything far better already 
|
Regarding the previous discussion about Chernobyl and radiation: I just read an article (in Polish) that Russian soldiers have been digging trenches in Red Forest, and now they are being evacuated (7 buses of them) for anti-radiation treatment. If it is true, its both sad and extremely hilarious.
I seem to recall some news about trench digging In Chernobyl early in the war, so there might be something in it...
|
On March 31 2022 18:44 Silvanel wrote: Regarding the previous discussion about Chernobyl and radiation: I just read an article (in Polish) that Russian soldiers have been digging trenches in Red Forest, and now they are being evacuated (7 buses of them) for anti-radiation treatment. If it is true, its both sad and extremely hilarious.
I seem to recall some news about trench digging In Chernobyl early in the war, so there might be something in it... Pretty sure it's too late. The main reason why Chornobyl is relatively safe is because the radiation is trapped. Walking on radioactive ground is probably not too good for your feet, but there's enough distance between that and the parts of your body that *really* matter. Digging trenches kicks up radioactive dust and water particles that you then inhale, at which point you're quite thoroughly fucked.
I just... don't understand it. Capturing Chornobyl and using it as a shortcut to get to Kyiv makes sense. Digging defensive positions inside the disaster zone just boggles the mind. What commander thought it was a good idea? And how submissive do you have to be as a soldier to follow a command to dig into radioactive soil? I guess they were told it was safe, but still.
|
Russian commanders don't care about their soldiers. We've seen enough evidence of that. The soldiers probably don't even know it's dangerous. A lot of them born in the early 2000s often from very poor families. Chances are they don't even know what happened there.
|
|
On March 31 2022 22:02 JimmiC wrote:Show nested quote +On March 31 2022 16:36 Harris1st wrote:On March 31 2022 15:07 Simberto wrote:On March 31 2022 10:40 iPlaY.NettleS wrote:On March 30 2022 16:16 midameko wrote:On March 30 2022 10:15 Mohdoo wrote:Now that Russia is tucking tail , let's do a recap: 1) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 2) Russia's military shown to be in complete shambles 3) Putin's inner circle shown to be incompetent and providing by info 4) Europe now on track to eliminate any and all need for Russian gas eventually 5) Russia's economy will take decades to recover 6) Zero benefit whatsoever 7) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 8) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 9) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 10) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" Europe needs at least five years to seriously reduce its dependence on Russian gas. Yes, I saw Russia is demanding payment in rubles for gas from 'unfriendly' countries.Germany is currently refusing to do that. Too bad Germany decommissioned the vast majority of their nuclear plants with the rest schedule to close this year.Interested to see who blinks first.Possibly Putin according to this article? See what happens. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/30/business/germany-gas-rationing.htmlHours later, the Kremlin appeared to defuse the standoff by detailing a plan that would allow Berlin or other European customers to keep paying in euros. The plan was relayed by Mr. Putin in a telephone call with Chancellor Olaf Scholz, according to statements released late Wednesday by the German government and by the Russian state news agency, Tass.
In the call, Mr. Putin said that a new Russian law requiring gas deliveries to be settled in rubles would go into effect April 1. But “payments would continue to be made exclusively in euros and transferred as usual to Gazprom Bank, which is not affected by the sanctions,” according to a statement from Mr. Scholz’s office summarizing the call. “The bank would then convert the money into rubles.” Okay, stupid question, but why does Putin want to be paid in rubles? Isn't getting outside currency far more valuable to russia than getting rubles, which they can print themselves? IIRC during the soviet era, the eastern block countries were always all about getting dollars and DM and stuff like that. Why does Putin now absolutely want to get rubles? I'm not big in fincances but I thought the idea behind this was to stabilize the worth of Rubel. + Show Spoiler +Exchange rate: Jan 1st 85 Rubel -> 1 Euro March 27th 144 Rubel -> 1 Euro March 31th 92 Rubel -> 1 Euro. Seems to be working I guess? The guys above have explained everything far better already  Here is a short list of how Russia has sustained the ruble. Does not sound very sustainable to me! 20% interest sounds great for saving, but horrible for spending, im assuming if this lasts home prices will plumet.
While that is theoretically true, it will probably still not be able to offset the inflation due to nobody wanting to have rubles due to inflation (and also sanctions, and the war, and...). I wouldn't try saving money in rubles right now, even with 20% interest. I might have 20% more rubles after a year, but if these 20% more rubles are worth half as much as a year before, i still lost real value.
|
On March 31 2022 22:02 JimmiC wrote:Show nested quote +On March 31 2022 16:36 Harris1st wrote:On March 31 2022 15:07 Simberto wrote:On March 31 2022 10:40 iPlaY.NettleS wrote:On March 30 2022 16:16 midameko wrote:On March 30 2022 10:15 Mohdoo wrote:Now that Russia is tucking tail , let's do a recap: 1) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 2) Russia's military shown to be in complete shambles 3) Putin's inner circle shown to be incompetent and providing by info 4) Europe now on track to eliminate any and all need for Russian gas eventually 5) Russia's economy will take decades to recover 6) Zero benefit whatsoever 7) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 8) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 9) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" 10) Twitter commies have lost their entire whataboutism argument about "tHe WeSt" Europe needs at least five years to seriously reduce its dependence on Russian gas. Yes, I saw Russia is demanding payment in rubles for gas from 'unfriendly' countries.Germany is currently refusing to do that. Too bad Germany decommissioned the vast majority of their nuclear plants with the rest schedule to close this year.Interested to see who blinks first.Possibly Putin according to this article? See what happens. https://www.nytimes.com/2022/03/30/business/germany-gas-rationing.htmlHours later, the Kremlin appeared to defuse the standoff by detailing a plan that would allow Berlin or other European customers to keep paying in euros. The plan was relayed by Mr. Putin in a telephone call with Chancellor Olaf Scholz, according to statements released late Wednesday by the German government and by the Russian state news agency, Tass.
In the call, Mr. Putin said that a new Russian law requiring gas deliveries to be settled in rubles would go into effect April 1. But “payments would continue to be made exclusively in euros and transferred as usual to Gazprom Bank, which is not affected by the sanctions,” according to a statement from Mr. Scholz’s office summarizing the call. “The bank would then convert the money into rubles.” Okay, stupid question, but why does Putin want to be paid in rubles? Isn't getting outside currency far more valuable to russia than getting rubles, which they can print themselves? IIRC during the soviet era, the eastern block countries were always all about getting dollars and DM and stuff like that. Why does Putin now absolutely want to get rubles? I'm not big in fincances but I thought the idea behind this was to stabilize the worth of Rubel. + Show Spoiler +Exchange rate: Jan 1st 85 Rubel -> 1 Euro March 27th 144 Rubel -> 1 Euro March 31th 92 Rubel -> 1 Euro. Seems to be working I guess? The guys above have explained everything far better already  Here is a short list of how Russia has sustained the ruble. Does not sound very sustainable to me! 20% interest sounds great for saving, but horrible for spending, im assuming if this lasts home prices will plumet. What has Moscow done to boost the ruble? The central bank has more than doubled interest rates to 20%. That encourages Russian savers to keep their money in local currency. Exporters have been ordered to swap 80% of their foreign currency revenues for rubles rather than holding onto US dollars or euros. Russian brokers have been banned from selling securities held by foreigners. Residents are not allowed to make bank transfers outside Russia. Russia has threatened to demand payment for natural gas in rubles, not euros or dollars. You should include your sources when quoting Jimmi. This is copy pasted from CNN edition.cnn.com
|
On March 31 2022 18:53 Acrofales wrote:Show nested quote +On March 31 2022 18:44 Silvanel wrote: Regarding the previous discussion about Chernobyl and radiation: I just read an article (in Polish) that Russian soldiers have been digging trenches in Red Forest, and now they are being evacuated (7 buses of them) for anti-radiation treatment. If it is true, its both sad and extremely hilarious.
I seem to recall some news about trench digging In Chernobyl early in the war, so there might be something in it... Pretty sure it's too late. The main reason why Chornobyl is relatively safe is because the radiation is trapped. Walking on radioactive ground is probably not too good for your feet, but there's enough distance between that and the parts of your body that *really* matter. Digging trenches kicks up radioactive dust and water particles that you then inhale, at which point you're quite thoroughly fucked. I just... don't understand it. Capturing Chornobyl and using it as a shortcut to get to Kyiv makes sense. Digging defensive positions inside the disaster zone just boggles the mind. What commander thought it was a good idea? And how submissive do you have to be as a soldier to follow a command to dig into radioactive soil? I guess they were told it was safe, but still. Probably just SOP around an important asset
|
|
On March 31 2022 18:53 Acrofales wrote:Show nested quote +On March 31 2022 18:44 Silvanel wrote: Regarding the previous discussion about Chernobyl and radiation: I just read an article (in Polish) that Russian soldiers have been digging trenches in Red Forest, and now they are being evacuated (7 buses of them) for anti-radiation treatment. If it is true, its both sad and extremely hilarious.
I seem to recall some news about trench digging In Chernobyl early in the war, so there might be something in it... Pretty sure it's too late. The main reason why Chornobyl is relatively safe is because the radiation is trapped. Walking on radioactive ground is probably not too good for your feet, but there's enough distance between that and the parts of your body that *really* matter. Digging trenches kicks up radioactive dust and water particles that you then inhale, at which point you're quite thoroughly fucked. I just... don't understand it. Capturing Chornobyl and using it as a shortcut to get to Kyiv makes sense. Digging defensive positions inside the disaster zone just boggles the mind. What commander thought it was a good idea? And how submissive do you have to be as a soldier to follow a command to dig into radioactive soil? I guess they were told it was safe, but still.
Does the soil look any different, especially if you're a young conscript? I know the red forest is named because everything turned red after the meltdown, but is that enough to deter you from digging?
I dunno if Hollywood has corrupted reality for most people, but there is a romanticized view of not following orders and sticking it to the man that just doesn't happen in real life. Even in America where we celebrate freedom the people who went against orders did not have a great life in the very short term after disobeying.
|
I'd like to think there tons of signs warning not to go into the area due to Radiation dangers etc.
|
It looks like a normal forest (it's not even red anymore). You can see some warning signs in the video below, but I don't think that's enough to conclude that "okay I can be here but only if I don't dig in the soil". At least not something you should expect from a young soldier.
+ Show Spoiler +
|
Wonder if we will ever know the casualty rates among Russian units during the invasion. According to the MoD a %15 casualty rate renders a units/group completely unfit for combat or frontline action.
Russia’s Vladimir Putin is calling up another 134,500 conscripts even as more and more of his own soldiers appear to be turning on him over humiliating losses in Ukraine.
According to a decree published on a Russian government portal Thursday, the troops will be called to begin service on April 1 until July 15. The Defense Ministry promised earlier this week that they “will not be sent to any hot spots,” and that all those called up in last spring’s draft will be sent home.
But those assurances seem likely to be overshadowed by a multitude of reports that say Russia’s senseless war against Ukraine has been marred by lies from the top down, with Russian troops claiming they were misled into the war and Putin’s own advisers said to be shielding him from the extent of the devastating losses.
Even as Putin signed the decree on Thursday, Ukraine’s Security Service released an intercepted call said to capture a Russian soldier railing against the incompetence of his own army.
“Our brigade has totally shit themselves. There are losses, many wounded,” he tells his wife.
Asked if the losses are a result of someone screwing up, he offers a blunt response: “The whole army with us is stupid morons.”
“It’s unclear why we are even here,” he says.
Another recording shared by Anton Gerashchenko, an adviser to Ukraine’s interior minister, captures a man identified as a Russian soldier named Maksim asking his mother what is being shown on Russian television, and if there are reports “they’re saying they will change anything.”
“Everything’s bad, almost no one among us is left. They said we will keep going until the very end, until everyone is killed,” he tells his mother.
Asked if his senior officer was still with the unit, he replies: “No, he dumped us yesterday. We’re all dead in the water if he left.”
The new recordings come just hours after Western officials said there was growing evidence of disarray and disillusionment among Russian troops, with Britain’s spy chief citing reports of troops “refusing to carry out orders, sabotaging their own equipment and even accidentally shooting down their own aircraft.”
Reporting by Meduza on Thursday largely aligned with Western assessments. Citing three sources close to the presidential administration, the news outlet reported that Russian military officials finally came to terms with the fact that they wouldn’t be able to seize control of Kyiv by late March. (Just a month earlier, according to Meduza, they were all but certain that the “special operation” would be quick, and the biggest headache would be organizing work by the “new administrations” put in place by Russia).
But they decided to shift their focus to the Donbas in the country’s east after realizing the full scale of military setbacks—and the damage wrought on the economy by Western sanctions.
Putin was personally presented with the reality of the sanctions only at the end of March, when officials showed him “the country will not be able to live normally under such sanctions,” one source was quoted telling Meduza.
The Russian leader has still not made a final decision on what he’s going to do next, and plenty of those close to him are reportedly pressuring him to go full steam ahead with the onslaught against Ukraine.
But the presidential administration is said to be concerned about how “a possible truce with Ukraine will hit Putin’s [approval] ratings.”
“The citizens were riled up by propaganda. Suppose a decision is made to stop at the territory of the Donbas. What about the Nazis then? Are we no longer fighting them? This word has been hammered into people so much that I can’t imagine how one can stop in Donbas without losing approval ratings,” one source told Meduza.
Perhaps as part of a long game, the Kremlin has now reportedly begun implementing plans to send psychologists from the FSB into Kherson, a city in the south of Ukraine where residents continue to resist the Russian forces who took over after the Feb. 24 invasion.
“To implement a scenario for the creation of another pseudo-republic in the territory of the Kherson region, there is work underway by employees of the FSB, 652 groups of information and psychological operations and officers of the 12th Main Directorate of the [Russian] General Staff,” the General Staff of the Armed Forces of Ukraine said in a statement Thursday.
Ukrainian officials said the FSB effort is an attempt to brainwash residents into supporting their new Russian authorities.
Russian law enforcement officials, prosecutors, and judges are also said to be on their way to occupied territories in Ukraine, with reports of Russian police officers being asked to take “business trips” to parts of the Donbas in Ukraine’s east.
Source
|
I read a newer article (also in Polish) and some radiation expert said it's very unlikely that radiation was the reason why those soldiers were transported to a clinic that specializes in treating radiation sickness. Normal hospitals were probably full and that's why Russians sent their wounded there.
|
Czech Republic12128 Posts
If this is correct, that Ukraine is transfering what appears to be unwounded soldiers through ambulances, let's wait for the outcry when Russia will start targeting them...
User was warned for this post.
|
Not finding this vid through google image search or on Al Jazeera. Until it gets corraborated by more legit sources, this looks like a troll factory product and convenient excuse to commit war crimes.
Cant see the vid through quick-browsing the Al Jazeera arabic live feed either, though to be fair, thats a quick browse rather than watching every minute.
|
A feed full of propaganda bullshit, replies blocked so no one can point out its fake, no mention at all of it existing on Aljazeera and all google gives is a youtube video without a link to the original.
Yeah I'm going to go with fake on that one.
Shocked to see someone warning for posting Trump troll conspiracies is now posting Russian troll conspiracies. /s
|
A dissident Russian journalist used a wealth of connections and sources from within Russia to compile how the views on the war evolved in the past month among both the elites and the general population there. The picture painted here is that in the past weeks Putin has been gaining support among both groups rather than losing it, and that the "Putin is being misinformed" narrative is far overstated.
It's quite long, here's some choice quotes if you're short on time:
“In the early days, we were losing the information war,” says a high-ranking source within a regional government. “The people had negative feelings [about the war]. There was a sharp 50/50 split in society. But then all the [state media] got together and started releasing decent content. And then, when they [in the West] began to say that all Russians are bad, to boycott artists and athletes, everything changed. Now about 75 percent support the military operation. That is, there’s a social consolidation happening. Calls against the war are not at all popular, it’s more of a marginal story now.”
[...]
"When I saw what they were doing to those poor Paralympians, that was it for me... I don't care about iPhones, I can use a Chinese phone. I have a German car — let me drive a Chinese or Russian one instead. Now I understand that the boss is right, that this whole thing had to happen one way or another. They would have imposed these sanctions anyway," says a high-ranking civil servant, who a month ago was saying that Russia’s imperial ambitions should be manifested in other ways, such as by growing a strong economy.
[...]
“All these personal sanctions cement the elites. Everyone who was thinking about a new life understands that, for the next 10-15 years at least, their lives are concentrated in Russia, their children will study in Russia, their families will live in Russia. These people feel offended. They will not overthrow anyone, but will build their lives here," says a high-ranking source in one of the sanctioned state companies.
[...]
Those who manage to talk to Putin complain that he himself speaks earnestly, but does not particularly listen to what he is told, says a person who has spoken to the President within the past month. They speculate that Putin needs the peace talks in order to stall, since he still believes in the military, which says he can tear the Donetsk and Luhansk regions and the Azov Sea coast from Ukraine.
[...]
A person close to him says that Kudrin warned Putin about the consequences of the war: that the economy would slide back to the early 1990s, and that this could lead to social upheaval. But there was no reaction from the President. Another of Kudrin’s acquaintances says that the head of the Accounts Chamber looked stunned for days after his conversation with Putin, as he let him know that this war would last.
[...]
Neither Kudrin, nor Gref, nor anyone else will persuade Putin to stop the war now, they will not even be listened to, a senior Russian official is confident. “How can you imagine that? It is useless. There is a military operation going on and this is not the time to go with such advice,” he says. According to him, all talk is possible only when the hot phase of the conflict is over. To say anything to Putin against the war now would be a kind of suicide, Russian businessman Mikhail Fridman, who has been sanctioned, told Bloomberg. My sources agree with him
https://faridaily.substack.com/p/now-were-going-to-fck-them-all-whats
|
|
|
|