EPTMass Effect 3 - Page 176
| Forum Index > General Games |
|
Medrea
10003 Posts
| ||
|
kheldorin
Singapore539 Posts
On July 03 2012 20:39 Talin wrote: Oddly, I found the first game to be easily the worst (I even found it mediocre back then). First, it seemed as if the developers were struggling to decide whether they want a KoTOR 3 or a third-person shooter - the RPG and shooter mechanics mixed really badly, and the latter part was very unresponsive and clunky. Secondly, the story in the first one reeked of a generic space opera. where you were kinda flying around the galaxy in your own ship with a crew of fancy looking (yet stereotypical) aliens. Overall it gave me one of those high production value but no soul impressions. Mass Effect 2 was a lot better executed, it's the part where I really got into the series, admittedly more because it played better than the first and the combat was fun(ish) than the quality of the story (although the story and characters had a lot more depth in this one). ME3 was IMO exceptional on all levels, from the smoothness of gameplay and controls, to the maturity and grittiness/darkness of the story and its conclusion (especially with the Refusal ending). Yeah ME1 basically showed that Bioware isn't good at making shooters and were better with RPG mechanics. In ME2, they cut out a lot of the RPG stuff like weapon/armor mods and inventory management to focus on the shooting. In ME3, you had the best of both worlds. ME3's combat is just so much better than the previous Mass Effect games. The classes and combat are so well designed that people can play a ton of multi-player even thought it's repetitive. It may be repetitive but it's core mechanic is just fun. Story-wise, I prefer ME1's. I'm beginning to feel that Bioware is at it's best with the "birth/rise of a hero" story. Or maybe those types of stories are the type of stories I prefer. I understand the need for a darker tone in ME3 but I didn't like it. I just cannot reconcile why my Shepard is having nightmares, being a lot more emotional than before and he seems a lot more depressed. I've always played my Shepard as someone that has a positive, light-hearted attitude in the face of adversity. The variation in dialogue and the choices that you get seems a lot more simplified and restricted in ME3. | ||
|
brachester
Australia1786 Posts
On July 04 2012 00:09 kheldorin wrote: Yeah ME1 basically showed that Bioware isn't good at making shooters and were better with RPG mechanics. In ME2, they cut out a lot of the RPG stuff like weapon/armor mods and inventory management to focus on the shooting. In ME3, you had the best of both worlds. ME3's combat is just so much better than the previous Mass Effect games. The classes and combat are so well designed that people can play a ton of multi-player even thought it's repetitive. It may be repetitive but it's core mechanic is just fun. Story-wise, I prefer ME1's. I'm beginning to feel that Bioware is at it's best with the "birth/rise of a hero" story. Or maybe those types of stories are the type of stories I prefer. I understand the need for a darker tone in ME3 but I didn't like it. I just cannot reconcile why my Shepard is having nightmares, being a lot more emotional than before and he seems a lot more depressed. I've always played my Shepard as someone that has a positive, light-hearted attitude in the face of adversity. The variation in dialogue and the choices that you get seems a lot more simplified and restricted in ME3. yeah, I was referring to the story, not the gameplay. | ||
|
Ansinjunger
United States2451 Posts
Problem Solution Personally, I found the one ending that was supposed to be happy + Show Spoiler + (Destroy, Shepard lives, etc.) the star kid. As to how the EC was represented, it really felt patchwork and like Bioware was saying, "happy now?" The arguments weren't refined; they felt pulled from a forum argument. Many of the loopholes they closed felt made up, rather than originally intended. + Show Spoiler + Especially Normandy showing up at the last dash to the Citadel beam. Way to completely change the pace of that scene! And I'm supposed to believe that was intended all along? | ||
XaI)CyRiC
United States4471 Posts
On July 07 2012 02:51 Ansinjunger wrote: Someone at Bioware's forums (BSN), Strange Aeons made the following blog posts regarding the problems that still exist, and posted ideas for fixing it. I found these fantastic, and yes, I feel the ending went from an F to a D- with the EC. Problem Solution Personally, I found the one ending that was supposed to be happy + Show Spoiler + (Destroy, Shepard lives, etc.) the star kid. As to how the EC was represented, it really felt patchwork and like Bioware was saying, "happy now?" The arguments weren't refined; they felt pulled from a forum argument. Many of the loopholes they closed felt made up, rather than originally intended. + Show Spoiler + Especially Normandy showing up at the last dash to the Citadel beam. Way to completely change the pace of that scene! And I'm supposed to believe that was intended all along? Great posts that you linked to. The "solution" ending was amazing and inspired, and would have been great. In particular, I like the manner in which the "golden ending" described would incorporate all the decisions you made in the previous games like Bioware had led people to believe they would. A pity that this solution would never be implemented, because it would truly create an epic ending worthy of the franchise and possibly end up being the greatest ending of any game so far. | ||
|
Sabu113
United States11047 Posts
| ||
|
Lokrium
United States131 Posts
On July 11 2012 13:03 Sabu113 wrote: Odd question, but do you guys know if its possible to get the PC version of mass effect on Steam ... or any non-origin way? It's Origin exclusive. If you don't want to deal with Origin's terrible interface & many bugs, I suggest pirating ME3. | ||
|
Thingdo
United States186 Posts
On July 07 2012 02:51 Ansinjunger wrote: Someone at Bioware's forums (BSN), Strange Aeons made the following blog posts regarding the problems that still exist, and posted ideas for fixing it. I found these fantastic, and yes, I feel the ending went from an F to a D- with the EC. Problem Solution Personally, I found the one ending that was supposed to be happy + Show Spoiler + (Destroy, Shepard lives, etc.) the star kid. As to how the EC was represented, it really felt patchwork and like Bioware was saying, "happy now?" The arguments weren't refined; they felt pulled from a forum argument. Many of the loopholes they closed felt made up, rather than originally intended. + Show Spoiler + Especially Normandy showing up at the last dash to the Citadel beam. Way to completely change the pace of that scene! And I'm supposed to believe that was intended all along? That ending would have been pretty awesome tbh. I really enjoy it when you can suffer severe consequences in a game for believing a character who is lying to you, but also avoid them by figuring out what they were up to. Very few games ever do this though, the only ones I can think of off the top of my head are Myst and ME2. | ||
|
polyphonyEX
United States2539 Posts
| ||
|
ghost_403
United States1825 Posts
| ||
|
Greggle
United States1131 Posts
On July 12 2012 01:18 polyphonyEX wrote: I just finished Mass Effect 3 for the first time last night and I found the 'refuse' ending to be quite satisfying. I'm ok with letting everything in Shepard's cycle die if it allowed the next cycle succeed. Backed by the knowledge of previous cycles, the civilizations that developed probably far surpassed the ones that would have otherwise been saved. It leaves a lot open for speculation, and I wish bioware would have fleshed it out a little bit, but I found it acceptable. No! I'm not okay with anything involving Tali dying =( | ||
|
neoghaleon55
United States7435 Posts
On July 12 2012 01:43 ghost_403 wrote: Holy hell, that ending by Strange Aeon was amazing. To me, this is now the canonical ending the Mass Effect series. Fuck you Bioware, this is how it should have been. do you have a link to that? post please! | ||
|
Ansinjunger
United States2451 Posts
My post this page. On July 12 2012 01:18 polyphonyEX wrote: I just finished Mass Effect 3 for the first time last night and I found the 'refuse' ending to be quite satisfying. I'm ok with letting everything in Shepard's cycle die if it allowed the next cycle succeed. Backed by the knowledge of previous cycles, the civilizations that developed probably far surpassed the ones that would have otherwise been saved. It leaves a lot open for speculation, and I wish bioware would have fleshed it out a little bit, but I found it acceptable. That was my initial impression when I played that ending, but someone at BSN pointed out the future cycle's people may have just used the options I refused, which could mean more cycles of refuse not working and then someone eventually giving in to the star child. The ending kind of implies Refuse resulted in an eventual victory without giving in to the star child, but Shepard doesn't know the ending when making this decision. It's like the ends justify the means--maybe, but that describes pretty much every ending. | ||
|
HeeroFX
United States2704 Posts
| ||
|
WhiteDog
France8650 Posts
| ||
|
althaz
Australia1001 Posts
| ||
|
NeMeSiS3
Canada2972 Posts
Dissapointment + Show Spoiler + ![[image loading]](http://imageshack.us/photo/my-images/843/demotivationalpostersdi.jpg/) | ||
|
nShade
Bulgaria296 Posts
I hope it brings some more answers, about the reapers. Just a few more hours! ^.^ | ||
|
NeMeSiS3
Canada2972 Posts
On August 27 2012 05:46 nShade wrote: I am extremely pumped for the Leviathan missions! I hope it brings some more answers, about the reapers. Just a few more hours! ^.^ to invest into a disappointment T.T | ||
|
nihlon
Sweden5581 Posts
On July 12 2012 10:46 HeeroFX wrote: I feel like the work they did on the endings was kinda weird. If Normandy just shows up during the dash, why does the whole crew not jump out and rush with Shepard to the beam, its the biggest and most important thing in the fight. Destory is the only option that truely closes out the the game. The reason I feel this way is that if you want to move forward with this universe the reapers really shouldn't exist anymore. And for the love of god, if you get the perfect ending, you get to see our hero take a breath of fresh air in rubble on Earth. Which makes me wonder, did he even go into the beam? Or did he just get knocked into a building and dreamed that he won. Is bioware just gonna pull out ME 4 countinuing the fight on earth ? I think they have said that any future games would take place prior or during the final battle of ME3. But who knows, maybe they'll do it just so they can try to redeem themselves and make a proper ending. | ||
| ||
