EPT20 April OnGameNet Dual Tournament Group E/F - Page 13
| Forum Index > Brood War Tournaments |
mikeymoo
Canada7170 Posts
| ||
thedeadhaji
39489 Posts
On April 19 2007 23:27 entityrj wrote: But I didn't claim how they got there as being different? I used the very general statement of: "that game was nothing like this" and by this, i clearly meant in my mind why that game was lost and won in response for the original poster drawing the connection between the two and citing it as a reason. I'm sorry if I sounded pompous, but you can see my intentions were honest... so now you are saying that you DIDNT claim that the progression to that point was different? Well I guess my english skills have really gone downhill now, because I don't see any other way of interpreting The end result is the same but how they got there... jesus as anything else. even with respect to the statement "that game was nothing like this", how can you begin to support this argument when the movement of the mutalisks and scourge, the buildings that were destroyed, the protoss' reaction by expanding to the other natural, could NOT have been more similar. The ONLY differences were (a) spawn loaction (b) scouting path of sair (c) the way the toss responded to the muta scourge attack. And obviously (c) was the only thing pertinent, as (a) and (b) did not prevent the game from progressing identically up to point (c). And at (c), free made a decision that kept him in the game, while stork made a decision that cost him the game. That is ONE difference at the very end of the game, the reason why the results were different in these two identical games. | ||
|
mikeymoo
Canada7170 Posts
| ||
Last Romantic
United States20661 Posts
| ||
|
SpiritAshura
United States1271 Posts
| ||
|
roadrunner_sc
United States1220 Posts
GF floating 4th cc down to bottom left. DonG double expands. Tries to push into middle & repelled by 4 dropship worth of tanks. GF's definitely showing much better mobility this game. 4 DS from DonG wraps around and drops bottom left. | ||
|
Last Romantic
United States20661 Posts
9 for goodfriend or something crazy like that gf clearly the better player, I think DG drops bottom left | ||
|
mikeymoo
Canada7170 Posts
GF drops 3:00. GF suffers unit losses + scv losses. GF suffers tank losses. GF got the better of that one. | ||
|
YoUr_KiLLeR
United States3420 Posts
On April 19 2007 23:33 entityrj wrote: But I DIDNT say you were "defending" the original poster OR that the "two games progressions were entirely different". To quote myself: "that game was nothing like this!" is a very general statement and I've tried my best to point out what I meant with "this". I admit I didn't have an exact memory of how that game STARTED, but remembering the game overall, I posted what I posted. You said yourself you had to rewatch the game right? But since I was operating on just general memory, that's why I said they were different. And I just want to defend myself... do I really sound like that's not what I meant? I'm sorry then... newsflash: nobody cares. | ||
|
thedeadhaji
39489 Posts
On April 19 2007 23:33 entityrj wrote: You said yourself you had to rewatch the game right? But since I was operating on just general memory, that's why I said they were different. You operated on FALSE presumptions and put down a poster based on this false information. What is your point. | ||
|
thedeadhaji
39489 Posts
On April 19 2007 23:33 entityrj wrote:I'm sorry then... Ok, case closed. | ||
|
mikeymoo
Canada7170 Posts
| ||
|
Last Romantic
United States20661 Posts
gf has more tanks similar numbers of ships for both | ||
|
thedeadhaji
39489 Posts
| ||
|
entityrj
United States185 Posts
On April 19 2007 23:35 thedeadhaji wrote: so now you are saying that you DIDNT claim that the progression to that point was different? Well I guess my english skills have really gone downhill now, because I don't see any other way of interpreting as anything else. even with respect to the statement "that game was nothing like this", how can you begin to support this argument when the movement of the mutalisks and scourge, the buildings that were destroyed, the protoss' reaction by expanding to the other natural, could NOT have been more similar. The ONLY differences were (a) spawn loaction (b) scouting path of sair (c) the way the toss responded to the muta scourge attack. And obviously (c) was the only thing pertinent, as (a) and (b) did not prevent the game from progressing identically up to point (c). And at (c), free made a decision that kept him in the game, while stork made a decision that cost him the game. That is ONE difference at the very end of the game, the reason why the results were different in these two identical games. I understand what you mean, but I just want to make it clear that the difference resulted in a much longer game, with my memory recalling most of that extenstion, and that's why I said they were "entirely different", the whole game ended up very differently after all didn't it? And when I said "how they got there", that's exactly what I meant, that game played out much longer and quite differently didn't it? I know you have a superior knowledge of that game than me and you've shown it, but you keep responding as if I had savagely posted an ignorant response when all I was saying was I remember them being different!! and you can see why I remember that!! I'm very sorry then to the original poster and haji, I really meant no harm. Edit: I know this is bothering everyone and as someone said, nobody cares, but I've tried to explain myself as best I could. | ||
|
Last Romantic
United States20661 Posts
GF gets fourth GF suiciding SCVs now, whoa | ||
|
mikeymoo
Canada7170 Posts
| ||
|
roadrunner_sc
United States1220 Posts
GF shifting his containment up, 4 tanks left. Another drop by GF into 5'o clock, repelled by DS contents from DonG. DonG has about +2 DS worth of units. GF tries to invade bottom right again. Doesn't want to engage DonG superior numbers, forced back. | ||
|
mikeymoo
Canada7170 Posts
| ||
|
Last Romantic
United States20661 Posts
that stupid decision to counter cost him advantage... he traded a base for nothing. should have just gone with the safe decision and defended. GF getting fifth multi, DG has scary army | ||
| ||
