EPTNew Protoss Victory Screen - Page 3
| Forum Index > BW General |
|
gngfn
United States1726 Posts
| ||
|
Essbee
Canada2371 Posts
Feels more epic, but also more childish. I have mixed feelings about it but at the same time, I really really REALLY don't care. It's just the victory screen ffs. | ||
FlaShFTW
United States9925 Posts
| ||
|
gngfn
United States1726 Posts
On June 02 2017 10:52 FlaShFTW wrote: i like the darker settings of everything as BW was a very dark era. i would argue that the darkest era was when there was no pro BW | ||
|
fabiano
Brazil4644 Posts
On June 02 2017 10:26 Essbee wrote: Not bad but it lost it's aura of mystery and instead gives shininess and a "we are doing this together, so heroic!" feel. Feels more epic, but also more childish. I have mixed feelings about it but at the same time, I really really REALLY don't care. It's just the victory screen ffs. I agree 100%. ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/oLUb3Yv.jpg) I thought BW was supposed to darker, more desolated, with a more mature ambience. While the new art itself is very good, doesn`t look like it portrays that. ![[image loading]](http://i.imgur.com/cPSFUWL.jpg) You see, even thought his eyes shows somewhat of a scared/surprised expression, the overall picture feels "heavier", somehow more mature than the new one? But like you said, who really cares too much? It's just a victory screen. | ||
|
reminisce12
Australia318 Posts
| ||
|
lestye
United States4133 Posts
Honestly the BW one seems a stoic alien standing in the dark. The new one has a clearly more determined aggressive look. Maybe it's guilty of throwing subtlety out the window, but overall I think it's great | ||
|
Dazed.
Canada3301 Posts
 | ||
|
Freakling
Germany1525 Posts
Why does everything have to look like the stereotypical action figure these days? The best aliens just look alien... Why would you even expect them to share human expressions, gestures or anatomy? | ||
|
ShuriKn
Canada20 Posts
| ||
|
Kare
Norway786 Posts
| ||
|
Essbee
Canada2371 Posts
On June 02 2017 11:14 fabiano wrote: I agree 100%. I thought BW was supposed to darker, more desolated, with a more mature ambience. While the new art itself is very good, doesn`t look like it portrays that. You see, even thought his eyes shows somewhat of a scared/surprised expression, the overall picture feels "heavier", somehow more mature than the new one? But like you said, who really cares too much? It's just a victory screen. Thanks for putting the pictures side by side like this. I feel like it would be much better if the "sc2" one was also looking directly at us, and also not have the clenched fist. I think the opened blade is alright, it can give a menacing look while still keeping the mysterious atmosphere. I like how you use the word "heavier" here, I totally agree. But I am going too far with this haha, like I've already said, this is only a victory screen, but it's still fun to discuss about it ^^ | ||
|
XERX
85 Posts
| ||
|
Essbee
Canada2371 Posts
On June 02 2017 16:54 XERX wrote: old one is garbage this one is dope "garbage" | ||
|
CrymeaTerran
149 Posts
I like the old one better, for that pic of blizzard it is good, overall, but it feels so "dont know", not good enough, the zealot is to young and from the look he gives me i think he is not wise enough, toss should be old, but he has blue eyes like a freshborn youngstar zealot and the psi blade is out cause the fight is still not over. Less gloss and aging the zealot = perfect. bye | ||
|
TT1
Canada9968 Posts
| ||
|
Shalashaska_123
United States142 Posts
These two pictures contrast each other like night and day. The Remastered art looks much more colorful and emotional compared to the original. There's not a single dark spot on the SC:R zealot's body. On the other hand, roughly half the zealot's body in the original picture is shrouded in darkness, and it has a much calmer, mysterious demeanor. Personally I prefer the original artwork because it better suits the dark (pun intended) storyline of the Protoss campaign. Not to mention the Zealot's armor in the original looks a lot cooler and more genuine compared to that of Remastered, which looks like a plastic toy. The original zealot is staring off into the distance, ready to face its destiny, whereas the Remastered zealot is looking up as if answering to a higher power. If you guys recall, the Protoss campaign was all about disobeying the Conclave and doing what was best for the race. Again, the new art doesn't really fit with the storyline in my opinion. My final thought is that the Remastered zealot looks a lot more like a human than the original one does. If you look close enough, you can see it's sporting a six-pack... That's a little comical if you ask me. Sincerely, Shalashaska_123 | ||
|
Glioburd
France1910 Posts
| ||
|
TT1
Canada9968 Posts
On June 02 2017 18:16 Glioburd wrote: I may have a dirty mind, but on the old protoss victory screen, I've always seen a wooden dick between the zealot's leggs. I'm sad it's gone. cant be unseen -_- im sticking w/ the old graphics even when remastered comes out  | ||
|
eviltomahawk
United States11133 Posts
I do like the subtle detailing in the background of the new background though, especially the reflections and the improvements to the planet. | ||
| ||
