If both of the pictures were put before us as conceptart in 1997, can anyone honestly say that they wouldn't have preferred the remastered one? The only reason to prefer the old screen seems to be our emotional attachment to it.

Freakling

Germany1529 Posts

June 03 2017 09:10 GMT

#122

On June 03 2017 09:12 lestye wrote:

Show nested quote +

I don't see why they wouldn't be triumphant and fist bumping, that completely fits the character. I think people are like projecting their idea of protoss as mindless emotionless husks when that couldn't be further from the truth.

Let's call these people group 1.
Group 2 are the ones who project their ideas of stereotypical human emotional expression on what is supposed to be an Alien race...

washikie

United States752 Posts

June 03 2017 09:20 GMT

#123

I'm cool with it, though i admit I was never a huge fan of the abdomen of protoss in original SC artwork, It just seemed to slender and frail for a race that fights in melee combat with plasma swords and it was the only unarmored part of them in the art. The in game models were cool but I was not the biggest fan of the way they looked in the cinematics. I just wish they kept more of the bulky armor feel of the original though; that's the thing I don't like about sc2 protoss art. I like the bulkiness of protoss units and structures in bw.

[nkc]moon

30 Posts

June 03 2017 11:02 GMT

#124

On June 03 2017 18:10 Freakling wrote:

Show nested quote +

Let's call these people group 1.
Group 2 are the ones who project their ideas of stereotypical human emotional expression on what is supposed to be an Alien race...

The new zealot is leaning over staring at something

The old one is like half slav squatting on its tippy toes

Wrath

3174 Posts

June 03 2017 11:25 GMT

#125

To sum up the issues for people who do not like it so far:

- Heavily SC2 influence in the look of the Zealot as in:

Shiny Colors [ Even eye colors changed from orange/brown to blue to match that of SC2 Zealot ]
Edgy poses
facial expression [ Don't remember that BW Protoss had facial expressions like angry or afraid or happy. They don't have a mouth so they do not smile or anything. But that doesn't mean their eyes will have any of that facial expression changes. Their face remained at every circumstances whether it was good or bad. As a mystical race, having no facial expression at all suits them better.
armor design change

Did I miss anything?

StylishVODs

Sweden5331 Posts

June 03 2017 12:00 GMT

#126

The Zealot now have abs.

Moonsalt

267 Posts

June 03 2017 12:45 GMT

#127

On June 03 2017 21:00 StylishVODs wrote:
The Zealot now have abs.

Yeah they hit the gym very hard the past 20 years.

Sinistro

Brazil684 Posts

June 04 2017 14:56 GMT

#128

not only gym, they gave a massive junk to the zealot, look at the old model with detail, there is only legs support, this one basically got an exoskeleton of his own.

vOdToasT

Sweden2870 Posts

June 05 2017 03:23 GMT

#129

Stop bluewashing Protoss history.
#WhiteLivesMatter

Alpha-NP-

United States1242 Posts

June 05 2017 03:38 GMT

#130

This picture looks amazing. Don't say it looks cartoonish. Nothing is 3d in the remastered.

ldv

United States103 Posts

June 15 2017 20:44 GMT

#131

Terran victory screen

Wrath

3174 Posts

June 15 2017 21:18 GMT

#132

I can't say there is something wrong with the new one but still going for nostalgia.

^ Sorry if I look like stealing your post, just added the old one for comparison.

Qikz

United Kingdom12022 Posts

June 15 2017 21:23 GMT

#133

On June 16 2017 06:18 Wrath wrote:

I can't say there is something wrong with the new one but still going for nostalgia.

^ Sorry if I look like stealing your post, just added the old one for comparison.

I love the new one!

Cele

Germany4016 Posts

June 15 2017 21:29 GMT

#134

meh it's mediocre, i like the old one better.

€: i like the new terran screen. I'd still go with the old one for nostalgia, but it's good.

ii.blitzkrieg

Canada1122 Posts

June 15 2017 21:43 GMT

#135

I like the addition of the bullet casings on the ground

Wrath

3174 Posts

June 15 2017 21:46 GMT

#136

Is it me or the guns in the old screen seems longer?

KameZerg

Sweden1761 Posts

June 15 2017 21:54 GMT

#137

I like the old one too solely because of the direction the artist took with the style. The new one is nice but the new one in the same direction as the old one would have been da bomb

iPlaY.NettleS

Australia4329 Posts

June 15 2017 22:05 GMT

#138

Again old one is better.

CobaltBlu

United States919 Posts

June 15 2017 22:09 GMT

#139

I think the quality of the art is pretty good.

It seems like at some point they sent a memo to the art team and told them to brighten everything up. The old BW art is all dark and in shadow and the new art all looks like it has studio lighting or something. I don't know if there is a point in complaining about it now but I prefer the darker style to the lighter one.

Alpha-NP-

United States1242 Posts

June 15 2017 22:10 GMT

#140

The new Terran victory screen is better.