|
On November 02 2016 08:03 Koshi wrote: Do we have reasons to believe Artanis his HP is really only 30?
Can ritoky kill Artanis EoD?
I can deal 15 damage, but you are going to get hurt too, which doesn't sound great
|
We need to try to do at least 50 to Artanis EoD.
@Bill Murray Do you have any damage spell or only heal + shield?
@Ritoky You already said it once but how much damage can you do EoD?
|
I attacked Koshi again like I said I would. Probably again today unless I change my mind and go to Artanis.
I don't really think Kurumi is mafia either.
I don't think it's Bill either.
Meh
|
Lynch Tubesock. Damage to Artanis.
|
On November 02 2016 08:25 Koshi wrote: We need to try to do at least 50 to Artanis EoD.
@Bill Murray Do you have any damage spell or only heal + shield?
@Ritoky You already said it once but how much damage can you do EoD?
15 during day, 30 at night with my current amount of clones.
|
On November 02 2016 08:27 Tubesock wrote: I attacked Koshi again like I said I would. Probably again today unless I change my mind and go to Artanis.
I don't really think Kurumi is mafia either.
I don't think it's Bill either.
Meh
outside of poe, why is it koshi? also have you claimed?
|
On November 02 2016 09:02 ritoky wrote:Show nested quote +On November 02 2016 08:27 Tubesock wrote: I attacked Koshi again like I said I would. Probably again today unless I change my mind and go to Artanis.
I don't really think Kurumi is mafia either.
I don't think it's Bill either.
Meh
outside of poe, why is it koshi? also have you claimed?
Not really based on poe. It's because he did nothing pro town until the "double lynch" where he killed a towny anyway. It's a good mafia play too. He brings up this double lynch ability when Vivax was 100% dying anyway. There's nothing that mafia could have done that would have stopped Vivax from dying. But if mafia!Koshi has a day vigi power then he could call it a double lynch and not shoot saying he was blocked.
He was on Skynx from early on though. So meh.
I claimed already. Ostarion and I'm basically a Vet.
|
Really it's I don't think he should be confirmed town for that and everyone else thinks so but I think they're wrong. Just doesn't seem possible the lock towns are really locked.
|
Yeah I think we lynch tubesock. Claiming attack on koshi or not. Tis dumb
|
|
Bill Murray - Vivax mentioned 39 times (some in quotes etc) Defends - once Scums - 4 times He never gives a reason why he scummed Vivax. Goes + Show Spoiler [Why vote V? & agrees with Koshi] +On October 24 2016 05:52 Bill Murray wrote: I don't even know why everyone was voting vivax On October 25 2016 08:28 Bill Murray wrote:Show nested quote +On October 25 2016 07:35 Koshi wrote: Ritoky/Vivax/Sicklucker/Lunatic/skynx
Endgame cred.
Afkers like Humahama/LT can be replaced with 1 Seems legit
Skynx mentioned 46 times. Mostly in quotes or some vote count analysis. Defends 1.5 times. The half is because he didn't like WoS's "check" since Bill was using wards. Scums 8 times. Was a point where he wanted to kill Skynx rather than vote him. and afterword he seemed to feel guilty about his all over the place voting and he was "backed up against a wall" + Show Spoiler +On November 01 2016 16:57 Bill Murray wrote: Look at my votes when u were wanting to Lynch skynx they were all over the place and so was my mind. I just didn't see how cop checks were a thing since I had that ward . On November 01 2016 16:57 Bill Murray wrote: Oh yeah 2 the point my point is that that's how town thinks if they're smart like I am ... kinda all over the place back against the wall kinda thinking. Scum can be more knowledgeable and all knowing
That seems kinda weird to me. He's not proven wrong yet about voting or being suspicious of WaveofShadow, ritoky, or Koshi and he did end up on Skynx. Seems really weird that he votes WoS on Day 1 and 4, but votes with the crowd on Days 2 & 3 with no reasoning. At least with WoS you can see what he's sort of thinking. And "back against the wall" thinking happens when mafia is in a spot they have to figure out if they are going to bus or not.
I totally get voting around like he did on Day 4. I thought it was towny even. But I don't think I'd feel guilty about it at all. When I saw the Night 4 flip I was stoked we killed 2 mafia at once and had 3 total. Why feel guilty? Kinda misplaced like Kurumi's anger the other day.
Koshi I apologize for attacking Koshi a bunch of times. He's town. Simply based on his D1 and D2 voting.
ritoky - First this response to Skynx:
On October 26 2016 07:33 ritoky wrote:Show nested quote +On October 26 2016 07:29 Skynx wrote: I sort of see your point but what i mean is it doesn't confirm other people.
S1: Koshi dead, flipped town. People visiting him still might be town on wrong track. He is like top sr of half the people here. Right, but you're thinking about it from a town perspective. I am not. I am looking for people who's kneecaps I have to kiss to keep me from being in any danger. Mind you I have realized, and please don't take offense to this mafias out there, that 1 or 2 mafia probably need to die for this game to go long enough for me to fulfill my win condition. So currently I am a bit more town sided, hence why I tried to use a sentry ward to help town.
Is ritoky capable of faking this underlined statement to his scumbuddy Skynx? I think this is a pretty strong town tell from ritoky.
Anyway there are 25 mentions of Skynx in ritoky's filter. He defends once (above quote) and then names him in a POE list with a lot of other people in it. That's it. I'm not counting the post he says that if Skynx flips red then I am town or busser of the century. But if he's mafia, then saying that about me just makes it much harder to get another mlynch and I'm a great candidate for that.
ritoky is town.
Kurumi- Mentions Vivax 11 times defends him 4. Votes him Day 4 but I didn't see why (policy maybe, Vivax isn't on any list). Mentions Skynx 7 times and only says anything about him in 2 of his lists where he is in weird () category.
+ Show Spoiler [Last List] +
There's zero reasoning on why he voted Vivax or Skynx. Looks like sheeping I guess. They were overwhelming wagons. Day 2 he was midpack vote on Lunaticman and the next day he voted sicklucker. Sicklucker was in his scum leans () section. And of course no reasoning whatsoever. He then somehow ends up on Vivax's wagon despite only defending him. Vivax never makes it onto Kurumi's lists despite Vivax being on the few votes Kurumi actually comments on.
I'm tired. I believe Artanis[Xp]'s 3p claim. WaveofShadow's town just on this filter and leadership.
|
Gah Forgot this part.
On October 22 2016 06:04 disformation wrote:Final Vote Count - Day 1 Tictock (8); Tubesock ritoky, Bill Murray, Koshi Koshi (4):, TubeSock Lunaticman (1): ritoky, KoshiVivax (2): Tubesock KoshiLord Tolkien (2): Kurumi, WaveofShadow WaveofShadow (1): Bill Murrayritoky (1): KoshiHolyflare (1): Bill Murrayptmc (0): WaveofShadowSkynx (0): Koshibeentheredonethat (0): WaveofShadowHopeless1der (0): KoshiKurumi (0): Kurumi Bill Murray
On October 25 2016 06:11 Half the Sky wrote:Final Vote Count - Day 2 Vivax (10):Koshi, Tubesock, WaveofShadow, Bill Murray, Tubesock Lunaticman *****(8): Koshi, Koshi, Artanis[xP], Kurumi, ritoky, Lord Tolkien Tubesock (1): VivaxLord Tolkien (0): KurumiExo_ (0): KoshiGlowingBear (0): Artanis[Xp]Skynx(0): Koshi. Artanis[X], Tubesock
On October 28 2016 06:02 disformation wrote:Final Vote Count - Day 3 Vivax (9): Tubesock, WaveofShadow, Bill Murray, Artanis[Xp], Kurumi Lunaticman**** (5):, Koshi, Artanis[Xp], ritoky sicklucker (0): Kurumi
On October 31 2016 05:28 AFK Jungle wrote:Vote Count - Day 4 Skynx (11): WaveofShadow, Tubesock, Koshi, Bill Murray Artanis[Xp], Kurumi, Bill Murray, ritoky Koshi (1): Skynx, Bill Murrayritoky (0): Bill MurrayWaveofShadow (0): Bill Murray
1. Artanis[Xp]**- Voted Day 1 - none Voted Day 2 - Skynx, GlowingBear, Lunaticman Voted Day 3 - Vivax, Lunaticman Voted Day 4 - Skynx
2. Kurumi - Voted Day 1 - Kurumi, Lord Tolkien Voted Day 2 - Lord Tolkien, Lunaticman Voted Day 3 - sicklucker, Vivax Voted Day 4 - Skynx
3. Koshi Voted Day 1 - Hopeless1der, Skynx, ritoky, Vivax, Lunaticman, Ticktock Voted Day 2 - Skynx, ExO_, Lunaticman, Vivax, Lunaticman Voted Day 3 - Lunaticman Voted Day 4 - Skynx
4. Tubesock Voted Day 1 - Vivax, Ticktock, Koshi Voted Day 2 - Skynx, Vivax Voted Day 3 - Vivax Voted Day 4 - Skynx
5. ritoky Voted Day 1 - Lunaticman, Tictock Voted Day 2 - Lunaticman Voted Day 3 - Lunaticman Voted Day 4 - skynx
7. Bill Murray Voted Day 1 - Kurumi, HolyFlare, WaveofShadow, Tictock Voted Day 2 - Vivax Voted Day 3 - Vivax Voted Day 4 - WaveofShadow, ritoky, Koshi, Skynx
9. WaveofShadow Voted Day 1 - beentheredonethat, ptmc, Lord Tolkien Voted Day 2 - Vivax Voted Day 3 - Vivax Voted Day 4 - Skynx
|
Forgot this too.
The first parts with the vote counts are with just the survivors. The second bit is the votes by player. They are not really in order of when they were cast. I underlined the vote that the player ended on. If there isn't a line that's underlined it's the last player listed that was on the final vote.
I don't think I'll be around for EoD.
I guess I think town should kill Kurumi, me, Bill then Artanis. Unless Wave is alive for couple more nights. Think about ritoky too. I think he's town, but he's really good at making some insane mafia plays. He could have floated that towntell for someone to find. And defending me and later lynching me isn't really that difficult to pull off.
|
Vote Count - Day 5
Kurumi (4): Bill Murray, WaveofShadow, Artanis[Xp], Tubesock Tubesock (1): Koshi Artanis[Xp] (1): Koshi, Bill Murray, Kurumi
Not voting (1): ritoky
It looks like Kurumi is about to get owned. Day 1 ends in at 21:00 GMT (+00:00) and resolves one hour later, at 22:00 GMT (+00:00).
The voting thread is here and only votes in the voting thread will be counted.
|
##unvote ##vote Kurumi
I like the big effort. I have some problems with your analysis but the main thing is that in your scumreads there is no room for an SK. If Kurumi is mafia, we have to look for an SK and not another mafia. Only when Kurumi flips SK, we should look for a mafia.
We are missing the damage on Exo en Dandel. So unless they took huge damage early on and Vivax didn't send in heals, I don't see how they died.
On November 02 2016 07:37 Kurumi wrote: And I'm going to vote Artanis for obvious reasons. 1) He's claimed 3p 2) that puts me on the top of the list, so I can shield damage from everyone by being on top Reason 2 is antitown thinking. Why would mafia/3p use kp on town!Kurumi? Only when Kurumi is one of the 2, then there is a good chance he will get targeted by KP by the other anti town.
|
Who are we punching today? Artanis?
|
On November 02 2016 21:10 WaveofShadow wrote: Who are we punching today? Artanis? No
|
told you my reads are shit
|
On November 02 2016 21:10 WaveofShadow wrote: Who are we punching today? Artanis? Yes
|
Okay guys, should I try to make killing Artanis easier, while dealing damage to Koshi, or should I just punch him/reduce his damage?
|
|
|
|