|
Mafia Trifecta Win completed. 3 times mafia in a row.
+ Show Spoiler +
ggwp. 180 pages are a lot so town didn't lose due to inactivity tbh. Oats made like 5 posts last 4 days... I scated by the entire game without pressure due to playing good for 3 hours EoD1 pushing Palmar.
Poor JAT having to defend himself the entire game lol. So hilarious to see. Props for doing it.
ggwp. Hosts can start rolling me town again. Playing only mafia last months is not that awesome.
|
On October 15 2016 07:10 Koshi wrote:Mafia Trifecta Win completed. 3 times mafia in a row. + Show Spoiler +ggwp. 180 pages are a lot so town didn't lose due to inactivity tbh. Oats made like 5 posts last 4 days... I scated by the entire game without pressure due to playing good for 3 hours EoD1 pushing Palmar. Poor JAT having to defend himself the entire game lol. So hilarious to see. Props for doing it. ggwp. Hosts can start rolling me town again. Playing only mafia last months is not that awesome. Your mom is hilarious to see...
|
On October 15 2016 07:13 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On October 15 2016 07:10 Koshi wrote:Mafia Trifecta Win completed. 3 times mafia in a row. + Show Spoiler +ggwp. 180 pages are a lot so town didn't lose due to inactivity tbh. Oats made like 5 posts last 4 days... I scated by the entire game without pressure due to playing good for 3 hours EoD1 pushing Palmar. Poor JAT having to defend himself the entire game lol. So hilarious to see. Props for doing it. ggwp. Hosts can start rolling me town again. Playing only mafia last months is not that awesome. Your mom is hilarious to see... hihi
This was so good if you know Calix would have redchecked Oats. My favorite moment in all scumgames I think. Because it was so clutch. Game winning. And I think we had to be both there to actually go through with it. Alone I wouldn't have had the balls.
Proud moment.
|
On October 15 2016 07:40 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On October 15 2016 07:13 justanothertownie wrote:On October 15 2016 07:10 Koshi wrote:Mafia Trifecta Win completed. 3 times mafia in a row. + Show Spoiler +ggwp. 180 pages are a lot so town didn't lose due to inactivity tbh. Oats made like 5 posts last 4 days... I scated by the entire game without pressure due to playing good for 3 hours EoD1 pushing Palmar. Poor JAT having to defend himself the entire game lol. So hilarious to see. Props for doing it. ggwp. Hosts can start rolling me town again. Playing only mafia last months is not that awesome. Your mom is hilarious to see... hihi This was so good if you know Calix would have redchecked Oats. My favorite moment in all scumgames I think. Because it was so clutch. Game winning. And I think we had to be both there to actually go through with it. Alone I wouldn't have had the balls. Proud moment. My read! But yeah, wouldn't have changed it on my own either. Team effort.
|
On October 15 2016 07:45 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On October 15 2016 07:40 Koshi wrote:On October 15 2016 07:13 justanothertownie wrote:On October 15 2016 07:10 Koshi wrote:Mafia Trifecta Win completed. 3 times mafia in a row. + Show Spoiler +ggwp. 180 pages are a lot so town didn't lose due to inactivity tbh. Oats made like 5 posts last 4 days... I scated by the entire game without pressure due to playing good for 3 hours EoD1 pushing Palmar. Poor JAT having to defend himself the entire game lol. So hilarious to see. Props for doing it. ggwp. Hosts can start rolling me town again. Playing only mafia last months is not that awesome. Your mom is hilarious to see... hihi This was so good if you know Calix would have redchecked Oats. My favorite moment in all scumgames I think. Because it was so clutch. Game winning. And I think we had to be both there to actually go through with it. Alone I wouldn't have had the balls. Proud moment. My read! But yeah, wouldn't have changed it on my own either. Team effort.
|
Koshi your scumplay is about to reach Superbia levels of out-thereness
|
Oh yeah, those blue moves were sick by you guys.
Hi skynx!
|
gg wp scum......koshi....you're tearing it up. Reading your filters, it'd been hard to make a case on either you or JAT the way it was going, only thing noticable is that you weren't driving lynches like you normally do as town. But IDK that argument alone would have ever gotten you lynched esp before the lynchbait.
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/514644-dota-2-mafia
FYI, next game up for signups will close Monday or Tuesday if you are up for a themed game.
|
So for those of you who played in this game and havent signed up for DOTA 2 Mafia.
Dota 2 signups are here and I await your /in. PHD programs and pregnancy are not valid reasons to not sign up.
|
Thx friends. I do it all for the fans.
|
Scum tore it up on day 1, and on day 2 JAT did really well to convince us to lynch Superbia.
I don't think the Palmar lynch should have happened, and I'm not quite sure why Marv went through with it. After the day 3 lynch I think town was already finished with Damdred/Scott still left as question marks for the majority of town.
Also as much as I'd like to take credit for getting the correct guess in obs, Btdt told us half the scum team lol.
|
Overall I think scum played pretty well and probably could have pulled off a win even without a Palmar lynch.
|
Wait what was going on with NU/Koshi discussion from the start of the game?
|
I didn't think Damdredwas scum but was pretty sure calix was so I would have been fail XD
|
my phone straight double posted I am sorry.
|
Host feedback
Okay! So, finally I have the time to sit down and give some insights about what I thought pregame, during the game, and now post game. First of all, my expectations towards this game were very high. Big names had signed up and various people told me beforehand that this would be a great game for lineup reasons already.
This is why it was pretty surprising to me that in my eyes, it was mainly Calix, NeverUnlucky and Grackaroni that drove the game. Turns out they didn't do a really great job, however especially Grack was on point with his reads and his comments, creating a good atmosphere for town. While NeverUnlucky managed to get townread by the most, I think his tone and also the way he went at other people didn't do much for town - the atmosphere all game felt like "wow, this is town going ham on other town", and at no point I as an observer felt like Scum were in danger to lose that game.
Other factors like Palmar and Marvellosity being afk for long times also nurtured the scum win but especially Koshi played a great game in my perception. Regarding justanothertownie: being the most active scum by far, I think he did a good job in driving a mislynch and averting lynch attempts that were aimed towards him. Still, having access to host QT, I think it would help jat to take a step back from the game and not be ad hom towards his teammates but that's just my impression.
Overall, everyone did a good job, Oats being the lurky scum, Koshi the medium active/"I'm townread by everyone anyways" and justanothertownie as "I create chaos where I can and keep them busy". Strong performance supported by a replacement that was sub-par (which I had taken Slam but yeah, I learnt from that).
Regarding hosting: Rels was absolutely great. We also had Vivax as a co-host but he kind of disappeared for most of the game. Rels however was not only a big help in solving potential resolution scenarios but also in other issues, including "how to handle actions that are against the spirit of the game", taking over the night post when I was tired as fuck, and being overall available and reachable for questions and feedback at pretty much any point in the game.It was really great to have him as a co-host and I really, really, really loved it.
Regarding the fluff: when the game started, I was ill (and had been ill for several days if not a full week already). There was sadly no way for me to do the writing. I did have the time but not the concentration needed to do it as writing in english can be quite hard for someone who's no native speaker - sorry for that again.
We had some issues with NeverUnlucky and his mod confirmation stuff. We decided to not modkill however after a good discussion and NU followed up to our inquiries in good ways, so we were able to resolve that trouble - good shit. Nevertheless, a warning was issued as it didn't go too well initially.
Okay! So, what have I as a host learned from this game? Here we go:
PMs Second game I host, second game PM stuff makes problems. I will add the following to my ruleset: "Do not talk about PMs in the slightest. No warning will be issued, but there will be blood." Or something like that.
Night action resolving I will add a section to my next OP containing how exactly night actions are being resolved.
Questions to host Questions will no longer be allowed to be asked ingame. All questions must be posted via PM to the hosts.
resolution period For convenience reasons, I will have a 30 minute resolution period before EoN.
Encryption I will not allow any form of out-of-game communication or encryption in my games. This is included in the standard mafia OP, however for reasons I do not know, it was not part of my OP.
So, yeah - thank you all for playing, and I hope I'll see you guys in more games.
|
There was only one situation that could possibly be seen as "ad hom" towards a teammate. That was when I called oats an idiot for being an idiot. And I was 100 % right in that case and it was important to get him to do the obviously right thing so taking a step back would have been bad. Just sayin.
|
Great hosting once again. Thank you.
|
On October 17 2016 03:38 Koshi wrote: Great hosting once again. Thank you.
|
|
|
|