On February 26 2016 02:54 Kuragari42 wrote:
As promised, here are my evaluations/reads for Cell D:
FF - Town.
VA - Early game: Spews off random reads w/o reasons. Preempt threat to shape.
Post 321: Setup actually follows this. + Show Spoiler +
Adamant on SL being mafia.
Post 620: Goofs percents. + Show Spoiler +
Post 636: Antagonizes darth for something he didn't even say. + Show Spoiler +
Post 730: Complete lie. Only me and darth were voting him at the time and he wasn't even scum reading me. + Show Spoiler +
748, you ignore him so he's not mafia? In response to darthfoley asking + Show Spoiler +
+ Show Spoiler +
751/758 bum confusion. Seems like a weak excuse but it is possible.
Post 805: Claims he is going to do something, never does it nor gives excuse. + Show Spoiler +
Post 955: What? If you are going to be confirmed town, why would you not get your non-mafia opinion out as much as you could? + Show Spoiler +
Breshke - Questions, questions, questions. Post 554 sus VA as scum and FF as town. Whole lotta nothing.
To sum up my reads, they both look scum. VA for bad posts and Breshke for doing jack nothing.
As promised, here are my evaluations/reads for Cell D:
FF - Town.
VA - Early game: Spews off random reads w/o reasons. Preempt threat to shape.
Post 321: Setup actually follows this. + Show Spoiler +
Arguably mafia has the most influence early with 5 members in the game so I would say the best thing to do is put a shit cell first and use a power and then follow that up with 2 easy ones. then 4th cell hard again then 5th should be a very easy one because only they will be in the game. You can feel out the harder ones mid game
Adamant on SL being mafia.
Post 620: Goofs percents. + Show Spoiler +
iim just waiting for ritoky to 50/50 this thing I dont feel like analyzing this shit if i have a 33% of being removed from the game immediately
Post 636: Antagonizes darth for something he didn't even say. + Show Spoiler +
On February 25 2016 01:35 darthfoley wrote:
No, he doesn't HAVE to be scum. The reason I think 50/50 would be quite beneficial on this group is simply because all three of the players have been underwhelming. I don't think any of them have added useful town discussion, so I consider this cell a crap shoot with VA/FF feeling more scummy than Breshke.
I'm unsure about FF right now because I have to accept the fact that only 1 out of 3 players in this meh scummy cell is scum.
So by proxy are you scum? if you truly believe that being underwhelming to discussion is what makes people scummy, then you must be scum right?
No, he doesn't HAVE to be scum. The reason I think 50/50 would be quite beneficial on this group is simply because all three of the players have been underwhelming. I don't think any of them have added useful town discussion, so I consider this cell a crap shoot with VA/FF feeling more scummy than Breshke.
I'm unsure about FF right now because I have to accept the fact that only 1 out of 3 players in this meh scummy cell is scum.
So by proxy are you scum? if you truly believe that being underwhelming to discussion is what makes people scummy, then you must be scum right?
Post 730: Complete lie. Only me and darth were voting him at the time and he wasn't even scum reading me. + Show Spoiler +
its not coincidence that all the people i have as scum are voting me, its because they are scum lol
748, you ignore him so he's not mafia? In response to darthfoley asking + Show Spoiler +
To switch gears a bit, your post implies that you can't be convinced that LS is mafia, why?
+ Show Spoiler +
because reading his (LS) posts give me a migraine similar to alakaslam so i just ignore them
751/758 bum confusion. Seems like a weak excuse but it is possible.
Post 805: Claims he is going to do something, never does it nor gives excuse. + Show Spoiler +
ok well i clearly need to re-assess that cell, what the fuck is this rofl
Post 955: What? If you are going to be confirmed town, why would you not get your non-mafia opinion out as much as you could? + Show Spoiler +
its possible mafia are just sac'ing this cell since we used 50/50 on it and just having breshke say nothing so he doesnt spew any info. mafia talk about that stuff all the time. as a result i also would not give anyone too much cred on this cell as time progresses.
I don't really feel a need to post beyond this.
I don't really feel a need to post beyond this.
Breshke - Questions, questions, questions. Post 554 sus VA as scum and FF as town. Whole lotta nothing.
To sum up my reads, they both look scum. VA for bad posts and Breshke for doing jack nothing.
You came same conclusion that I did. That VA seems to be watching the clock and etc. And that Breshke is just, Urg. But I must ask, Do you think Darth looks more scummy or less scum if Breshke is town?
I actually like this thought process from you, The Last Readbender, keep it up.