|
On March 23 2014 23:30 Palmar wrote:Show nested quote +On March 23 2014 23:27 raynpelikoneet wrote:On March 23 2014 23:26 Palmar wrote:On March 23 2014 23:24 raynpelikoneet wrote: Like, if you do not believe Oats is mafia then you MUST believe Djodref is mafia because otherwise Oats' play makes no sense from town pov.
So we are not lynching Slam, we are lynching Oats or Djodref. I have no idea why this has to be true. Oats being town and wrong/bad on djodref is entirely possible. The only thing I think is highly unlikely is them both being scum. Oats is generally REALLY all over the place as town. He is not here. I doubt he has done nothing but bussed his teammate but it's entirely possible he has done nothing but tried to lynch a townie, because everybody was accusing mafia on D1. Yes I get that, the point I was making that if Oats is NOT mafia, that does not mean that Djodref is 100% mafia. I know. But he is scummier than Slam who at least sheeps right people. HE is scummier than VE who also sheeps right people. HE is scummier than everyone in this game, even by his own definition.
|
On March 23 2014 23:24 raynpelikoneet wrote: Like, if you do not believe Oats is mafia then you MUST believe Djodref is mafia because otherwise Oats' play makes no sense from town pov.
So we are not lynching Slam, we are lynching Oats or Djodref.
What if oats is town and wrong?
|
On March 22 2014 20:01 Djodref wrote: On a side note, I would say that mafia use the Luger on HF and the real kill on Koshi. Rayn was getting protected for sure so you want to shut down another town hero. If that's the case, I don't think HF kill is so relevant. But it means that Koshi list could be more threatening to mafia than, let's say, Palmar's list... Interesting...
Can we talk about this? Is this scummy?
I am bothered by it.
|
Do I have to ##unvote in paint as well? [/QUOTE]
Fuck it. I got already shot by mafia. I did my job.
|
On March 23 2014 23:34 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On March 22 2014 20:01 Djodref wrote: On a side note, I would say that mafia use the Luger on HF and the real kill on Koshi. Rayn was getting protected for sure so you want to shut down another town hero. If that's the case, I don't think HF kill is so relevant. But it means that Koshi list could be more threatening to mafia than, let's say, Palmar's list... Interesting...
Can we talk about this? Is this scummy? I am bothered by it.
Yes that is scummy. He is basically saying. No guys, this is what mafia did because I know because I am mafia. Rayn caught someone in titanic 2 for doing exactly that.
|
On March 23 2014 07:26 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On March 23 2014 06:53 raynpelikoneet wrote: No SK in this game.
And i don't honestly believe Oats thinks Djodref is mafia because that would mean mafia did absolutely nothing on D1 and we had three viable lynch targets and all were mafia. That's just bullshit. I dont see why this is so totally unlikely, all 3 pushes were started by different people. Also none of the scum were on Djo, the only possible other lynch so why would they want townDjo to live and Scum Vivax/GT to die? This is what i don't get, at all. Mafia bussed D1, it's clear (assuming Oats is town like he says). Why did mafia bus godfather and roleblocker over Djodref? Like if you are mafia set on one of your own getting lynched on D1 i would have had Djodref claim scum so i can have my GF/roleblocker alive on N1.
|
Things I don't like about djodref: 1) entered game with strange case on rayn. (ignoring meta + the seal thing was strange) 2) dropped it after rereading the entire thread. 3) Made friends with everybody 4) Made a very brave list in which he put DP, thrawn and Hopeless as town. He puts Palmar as null. 5) His reaction to Palmar null read. "It is because Palmar is going after GT and I think GT is town, but if GT is scum I put you on town hero level Palmar". GT was likely scum on djodref list. 6) Oats tunnel. "He is not interested in anybody else today" = scum mentality.
|
It has been decided. I am on djodref again.
|
Point 5 is really good btw. Makes it obvious djodref doesn't have more than 1 scumread except his "tunnel".
|
Well i can lynch Djodref too. He is not doing anything. I just don't believe mafia team is that stupid.
|
On March 23 2014 23:46 Koshi wrote: Point 5 is really good btw. Makes it obvious djodref doesn't have more than 1 scumread except his "tunnel". So does Oats have more than 1 scumread?
|
Oats/Slam/djof needs to be checked lynched anyway I feel like.
The NK are really strange though. If those are scum. Why Holyflare? For them it makes no sense.
|
On March 23 2014 23:47 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On March 23 2014 23:46 Koshi wrote: Point 5 is really good btw. Makes it obvious djodref doesn't have more than 1 scumread except his "tunnel". So does Oats have more than 1 scumread? Nope. Oats can be lynched as well. But I feel like Oats might be easier to read later?
Just vote which one you want. I think that is best. Oats can easily be scum. I just prefer djof atm.
|
Holyflare kill makes no sense to anyone but DarthPunk as i have said.
|
On March 22 2014 08:45 DarthPunk wrote: OK caught up with the thread.
SOme thoughts:
Ve is totes town. Here is why.
His analysis of holyflare's case was spot on. He clearly read through the case at each point, then read my filter and drew a good conclusion from it.
Which is more than I can say for people who are confirmed town like Koshi.
His rage out felt very 'town ve' in a similar way to the reason I called him town correctly in the shadow podcast.
Rayn. You also called VE town in the podcast. Do you agree with my assessment of his alignment right now?
I don't know what the fuck the scum team is doing LOL. Why would they shoot holyflare. I was certainly going to try and lynch him today. Several others had expressed doubt as to his alignment. I think it is clear the scum team are playing like scrubs.
Nice shot whoever the vig is. (certainly not Holyflare ahahahahahah)
Koshi now that people have flipped has your read on me changed? Why/why not?
Djo you said that there was one scum between myself and holyflare. Now that holy has flipped town you should be pressuring me correct?
Why have you not mentioned me nor that read at all.
This is really werid because i already claimed vigi. It reads more as "idk what to say" than anything.
|
Yep. I think djo is much more likely to be scum than oats.
Slam is a pain though.
|
On March 23 2014 23:52 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On March 22 2014 08:45 DarthPunk wrote: OK caught up with the thread.
SOme thoughts:
Ve is totes town. Here is why.
His analysis of holyflare's case was spot on. He clearly read through the case at each point, then read my filter and drew a good conclusion from it.
Which is more than I can say for people who are confirmed town like Koshi.
His rage out felt very 'town ve' in a similar way to the reason I called him town correctly in the shadow podcast.
Rayn. You also called VE town in the podcast. Do you agree with my assessment of his alignment right now?
I don't know what the fuck the scum team is doing LOL. Why would they shoot holyflare. I was certainly going to try and lynch him today. Several others had expressed doubt as to his alignment. I think it is clear the scum team are playing like scrubs.
Nice shot whoever the vig is. (certainly not Holyflare ahahahahahah)
Koshi now that people have flipped has your read on me changed? Why/why not?
Djo you said that there was one scum between myself and holyflare. Now that holy has flipped town you should be pressuring me correct?
Why have you not mentioned me nor that read at all.
This is really werid because i already claimed vigi. It reads more as "idk what to say" than anything.
I missed it obviously. The thread is quite long and to be honest I started skimming after day one.
|
On March 23 2014 23:49 raynpelikoneet wrote: Holyflare kill makes no sense to anyone but DarthPunk as i have said. Yes, but Palmar/VE could kill Holyflare and it isn't a real problem. Especially if I die as well. It puts them on the background when it is time to "lynch the vets" and DP front row.
But if it is only Oats/GT/Slam/djof... GT just lost his tunnel. Thread gets cleaner because the DP vs Holyflare townfight isn't happening.
Strange.
|
On March 23 2014 23:53 Koshi wrote:Show nested quote +On March 23 2014 23:49 raynpelikoneet wrote: Holyflare kill makes no sense to anyone but DarthPunk as i have said. Yes, but Palmar/VE could kill Holyflare and it isn't a real problem. Especially if I die as well. It puts them on the background when it is time to "lynch the vets" and DP front row. But if it is only Oats/GT/Slam/djof... GT just lost his tunnel. Thread gets cleaner because the DP vs Holyflare townfight isn't happening. Strange. No in that case you shoot DarthPunk who noone thinks is mafia except for Holyflare.
|
On March 23 2014 23:49 raynpelikoneet wrote: Holyflare kill makes no sense to anyone but DarthPunk as i have said.
And I have pointed out why that is an unreasonable conclusion. Holyflare being alive was much better for scum!DP. He looked increasingly ridiculous and was not getting me lynched. Why not continue to crap up the thread with him? Perhaps scum tried to frame me. Perhaps they think Holy is a good player. (for some reason) perhaps they aren't reading the thread properly and just saw a vig claim and blue sniped.
Who knows. But I DO know that there is not just ONE explanation.
If you think I am scum find some evidence that is not NK wifom, or get the cop to check me preferably.
|
|
|
|