Something like the voting system we used for map contests back in the day at broodwarmaps.net would be great, where you could give 5, 3 and 1 (I think) points respectively to up to 3 different maps.

sixfour

England11061 Posts

May 12 2015 12:53 GMT

#42

am i right in thinking ecosphere has fixed spawns?

edit - just checked the other thread and it is. can't anyone make a 2+ player map anymore?

The_Templar

your Country52797 Posts

May 12 2015 12:58 GMT

#43

On May 12 2015 20:57 ejozl wrote:
I have a real hard time deciding what to vote for here, they all look pretty cool and different.

It looks like Noah's Ark have super annoying lighting, making it harder to see stuff, can anyone confirm?

I watched a game or two on it, didn't seem that bad.

Ej_

47656 Posts

May 12 2015 13:02 GMT

#44

On May 12 2015 21:58 The_Templar wrote:

Show nested quote +

I watched a game or two on it, didn't seem that bad.

it's fine, but don't vote it!

The_Templar

your Country52797 Posts

May 12 2015 13:03 GMT

#45

On May 12 2015 22:02 Ej_ wrote:

Show nested quote +

it's fine, but don't vote it!

Yeah, vote Mutiny instead.

Randomaccount#77123

United States5003 Posts

May 12 2015 13:08 GMT

#46

--- Nuked ---

Obsi

87 Posts

May 12 2015 13:32 GMT

#47

Where is the "All suck" option? They're all pretty retarded tbh. The current map pool showed us what backrocks in your main and gold bases are good for. Stupid games and even more stupid all ins.

[PkF] Wire

France24238 Posts

May 12 2015 13:35 GMT

#48

Terraform is the most solid map by a mile. Got my vote without a second of doubt.

PS : who the hell turned that contest in a backdoors festival ?

Psychotikah

Canada101 Posts

May 12 2015 13:44 GMT

#49

I don't like these maps

.

They are nice looking and I am sure the makers did put a lot of effort into them but they seem very silly.

Terraform is decent though. It gets my vote. Maybe it's a blast to play on.

The natural choke is pretty wide though. Oh well.

Good luck!

Dingodile

4139 Posts

May 12 2015 13:56 GMT

#50

On May 12 2015 22:32 Obsi wrote:
Where is the "All suck" option? They're all pretty retarded tbh. The current map pool showed us what backrocks in your main and gold bases are good for. Stupid games and even more stupid all ins.

Hardcounter units and FF are the main reasons why all maps since 2011 are pretty similar. The biggest difference begins the position at 4th base but however most are the same again.
I feel bad for mapmakers and blizzard did a very horrible job around this.

Great example is Cloud Kingdom and Daybreak, first 3 bases are on the most boring places, the 4th are on most interesting places. Another thing is the biggest stalement begins shortly before you take the 4th base (on all maps), thats why many ppl think the position of 4th base isnt important because the stalement is superior (less superior on Cloud kingdom and Daybreak).

Salteador Neo

Andorra5591 Posts

May 12 2015 14:00 GMT

#51

Voted Terraform, it just seems more interesting and looks better than the rest

Ej_

47656 Posts

May 12 2015 14:03 GMT

#52

On May 12 2015 22:08 Barrin wrote:
I can't bring myself to vote for Noah's Ark until I see some ZvP's or ZvT's on it.

a ZvT starts here around 1h 25min http://www.twitch.tv/basetradetv/v/4892173

Superouman

France2195 Posts

May 12 2015 14:12 GMT

#53

On May 12 2015 21:49 Freakling wrote:

Show nested quote +

Something like the voting system we used for map contests back in the day at broodwarmaps.net would be great, where you could give 5, 3 and 1 (I think) points respectively to up to 3 different maps.

Oh hi freakling, nice to see you around!

On May 12 2015 22:02 Ej_ wrote:

Show nested quote +

it's fine, but don't vote it!

Nyu, why you lobby against it

Vote for terraform, it will win anyway

The lighting is standard, check your screen options.

Barrin, go play some games with the right mu

Cricketer12

United States13994 Posts

May 12 2015 14:16 GMT

#54

Bridgehead for all that BW nostalgia

Cricketer12

United States13994 Posts

May 12 2015 14:17 GMT

#55

On May 12 2015 22:03 The_Templar wrote:

Show nested quote +

Yeah, vote Mutiny instead.

Lets just vote for Cactus Valley again. Because it is that hype.

Ej_

47656 Posts

May 12 2015 14:30 GMT

#56

ok all in all, I voted Ecosphere. I think it has the most standard base layout out of all bases and it plays out very fun, not forcing people into either strategies.

NasusAndDraven

359 Posts

May 12 2015 14:48 GMT

#57

i just noticed the random vespene geysers at the center area of the map of ecosphere . lol whats the point did the desinger think they will ever be taken? if you are so much ahead that you can mine from there, then you can just finish enemy trough the trillion entrances their base has

zerge

Germany162 Posts

May 12 2015 14:50 GMT

#58

After playing a few games on these maps i have to say that i don't like any them of very much. Ecosphere seems to be most tolerable map even though it's full of rocks. Bridgehead seems to be good for zerg which might not be the worst considering the recent nerf to swarmhost.
I can not understand why Noah's Ark would ever make it into the voting, the 3rd and 4th base are so easily defendable and the narrow path in the middle is easily abusable against zerg.

Pyloss

Germany1515 Posts

May 12 2015 15:09 GMT

#59

Taff call, for me its close between Dash and Terminal and Ecosphere. Both are pretty and nice to play on. Tock the first one in the end.

KalWarkov

Germany4126 Posts

May 12 2015 16:00 GMT

#60

so many cool ideas, but from going over the maps briefly and imagining high level games on them, only Noah's Ark and Terraform seem playable.

Noah's Ark is probably the better map of both, but Terraform is a bit more innovative, so it gets my vote. expansions / defending them is very awkward or even impossible on some maps unfortionally - allins way too strong