|
IMO this decay is great and I wish it would happen more. Muddles with everything, sure, and there are a lot of fucked up ranks, sure, but what is good is that you can experiment and formulate solid builds while moving back up again - sort of like Day9's podcast on playing weaker players ^^.
Enjoy it, because this is the one chance you have to truly start testing and experimenting on the ladder in a less cutthroat environment. And if you're really as good as you say (masters to silver, lol - it was an inactive period of 9 MONTHS -_-) then you should zoom back up in no time!
I think the way everything is all fucked up and players of all different leagues are everywhich place is a valid complaint though. Comes with not being able to RESET your league -_-.
|
On December 05 2013 04:40 Qwyn wrote: IMO this decay is great and I wish it would happen more. Muddles with everything, sure, and there are a lot of fucked up ranks, sure, but what is good is that you can experiment and formulate solid builds while moving back up again - sort of like Day9's podcast on playing weaker players ^^.
Enjoy it, because this is the one chance you have to truly start testing and experimenting on the ladder in a less cutthroat environment. And if you're really as good as you say (masters to silver, lol - it was an inactive period of 9 MONTHS -_-) then you should zoom back up in no time!
I think the way everything is all fucked up and players of all different leagues are everywhich place is a valid complaint though. Comes with not being able to RESET your league -_-.
You're thinking exactly the opposite of what's happening. Everyone in lower leagues is now a much higher skill level then they used to be, so it's even more "cut-throat" then before
|
On December 05 2013 04:40 Qwyn wrote: IMO this decay is great and I wish it would happen more. Muddles with everything, sure, and there are a lot of fucked up ranks, sure, but what is good is that you can experiment and formulate solid builds while moving back up again - sort of like Day9's podcast on playing weaker players ^^.
Enjoy it, because this is the one chance you have to truly start testing and experimenting on the ladder in a less cutthroat environment. And if you're really as good as you say (masters to silver, lol - it was an inactive period of 9 MONTHS -_-) then you should zoom back up in no time!
I think the way everything is all fucked up and players of all different leagues are everywhich place is a valid complaint though. Comes with not being able to RESET your league -_-.
It's a good thing that something like an unranked mode doesn't invalidate your entire post.
|
On December 05 2013 04:19 synapse wrote:Show nested quote +On November 28 2013 07:17 Excalibur_Z wrote:On November 28 2013 07:03 synapse wrote:On November 27 2013 22:26 iPhoneAppz wrote:On November 27 2013 20:10 Cascade wrote:On November 27 2013 05:02 iPhoneAppz wrote: Blizzard should just display your MMR and your opponent's MMR on the loading screen like it's a chess rating. Then, you'd know exactly what you are up against. They should also set, and make public, MMR levels for promotion to each league so you always know where you stand. Except that with the current decay rates, you would still ave no idea what you are up against, as MMR is not a good measure of skill for a lot of people.  I do agree with you though. Only that step one has to make MMR represent skill in a decent way. Which it did (better) before the decay patch. I totally agree. As far as MMR decay goes, as others have mentioned, I think that it's OK but it should decay at a much slower rate. slower and also have a limit. a former masters player not playing for a year ends up in bronze. sure they're probably not still masters level but cmon the poor bronze players that have to face them... There is a limit. Whether you're inactive 4 weeks or 14 weeks you still drop the same amount. The scenario where you don't play for a year would result in playing 5 placement matches meaning no prior MMR history and a clean slate. i went from diamond -> bronze after about 4 or 5 months of inactivity, never got a reset. You should be running the standard MMR Plugin and post the results. Such as you describe it, nothing can be gleaned. I'm guessing you mean us to say that after 16 weeks of activity, it only gave you one placement match and simultaneously the previous match you played 16 weeks ago was known to be a diamond MMR?
|
On December 05 2013 04:42 ffadicted wrote:Show nested quote +On December 05 2013 04:40 Qwyn wrote: IMO this decay is great and I wish it would happen more. Muddles with everything, sure, and there are a lot of fucked up ranks, sure, but what is good is that you can experiment and formulate solid builds while moving back up again - sort of like Day9's podcast on playing weaker players ^^.
Enjoy it, because this is the one chance you have to truly start testing and experimenting on the ladder in a less cutthroat environment. And if you're really as good as you say (masters to silver, lol - it was an inactive period of 9 MONTHS -_-) then you should zoom back up in no time!
I think the way everything is all fucked up and players of all different leagues are everywhich place is a valid complaint though. Comes with not being able to RESET your league -_-. You're thinking exactly the opposite of what's happening. Everyone in lower leagues is now a much higher skill level then they used to be, so it's even more "cut-throat" then before
You're both right, I think. Previously inactives players (with heavily decayed mmr) can enjoy the testing ground Qwyn is referring to. Active players (with undecayed MMR) are now in a very cutthroat environment where they are often matched against people well above their skill level, potentially pushing them down in the MMR rankings.
edit: And this, 
It's a good thing that something like an unranked mode doesn't invalidate your entire post.
|
Well I played a bunch tonight (I'd had roughly a 2-month hiatus up to a week ago). Absolutely stomped most of my games. Lost two, one to a 6 or 7 pool that I miscontrolled against (I think he was a former higher player that dropped down too actually) and one to a marine all-in that I wouldn't have lost to if I'd not screwed my build up or actually bothered to scout at all (yeah, I know, got lazy).
Its just not even fair on the people I'm playing honestly. One PvP I went for a weird proxy oracle in parallel with a 4-gate + Void ray thing. My opponent had two sentries, one stalker and a couple of zealots as well as 2 gates built and two just finishing when I rolled in with about a dozen gateway units, a void ray and an oracle to tear up his mineral line. I felt really bad for the guy. :-\
|
Been trying to get from silver into gold for the past couple of weeks. Been doing well enough to find myself hanging around top 8 silver, but every time a promotion seems close, I get "low Gold" players that were frequently platinum or even diamond just 1-2 seasons ago. Very demoralizing, except for those that have been giving me tips on how to improve as fast as possible so I can reach gold by the season lock.
On one hand, I like the idea that I am getting better because I am constantly pushing myself to the limit against people that are quite frankly way better than me, but having 4 crippling losses in a row and knowing there was nothing I could have done about it is frustrating.
|
On December 05 2013 04:40 Qwyn wrote: IMO this decay is great and I wish it would happen more. Muddles with everything, sure, and there are a lot of fucked up ranks, sure, but what is good is that you can experiment and formulate solid builds while moving back up again - sort of like Day9's podcast on playing weaker players ^^.
Enjoy it, because this is the one chance you have to truly start testing and experimenting on the ladder in a less cutthroat environment. And if you're really as good as you say (masters to silver, lol - it was an inactive period of 9 MONTHS -_-) then you should zoom back up in no time!
I think the way everything is all fucked up and players of all different leagues are everywhich place is a valid complaint though. Comes with not being able to RESET your league -_-. Zoom back in no time? You have to stomp/win like 100games just to get from silver to diamond. If you only play for fun it takes quite a while. Especially if you want to play with friends once in a while.
|
Ladder is for grinding games, if you aren't playing a few hundred games a season you shouldn't expect to be in the top leagues.
|
On December 05 2013 16:00 Soldier92 wrote: Ladder is for grinding games, if you aren't playing a few hundred games a season you shouldn't expect to be in the top leagues. If you're good enough, yes, you should. Starcraft is not an MMORPG :D
|
A few hundred games is more than enough to keep your MMR up, and is not a lot to ask over the long ladder seasons. Remember, who you're playing and beating is more important than your actual ladder rank and league.
|
On December 05 2013 16:05 Soldier92 wrote: A few hundred games is more than enough to keep your MMR up, and is not a lot to ask over the long ladder seasons. Remember, who you're playing and beating is more important than your actual ladder rank and league. I was talking about how many games you'd have to win in order to get back/climb four leagues. The guys said "..you should zoom back up in no time!" and 100games (with pretty much no losses) is not "no time".
|
On December 05 2013 15:21 Eatme wrote:Show nested quote +On December 05 2013 04:40 Qwyn wrote: IMO this decay is great and I wish it would happen more. Muddles with everything, sure, and there are a lot of fucked up ranks, sure, but what is good is that you can experiment and formulate solid builds while moving back up again - sort of like Day9's podcast on playing weaker players ^^.
Enjoy it, because this is the one chance you have to truly start testing and experimenting on the ladder in a less cutthroat environment. And if you're really as good as you say (masters to silver, lol - it was an inactive period of 9 MONTHS -_-) then you should zoom back up in no time!
I think the way everything is all fucked up and players of all different leagues are everywhich place is a valid complaint though. Comes with not being able to RESET your league -_-. Zoom back in no time? You have to stomp/win like 100games just to get from silver to diamond. If you only play for fun it takes quite a while. Especially if you want to play with friends once in a while.
Yes, this is exactly right. Plus, think about the people (like me) that you're stomping. It's no fun for them and they are not learning or getting better while being stomped by players that should be 4 leagues higher.
|
On December 05 2013 15:04 starcraftidiot wrote: Been trying to get from silver into gold for the past couple of weeks. Been doing well enough to find myself hanging around top 8 silver, but every time a promotion seems close, I get "low Gold" players that were frequently platinum or even diamond just 1-2 seasons ago. Very demoralizing, except for those that have been giving me tips on how to improve as fast as possible so I can reach gold by the season lock.
On one hand, I like the idea that I am getting better because I am constantly pushing myself to the limit against people that are quite frankly way better than me, but having 4 crippling losses in a row and knowing there was nothing I could have done about it is frustrating.
This is exactly my situation too. I love this game. I love to feel like I'm improving. I love getting matches where I win 50% and lose 50% because the wins make me feel good, like I'm improving and the losses point me to things that I can improve to get better. The problem is when I face a player that should be leagues above me and I lose embarrassingly and don't learn anything because I was totally outclassed. The reason why the SC matchmaking system has historically been so great is because you could always find a game against a relatively evenly matched opponent. When Blizzard put the MMR decay in, they broke that. Now, I don't know if I'm going to get an even match, or matched up against someone wildly better than I am with just a 'decayed' MMR.
|
On December 05 2013 21:57 iPhoneAppz wrote:Show nested quote +On December 05 2013 15:21 Eatme wrote:On December 05 2013 04:40 Qwyn wrote: IMO this decay is great and I wish it would happen more. Muddles with everything, sure, and there are a lot of fucked up ranks, sure, but what is good is that you can experiment and formulate solid builds while moving back up again - sort of like Day9's podcast on playing weaker players ^^.
Enjoy it, because this is the one chance you have to truly start testing and experimenting on the ladder in a less cutthroat environment. And if you're really as good as you say (masters to silver, lol - it was an inactive period of 9 MONTHS -_-) then you should zoom back up in no time!
I think the way everything is all fucked up and players of all different leagues are everywhich place is a valid complaint though. Comes with not being able to RESET your league -_-. Zoom back in no time? You have to stomp/win like 100games just to get from silver to diamond. If you only play for fun it takes quite a while. Especially if you want to play with friends once in a while. Yes, this is exactly right. Plus, think about the people (like me) that you're stomping. It's no fun for them and they are not learning or getting better while being stomped by players that should be 4 leagues higher. And I for one get tired of stomping others well before I am back on my correct MMR.
|
Just to add another point... It's also depressing that, if you're stomped by someone that is way more skilled, you usually shouldn't drop too far down in MMR, because you're expected to lose. Yet you are dropped as far as if you'd lost aginst someone on your skill level. And on the other side, if you'd happen to win (for whatever strange coincidence), you should climb up a lot more, because you were expected to lose. Yet you just climb a bit like when you'd won against someone on your skill level.
|
I barely played for the past 6 months, got placed in diamond and played 10ish games and was back in masters. For me the mmr decay was just a good thing, and no tedious grind ;o
|
On December 06 2013 19:45 BurningRanger wrote: Just to add another point... It's also depressing that, if you're stomped by someone that is way more skilled, you usually shouldn't drop too far down in MMR, because you're expected to lose. Yet you are dropped as far as if you'd lost aginst someone on your skill level. And on the other side, if you'd happen to win (for whatever strange coincidence), you should climb up a lot more, because you were expected to lose. Yet you just climb a bit like when you'd won against someone on your skill level.
Yes. It's essentially the same thing as mass smurfing.
|
On December 05 2013 04:42 ffadicted wrote:Show nested quote +On December 05 2013 04:40 Qwyn wrote: IMO this decay is great and I wish it would happen more. Muddles with everything, sure, and there are a lot of fucked up ranks, sure, but what is good is that you can experiment and formulate solid builds while moving back up again - sort of like Day9's podcast on playing weaker players ^^.
Enjoy it, because this is the one chance you have to truly start testing and experimenting on the ladder in a less cutthroat environment. And if you're really as good as you say (masters to silver, lol - it was an inactive period of 9 MONTHS -_-) then you should zoom back up in no time!
I think the way everything is all fucked up and players of all different leagues are everywhich place is a valid complaint though. Comes with not being able to RESET your league -_-. You're thinking exactly the opposite of what's happening. Everyone in lower leagues is now a much higher skill level then they used to be, so it's even more "cut-throat" then before Remember how everyone complained how shitty the SC2 ladder distribution was compared to iccup?
|
Does a team game count as being active overall to stop decaying of 1v1 and vice versa?
|
|
|
|