|
Knock off the SC2 vs BW vs LoL vs whatever crap please. |
On March 25 2012 02:18 lottopk wrote: Its inevitable. Everything must progress and bw is getting old.
User was warned for this post
dunno y you got warned but i agree. good to hear a pro league in KR is finally coming.. even if i already considered GSL to be one :-P
|
On March 25 2012 09:06 Jongl0 wrote: Sad to see BW going but I guess it can't go on forever.
Atleast we got 10+ year, what does your sc2 have do you think you'll have? after your 'last expansion' maybe 2 or 3 years? 4 at the highest? pretty pathetic, if you ask me.
|
On March 25 2012 05:12 Xiphos wrote:Show nested quote +On March 25 2012 05:10 Clbull wrote:On March 25 2012 02:18 lottopk wrote: Its inevitable. Everything must progress and bw is getting old.
User was warned for this post I don't see why he's been warned for this post. No offence but Brood War is very dated in terms of many things: - Graphics look so dated that the game could probably have been ported to the SNES with little trouble.
- In terms of gameplay mechnics and controls, the game is more tedious to play than Kid Icarus: Uprising (a recently released brilliant game that is sadly hampered by terrible controls.) Remember that Brood War is from an era where the concepts of having more than 12 units or 1 building in a control group didn't exist and smart casting wasn't even implemented. To call Brood War a mechanically nice game to play would be a complete lie. Larger control groups didn't arrive until Age of Empires 2 in 1999.
- Every other country's e-sports scene has virtually abanadoned Brood War. Currently, iCCup and Garena are the only remaining popular ladder choices, it's been dropped as a World Cyber Games event and many ex-BW pros have switched either to LoL or SC2.
- For the last 14 years of Brood War's existence, South Korea has been entirely dominating in the e-sport to the point where there's virtually no way for a non-Korean to compete in Korea.
And that's not the same as SC2? Seriously, SC2 is dominated just as much by the Korean than in BW.
Playerwise, Koreans are still generally the best in the world, but foreigners are FAR better off than they were in BW. We have live English casters and multiple events that are primarily English as opposed to Korean. SC2 is more foreigner friendly than BW. By no means is it equal, but it sure is more friendly.
|
On March 25 2012 02:18 lottopk wrote: Its inevitable. Everything must progress and bw is getting old.
User was warned for this post Lol why the fuck was he warned for this?!?! Seems like a good opinion imo.
|
your Country52797 Posts
Hmm, I don't see the point of getting rid of such a beloved game as BW unless it's being shown to be detrimental to eSports... and I'm pretty sure it's not. EDIT:
Lol why the fuck was he warned for this?!?! Seems like a good opinion imo.
He was probably warned because either: 1. It was a one line post that didn't add anything to the discussion. 2. It was a one line post in a long history of one line posts. 3. It was a one line post that mods felt would derail the thread or lead to excess flaming.
|
On March 25 2012 08:12 AnachronisticAnarchy wrote:Show nested quote +On March 25 2012 03:21 Marti wrote:On March 25 2012 02:36 avilo wrote: One side of me is saying, "good, people need to move on from brood war it's an old game. Baseball is over 100 years old, is one side of you saying " people need to move on from baseball it's an old game" ? So what's your point ? Comparing physical sports and the effects of aging to electronic sports and the effects of aging on them is, well, ineffective. In physical sports, they only get better with age due to things like enhanced gear and viewing equipment due to technological advancements; however, electronic sports are constantly recycled because that very technological advancement means that games become obsolete. Let's be honest here: BW looks like shit and has horrible, horrible AI and poor methods of controlling your units compared to modern standards. Furthermore, the playerbase has been steadily consolidated to the truly good players, meaning that anyone who does happen to see a shitty looking game and still wants to play it will soon be deterred from playing anyways due to being endlessly slaughtered. That means that the playerbase and fanbase will steadily atrophy away, causing a slow death for the video game. These factors have been the cause of death for many eSPORTS. There is no reason to believe the cycle will stop just because BW has an incredibly hardcore fanbase. You aren't the first, and you won't be the last.
No, i am being honest, BW does not " look like shit " and compared to sc2's cartoony, WAR3-ish grahpics, it's still pretty decent. And the fact that there are good players is a pro, not a con. THE GRAPHICS BECOME OBSOLETE THE GAMEPLAY DOES NOT. That's like saying mozart sucks because now we have technology and dubstep. Did you know that, even today, you have amateur houses where people pay to live and be trained by coaches so they can become progamers ? CS 1.6 does not look dead to me, source has never beat 1.6 in any aspect. So i don't really see this "death of many eSPORTS" and "electronic sports being constantly recycled". We might still be playing 1.5 if they hadn't shut down the WON system. The reason why mbcgame was shut down, and the viewers have dropped, is mostly the match fixing scandal. So no, there is no reason to " recycle " games like that, all you really need is a way to get the newer generation to play it, and guess what, having brood war on a freaking TV channel just might be the best way to do that. The problem, the real reason why people don't play so called esports games, is because most people don't know about them. How does the average teenager hears of quakelive, cs 1.6 or brood war ???? He sure as hell will know when the latest call of duty is released, but esports is mostly a niche.
|
BW is soo much better, but it will be nice to see the BW pros switch to SC2.
i mean OGSFin is a fantastic player to watch. that game 1 vs leenock in GSL 2012 season 1 is probably my fave SC2 game so far.
if other BW pros can crop games like those up in SC2 then i will welcome their arrive with open arms.
|
On March 25 2012 09:09 shaftofpleasure wrote:Show nested quote +On March 25 2012 09:06 Jongl0 wrote: Sad to see BW going but I guess it can't go on forever. Atleast we got 10+ year, what does your sc2 have do you think you'll have? after your 'last expansion' maybe 2 or 3 years? 4 at the highest? pretty pathetic, if you ask me. You are the kind of a poster we don't need in this thread. Go bash on SC2 in reddit or something.
|
It kind of makes me worry for a few reasons. I never watched BW so that isn't one of them for me.
I wonder how this will pan out for GomTV. I know obviously they said it will still go on of course, but GSL is the only window into the top SC2 in the world. They'll lose that monopoly.
I would assume they'll have an English broadcast, I wonder who will cast it. GomTV has struggled with casters (in a way).
|
On March 25 2012 09:10 TehTemplar wrote:Hmm, I don't see the point of getting rid of such a beloved game as BW unless it's being shown to be detrimental to eSports... and I'm pretty sure it's not. EDIT: He was probably warned because either: 1. It was a one line post that didn't add anything to the discussion. 2. It was a one line post in a long history of one line posts. 3. It was a one line post that mods felt would derail the thread or lead to excess flaming.
Its probably just down to money. BW doesn't pull the same sponsorship dollars it used to so KeSPA has to diversify. I suspect they may not have to kill off BW though if SC2 joins Proleague.
As odd as this may sound to some, having Proleague bring in new SC2 viewers could see a boost in SCBW viewership if hardcore SC2 fans are able to appreciate SCBW level play quicker then an average fresh viewer. This could be a good thing for a globalization of BW interest and be kind of a shot in the arm if this is positioned right. The could definitely be cross over, unless KeSPA or the teams do want/have the resources to split up into two games and skill retain the level of skill and quality expected of them.
|
On March 25 2012 09:09 Poebes wrote:Show nested quote +On March 25 2012 02:18 lottopk wrote: Its inevitable. Everything must progress and bw is getting old.
User was warned for this post Lol why the fuck was he warned for this?!?! Seems like a good opinion imo.
Don't speak poorly of SC:BW. Articles like Elephant in the Room are fine, but mentioning BWs age is not.
+ Show Spoiler +J/k
And yeah don't worry I know elephant in the room was backed up with reasoning etc. There's a lot of people very touchy about BW so it's not the cleverest comment to make here.
|
On March 25 2012 07:57 StarStruck wrote:Show nested quote +On March 25 2012 07:55 Zato-1 wrote: If their handling of the BW scene is any indication, I'm not sure KeSPA getting involved in SC2 is a good thing for SC2. That could happen to any title man. Doesn't matter. If they're having a hard time finding new sponsors then there's really nothing else they can do about it. If a game gets really big, they cannot ignore it either. That's not what I meant. What I did mean is, I'm not a fan of all the KeSPA BW shenanigans- disqualifying players for not typing the proper request for a pause, boycotting the GomTV Intel Classic BW tournaments, creating a huge legal drama with Blizzard over Starcraft broadcasting rights, that kind of thing.
Just like how you can like music but not be a fan of the RIAA, I was once a fan of BW but disliked KeSPA; now, I am no longer a fan of BW, but I'm still wary of KeSPA.
|
On March 25 2012 05:16 InoyouS2 wrote:Show nested quote +On March 25 2012 05:13 HellionDrop wrote:On March 25 2012 05:03 TheTurk wrote:On March 25 2012 02:18 lottopk wrote: Its inevitable. Everything must progress and bw is getting old.
User was warned for this post Clearly you're an ignorant moron. BW has been around longer yes, but it is currently and in my opinion will and should always be present in the competitive scene. It's a different game. You'll find dozens of threads explaining and discussing this all over TL. Please do some research before you make stupidly obtuse statements on subjects you have no informational basis to comment on. lol, if nobody is watching BW then it will die. i don't know how many people in Korea still watch it, but if the numbers are high enough, there is no reason for them to shut it down. i don't know why so many sc2 fans want BW to fail, maybe they want all the BW pros to switch to sc2 so they can see how those BW legends fare against the current top players. None of the SC2 fans want BW to fail, NONE of them, the only positives for SC2 that come from it are possibly a few of the top dogs moving to SC2. However the people who want that are already fans of those players. There is a sad misconception that it seems a lot of the BW fans in this thread are holding onto; that SC2 fans are against BW.
From your experience, do a lot of BW fans actually think that? I mean, I find that perception to be... unusual, I guess would be the best word. I think most of us these days just follow the out of sight, out of mind mindset and are content with the current arrangement of separate games, forums and tournaments. It would be odd to find out that the majority of you guys actually think we hate BW.
|
On March 25 2012 09:12 Cokefreak wrote:Show nested quote +On March 25 2012 09:09 shaftofpleasure wrote:On March 25 2012 09:06 Jongl0 wrote: Sad to see BW going but I guess it can't go on forever. Atleast we got 10+ year, what does your sc2 have do you think you'll have? after your 'last expansion' maybe 2 or 3 years? 4 at the highest? pretty pathetic, if you ask me. You are the kind of a poster we don't need in this thread. Go bash on SC2 in reddit or something.
I'm just playing the 'inevitability' card here. And this isn't your thread nor your website so people don't have to follow you or your biases.
|
On March 25 2012 09:07 writer22816 wrote: I was wondering why all these trash posters weren't getting banned or even warned; then I realized this was the SC2 forums. Well, now that this thread is in "Community News" perhaps some fairer judgment can be taken? All you SC2 players don't know what you are missing out on if BW dies. If you were able to look past the dated graphics you would see that this game is superior to SC2 in pretty much every aspect. There is a reason why many people here are upset and it's not because of elitism or nostalgia. It's because we played and watched both games and think that BW is better.
If BW dies I'd rather watch LoL than SC2. Judging from this thread the LoL community is really not that worse than the SC2 community and I'd rather watch a different genre game than a bastardization of the greatest esport.
Just out of curiosity, how much SC2 have you played/watched. I'll admit that its neither is a perfect game, but I don't get your mindset. Even if BW were more skilled in every way and more entertaining, I'd still rather watch a similar game if it were to go away completely. Similarly, If all professional Hockey were to suddenly disappear, I'd rather watch an amateur league at the local rink than watch professional Soccer. Really, I don't consider this to be much better than anyone claiming "BW is too old, time to progress to SC2".
|
On March 25 2012 09:19 shaftofpleasure wrote:Show nested quote +On March 25 2012 09:12 Cokefreak wrote:On March 25 2012 09:09 shaftofpleasure wrote:On March 25 2012 09:06 Jongl0 wrote: Sad to see BW going but I guess it can't go on forever. Atleast we got 10+ year, what does your sc2 have do you think you'll have? after your 'last expansion' maybe 2 or 3 years? 4 at the highest? pretty pathetic, if you ask me. You are the kind of a poster we don't need in this thread. Go bash on SC2 in reddit or something. I'm just playing the 'inevitability' card here. And this isn't your thread nor your website so people don't have to follow you or your biases.
You're BW bias is showing...
|
On March 25 2012 09:19 shaftofpleasure wrote:Show nested quote +On March 25 2012 09:12 Cokefreak wrote:On March 25 2012 09:09 shaftofpleasure wrote:On March 25 2012 09:06 Jongl0 wrote: Sad to see BW going but I guess it can't go on forever. Atleast we got 10+ year, what does your sc2 have do you think you'll have? after your 'last expansion' maybe 2 or 3 years? 4 at the highest? pretty pathetic, if you ask me. You are the kind of a poster we don't need in this thread. Go bash on SC2 in reddit or something. I'm just playing the 'inevitability' card here. And this isn't your thread nor your website so people doesn't really have to follow you or your biases.
Its just a nod of respect to the game that this site was based upon and provided the foundation for SC2. BW fans are not stupid and they know BW cannot in all likelihood go on forever, but all the history and emotional investment never the less stings. So phrasing is kind of important when posting here compared to most other SC related sites. Talking about BW's relative decline isn't taboo so much as how people go about discussing it. You are entitled to your opinion, but also understand the environment you are posting.
Its like posting pictures of Lenardo Dicaprio in Nada's Body thread and saying Nada is a hideous chobo. You just dont do it unless your Hot Bid or Rekrul.
|
On March 25 2012 09:15 Torpedo.Vegas wrote:Show nested quote +On March 25 2012 09:10 TehTemplar wrote:Hmm, I don't see the point of getting rid of such a beloved game as BW unless it's being shown to be detrimental to eSports... and I'm pretty sure it's not. EDIT: Lol why the fuck was he warned for this?!?! Seems like a good opinion imo.
He was probably warned because either: 1. It was a one line post that didn't add anything to the discussion. 2. It was a one line post in a long history of one line posts. 3. It was a one line post that mods felt would derail the thread or lead to excess flaming. Its probably just down to money. BW doesn't pull the same sponsorship dollars it used to so KeSPA has to diversify. I suspect they may not have to kill off BW though if SC2 joins Proleague. As odd as this may sound to some, having Proleague bring in new SC2 viewers could see a boost in SCBW viewership if hardcore SC2 fans are able to appreciate SCBW level play quicker then an average fresh viewer. This could be a good thing for a globalization of BW interest and be kind of a shot in the arm if this is positioned right. The could definitely be cross over, unless KeSPA or the teams do want/have the resources to split up into two games and skill retain the level of skill and quality expected of them.
Well, if they would just run an SC2 proleague ALONG, it wouldn't really hurt anybody and we might actually benefit from it. But the thing is BW mostly appeals to koreans. SC2 mostly appeals to foreigners. I don't think OGN has any english casters. So how is it gonna be ? Is OGN just going to try and get koreans into sc2 ?? Or will they try something like GOMTV with a web TV and english casters ? Because most of the viewers of proleague and osl are koreans and some chinese, so if they actually bothered getting english casters for bw it would be kind of a waste of money given how small the foreign bw fanbase is. But sc2 doesn't really appeal to koreans that much. That's why i fear they might just try to force sc2 down the throat of everyone. This just might hurt both scenes nstead of allowing them to grow a bit. I also think league of legends right now might be the most interesting game for OGN.
|
On March 25 2012 09:18 Zato-1 wrote:Show nested quote +On March 25 2012 07:57 StarStruck wrote:On March 25 2012 07:55 Zato-1 wrote: If their handling of the BW scene is any indication, I'm not sure KeSPA getting involved in SC2 is a good thing for SC2. That could happen to any title man. Doesn't matter. If they're having a hard time finding new sponsors then there's really nothing else they can do about it. If a game gets really big, they cannot ignore it either. That's not what I meant. What I did mean is, I'm not a fan of all the KeSPA BW shenanigans- disqualifying players for not typing the proper request for a pause, boycotting the GomTV Intel Classic BW tournaments, creating a huge legal drama with Blizzard over Starcraft broadcasting rights, that kind of thing. Just like how you can like music but not be a fan of the RIAA, I was once a fan of BW but disliked KeSPA; now, I am no longer a fan of BW, but I'm still wary of KeSPA. Yup KeSPA is evil. The players never said that they dotn train for GomTV and that the schedule was 2 tight so they dont want 2 play it. nope KeSPA forced them out instantly so the new tournament would never become big. big bad evil KeSPA give the progamers more time. Dont see how Kespa is so uberevil and Blizzard is kind of fine in the legal shit?.
and the GG shit is kinda harsh. and they changed it a little bit but the players know the rules.
|
On March 25 2012 04:41 1Eris1 wrote:Show nested quote +On March 25 2012 04:17 GeNeSiDe wrote:
When, in 2009? Cause i looked for current viewership numbers and literally the only definitive number I can find are the TL restreams, which hit like 12-15k from what I can see.
And we should always believe EVERYTHING players who are paid money say in interviews. Do you believe Tevez when he tells you he is 100% dedicated to Man City after taking a hiatus in Argentina for 5 months? Part of your pay is to say what your sponsors, fans and team expect you to say? Would you like a player who stated in interviews that he is only there because he gets 50k a year to play a video game? I'm not saying they hate it I'm saying, they "love" this game because it allowed them to make a living doing what they love. Why wouldn't they like the next generation of that game and a new challenge?
Good job being a complete dickhead with your reply, typical of a BW die-hard. Go play on ICCUP and leave the millions of SC2 players and fans alone with your negative attitude. If you would let SC2 into your heart you would see the evolution between release and now in terms of strategy and depth of gameplay. Continue to be ignorant and assume SC2 is as mindless and coinflippy as LoL. KLeep in mind SC2 is at the stage that SC1:Vanilla was at before BW, and at that time, Vanilla was a imbalanced ass game with massive problems, I know cause I played it for years. When SC2 hits LOTV, if it still dissapoints you, then maybe I will take your comments as anything but "well it was better back in the day".
In 1 year when BW is no longer player professionally what are you gonna do then? Say your goodbyes now and let BW have the honorable death it deserves as the godfather of eSports. Wow alright. Let me break something down for you. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starleague_(Ongamenet)Show nested quote +Finals for Starleague now regularly attract more than 50,000 fans, and viewed nationwide on television by millions This is a fucking T.V. station. Not a little stream that gets run over the computer, but a fucking T.V. station. It has prime time viewing and regularly brings in MILLIONS of viewers for the big event. I could give two shits how many a stream on TL brings up, IT HAS NOTHING ON SOMETHING LIKE THIS. The fact that you would even try to use that as a basis of an arguement just shows uninformed and frankly deluded you are. Oh, so now interviews are fake? Yeah of course they're not going to saythey plays for the money, but that doesn't mean they aren't telling the truth. Have you actually read their interviews, or looked at their words? Hint: It's not just, "I play SC BW because it's fun." Here's a recent one with Stork. Throughout the interview he talks about how he grew up watching and playing the game, desperately wanting to be a progamer like the big names at the time. He talks about how his rivalry with the other great players is the drive the makes him try to be the best at BW, and son. Why don't you actually read it before you dismiss it as bullshit. http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=322739And really? You're going to call me out on that? Do you know how many hours of SC2 I've watched? Do you know how many GSL tickets I've purchased, or how many streams I've watched for hours on end? Do you know how many times I've stayed up all night just to see a match get played? No you don't, so don't fucking accuse me of stuff when you have no idea what you're talking about. I've been following SC2 from the Beta up until now and I've probably watched over 500 hours of SC2 altogether, if not much more. It's hard to keep count when you get to amounts that high spread over such a time. And you know what, of these 4900 posts or whatever, probably a good 3000 of them are SC2 related. SC2 is actually what brought me onto to TL. Before the game was the released I hadn't watched a proffesional BW series in over 5 years and hadn't played the game for even longer. And come on SC2 has been out for two years now, and it has had the 10+ years of BW expierence to build off. If it's still in it's "infant" stages, then it shouldn't be considered an esport. Fact is Blizzard had plenty of chances to make it great, and they botched it. If BW dies in a year, then alright. I'll say my goodbyes. I'm not deluding myself or anything, I know how it is. But that doesn't give you the right to just come in here and make up bullshit.
For one, let's get facts straight. You act like I said that BW wasn't on TV etc, because I state that the viewership of a Starcraft2 Website, is it impossible that these two facts can co-exist?
At no point did I take away from BW accomplishments, I am simply stating the obvious that while SC2 viewership is going up, BW viewership is going down and has been going down up. Also, you can't compare TV viewership to online viewership, if you compare online viewership to online viewership of English language content then SC2 viewership is higher than BW viewership. Frankly you say there are Chinese streams with millions of views but 1. I cant for the life of me find them, the only content I can find is the TL youtube links which average out at about 2500-3000 views.
You state a common misunderstood fallacy that OGN and MBC Game are dedicated Starcraft channels, yes they air alot of BW and get millions of views, but obviously your forgetting the fact that MBC Game turned into a music channel.....
While I agree that you share fast that you are quick to fall into the stereotype of the typical BW die-hard.
|
|
|
|