MLG Summer KR-TW Invite OQ - Page 6
Forum Index > StarCraft 2 Tournaments |
ClueClueClue
Sweden1203 Posts
| ||
Talin
Montenegro10532 Posts
On July 01 2012 21:28 Xoronius wrote: If you look at math, it surely isn´t, I am aware of that. If you look at reality, if indicates the better player at this MU. Math describes reality, so rules that apply to one inevitably apply to the other. Point being, SaSe being 4-0 against Taeja is an anomaly, even when you look at only that one specific matchup (TvP/PvT). So two things can happen in the future - SaSe can beat Taeja a few more times against almost impossible and ever increasing odds, or that statistic will start swinging into Taeja's favor rather quickly as the sample size of games grows. That's what the probability tells us. What Starcraft tells us is that Taeja is perfectly equipped to deal with the best Protoss players in the world. The possibility that SaSe knows some sort of arcane secret of how to beat Taeja specifically and that he can do that repeatedly over a long period of time is incredibly unlikely from either Starcraft or the probabilistic standpoint. | ||
Xoronius
Germany6362 Posts
On July 01 2012 21:38 Talin wrote: Math describes reality, so rules that apply to one inevitably apply to the other. Point being, SaSe being 4-0 against Taeja is an anomaly, even when you look at only that one specific matchup (TvP/PvT). So two things can happen in the future - SaSe can beat Taeja a few more times against almost impossible and ever increasing odds, or that statistic will start swinging into Taeja's favor rather quickly as the sample size of games grows. That's what the probability tells us. What Starcraft tells us is that Taeja is perfectly equipped to deal with the best Protoss players in the world. The possibility that SaSe knows some sort of arcane secret of how to beat Taeja specifically and that he can do that repeatedly over a long period of time is incredibly unlikely from either Starcraft or the probabilistic standpoint. I know, how maths works. Sase´s odds to beat Taeja are not increasing, as things in the past do not effect future probabilities (If you flip 5 coins and get 5 numbers, the chance for the 6th is again 50%). If they stay both at the same skill level, Sase has the same chance "p" to beat Taeja, each time they meet. I am just saying, the the past indicates, that this "p" is relatively high. | ||
Proseat
Germany5113 Posts
![]() | ||
CygnusAres
Singapore893 Posts
On July 01 2012 22:01 Proseat wrote: According to the official bracket HerO seems to have beaten aLive 2:1 in the Grand Final. Well done! ![]() Not yet, it's extended series match, HerO beat Alive 2:1 on the winner round earlier. | ||
Proseat
Germany5113 Posts
On July 01 2012 22:04 CygnusAres wrote: Not yet, it's extended series match, HerO beat Alive 2:1 on the winner round earlier. Ah ok, I missed that. Then apparently the Grand Final hasn't started yet. Wasn't it scheduled for 2200 KST even? I guess it's starting now then. | ||
Talin
Montenegro10532 Posts
On July 01 2012 21:46 Xoronius wrote: I know, how maths works. Sase´s odds to beat Taeja are not increasing, as things in the past do not effect future probabilities (If you flip 5 coins and get 5 numbers, the chance for the 6th is again 50%). If they stay both at the same skill level, Sase has the same chance "p" to beat Taeja, each time they meet. I am just saying, the the past indicates, that this "p" is relatively high. That is certainly not how math works. In both cases, if you look at 4-5 coins/games, the combination of outcomes does affect the probability distribution of the next toss/game. You are looking at the possible outcomes for 5-6 coins/games, not just one. If you flip 4 coins and get 4 heads, the probability of next one being a head as well is actually .03125, not .5. This is where SaSe's at if we assume that he has .5 chance of beating Taeja in a singular game (which is a very favorable assumption for SaSe). What you're saying is that the probability of a 5 win streak for one player against the other (WWWWW) is the same as all the other outcomes of a 5 game series combined. | ||
![]()
tree.hugger
Philadelphia, PA10406 Posts
| ||
![]()
opterown
![]()
Australia54784 Posts
On July 01 2012 22:32 Talin wrote: If you flip 4 coins and get 4 heads, the probability of next one being a head as well is actually .03125, not .5. ???? | ||
Talin
Montenegro10532 Posts
![]() (I'm actually not sure now fs, been a while ![]() | ||
Fermats_last
England336 Posts
| ||
Xoronius
Germany6362 Posts
On July 01 2012 22:32 Talin wrote: That is certainly not how math works. In both cases, if you look at 4-5 coins/games, the combination of outcomes does affect the probability distribution of the next toss/game. You are looking at the possible outcomes for 5-6 coins/games, not just one. If you flip 4 coins and get 4 heads, the probability of next one being a head as well is actually .03125, not .5. This is where SaSe's at if we assume that he has .5 chance of beating Taeja in a singular game (which is a very favorable assumption for SaSe). If you flip a coin, you have always an exact probability of 0.5 to score head. The physics of the coin are not effected in any way by the previous outcomes, which means it is the same coin as always with the same head-ratio, which is 0.5. If you think about the ratio of getting 5 heads in a row, before even flipping one coin, it is smaller, but if you already scored 4 heads, the probability of getting the fifth is still 0.5. But this has nothing to do with SC2, let alone the korean qualifier, anymore. So if you want, we can discuss this via. PM, but we should not annoy the other guys with a discussion about stochastic. Edit@ at Fermats_last: 9 slots. | ||
Talin
Montenegro10532 Posts
| ||
Proseat
Germany5113 Posts
On July 01 2012 22:44 Fermats_last wrote: I'm confused, how many qualify from this? The top 9 players in this tournament qualify for MLG Summer Arena. Grand Final is still pending (HerO/aLive will play for first or second seed = TBA). 1위: TBA | ||
Gorlin
United States2753 Posts
Top! Wow, I really hope he gets picked up soon. Qualifies for this qualifier in a stacked bracket, and now the arena itself, very impressive. Nestea and MMA, why ![]() | ||
dragonborn
4781 Posts
| ||
vthree
Hong Kong8039 Posts
| ||
Proseat
Germany5113 Posts
On July 01 2012 23:43 vthree wrote: I think IM.First is a Protoss? The official bracket has him listed as Zerg. Not sure if it's an error or if he's switched races. http://leveltory.com/mlg2012_summer_invite_kt | ||
CygnusAres
Singapore893 Posts
| ||
Rhaegar_tar
France847 Posts
On July 01 2012 20:31 Hall0wed wrote: Stephano hasn't won a major tournament since IPL3 and since when does beating a particular person make you automatically better than them? There are so many examples of one person beating another when the loser in that situation is the superior player, I wouldn't even know where to start if I wanted to list them all. Go ahead and list Sase and Stephano's results in Korea though, I will anticipate these stats on their great play there. No, I shit on ignorance. I like many foreign players and think some a quite good but I can't stand how many people overhype them to beyond ridiculous levels. I always try to avoid places where the overhype happens but apparently I'm not even safe in a Korean qualifier thread anymore. Go ahead and make your case for how Sase is better than Taeja though, I am interested in what Sase has done that is better than all-killing Prime, and that is just the start of the list. Stephano is much better than Taeja(he's won a lot of tourneys in 2012 and is always top 3 in others), he placed way better than him in all the tourneys that oth entered...You speak about a lot of Taeja's achievements but Stephano wasn't there so it's pretty stupid to compare them based on this(Ro8of code S or winning some MLG qualifier)... But i agree on Sase's part, the guy is so overrated it ain't funny, doing well in one tourney doesn't mean shit(hell, he's not even GM on the korean ladder). | ||
| ||