• Log InLog In
  • Register
Liquid`
Team Liquid Liquipedia
EST 08:36
CET 14:36
KST 22:36
  • Home
  • Forum
  • Calendar
  • Streams
  • Liquipedia
  • Features
  • Store
  • EPT
  • TL+
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Smash
  • Heroes
  • Counter-Strike
  • Overwatch
  • Liquibet
  • Fantasy StarCraft
  • TLPD
  • StarCraft 2
  • Brood War
  • Blogs
Forum Sidebar
Events/Features
News
Featured News
[ASL22] Finals Preview: Sweet Victory!12[ASL22] Ro4 Preview: Mirror Mirror6[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: Within Reach5[ASL22] Ro8 Preview: In A Tizzy11[ASL22] Ro16 Preview: Holy Diver5
Community News
Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over0Dark completes military service, returns to SC212[BSL23] RO16 Group Stage20Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?2Weekly Cups (Oct 26 - Nov 1): MaxPax, herO, Solar win0
StarCraft 2
General
No more SC2 streamers on team liquid? Weekly Cups (Nov 9-15): Clem and herO take over Dark completes military service, returns to SC2 Serral's getting trashed by New Catsle's Mind Weekly Cups (Nov 2-8): herO back on top?
Tourneys
RSL goes to London! 2026 Offline Finals Nov 21-22 Sparkling Tuna Cup - Weekly Open Tournament Sea Duckling Open (Global, Bronze-Diamond) Dark returns! GSL CK #7 4v4 Team Battle (Nov 19) soO & FanTaSy return! SC2 Kevin Scrim 4v4 (Nov 16)
Strategy
[H] ZvP Mid-Late Game: Stalkers Collossi HT
Custom Maps
[G] How to playtest arcade maps Starcraft 2 Advance [D] the control group Simple Questions/Answers
External Content
Mutation # 552 Secret Storm The PondCast: SC2 News & Results Mutation # 551 Robotic Revival Mutation # 550 Graveyard Shift
Brood War
General
List of top players active on ShieldBattery BW General Discussion NaDa's Body Shield Battery Server New Patch BGH Auto Balance -> http://bghmmr.eu/
Tourneys
SC1 Kevin Scrim hosted by SOOP (Nov 18-19) [IPSL] Winter 26-27 Round of 16! [Megathread] Daily Proleagues 2v2v2v2 Tournament Stage 2: Players
Strategy
Pluto's TvP 5Marine 2Medic Push Simple Questions, Simple Answers Infested Terran strategies in 2026 Nuke strategy worked in K-League 2026-11-09
Other Games
General Games
Stormgate/Frost Giant Megathread Free Space RTS Game, optimised f. Phone/Tablet etc Nintendo Switch Thread List of Game Threads The PlayStation 5
Dota 2
League of Legends
[TL LoL EUW IHs] Teemo shall perish
Heroes of the Storm
Heroes of the Storm 2.0
Hearthstone
Deck construction bug
TL Mafia
TL Mafia Community Thread
Community
General
US Politics Mega-thread Russo-Ukrainian War Thread Artificial Intelligence Thread Things Aren’t Peaceful in Palestine Trading/Investing Thread
Fan Clubs
Fan Club Resource Thread Reynor Fan Club The Flash Fan Club
Media & Entertainment
Movie Discussion! Anime Discussion Thread [Manga] One Piece
Sports
Football (Soccer) Thread TeamLiquid Health and Fitness Initiative For 2023 MLB/Baseball 2023
World Cup 2022
Tech Support
Computer Build, Upgrade & Buying Resource Thread
TL Community
The Automated Ban List Recent Gifted Posts
Blogs
The time I organised my…
AssyrianKing
Why I built Repalyzer (1.1.…
BlueStar
Innovate or Game Over?
TrAiDoS
ShieldBattery on Mac
Kraekkling
Can Bots Beat Pros?? Starcr…
namkraft
StarCraft improvement
iopq
Socialism Anyone?
GreenHorizons
Customize Sidebar...

Website Feedback

Closed Threads



Active: 11075 users

[D] The new Zerg standard for all match-ups? - Page 20

Forum Index > StarCraft 2 Strategy
Post a Reply
Prev 1 18 19 20 21 22 50 Next All
Obsolescence
Profile Joined August 2010
United States270 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-12-03 17:49:36
December 03 2010 17:46 GMT
#381
On December 04 2010 02:35 jacobman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2010 02:14 Obsolescence wrote:
On December 04 2010 01:16 jacobman wrote:
On December 04 2010 01:13 Ryhn wrote:
Why so hostile Jacob?

I understand you're tired, but there's no need to get snarky with me. I read the first few pages, then skimmed to the end of the thread because I was excited.

We have too many conflicting results, so we need more data. I'm not ready to claim either build to be conclusively 'more right' for an early pool - my nudge to you was a request for further testing, I did not mean to offend.


It's okay, I was just a little annoyed at the moment because I spent a lot of time testing this and people seemed to just pretend I wasn't presenting any possible contradictory data. Sorry if I was hostile.

I just tested your 13/15 replay against an adaptation of the 11/18 (11/15). I figured that your build was ahead by ~100 minerals because you got your hatch at 15, before queen.

Using this build (adapted from 11/18)

10 - extractor trick
11 - ovie
11 - pool
15 - hatch
15 - queen
17 - ovie

I use the 11-overpool, but go for hatch at 15 in order to mimic your build. Since both builds converge on a 15-hatch, the period following it is irrelevant (assuming all else equal). On my first try, spawning south Xel'Naga, here were my results:

11/15
Pool: 1:32
Hatch: 2:39

13/15 (from Jacob's replay)
Pool: 1:46
Hatch: 2:37

The 11 pool comes out 14 seconds faster, and the hatch being delayed by 2 seconds was simply the difference in 1 drone mining wave (you can check the replays yourself). So the 11-overpool, regardless of getting a hatch at 15, or 18, is at worst equivalent in economy but with an earlier pool. Please, let me know if you see some glaring flaw in my logic.

Also, if you go to 6:00 min mark, you'll find I'm behind by 95 minerals. However, if you take a look at my maynarding of workers, I think you'll see why I don't think this is a reasonable sample to draw any conclusion from. Since this build and the 13/15 converge on a 15-hatch, I don't think further comparison is necessary since the difference could only be less than a hatch larva cycle (one build or the other rebuilds their 15th drone <15 seconds early).

[image loading]



Okay, I looked at the replay. Interesting idea to kind of combine the two. I'm a little bit confused by what you're trying to say though. I'm not sure about your logic on how you got to an 11-overpool with a hatch at 15 or 18 is at worst equivalent in economy. I don't see how that follows from anything posted.

I do however agree that the replay isn't quite a reasonable sample to draw conclusions from. You definitely didn't have a good maynard, but this replay only reached 4469 at the 6:00 mark. This is a 160 mineral difference compared to the 13 pool I did, which mined 4630 by that time. I'm not sure if that whole difference can be accounted for by the maynarding. It seems unlikely, and unless I'm missing something It defintely still leaves the possibility that the 13 pool is 100 minerals ahead.


11/15 and 13/15 are great for comparing the economy of the builds because both require these things:

15 drones, 2 overlords, 1 spawning pool, and 1 hatchery EDIT: And 300 minerals!

Because the end goal is identical, we can compare their economies based on how quickly they can accomplish that goal. Therefore, if 11/15 gets a pool faster and a hatch at the same time as a 13/15, while matching the 13/15 in every other respect, then we can, as I did, conclude that the 13/15 should not be significantly worse or better following the production of the 15-hatch. The point is that, sure, 13/15 might get +100 minerals at 6:00 because you were able to mine from your second base sooner, but when both builds get their hatch at the same time, there will be no difference.

Also, just counting the final minerals is not a good approach to comparing minerals mined. Instead of that method, I recorded the remaining minerals for each of the 16 patches and compared their sum to the initial value (1500 per patch X 16 patches). If you use this method you will find that I am 95 minerals behind at 6:00.
It doesn't think. It doesn't feel. It doesn't laugh or cry. All it does from dusk till dawn is make the soldiers die. -Phyrexian Hulk
jdseemoreglass
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
United States3773 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-12-03 23:03:19
December 03 2010 17:46 GMT
#382
On December 04 2010 02:15 nehl wrote:
i dont think you can play this vs all races. vs an all in ling att, the fe will die, most likely the main as well. but vs t and p it seems solid. im suprised the 11pool is econ wise effective though. ill check it out...


God, I can't understand how people come up with this stuff. How can you possibly, possibly come to the conclusion that this will die to ling all ins? How? This build gets an 11 pool and more larva than ANY OTHER BUILD. I provided TWO replays of me CRUSHING zergs with ling all ins.

And people, STOP claiming this build is behind or sacrifices larva or minerals or anything else early on, because I have demonstrated this to be false. Can you not read the OP? Here, let me help you.

Note: when I began producing lings, we both had exactly 17 drones. I wasn't behind a drone, or half a drone, or whatever...
Note: I didn't catch up in drones due to a queen, I was caught up before I started my first inject!
Note: At every point from 1:30 until 4:30 when I began making lings, I was AHEAD in minerals mined!

Do you get it? Hello? I am AHEAD IN DRONES by 15 supply. 15 Supply. I am ahead in drones at 11 supply too. Where am I behind? Please, either provide evidence or quit lying on my thread.
"If you want this forum to be full of half-baked philosophy discussions between pompous faggots like yourself forever, stay the course captain vanilla" - FakeSteve[TPR], 2006
Obsolescence
Profile Joined August 2010
United States270 Posts
December 03 2010 17:48 GMT
#383
On December 04 2010 02:46 jdseemoreglass wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2010 02:15 nehl wrote:
i dont think you can play this vs all races. vs an all in ling att, the fe will die, most likely the main as well. but vs t and p it seems solid. im suprised the 11pool is econ wise effective though. ill check it out...


God, I can't understand what is wrong with people here. How can you possibly, possibly come to the conclusion that this will die to ling all ins? How? HOW? This build gets an 11 pool and more larva than ANY OTHER BUILD. I provided TWO replays of me CRUSHING zergs with ling all ins. WTF?

And people, STOP claiming this build is behind or sacrifices or anything else early on, because I have demonstrated this to be false. Can you not read the OP? Here, let me help you.

Note: when I began producing lings, we both had exactly 17 drones. I wasn't behind a drone, or half a drone, or whatever...
Note: I didn't catch up in drones due to a queen, I was caught up before I started my first inject!
Note: At every point from 1:30 until 4:30 when I began making lings, I was AHEAD in minerals mined!

Do you get it? Hello? I am AHEAD IN DRONES by 15 supply. 15 Supply. I am ahead in drones at 11 supply too. Where am I behind? Please, either prove evidence or quit lying on my thread!

God I'm gonna tear my hair out here...


DNFTT...

I think I remember you saying that less than 2 pages ago :-p
It doesn't think. It doesn't feel. It doesn't laugh or cry. All it does from dusk till dawn is make the soldiers die. -Phyrexian Hulk
jacobman
Profile Joined December 2010
217 Posts
December 03 2010 17:50 GMT
#384
On December 04 2010 02:46 jdseemoreglass wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2010 02:15 nehl wrote:
i dont think you can play this vs all races. vs an all in ling att, the fe will die, most likely the main as well. but vs t and p it seems solid. im suprised the 11pool is econ wise effective though. ill check it out...


God, I can't understand what is wrong with people here. How can you possibly, possibly come to the conclusion that this will die to ling all ins? How? HOW? This build gets an 11 pool and more larva than ANY OTHER BUILD. I provided TWO replays of me CRUSHING zergs with ling all ins. WTF?

And people, STOP claiming this build is behind or sacrifices or anything else early on, because I have demonstrated this to be false. Can you not read the OP? Here, let me help you.

Note: when I began producing lings, we both had exactly 17 drones. I wasn't behind a drone, or half a drone, or whatever...
Note: I didn't catch up in drones due to a queen, I was caught up before I started my first inject!
Note: At every point from 1:30 until 4:30 when I began making lings, I was AHEAD in minerals mined!

Do you get it? Hello? I am AHEAD IN DRONES by 15 supply. 15 Supply. I am ahead in drones at 11 supply too. Where am I behind? Please, either prove evidence or quit lying on my thread!

God I'm gonna tear my hair out here...


lol, at least I'm not claiming that. If you'll die to a ling all in with an 11 pool build then there isn't much else you can do as zerg.
jdseemoreglass
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
United States3773 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-12-03 17:56:09
December 03 2010 17:52 GMT
#385
jacobman, I tested your build. Honestly, the build doesn't make much sense. You get an overlord at 43/44 supply, leaving you supply capped for quite some time after a larvae pop. Is this a mistake? It could explain why you are showing a short-run increase in your mining. Anyway, here are my results:

5:00
13Pool : 3150 + 275 = 3425
11Pool : 3350 + 70 = 3420

6:00
13Pool : 4150 + 490 = 4640
11Pool : 4150 + 430 = 4539

7:00
13Pool : 5150 + 975 = 6125
11Pool : 5000 + 1124 = 6124

The reason you are showing higher results for the 6 minute mark is because you are delaying the overlord before the 6:00 mark. The results after that are pretty equal, except in drone count which the 11pool leads.
"If you want this forum to be full of half-baked philosophy discussions between pompous faggots like yourself forever, stay the course captain vanilla" - FakeSteve[TPR], 2006
Obsolescence
Profile Joined August 2010
United States270 Posts
December 03 2010 17:59 GMT
#386
On December 04 2010 02:52 jdseemoreglass wrote:
jacobman, I tested your build. Honestly, the build doesn't make much sense. You get an overlord at 43/44 supply, leaving you supply capped for quite some time after a larvae pop. Is this a mistake? It could explain why you are showing a short-run increase in your mining. Anyway, here are my results:

5:00
13Pool : 3150 + 275 = 3425
11Pool : 3350 + 70 = 3420

6:00
13Pool : 4150 + 490 = 4640
11Pool : 4150 + 430 = 4539

7:00
13Pool : 5150 + 975 = 6125
11Pool : 5000 + 1124 = 6124

The reason you are showing higher results for the 6 minute mark is because you are delaying the overlord before the 6:00 mark. The results after that are pretty equal, except in drone count which the 11pool leads.


If you sum the minerals left in all the patches and subtract that sum from 24,000 then you will get a true value for minerals mined (it wont matter what anyone built / didn't build).
It doesn't think. It doesn't feel. It doesn't laugh or cry. All it does from dusk till dawn is make the soldiers die. -Phyrexian Hulk
jdseemoreglass
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
United States3773 Posts
December 03 2010 18:01 GMT
#387
On December 04 2010 02:48 Obsolescence wrote:

DNFTT...

I think I remember you saying that less than 2 pages ago :-p


Yes, you are right. For every one that leaves another shows up. And there are so many people who will read those posts and think to themselves "huh, that makes sense."

I obviously can't help people having trouble understanding these things. I will stop trying.
"If you want this forum to be full of half-baked philosophy discussions between pompous faggots like yourself forever, stay the course captain vanilla" - FakeSteve[TPR], 2006
jdseemoreglass
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
United States3773 Posts
December 03 2010 18:03 GMT
#388
On December 04 2010 02:59 Obsolescence wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2010 02:52 jdseemoreglass wrote:
jacobman, I tested your build. Honestly, the build doesn't make much sense. You get an overlord at 43/44 supply, leaving you supply capped for quite some time after a larvae pop. Is this a mistake? It could explain why you are showing a short-run increase in your mining. Anyway, here are my results:

5:00
13Pool : 3150 + 275 = 3425
11Pool : 3350 + 70 = 3420

6:00
13Pool : 4150 + 490 = 4640
11Pool : 4150 + 430 = 4539

7:00
13Pool : 5150 + 975 = 6125
11Pool : 5000 + 1124 = 6124

The reason you are showing higher results for the 6 minute mark is because you are delaying the overlord before the 6:00 mark. The results after that are pretty equal, except in drone count which the 11pool leads.


If you sum the minerals left in all the patches and subtract that sum from 24,000 then you will get a true value for minerals mined (it wont matter what anyone built / didn't build).


This provides the exact same result + 700 minerals. It makes no difference comparatively.
"If you want this forum to be full of half-baked philosophy discussions between pompous faggots like yourself forever, stay the course captain vanilla" - FakeSteve[TPR], 2006
Obsolescence
Profile Joined August 2010
United States270 Posts
December 03 2010 18:03 GMT
#389
On December 04 2010 03:01 jdseemoreglass wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2010 02:48 Obsolescence wrote:

DNFTT...

I think I remember you saying that less than 2 pages ago :-p


Yes, you are right. For every one that leaves another shows up. And there are so many people who will read those posts and think to themselves "huh, that makes sense."

I obviously can't help people having trouble understanding these things. I will stop trying.


Did you happen to notice this post or the replay in the nested quotes? I'm curious about your opinion.

Post

New builds always bring out the trolls. I'm happy to see jacob actually provides new data rather than just theory-babbling.
It doesn't think. It doesn't feel. It doesn't laugh or cry. All it does from dusk till dawn is make the soldiers die. -Phyrexian Hulk
Alejandrisha
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
United States6566 Posts
December 03 2010 18:07 GMT
#390
It seems like this is a toss-up with hatch-pool to parry the 2rax as we've seen in the gsl and it comes down to wanting more slow lings and having the wherewithal the pull drones and surround when needed (hatch first) or get faster speed lings out and deal with it that way (gas pool then expand).

As a protoss, I can't remember the last time I saw a zerg go hatch first even if they scout 14gate + gas at close air positions, though I can't say for sure that they were all 11 pools.

I can't really say much about zvz as I haven't watched many and obviously don't have any knowledge through experience
get rich or die mining
TL+ Member
kcdc
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
United States2311 Posts
December 03 2010 18:08 GMT
#391
On December 04 2010 02:46 jdseemoreglass wrote:
And people, STOP claiming this build is behind or sacrifices or anything else early on, because I have demonstrated this to be false. Can you not read the OP? Here, let me help you.


You need to calm down, man. You haven't demonstrated this. You just haven't.

If you want to put an end to this, graph drones and minerals mined of an 11 overpool/18 hatch vs a 14 pool/16 hatch from 2:30 to 5:00. I will be surprised if 11 overpool is less than 100 minerals behind at 5:00.
AJMcSpiffy
Profile Blog Joined May 2010
United States1154 Posts
December 03 2010 18:13 GMT
#392
I wanted to try this build out before commenting in the thread, and I just had a pretty great game with it on Jungle Basin against a Protoss. The early pool delayed his tech without me even needing to build zerglings since he went for a forge before gateway to try and defend against what he expected to be an all in. I really felt ahead the whole time with a really strong economy and great map control (this build sets you up for a strong mutalisk mid-game) allowing me to keep an expansion or two ahead the entire match.

I need to try it more before saying it's definitely my go-to build order, but between your replays and the success I've had so far, I think this is going to be a very strong opening.

I really can't emphasize enough how important the early pool is. It's deceptive enough to start a defensive reaction, and if you can get rid of the scout before throwing down your hatchery then you're golden. Major thanks for posting/optimizing this build!
If the quarter was in your right hand, that would've been micro
Obsolescence
Profile Joined August 2010
United States270 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-12-03 18:15:09
December 03 2010 18:13 GMT
#393
On December 04 2010 03:03 jdseemoreglass wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2010 02:59 Obsolescence wrote:
On December 04 2010 02:52 jdseemoreglass wrote:
jacobman, I tested your build. Honestly, the build doesn't make much sense. You get an overlord at 43/44 supply, leaving you supply capped for quite some time after a larvae pop. Is this a mistake? It could explain why you are showing a short-run increase in your mining. Anyway, here are my results:

5:00
13Pool : 3150 + 275 = 3425
11Pool : 3350 + 70 = 3420

6:00
13Pool : 4150 + 490 = 4640
11Pool : 4150 + 430 = 4539

7:00
13Pool : 5150 + 975 = 6125
11Pool : 5000 + 1124 = 6124

The reason you are showing higher results for the 6 minute mark is because you are delaying the overlord before the 6:00 mark. The results after that are pretty equal, except in drone count which the 11pool leads.


If you sum the minerals left in all the patches and subtract that sum from 24,000 then you will get a true value for minerals mined (it wont matter what anyone built / didn't build).


This provides the exact same result + 700 minerals. It makes no difference comparatively.


If you just count the resources at 6:00 then you are neglecting the possibility that a player skipped an ovie, or is in the process of building something, etc. The minerals can't deceive you. If a patch says 1256, then 244 minerals have been mined by drones at some point in time. I thought you were all about accuracy :-p this is the most accurate method and has 0 possibility for error (which is increasingly important as the mineral difference in your comparisons approaches 0).
It doesn't think. It doesn't feel. It doesn't laugh or cry. All it does from dusk till dawn is make the soldiers die. -Phyrexian Hulk
Zeddicus
Profile Blog Joined November 2010
United States239 Posts
December 03 2010 18:17 GMT
#394
Thanks OP, I'm loving this build... Was using it last night in some 3v3s, it's pretty strong. Lings come out so fast! It is indeed very versatile. I really like it!
jacobman
Profile Joined December 2010
217 Posts
Last Edited: 2010-12-03 18:30:52
December 03 2010 18:17 GMT
#395
On December 04 2010 02:46 Obsolescence wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2010 02:35 jacobman wrote:
On December 04 2010 02:14 Obsolescence wrote:
On December 04 2010 01:16 jacobman wrote:
On December 04 2010 01:13 Ryhn wrote:
Why so hostile Jacob?

I understand you're tired, but there's no need to get snarky with me. I read the first few pages, then skimmed to the end of the thread because I was excited.

We have too many conflicting results, so we need more data. I'm not ready to claim either build to be conclusively 'more right' for an early pool - my nudge to you was a request for further testing, I did not mean to offend.


It's okay, I was just a little annoyed at the moment because I spent a lot of time testing this and people seemed to just pretend I wasn't presenting any possible contradictory data. Sorry if I was hostile.

I just tested your 13/15 replay against an adaptation of the 11/18 (11/15). I figured that your build was ahead by ~100 minerals because you got your hatch at 15, before queen.

Using this build (adapted from 11/18)

10 - extractor trick
11 - ovie
11 - pool
15 - hatch
15 - queen
17 - ovie

I use the 11-overpool, but go for hatch at 15 in order to mimic your build. Since both builds converge on a 15-hatch, the period following it is irrelevant (assuming all else equal). On my first try, spawning south Xel'Naga, here were my results:

11/15
Pool: 1:32
Hatch: 2:39

13/15 (from Jacob's replay)
Pool: 1:46
Hatch: 2:37

The 11 pool comes out 14 seconds faster, and the hatch being delayed by 2 seconds was simply the difference in 1 drone mining wave (you can check the replays yourself). So the 11-overpool, regardless of getting a hatch at 15, or 18, is at worst equivalent in economy but with an earlier pool. Please, let me know if you see some glaring flaw in my logic.

Also, if you go to 6:00 min mark, you'll find I'm behind by 95 minerals. However, if you take a look at my maynarding of workers, I think you'll see why I don't think this is a reasonable sample to draw any conclusion from. Since this build and the 13/15 converge on a 15-hatch, I don't think further comparison is necessary since the difference could only be less than a hatch larva cycle (one build or the other rebuilds their 15th drone <15 seconds early).

[image loading]



Okay, I looked at the replay. Interesting idea to kind of combine the two. I'm a little bit confused by what you're trying to say though. I'm not sure about your logic on how you got to an 11-overpool with a hatch at 15 or 18 is at worst equivalent in economy. I don't see how that follows from anything posted.

I do however agree that the replay isn't quite a reasonable sample to draw conclusions from. You definitely didn't have a good maynard, but this replay only reached 4469 at the 6:00 mark. This is a 160 mineral difference compared to the 13 pool I did, which mined 4630 by that time. I'm not sure if that whole difference can be accounted for by the maynarding. It seems unlikely, and unless I'm missing something It defintely still leaves the possibility that the 13 pool is 100 minerals ahead.


11/15 and 13/15 are great for comparing the economy of the builds because both require these things:

15 drones, 2 overlords, 1 spawning pool, and 1 hatchery EDIT: And 300 minerals!

Because the end goal is identical, we can compare their economies based on how quickly they can accomplish that goal. Therefore, if 11/15 gets a pool faster and a hatch at the same time as a 13/15, while matching the 13/15 in every other respect, then we can, as I did, conclude that the 13/15 should not be significantly worse or better following the production of the 15-hatch. The point is that, sure, 13/15 might get +100 minerals at 6:00 because you were able to mine from your second base sooner, but when both builds get their hatch at the same time, there will be no difference.

Also, just counting the final minerals is not a good approach to comparing minerals mined. Instead of that method, I recorded the remaining minerals for each of the 16 patches and compared their sum to the initial value (1500 per patch X 16 patches). If you use this method you will find that I am 95 minerals behind at 6:00.


I see what you're trying to say now. The flaw in the logic that I see though is that you're extending the conclusion for the 11 pool 15 hatch modification to the 11 pool 18 hatch. You just prove that the 11 overpool only put you two seconds behind compared to a 13 pool, which has no bearing on if a 15 hatch or 18 hatch work better. As long as the 2 second difference doesn't have some unforseen consequences that I'm not anticipating, the 11 pool 15 hatch technically should be able to reach pretty much the same economy as the 13 pool version. I would have to test it a few times to make sure I'm not missing something, but it makes sense.

I also noticed you made an extra drone before the first queen. That might account for some of the mineral discrepancy. Also, I think you made a mistake somehow with your minerals mined method. I didn't double check yet, but the only difference between my method and yours that I can think of would be the minerals lost in the extractor trick. I simply take the minerals spent and add the minerals I have to get the total minerals "mined". It's not the exact minerals mined because the game includes 700 minerals worth of what you start with, but the difference between the two replays should still be the same either way, 160.
jdseemoreglass
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
United States3773 Posts
December 03 2010 18:18 GMT
#396
On December 04 2010 03:08 kcdc wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2010 02:46 jdseemoreglass wrote:
And people, STOP claiming this build is behind or sacrifices or anything else early on, because I have demonstrated this to be false. Can you not read the OP? Here, let me help you.


You need to calm down, man. You haven't demonstrated this. You just haven't.

If you want to put an end to this, graph drones and minerals mined of an 11 overpool/18 hatch vs a 14 pool/16 hatch from 2:30 to 5:00. I will be surprised if 11 overpool is less than 100 minerals behind at 5:00.


No, I am done beating my head against a wall. This will clearly never end. I could waste hours of my life proving with the most meticulous testing and graphing and argumentation, and someone would come out and say "well what about THIS build. Or THAT circumstance. You are behind that!"

Just believe whatever you want to believe. I no longer care in the slightest.
"If you want this forum to be full of half-baked philosophy discussions between pompous faggots like yourself forever, stay the course captain vanilla" - FakeSteve[TPR], 2006
Obsolescence
Profile Joined August 2010
United States270 Posts
December 03 2010 18:26 GMT
#397
On December 04 2010 03:17 jacobman wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2010 02:46 Obsolescence wrote:
On December 04 2010 02:35 jacobman wrote:
On December 04 2010 02:14 Obsolescence wrote:
On December 04 2010 01:16 jacobman wrote:
On December 04 2010 01:13 Ryhn wrote:
Why so hostile Jacob?

I understand you're tired, but there's no need to get snarky with me. I read the first few pages, then skimmed to the end of the thread because I was excited.

We have too many conflicting results, so we need more data. I'm not ready to claim either build to be conclusively 'more right' for an early pool - my nudge to you was a request for further testing, I did not mean to offend.


It's okay, I was just a little annoyed at the moment because I spent a lot of time testing this and people seemed to just pretend I wasn't presenting any possible contradictory data. Sorry if I was hostile.

I just tested your 13/15 replay against an adaptation of the 11/18 (11/15). I figured that your build was ahead by ~100 minerals because you got your hatch at 15, before queen.

Using this build (adapted from 11/18)

10 - extractor trick
11 - ovie
11 - pool
15 - hatch
15 - queen
17 - ovie

I use the 11-overpool, but go for hatch at 15 in order to mimic your build. Since both builds converge on a 15-hatch, the period following it is irrelevant (assuming all else equal). On my first try, spawning south Xel'Naga, here were my results:

11/15
Pool: 1:32
Hatch: 2:39

13/15 (from Jacob's replay)
Pool: 1:46
Hatch: 2:37

The 11 pool comes out 14 seconds faster, and the hatch being delayed by 2 seconds was simply the difference in 1 drone mining wave (you can check the replays yourself). So the 11-overpool, regardless of getting a hatch at 15, or 18, is at worst equivalent in economy but with an earlier pool. Please, let me know if you see some glaring flaw in my logic.

Also, if you go to 6:00 min mark, you'll find I'm behind by 95 minerals. However, if you take a look at my maynarding of workers, I think you'll see why I don't think this is a reasonable sample to draw any conclusion from. Since this build and the 13/15 converge on a 15-hatch, I don't think further comparison is necessary since the difference could only be less than a hatch larva cycle (one build or the other rebuilds their 15th drone <15 seconds early).

[image loading]



Okay, I looked at the replay. Interesting idea to kind of combine the two. I'm a little bit confused by what you're trying to say though. I'm not sure about your logic on how you got to an 11-overpool with a hatch at 15 or 18 is at worst equivalent in economy. I don't see how that follows from anything posted.

I do however agree that the replay isn't quite a reasonable sample to draw conclusions from. You definitely didn't have a good maynard, but this replay only reached 4469 at the 6:00 mark. This is a 160 mineral difference compared to the 13 pool I did, which mined 4630 by that time. I'm not sure if that whole difference can be accounted for by the maynarding. It seems unlikely, and unless I'm missing something It defintely still leaves the possibility that the 13 pool is 100 minerals ahead.


11/15 and 13/15 are great for comparing the economy of the builds because both require these things:

15 drones, 2 overlords, 1 spawning pool, and 1 hatchery EDIT: And 300 minerals!

Because the end goal is identical, we can compare their economies based on how quickly they can accomplish that goal. Therefore, if 11/15 gets a pool faster and a hatch at the same time as a 13/15, while matching the 13/15 in every other respect, then we can, as I did, conclude that the 13/15 should not be significantly worse or better following the production of the 15-hatch. The point is that, sure, 13/15 might get +100 minerals at 6:00 because you were able to mine from your second base sooner, but when both builds get their hatch at the same time, there will be no difference.

Also, just counting the final minerals is not a good approach to comparing minerals mined. Instead of that method, I recorded the remaining minerals for each of the 16 patches and compared their sum to the initial value (1500 per patch X 16 patches). If you use this method you will find that I am 95 minerals behind at 6:00.


I see what you're trying to say now. The flaw in the logic that I see though is that you're extending the conclusion for the 11 pool 15 hatch modification to the 11 pool 18 hatch. You just prove that the 11 overpool only put you two seconds behind compared to a 13 pool, which has no bearing on if a 15 pool or 18 pool work better. As long as the 2 second difference doesn't have some unforseen consequences that I'm not anticipating, the 11 pool 15 hatch technically should be able to reach pretty much the same economy as the 13 pool version. I would have to test it a few times to make sure I'm not missing something, but it makes sense.

I also noticed you made an extra drone before the first queen. That might account for some of the mineral discrepancy. Also, I think you made a mistake somehow with your minerals mined method. I didn't double check yet, but the only difference between my method and yours that I can think of would be the minerals lost in the extractor trick. I simply take the minerals spent and add the minerals I have to get the total minerals "mined". It's not the exact minerals mined because the game includes 700 minerals worth of what you start with, but the difference between the two replays should still be the same either way, 160.


I explicitly discarded the results after the hatch goes down, because of poor maynarding and, yes, i got a 15-queen instead of 14-queen.

I don't see what people don't like about my method for minerals mined. It does take a little longer to calculate, but it is 100% accurate. There is no possibility for error.

1500 minerals in a new patch. If at time X there are less than 1500 minerals in that patch, then the player must have mined them. By counting this difference, we don't have to worry if someone did or did not build Y overlord or Z drones as they approached the 6:00 mark. This method won't allow a player to game the system to get a small boost. Although, I suppose you would need to subtract 7 (or 6?) from a player if they use the extractor trick since those are minerals which are mined and lost.
It doesn't think. It doesn't feel. It doesn't laugh or cry. All it does from dusk till dawn is make the soldiers die. -Phyrexian Hulk
jacobman
Profile Joined December 2010
217 Posts
December 03 2010 18:26 GMT
#398
On December 04 2010 02:52 jdseemoreglass wrote:
jacobman, I tested your build. Honestly, the build doesn't make much sense. You get an overlord at 43/44 supply, leaving you supply capped for quite some time after a larvae pop. Is this a mistake? It could explain why you are showing a short-run increase in your mining. Anyway, here are my results:

5:00
13Pool : 3150 + 275 = 3425
11Pool : 3350 + 70 = 3420

6:00
13Pool : 4150 + 490 = 4640
11Pool : 4150 + 430 = 4539

7:00
13Pool : 5150 + 975 = 6125
11Pool : 5000 + 1124 = 6124

The reason you are showing higher results for the 6 minute mark is because you are delaying the overlord before the 6:00 mark. The results after that are pretty equal, except in drone count which the 11pool leads.


That's a valid point. I'll definitely test out changing the overlord time to be optimal. I think I mentioned that I wasn't sure if that overlord time was exactly right or not. I really doubt that it can make 100 minerals of difference though. I still have the same number of overlords bought and drones out on the field at that point. I'll test it because I'm not sure what the effect would be, but my gut feeling tells me that it's not 100 minerals worth.

I'll also have to take a look at the 7 minute mark to like you said. It seems odd that the 11 pool would catch up during that time since we pretty much reach full saturation at 6:00 ish. The reason it catches up at seven might actually be because of the supply block you mentioned though. While I doubt that it makes much of a difference at 6:00 not being able to make the drones at 52 might affect the 7:00 mark a lot.
jdseemoreglass
Profile Blog Joined July 2010
United States3773 Posts
December 03 2010 18:29 GMT
#399
On December 04 2010 03:26 Obsolescence wrote:
Show nested quote +
On December 04 2010 03:17 jacobman wrote:
On December 04 2010 02:46 Obsolescence wrote:
On December 04 2010 02:35 jacobman wrote:
On December 04 2010 02:14 Obsolescence wrote:
On December 04 2010 01:16 jacobman wrote:
On December 04 2010 01:13 Ryhn wrote:
Why so hostile Jacob?

I understand you're tired, but there's no need to get snarky with me. I read the first few pages, then skimmed to the end of the thread because I was excited.

We have too many conflicting results, so we need more data. I'm not ready to claim either build to be conclusively 'more right' for an early pool - my nudge to you was a request for further testing, I did not mean to offend.


It's okay, I was just a little annoyed at the moment because I spent a lot of time testing this and people seemed to just pretend I wasn't presenting any possible contradictory data. Sorry if I was hostile.

I just tested your 13/15 replay against an adaptation of the 11/18 (11/15). I figured that your build was ahead by ~100 minerals because you got your hatch at 15, before queen.

Using this build (adapted from 11/18)

10 - extractor trick
11 - ovie
11 - pool
15 - hatch
15 - queen
17 - ovie

I use the 11-overpool, but go for hatch at 15 in order to mimic your build. Since both builds converge on a 15-hatch, the period following it is irrelevant (assuming all else equal). On my first try, spawning south Xel'Naga, here were my results:

11/15
Pool: 1:32
Hatch: 2:39

13/15 (from Jacob's replay)
Pool: 1:46
Hatch: 2:37

The 11 pool comes out 14 seconds faster, and the hatch being delayed by 2 seconds was simply the difference in 1 drone mining wave (you can check the replays yourself). So the 11-overpool, regardless of getting a hatch at 15, or 18, is at worst equivalent in economy but with an earlier pool. Please, let me know if you see some glaring flaw in my logic.

Also, if you go to 6:00 min mark, you'll find I'm behind by 95 minerals. However, if you take a look at my maynarding of workers, I think you'll see why I don't think this is a reasonable sample to draw any conclusion from. Since this build and the 13/15 converge on a 15-hatch, I don't think further comparison is necessary since the difference could only be less than a hatch larva cycle (one build or the other rebuilds their 15th drone <15 seconds early).

[image loading]



Okay, I looked at the replay. Interesting idea to kind of combine the two. I'm a little bit confused by what you're trying to say though. I'm not sure about your logic on how you got to an 11-overpool with a hatch at 15 or 18 is at worst equivalent in economy. I don't see how that follows from anything posted.

I do however agree that the replay isn't quite a reasonable sample to draw conclusions from. You definitely didn't have a good maynard, but this replay only reached 4469 at the 6:00 mark. This is a 160 mineral difference compared to the 13 pool I did, which mined 4630 by that time. I'm not sure if that whole difference can be accounted for by the maynarding. It seems unlikely, and unless I'm missing something It defintely still leaves the possibility that the 13 pool is 100 minerals ahead.


11/15 and 13/15 are great for comparing the economy of the builds because both require these things:

15 drones, 2 overlords, 1 spawning pool, and 1 hatchery EDIT: And 300 minerals!

Because the end goal is identical, we can compare their economies based on how quickly they can accomplish that goal. Therefore, if 11/15 gets a pool faster and a hatch at the same time as a 13/15, while matching the 13/15 in every other respect, then we can, as I did, conclude that the 13/15 should not be significantly worse or better following the production of the 15-hatch. The point is that, sure, 13/15 might get +100 minerals at 6:00 because you were able to mine from your second base sooner, but when both builds get their hatch at the same time, there will be no difference.

Also, just counting the final minerals is not a good approach to comparing minerals mined. Instead of that method, I recorded the remaining minerals for each of the 16 patches and compared their sum to the initial value (1500 per patch X 16 patches). If you use this method you will find that I am 95 minerals behind at 6:00.


I see what you're trying to say now. The flaw in the logic that I see though is that you're extending the conclusion for the 11 pool 15 hatch modification to the 11 pool 18 hatch. You just prove that the 11 overpool only put you two seconds behind compared to a 13 pool, which has no bearing on if a 15 pool or 18 pool work better. As long as the 2 second difference doesn't have some unforseen consequences that I'm not anticipating, the 11 pool 15 hatch technically should be able to reach pretty much the same economy as the 13 pool version. I would have to test it a few times to make sure I'm not missing something, but it makes sense.

I also noticed you made an extra drone before the first queen. That might account for some of the mineral discrepancy. Also, I think you made a mistake somehow with your minerals mined method. I didn't double check yet, but the only difference between my method and yours that I can think of would be the minerals lost in the extractor trick. I simply take the minerals spent and add the minerals I have to get the total minerals "mined". It's not the exact minerals mined because the game includes 700 minerals worth of what you start with, but the difference between the two replays should still be the same either way, 160.


I explicitly discarded the results after the hatch goes down, because of poor maynarding and, yes, i got a 15-queen instead of 14-queen.

I don't see what people don't like about my method for minerals mined. It does take a little longer to calculate, but it is 100% accurate. There is no possibility for error.

1500 minerals in a new patch. If at time X there are less than 1500 minerals in that patch, then the player must have mined them. By counting this difference, we don't have to worry if someone did or did not build Y overlord or Z drones as they approached the 6:00 mark. This method won't allow a player to game the system to get a small boost. Although, I suppose you would need to subtract 7 (or 6?) from a player if they use the extractor trick since those are minerals which are mined and lost.


What you aren't understanding is that building anything at anytime will not change the difference between methods at all.

Building an overlord = (minerals spent +100) (minerals owned - 100)
Not building an overlord = (minerals spent -100) (minerals owned +100)


"If you want this forum to be full of half-baked philosophy discussions between pompous faggots like yourself forever, stay the course captain vanilla" - FakeSteve[TPR], 2006
kcdc
Profile Blog Joined April 2010
United States2311 Posts
December 03 2010 18:29 GMT
#400
Ran a quick test. With a scout at about the same time, 11 overpool is about 100 minerals mined behind 14 pool at 4:40 game time. Larvae injection pops earlier for 11 overpool. If you want more early minerals and your hatch to finish earlier, go with 14 pool. If you want more larvae (could be drones, could be units), go with 11 overpool.
Prev 1 18 19 20 21 22 50 Next All
Please log in or register to reply.
Live Events Refresh
LiuLi Cup
20:00
#55
Clem vs herOLIVE!
IntoTheiNu 1225
TKL 299
IndyStarCraft 175
Rex133
Liquipedia
[ Submit Event ]
Live Streams
Refresh
StarCraft 2
TKL 299
IndyStarCraft 175
Rex 133
Codebar 51
StarCraft: Brood War
Britney 47832
Calm 5957
GuemChi 1298
Jaedong 1223
Horang2 713
EffOrt 662
Light 628
Mini 462
actioN 450
Larva 394
[ Show more ]
BeSt 380
Zeus 362
Soulkey 336
Yoon 245
firebathero 216
Rush 193
Stork 191
ZerO 142
ProTech106
Barracks 84
hero 80
Leta 76
Hyun 68
Sea.KH 63
Pusan 61
JYJ 55
Free 45
Killer 30
Classic 25
Bishop 23
ToSsGirL 23
Sacsri 22
soO 21
sorry 19
Movie 18
zelot 16
Terrorterran 14
Noble 13
Sharp 12
yabsab 11
sOs 10
Rock 8
scan(afreeca) 8
Icarus 5
Dota 2
XcaliburYe406
monkeys_forever364
Counter-Strike
olofmeister1479
allub685
markeloff90
Heroes of the Storm
Trikslyr23
Other Games
B2W.Neo670
Lowko319
hiko208
Pyrionflax170
crisheroes163
dupreeh120
Mew2King47
ZerO(Twitch)12
Organizations
StarCraft: Brood War
lovetv 6
[ Show 12 non-featured ]
StarCraft 2
• StrangeGG 46
• AfreecaTV YouTube
• intothetv
• Kozan
• IndyKCrew
• Migwel
StarCraft: Brood War
• iopq 8
• BSLYoutube
• STPLYoutube
• ZZZeroYoutube
League of Legends
• TFBlade332
Other Games
• WagamamaTV198
Upcoming Events
Monday Night Weeklies
3h 25m
PiGosaur Cup
11h 25m
The PondCast
20h 25m
LiuLi Cup
21h 25m
Rogue vs TBD
Maru vs TBD
OSC
1d 2h
Replay Cast
1d 9h
GSL
1d 21h
Maru vs Dark
Patches Events
2 days
OSC
2 days
Replay Cast
2 days
[ Show More ]
KCM Race Survival
2 days
RSL Revival
3 days
BSL
4 days
eOnzErG vs StRyKeR
Cross vs JDConan
RSL Revival
4 days
IPSL
5 days
Ret vs ggnore13
nOmaD vs Aether
BSL
5 days
Bonyth vs Doodle
Kyrie vs Jimin
Replay Cast
5 days
WardiTV Weekly
5 days
Kung Fu Cup
6 days
Liquipedia Results

Completed

Proleague 2026-11-16
Blizzard Classic Cup 2026
HCC Season 3

Ongoing

Acropolis #5
KCM Race Survival 2026 Season 4
International ShieldBattery League
BSL Season 23
IPSL Winter 2026-27
Calamity Cup Div. A Season 8
Underdog Cup 2026 Div 2-3
Stake Ranked Episode 6
BLAST Rivals Fall 2026
IEM Beijing 2026
PGL Masters Bucharest 2026
Stake Ranked Episode 5
1win Private Club #2
Thunderpick World Champ. '26
ESL Pro League Season 24
Stake Ranked Episode 4
1win Private Club #1
Logitech G Play Connect 2026
SL StarSeries Fall 2026
FISSURE Playground #3
BLAST Open Fall 2026

Upcoming

Sector 591
YSL S4
SC4ALL II: Brood War
NBSL 2026 Xiamen LAN
BSL 23: Non-Korean Championship
HSC XXX
Stellar Fest 2: Lunar Cup
StarCraft2 Weekly Open Tournament 2026 Grand Finals
SC4ALL II: StarCraft II
Kung Fu Cup 2026 Grand Finals
RSL Offline Finals
IEM Kraków 2027
PGL Bucharest 2027
BLAST Bounty Winter 2027
PGL Major Singapore 2026
TLPD

1. ByuN
2. TY
3. Dark
4. Solar
5. Stats
6. Nerchio
7. sOs
8. soO
9. INnoVation
10. Elazer
1. Rain
2. Flash
3. EffOrt
4. Last
5. Bisu
6. Soulkey
7. Mini
8. Sharp
Sidebar Settings...

Advertising | Privacy Policy | Terms Of Use | Contact Us

Original banner artwork: Jim Warren
The contents of this webpage are copyright © 2026 TLnet. All Rights Reserved.