Mafia VII - GG - Page 2

On May 08 2009 09:55 LucasWoJ wrote:
Yeah, it wasn't to much the town playing poorly as the mafia playing extremely well.

On May 08 2009 09:57 Malongo wrote:

Meh thats just because mafia got active just look at the townies active.

On May 08 2009 10:00 Malongo wrote:

LOL sorry but you were the one suspicious to me in PMs. My medic list was... how to say... no medic list at all.

On May 08 2009 10:04 JeeJee wrote:
but yeah, towards the end (around day 3 or whatever it was; not counting the ones where qatol/me/monoxide died, those are post-game as far as im concerned)
once i figured out L and lucas it was like day 3 or day 4 or whatever and not enough townies alive (that listen to reason i mean).

but yeah incognito's pro. and why didn't you listen to me ilovektf T____T well it wouldn't have changed anything but still

On May 04 2009 17:04 Ace wrote:
After the game is over I'll write up a really long post with some basic tips for playing mafia. No more talking from me.

On May 08 2009 10:31 Qatol wrote:
Oh seriously one of the most surprising moments in the game to me: when t_co called me out. I didn't expect that at all. MAJOR props. You even had my plan figured out (you were going to be a sacrifice).

Also another idea: whenever we send PMs to one another concerning mafia, we both send a copy of the PM to Qatol. This will allow him to gradually build up a network of confirmed blues/townies with which to begin analysis.

On May 08 2009 10:47 LucasWoJ wrote:
I'd like to help with that game if possible. I imagine one probably learns more from the administrative side anyway.

On May 08 2009 11:34 BloodyC0bbler wrote:



I would have forced them to in the end, but as stated many times earlier by mafia members. Its in their best interest to rape the town first then eachother. They happened to trust eachother fully soon as they found eachother which in this game would have led to a double ko of the mafia.

On May 08 2009 11:40 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
They had roleclaimed fully to eachother right after bockits death.

HAD at that point i said, sorry you have to kill eachother. We would have two dead mafia families and a town winning who deff did not earn it.

the biggest issue in this game was mainly inactivity and people auto claiming to friends. This leads to huge issues as a host balance wise :p.

On May 08 2009 11:48 LTT wrote:


Not quite. The way that the members and killpower was set up, it was nearly impossible for one side to take the other out in a single night. This meant leaving survivors who could then just out the entire other mafia team. Mafia fighting each other was more mutually assured destruction than the prisoner's dilemma.

On May 08 2009 12:00 BloodyC0bbler wrote:
shows your not m uch of a friend

On May 08 2009 12:44 Qatol wrote:
OK I think I'm mostly done with my writeup of this game from my perspective.
http://www.teamliquid.net/blogs/viewblog.php?topic_id=92894

On May 10 2009 05:51 Mynock wrote:


That's just what I said but it's phrased differently. The game would have ended right there, so BC patched things up so it isn't. Mafia went complaining to BC first, since they noticed it first, and got what they wanted. So you really think the game was meant to be played that way? Obviously not, since you disagree with BC's ways as well. BC should have made the two families completely separate, and actually that's what the Town always believed is the case. THE WHOLE GAME. EVERY goddamn lynch attempt was made with that in mind. This also goes to Qatol. You also used this misconception, and based all your defense on it. You knew the rules didn't work like that by then, because by that time BC told you the truth. Ver also knew, and he then came up with his own defense, which was ALSO based on how the two families would have to kill each other in the end. You were basically lying to the Town about the RULES of the game, even tho you guys were ready to throw it all when you felt that YOU were being lied to. Still, it's OK to deceive the Town in the same way, right?

Qatol, you're saying Town played poorly by not lynching a mafia earlier? Town partly left you in office for all that time, because it figured you will at least fight the other Mafia. BC was watching all that, and never ever decided that maybe Town should actually know what they're playing. Hell, there might have been a surprise third faction of Vampires, how would we know?

Yes, maybe BC lied to you guys for the first night, but he never told the truth to the Town for the WHOLE game. You had a slow start, Town was crippled from the beginning to the very end.

Lying about in-game stuff is OK (hell, that's what this game is about, deception), lying about the RULES of the game, when you, in fact, know better, is pretty dirty.