|
On February 07 2017 18:15 Vivax wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2017 18:08 RtaniSoul wrote: You're basically saying "your reads are wrong because you SHOULD be townreading grack and silver and me 100% and sharkie SHOULD therefore be mafia to you if the mission fails so clearly you're mafia with sharkie if it fails!" Which is utterly and incredibly dumb. It's not dumb if this mission fails  With me being 100 % on swika grack being resistance, if a team with you + me alongside them failed, I would have forced a scenario where people had to choose between you and me, which is in my interest as I believe you are spies. Grack understood it correctly as he called it a sort of copcheck on you. Now if this mission fails you will still be around to sneak into teams as you can say "but how do you know we were never on a mission." You're only seeing it from your perspective again. I am not certain on grack and yourself. I'm telling you to look at it from my perspective and figure out how it all makes sense from me being town, but you're too tunneled on your tinfoil theory.
|
On February 07 2017 18:13 Superbia wrote: Btw, when this team fails at least one between myself and EC has to be town. We cannot both be mafia. Why?
|
I can still see a Superbia/Vivax/EC world as that'd explain the day1 nay votes and with the arguments you've made by then it'd have been hard to justify a day 2 pro-vote, plus with thread sentiment going in favour it seems likely it would pass anyway, but yeah, that's just one team. It does seem likely at least one of you would be town.
|
On February 07 2017 18:22 Vivax wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2017 18:20 Superbia wrote:On February 07 2017 18:19 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 18:13 Superbia wrote: Btw, when this team fails at least one between myself and EC has to be town. We cannot both be mafia. Why? Check the votes man. Jesus. Sharkies last vote is a wifom vote btw (ie he wants to gain cred from it if the mission fails). If it passes, disregard. Please respond to my last response. Actually try to put yourself in my position with my reads rather than just trying to force into my perspective with YOUR reads.
|
On February 07 2017 18:17 Superbia wrote: I don't understand sharkie's play at all btw.
50% of the times he knows what he's doing, like voting no on the prev mission and making the big post.
50% of the times he says dumb shit like "ec and sup are 100% mafia because they voted against the team that passed!" I feel like he's just a smart guy that didn't have experience and is picking shit up. It's not like he's still being clueless but you can see that he doesn't know how to interpret certain situations. Throughout all his analysis you can very clearly follow why he's doing what he's doing.
Why do you feel this transition is unnatural?
|
On February 07 2017 18:25 sharkie wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2017 18:22 Vivax wrote:On February 07 2017 18:20 Superbia wrote:On February 07 2017 18:19 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 18:13 Superbia wrote: Btw, when this team fails at least one between myself and EC has to be town. We cannot both be mafia. Why? Check the votes man. Jesus. Sharkies last vote is a wifom vote btw (ie he wants to gain cred from it if the mission fails). If it passes, disregard. You make me fume?! I explained earlier why I voted no in this mission! Has nothing to do with anything except gathering information... Posts like this make me really sure Sharkie is town. It's this certainty of knowing what his reason was and not understanding how people couldn't believe him. It doesn't even enter his system that people can have scum reasons for it.
|
On February 07 2017 18:26 Superbia wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2017 18:25 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 18:17 Superbia wrote: I don't understand sharkie's play at all btw.
50% of the times he knows what he's doing, like voting no on the prev mission and making the big post.
50% of the times he says dumb shit like "ec and sup are 100% mafia because they voted against the team that passed!" I feel like he's just a smart guy that didn't have experience and is picking shit up. It's not like he's still being clueless but you can see that he doesn't know how to interpret certain situations. Throughout all his analysis you can very clearly follow why he's doing what he's doing. Why do you feel this transition is unnatural? He's said multiple times he's played resistance before. Pretty sure. Live resistance, not forum resistance. Whole different ballgame.
|
On February 07 2017 18:29 Superbia wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2017 18:28 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 18:26 Superbia wrote:On February 07 2017 18:25 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 18:17 Superbia wrote: I don't understand sharkie's play at all btw.
50% of the times he knows what he's doing, like voting no on the prev mission and making the big post.
50% of the times he says dumb shit like "ec and sup are 100% mafia because they voted against the team that passed!" I feel like he's just a smart guy that didn't have experience and is picking shit up. It's not like he's still being clueless but you can see that he doesn't know how to interpret certain situations. Throughout all his analysis you can very clearly follow why he's doing what he's doing. Why do you feel this transition is unnatural? He's said multiple times he's played resistance before. Pretty sure. Live resistance, not forum resistance. Whole different ballgame. Only partially. I would say town is better on the forum if town is willing to play it slow. That's not the point. In a live setting it's more about reading faces and stupid shit like that. Forum has far, far more analysis in much deeper ways.
|
On February 07 2017 18:35 Vivax wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2017 18:16 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 18:15 Vivax wrote:On February 07 2017 18:08 RtaniSoul wrote: You're basically saying "your reads are wrong because you SHOULD be townreading grack and silver and me 100% and sharkie SHOULD therefore be mafia to you if the mission fails so clearly you're mafia with sharkie if it fails!" Which is utterly and incredibly dumb. It's not dumb if this mission fails  With me being 100 % on swika grack being resistance, if a team with you + me alongside them failed, I would have forced a scenario where people had to choose between you and me, which is in my interest as I believe you are spies. Grack understood it correctly as he called it a sort of copcheck on you. Now if this mission fails you will still be around to sneak into teams as you can say "but how do you know we were never on a mission." You're only seeing it from your perspective again. I am not certain on grack and yourself. I'm telling you to look at it from my perspective and figure out how it all makes sense from me being town, but you're too tunneled on your tinfoil theory. Have it your way then. As team leader, I put a spy into the team. He lets it pass cause he'd be at risk if it fails. Everyone agrees on same team + previous leader. I request to take out the previous spy and replace it with you as resistance. Denied. If the team fails, as resistance you would know exactly who to blame: Me. Nobody is so bullheaded to not acknowledge that Grack and swika are simply town. Spies will only let a mission pass if they know that it will get them excluded for the rest of the game. During nomination phase, we all agreed on swika and Grack, and I even asked you who you think should be the third. You said: Sharkie or yourself. I chose sharkie. When I make a suggestion very similar to your previous one, where one of the three is someone you suggested previously, this happens: You refuse cuz being afraid of being on a failing team, which btw isn't in line with your thoughts on sharkie so far. What?
I have consistently and continuously argued with the bolded. I do not believe Grack is simply town. Nor do I believe you're simply town.
|
On February 07 2017 18:36 Superbia wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2017 18:33 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 18:29 Superbia wrote:On February 07 2017 18:28 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 18:26 Superbia wrote:On February 07 2017 18:25 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 18:17 Superbia wrote: I don't understand sharkie's play at all btw.
50% of the times he knows what he's doing, like voting no on the prev mission and making the big post.
50% of the times he says dumb shit like "ec and sup are 100% mafia because they voted against the team that passed!" I feel like he's just a smart guy that didn't have experience and is picking shit up. It's not like he's still being clueless but you can see that he doesn't know how to interpret certain situations. Throughout all his analysis you can very clearly follow why he's doing what he's doing. Why do you feel this transition is unnatural? He's said multiple times he's played resistance before. Pretty sure. Live resistance, not forum resistance. Whole different ballgame. Only partially. I would say town is better on the forum if town is willing to play it slow. That's not the point. In a live setting it's more about reading faces and stupid shit like that. Forum has far, far more analysis in much deeper ways. Eh. Sure. Whatever. I feel like this is going in a useless direction. :p Sharkie has said he bases things mostly on votes. That being said, I'm okay with his responses for now. Which makes this game a little hard. From my POV there's always a mafia in sharkie/silver/vivax. Why not Grack?
|
On February 07 2017 18:38 Superbia wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2017 18:37 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 18:36 Superbia wrote:On February 07 2017 18:33 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 18:29 Superbia wrote:On February 07 2017 18:28 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 18:26 Superbia wrote:On February 07 2017 18:25 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 18:17 Superbia wrote: I don't understand sharkie's play at all btw.
50% of the times he knows what he's doing, like voting no on the prev mission and making the big post.
50% of the times he says dumb shit like "ec and sup are 100% mafia because they voted against the team that passed!" I feel like he's just a smart guy that didn't have experience and is picking shit up. It's not like he's still being clueless but you can see that he doesn't know how to interpret certain situations. Throughout all his analysis you can very clearly follow why he's doing what he's doing. Why do you feel this transition is unnatural? He's said multiple times he's played resistance before. Pretty sure. Live resistance, not forum resistance. Whole different ballgame. Only partially. I would say town is better on the forum if town is willing to play it slow. That's not the point. In a live setting it's more about reading faces and stupid shit like that. Forum has far, far more analysis in much deeper ways. Eh. Sure. Whatever. I feel like this is going in a useless direction. :p Sharkie has said he bases things mostly on votes. That being said, I'm okay with his responses for now. Which makes this game a little hard. From my POV there's always a mafia in sharkie/silver/vivax. Why not Grack? Due to the day 4 votes. This vote?
On February 04 2017 07:00 disformation wrote: The team consisting of Grackaroni, sharkie, Silverika has been approved.
Votes for: Grackaroni, RtaniSoul, sharkie, sicklucker, Silverika, Tumblewood, Vivax. Votes against: emperorchampion, Superbia.
The team will now embark on the mission. If there are any spies on the mission team, they may sabotage the mission by PM to all hosts with ##sabotage.
Deadline/Mission results on Saturday, Feb 04 10:00pm GMT (GMT+00:00) in . Why does that exclude Grack as an option for you?
|
On February 07 2017 18:39 Vivax wrote: All RtaniSoul are doing is spreading doubts all over the team and basically the entire game when it's blatantly obvious that sharkie was the most risky in it from the get go, a free invitation to Grack and Swika to make the first team fail and exclude him for the rest of the game. In other words, we have different reads from you and that's scummy. Okay Vivax.
We have never argued that Silver isn't town. We also don't have the 100% townreads you seem to have magically acquired based on fairy magic.
|
The reason not to fail the first mission as grack is precisely what you're quoting. Never be suspected again!
|
Superbia, given that Vivax and others are tunneling the shit out of me I've just decided you're going to be town because you townread me. Congratulations on your promotion.
|
On February 07 2017 18:55 RtaniSoul wrote: Superbia, given that Vivax and others are tunneling the shit out of me I've just decided you're going to be town because you townread me. Congratulations on your promotion.
just ftr this is a rogue decision that the rsoul does not endorse -throws a shoe at the lexy-
|
On February 07 2017 18:57 Superbia wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2017 18:55 RtaniSoul wrote: Superbia, given that Vivax and others are tunneling the shit out of me I've just decided you're going to be town because you townread me. Congratulations on your promotion. That TR is way too late. It's obvious my interest in this game is rekindled and I have been pretty right this game from the get-go.
rofl
|
On February 07 2017 18:59 Superbia wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2017 18:57 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 18:57 Superbia wrote:On February 07 2017 18:55 RtaniSoul wrote: Superbia, given that Vivax and others are tunneling the shit out of me I've just decided you're going to be town because you townread me. Congratulations on your promotion. That TR is way too late. It's obvious my interest in this game is rekindled and I have been pretty right this game from the get-go. rofl How's that TW tr doing? ;p After this
On February 07 2017 11:28 Tumblewood wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2017 06:43 RtaniSoul wrote:On February 07 2017 06:24 Tumblewood wrote: here's where I'm at right now:
very town vivax silverika
town, probably sharkie (trending up) grack (trending up) rtanisoul (trending down)
scum super ec sl (trending down) So... we're trending down whilst our top scumreads are literally identical to yours? when I do it it's just smart. when you do it it's TMI aka buddyingit's just you're reaching the same point as me but it's not a mindmeld because you're taking a different way to get there. makes me uncomfortable, like you're picking conclusions and then coming up with reasoning, but it's probably irrational... probably Kinda dead in the water.
|
On February 07 2017 19:22 Vivax wrote: You won't get anywhere just with vote analysis. It's too easy to tamper with.
According to vote analysis one would conclude rtanisoul is town just cause they nay-voted a team with themselves on it. Still waiting
|
On February 07 2017 20:30 emperorchampion wrote:Hmm I looked into grack but I'm not sure. Look at these posts: Show nested quote +On February 05 2017 15:48 Grackaroni wrote: Ok I might be slightly stupid, but I swear this mission is going to fail. This game is way too easy right now. And the spy isn't Vivax. It's one of Silver/sharkie. Show nested quote +On February 07 2017 03:13 Grackaroni wrote: my team makes sense to me. I'm pretty sure the next mission is going to fail.
Silverika is too indignant to be scum.
Vivax is actually coming up with a lot of thought out scum pairings without trying too hard to be town read. Plus he said right off the bat that Silver/I aren't scum, which is a good thing from my perspective.
Tumblewood/Artanis are both like "I think Grack could definitely be scum here. Full steam ahead guys!" ##Accept. Plus Tumblewood is super blendy while Rtanisoul seems to mainly be trying to buddy Silver.
Everyone else seems to be showing at least some level of skepticism over the team. I think we are (were) at similar points in this game. Another issue with grack as scum for me, is that when I look at sl's play it completely turned at mission 1. I'm thinking through if sl passes mission 1 for a town read on either sharkie/silver. If you look at all the reasons that he fails attempt 3 vs attempt 4: it's grack not on the team, leader not on the team, and not silver nominating VS silver on the team anyways, sharkie on the team, and leader still not on team. I don't see how town sl votes down my team by votes up vivax's team, so sl as scum conditions my read on grack as well. Also given this: Show nested quote +On February 04 2017 01:21 Grackaroni wrote: Right now I see the game in terms of 3 groups (listed in no particular order):
The definite town: Grackaroni Silverika
The townie feels Artanisoul Vivax Sharkie
The people without townie feels Emperorchampion
The one of these two is scum group Tumblewood Superbia
The definite scum Sicklucker
I still think at least one of Super/Tumble will be red. Don't see grack/sl, putting his team mate at the bottom, don't think scum usually does that. Especially since I think that grack has pretty easy out for a town read on sl earlier. Pretty sure given the interactions silver/sl is not a team. Maybe I'm just mega tunneled but I'm also running out of places to look, I'm in an sl/sharkie world right now. I dunno, I don't have the same issue of grack/sl not being a team. SL has played an incredibly low-effort game and pretty much everyone and their mom has scumread him. It'd be difficult for Grack to get any mission in with SL on it so there's not much harm done by bussing him. Plus, if thread sentiment changes, he can change his position too anyway.
I'm not sure where you're going with the mission 3/4 thing regarding SL. Could you explain that a bit further?
On February 07 2017 20:38 Vivax wrote: Can't be in a sharkie world without rtanisoul in it tbh.
If this fails I'm ride or die sharkie + rtanisoul I'm glad we got tunnelvivax back.
|
Tunnelvivax, you still seem to have not processed this. Please do.
On February 07 2017 18:16 RtaniSoul wrote:Show nested quote +On February 07 2017 18:15 Vivax wrote:On February 07 2017 18:08 RtaniSoul wrote: You're basically saying "your reads are wrong because you SHOULD be townreading grack and silver and me 100% and sharkie SHOULD therefore be mafia to you if the mission fails so clearly you're mafia with sharkie if it fails!" Which is utterly and incredibly dumb. It's not dumb if this mission fails  With me being 100 % on swika grack being resistance, if a team with you + me alongside them failed, I would have forced a scenario where people had to choose between you and me, which is in my interest as I believe you are spies. Grack understood it correctly as he called it a sort of copcheck on you. Now if this mission fails you will still be around to sneak into teams as you can say "but how do you know we were never on a mission." You're only seeing it from your perspective again. I am not certain on grack and yourself. I'm telling you to look at it from my perspective and figure out how it all makes sense from me being town, but you're too tunneled on your tinfoil theory.
|
|
|
|