Season of the Witch 2 - Page 3

On September 18 2015 05:08 Rels wrote:
Now geript what is your read on damdred ? Cause there are many scum signs so I don't understand you neither want him lynched or checked

On September 18 2015 05:20 Rels wrote:

What about:
His inactivity which is his scum meta according to rayn ?
The fact that he gave only two obvious townreads ?

On September 17 2015 04:53 geript wrote:
@Rayn, here's where I'm at:
Dandel might be town but ugh. He usually hates playing as mafia often to the point of getting his team to bus him for credit. Usually as mafia he's low to super low activity, which is what I see here. It's not a 100% thing but I think it's a decent flip.
LS. I think the meta thing re: questioning your martry claim without having a clear thought/reason/explanation/idea why not still feels very accurate. Another thing that in looking at his filter that really bugs me is the "people that tend to push me genearlly are mafia." I don't think that's actually true. In my experience, usually the first few pushes on him tend to come from town; but I don't think him being wrong on it is damning in and of itself as it could just be a difference in perception. The grail vote is a little odd but eh. A specific thing that bugs me is I'm not seeing him related games to current status. IE he's bringing up games, but it's not really as a marker point relating to the current state. The closest thing is when we were on a scum team in JOAT, but that's not really relational to the game states etc but commentary on how he could see something. Not sure I am explaining that one well.
HTS: I kinda like her read on FF. Not a huge fan of her reads post though, specificially:


It's really weird to have both me and LS in the scum category, especially since I can be scum because I can bus D1 for great benefit. But there's really not any benefit to bus in this setup and bussing in a no-flip setup for benefit is just a really odd thought.
Fido has a few odd posts. Thinking I was mostly RPing in Personality (when I had maybe 1 rp post) and was constantly bitching about the long D1 RP/useless phase. I can't put my finger on this one yet even after staring at his filter for a bit. Maybe I'm just tired.

Just get back to me on what you think and which you think is hte best lynch since ~2hrs i think.

On September 18 2015 05:24 Fidei86 wrote:
@geript I just haven't had a lot of time over the past couple of days. *shrug* no offence to Palmar, but I didn't sign up for this game, and if I had had time it would have been spent filter diving in Newbie XIV where we're near LyLo. I've junked a work event early to come home now, and I'll post some more detailed thoughts.

On September 18 2015 05:25 Rels wrote:

Maybe for you but every I played / obsed with him he started by getting townreads, then poeing his way to scumread.
I understand this is meta so it is unreliable, but I m not townreading him.

On September 18 2015 05:27 Rels wrote:

His catch up post was super logical though.
Damdred saying multiple times he will catch up while not doing so is weird.

On September 18 2015 05:28 Half the Sky wrote:


To make sure I'm not biased here - what did he actually post that came off as scummy to you?

On September 18 2015 05:27 Rels wrote:

His catch up post was super logical though.
Damdred saying multiple times he will catch up while not doing so is weird.

On September 18 2015 05:36 Fecalfeast wrote:

How much time have i spent in filters before making my comments on the thread? You're just assuming how much time I've put into the game and that's not cool.

I'm not saying you're wrong about my projecting town but to cite the time I've spent is something you can't actually prove...

On September 18 2015 05:36 Rels wrote:

Here it is

On September 18 2015 05:40 Rels wrote:

Will quote my post I made at the time
In exchange can you read / comment my dandel case ? Cause we re starting to talk about a lot of things but I'm still pretty sure he's mafia

On September 18 2015 05:49 Vivax wrote:
I'm about to take my leave as I don't have permanent internet access for still like 1-2 weeks.

Going to vote Damdred as I am still not impressed by his plaý and he seems to have the best chances of getting lynched among my suspects.

I really think BM is mafia but you aren't convinced. Well, enjoy having him around I say, whatever happens I'm going to die tonight.

Remember this: My death will be announced if I die by martyring. Not sure if the actual target will be revealed atm and dont wanna check. Anyway the point is that whoever was targeted can as well role claim since mafia will know his role even if I sacrifice myself for him.