Newbie Student Mafia VII - Page 72

VOTE: prplhz voted Half the Sky (post)
VOTE: rsoultin voted Half-the-Sky (Half the Sky) (post)
VOTE: Breshke voted Stutters (Stutters695) (post)
VOTE: Tubesock voted Half the Sky (post)
VOTE: Stutters695 voted prplhz (post)
VOTE: rsoultin unvoted Half the Sky (post)
VOTE: Breshke unvoted Stutters695 (post)
VOTE: Tubesock unvoted Half the Sky (post)
VOTE: jarjarbinks voted Prp (prplhz) (post)
WARNING: prplhz changed vote without unvote (post)
VOTE: prplhz unvoted Half the Sky (post)
VOTE: prplhz voted Bourneq (post)

So, The Shining read 16 pages (320 posts) in 30 minutes? That's a post every six seconds. He's not reading very carefully at all.
And this post isn't very good. His first point, about Ace1312 as a fallback policy lynch, is fair. But that isn't enough to lynch someone for. He scumreads Stutters695 for being suspicious about several of his (The Shining's) townreads, but he doesn't explain why he has these reads. And he doesn't show why the disagreement in reads is alignment indicative.And the fact that he had to go back and clarify this doesn't help him. He's provided some thoughts, but nothing special, nothing unique, nothing influential, nothing that stands out, nothing memorable. All he's done is share some thoughts. He doesn't seem to be pushing anything, just providing reads for the purpose of not dying.

---

Again, this simply isn't true. Holyflare would be the nightkill here even with a scum team of three newbies who have never played with him before.

Rsoultin's comments on Half the Sky simply aren't alignment indicative. The scum motivation for that vote switch isn't there, and definitely doesn't outweigh the burden of trying to explain it. Half the Sky can go back to a slight town lean.

I like the confidence that prplhz has with regards to not being scumread. Given his level of play, it seems reasonable for him to expect to not be scumread. I'm not sure if he would act like this as town.

This is very good. However, I don't see why scum would be so willing to switch off of a town who claimed scum. He would never get lynched for mislynching plotspot here. This point makes a lot of sense if Tubesock is scum with Stutters695, but I don't want to make unflipped association reads. The most likely conclusion is that Tubesock re-evaluated without sharing with the thread, though this certainly makes him look worse. Rsoultin pointed out some missing posts, though. Still leaning town on Tubesock, definitely, just not as much as before.

Ugh, I'm super sleepy. I skimmed up to the point where I replaced in. Sorry this isn't particularly detailed. Good night.