Campus Mafia (New/Newish Players Welcome)

On October 28 2014 09:14 Superbia wrote:
/in. Don't really need coach (i.e. has no priority).

On November 08 2014 09:28 Fecalfeast wrote:

kelsier(you) counterclaimed and didn't rescind his claim til 3 mins before deadline.

You were the slot that was going to be lynched before kush got domed

On November 08 2014 09:53 raynpelikoneet wrote:

yo you are scum?

On November 08 2014 19:04 Breshke wrote:
For when you wake up obi is your town read on rayn based off sstuff you have read from the person he replaced or his own play?

On November 08 2014 23:25 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Kelsier had really easy-to-follow posts and really good reads.
This is probably the best:

..which is exactly why i have a strong scumread on Sentinel.

Basically if you count out the claim shennies (which could be seen scummy) there is absolutely nothing scummy he has done, he squirts green all over the place.

On November 09 2014 04:36 sicklucker wrote:


er I donno the new guy that ksc got replaced by. Hes been really townie but the guy hes replacing it would hard to go to the end of the gmae with that guy.

On November 09 2014 13:09 Breshke wrote:
serejai/bats- Town

Sent/one of the new guys - Mafia

Other than sent im not actually sure I havn't thought about it that much and the only reason it isn't you or superbia is because I don't think you guys are with sentinel. Also I give you a certain amount of town cred because without



I don't think kush would have been lynched.

On November 10 2014 07:27 Elvis! wrote:
Obi KSC admittedly fake-claimed , but you live ... hmmmmm....

On November 10 2014 07:31 Elvis! wrote:
Like this is never 100% because, WIFOM, isn't it?

On November 10 2014 07:33 Superbia wrote:
Obi did you figure out who the scum is yet? Also, how does it feel to replace scum in this situation? Miss me in the QT?

On November 10 2014 07:43 Superbia wrote:


Son there is no hierarchy in this classroom.

Any reads yet? You can sheep my explanation on why we should definitely kill the guy who lynched the cop (you) if you want.

On November 10 2014 08:03 Serejai wrote:
Mafia could have not attacked for whatever reason. We have no way of knowing whether or not a shot went off now that the rules in the op have been changed.

On November 10 2014 08:07 Superbia wrote:


Then rayn is mafia and had to have known 100% where the save is going to be? And then has to explain how is he still alive as confirmed town AND as an experienced player if the game reaches final 3?

On November 10 2014 08:35 batsnacks wrote:
I thought it would be night already. Do I have to wait for tomorrow?

On November 11 2014 01:04 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Mind anyone explain me what this discussion is about?
Cava/Superbia?

From what the OP i am reading i gather it says "each night mafia must choose a player to kill". It's been like this since i first read the OP. "noone" is not a player in this game so explain please?

On November 11 2014 01:35 raynpelikoneet wrote:

hmm okay.

There is not gonna be a fucking way mafia shot anyone and roleblocked their shooter.
If that's what happened then whoever did that deserves to win and i raise my hat to them (BECAUSE THE CHANGE WAS MADE 2min BEFORE THE N2 deadline!!!! no time for mafia to react).

Now the situation is:
bats - obvtown
Breshke - obvtown
Serejai - mostly obv town
sicklucker - town

Cava/Fecal/Superbia/Elvis -- I really do not have any fucking idea atm

Sentinel - scummyscumscumclaimedscum

I actually have to do something after this phase... I thought we were gonna win straight up. Can someone of those four claim town so we can just win?

On November 11 2014 02:37 [UoN]Sentinel wrote:
All of your assumptions hinge on the fact that I am but I'm not

On November 12 2014 02:31 batsnacks wrote:
I think the last mafia is Superbia.

On November 12 2014 10:35 Breshke wrote:
If ff voted for you would you then have as much reason to vote him as you do superbia?

On November 12 2014 12:18 Fecalfeast wrote:
so let me get this straight, your scumread on me that makes me the best lynch today is my being afk with my vote on a counterclaimed cop deadline D1 and my 30s late vote D2? Solid case. I should probably just concede since you totally outed me in front of everyone.

I can't believe I made such a scumslip. To be confused when the person who counter-claimed the cop votes for someone other than who he was counterclaiming is probably the scummiest thing anyone in any mafia game has done.

sicklucker if you're the last scum and we lose because nobody listened I'll be so mad.

On November 12 2014 12:21 sicklucker wrote:
Final Vote Count


Kushm4sta (4): [UoN]Sentinel, batsnacks, Breshke, sicklucker
sicklucker (3): Elvis!, Serejai, FecalFeast
KelsierSC (1): Superbia
[UoN]Sentinel (1): kushm4sta

Not Voting (2): KelsierSC, Immateria

Wow both sent and kush coulda hammered on me mafia has played so bad they dont deserve to win. The reason I said ff was the hammer here is because I felt like he was waiting for one of his two buddys to log on and save themselves. When he realized they were not I feel like he changed his vote after blaze said voting is over to save face but it was not counted.

(and yes im aware this vote count makes me look mafia I wouldnt bring it up if I was)

On November 12 2014 12:36 Fecalfeast wrote:

nah, you can read the thread I'm tired of talking to myself.

On November 12 2014 13:09 Fecalfeast wrote:
Okay sicklucker I'll lay it all out for you. If you still don't believe me by all means continue.

1. Normally deadline is later in the day. The earliest deadline for a game i have been a part of before this was 4pm (this one is 2pm for me) I usually sleep from 2-4am until 10-1

2. I do not and will not use my phone while driving.

3. I combust cannabis on the daily and was legitimately distracted at deadline d2

4. (Wifom)i would have conceded by now


Obi, yeah he's inconsistent and spent d1 and 2 bluehunting

On November 13 2014 07:50 Superbia wrote:


What do you actually plan to do this game?

On November 13 2014 08:18 Superbia wrote:


Like there's two ways you come into a thread as a standin, either you read the entire thread, which is usually boring as shit. Or you start asking questions and interact with everyone to see where everyone is at. Or some kind of combination. It's one thing to be lazy, it's another to do absolutely fuck all. Like all of the town standins I've seen come into the thread guns blazing in some sort of way. They do something like immediately declare that they're not going to read the entire thread and/or they just fucking go and do shit. Like they immediately jump in and start interacting and reading when necessary.

You haven't done anything. At all. You've made a promise about reading the thread, which in all honesty, I don't give a shit about. I could've told you exactly what happened from my POV if you bothered to fucking ask. A promise to read the thread, feeling dejected about it and then just doing nothing else is exactly what I expect a mafia subbing in to do here. There were other options you could've pursued after you figured out that reading the thread was not going to work for you, you did none of them. I was in the exact same situation last game, where I subbed into a mafia spot and mafia were losing hard, and your mind set feels completely similar.

On November 13 2014 21:46 Serejai wrote:
sicklucker, as much as I hate to say it... you're town.

Breshke also seems town based on his responses.

Obiwan why do you doubt I am scum? That sounds like a convenient cover for you to use if I get lynched and flip town. "I told you guys!". You've admitted that you don't read the thread, and yet you're somehow confident I am town; even more confident than people like rayn who had me confirmed as town nearly all game. Do you know something the rest of us don't?

Superbia, you didn't seem very convinced, either. Why is that?

Out of everyone who has posted a comment, I would say the actual scum is either Obiwan, Elvis, or Superbia based on the responses. Fecal's responses could be seen as scummy but I'm more inclined to believe he's just a bad player; same reason I think sicklucker is town now.

On November 14 2014 06:54 raynpelikoneet wrote:

I don't even know who fecalfeast convinced you to vote for but i think you think he is mafia (at least thought today) so no... Doesn't fly.

On November 14 2014 06:56 raynpelikoneet wrote:

oh rly?

On November 14 2014 06:58 Serejai wrote:
I'm always serious. Those of us who are town never make jokes. Play to win or don't play at all.

On November 14 2014 06:59 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Have you been serious in this game?
Like srsly srs?

On November 14 2014 07:03 Serejai wrote:
rayn confirmed scum for that last second vote switch

On November 15 2014 08:39 Breshke wrote:
Obi why shouldnt we lynch you today and who should we lynch instead?

On November 15 2014 13:33 Breshke wrote:
Ff what do you think of superbiad play this game

On November 15 2014 16:09 Fecalfeast wrote:
also my read on you is based on you popping into thread multiple times and then disappearing. Classic scumlurker obiwan

On November 15 2014 16:08 Fecalfeast wrote:
serejai literally claimed scum

On November 15 2014 16:17 Fecalfeast wrote:
you're all potentially scum in my mind but serejai atleast has the stupid roleblock stuff as evidence for towniness

On November 15 2014 16:25 Fecalfeast wrote:
1.breshke deserves the win if he's last scum.
2.serejai assuming roleblocks are pmed to vts she is town or the roleblocker who never roleblocked anyone to confirm herself

On November 16 2014 07:45 sicklucker wrote:
Hum of course obiwan votes me scum. mafia does it 10/10, town does it most of the time too. Im fairly certain super votes him as well who I have a pretty town read on for someone who posted so little so I dont expect him to change that.
Thats 2-2 as expected which is why I said your vote is big here ff. Im taking alot of risk of you or super turning scum here thats how sure I am obis mafia now.

As rayn pointed out and kind of the main reason he almost pushed a vote against him last week he changed his mind about me pretty easy and sheeped ff. Im dead tormorow if not today theirs only town motivation here. Even if im myslynched make sure you get obi when I turn town tormorow im not going super hard to defend myself now that I narrowed it from 2 to 1 and me dying does not matter as much.

Looks like im going to get hammered tonight on short notice on little sleep so thats probably all your getting out of me untill close to vote time have fun and vote well. I feel I moved the conversation forward all game and that should be worth alot here, over someone who killed are cop and half his posts were jokes.

On November 16 2014 11:53 Breshke wrote:
Intresting, my problem is i keep finding reasons to read ff, superbia and SL as town but then i keep flipping on those reasons. Then theres you who i have literally no idea about based on your play and a weird townread based on KSCs play

On November 16 2014 19:05 Fecalfeast wrote:
##vote obiwanshinobi

Im not gona sleep through deadlinebwith no vote im town dont lynch me

On November 17 2014 06:08 Superbia wrote:
Where the fuck are Obi/FF?

On November 17 2014 08:18 sicklucker wrote:


Hey at least im not serjai. Im willing to change if you give good reasons too. Its gonna be hard tho poe is not in your favor.

On November 17 2014 08:36 sicklucker wrote:
I mean you should ... as town. If your mafia you dont care because you already have the two votes you need against me.
Your kind of burying yourself

On November 17 2014 10:58 Superbia wrote:
Obi any thoughts now that FF flipped town?

On November 17 2014 10:53 sicklucker wrote:
I mean put my case aside I was not talking about that. Your the day 1 cop killer whos been left alive way too long and kinda the only one left in my world from poe. If you are town you gotta put out a replacement because f both of us are town were really fucked. The fact your not targeting anyone tells me your trying to win votes not the game.

On November 17 2014 11:02 sicklucker wrote:


Like were kind of in a rush do you not understand the tie concept? Do you not think serjaias voteing for me?

On November 17 2014 11:14 sicklucker wrote:


I dont know what else to say then gg wp mafia town concedes I tried

On November 17 2014 11:20 Superbia wrote:
I think I've solved the game. There's a hidden 3rd party.

sicklucker = 3rd party. Obi = scum. Game = solved.

On November 17 2014 11:31 sicklucker wrote:
Im perfectly fine im just trying to win here like do you honestly think serejais gonna not vote me like seriously? Hes threatened to spite vote me multiple times. You guys need to let your egos go and just believe.

On November 17 2014 11:37 sicklucker wrote:


Then how can you suggest sleeping and having both of us in the final 3? Is this a mafia trap.

On November 17 2014 11:47 sicklucker wrote:
Like it doesint matter if hes scum the way your playing hes already won. If hes scum he will convince you to sleep for the autowin. We just vote out obi

On November 17 2014 11:51 sicklucker wrote:
Im starting to think there might be a mafia between breske and super tho. Theres no way there both that dumb to not snap vote and sleep with 2 guaranteed votes against me. Well if they are they played a good game my hats off to you.

On November 17 2014 12:14 Serejai wrote:
Beyond policy at this point

On November 17 2014 12:28 sicklucker wrote:


Im not trying to lynch shit im just saying vote at 5pmest Theirs 0 reason not to you can change your vote theirs no drawback and its not scummy to try and increase towns chances and options.

On November 18 2014 10:26 sicklucker wrote:
And super you have to understand we cant sleep here I would rather figure this game out with 2 confirmed towns in my mind (meplusu)

Obi if you unvote sleep ill think your way more town here

On November 18 2014 13:16 sicklucker wrote:
But when you got a cop killer and a players that completely checked out does it really matter? No one should be tryinglynch outside of you two from a town perspective imo.

On November 18 2014 14:29 sicklucker wrote:
You didnt even answer my question. I know what your trying to do the reason your not voting me yet is because serejai might sleep which is an autowin rather then the likely win.

On November 18 2014 14:59 sicklucker wrote:


Nope I can convince super to side with me which is my only play since your not budging since your probably mafia. WHICH IS WHY IVE BEEN WONDERING WHERE THE HELL HE IS ={

On November 18 2014 23:12 Superbia wrote:
I'm also currently okay with that vote anyway, so whatever. If you're scum here you'll probably win because I don't think I'm ever going to call you mafia.

Vote: ObiWanShinobi

On November 18 2014 23:18 Superbia wrote:


But then me and SL can switch to her???

On November 18 2014 23:20 Superbia wrote:


So I'm the mafia here?

On November 18 2014 23:23 sicklucker wrote:


Why did you tell her that dude? .Also if she does this we know shes the mafia and we all just vote her?

On November 18 2014 23:24 Superbia wrote:


What if SL dies then?

On November 18 2014 23:27 Superbia wrote:


Why not do it now? At this point I'm pretty damn sure SL is town with me and one of us will die during the night.

On November 18 2014 23:28 sicklucker wrote:
Super most of my interactions with obiwan tonight have suggested hes the scum here. He also thinks your a likely scum but at the same time he also wants to sleep? If we sleep and your the mafia we also lose so Hes kind of caught imo

Basically I went into this setting a trap. Whoever wants to sleep has to clearly be scum here. while the one who is convinced by me that sleeping is really bad (because it is) The fact you came out and canceled the sleep vote is why your now confirmed town and why hes probably the scum.

On November 18 2014 23:30 sicklucker wrote:
Basically obis whole case is he wants the hammer. But hes risking the whole game by doing so. Both signs suggest hes mafia.

On November 18 2014 23:32 Superbia wrote:


His logic on sleeping + me being mafia = auto-lose should check out from your POV.

On November 18 2014 23:42 sicklucker wrote:
No my logic is sound. Making fun of me here is not helping your case. If we dont sleep super has the hammer and he says hes not voting me. So your job as town or mafia here is to convince us to move onto serejai

On November 18 2014 23:45 Serejai wrote:
Reading SL's filter feels like I'm reading a script for Back To The Future 4 or something. So much WIFOM, so much insider knowledge about things. "This will happen, that will happen. This person will get shot, this person will never get shot."

On November 18 2014 23:50 sicklucker wrote:
No im saying hes town. I know your mafia by the way your acting.
You guys are both resorting to trash talk now to push your agendas of winning/throwing the game

On November 19 2014 00:01 sicklucker wrote:
Its not that I haven't explained myself, you barely did that. Its that in everyworld im right and you cant argue against the true.

Its extremely alignment indicative im putting the hammer in someone elses hands your putting it in your own. You have not looked for one town. We need two towns to win the game. I found my town

On November 18 2014 23:51 Serejai wrote:


LOL. Did you just threaten me? Good lord... what a character.

On November 19 2014 00:14 sicklucker wrote:


But you want it at the risk of a 33% autolose from your town pov which doesint make sense as a town. And if you factor in all 4 players having equal chance of being mafia its a 50% autolose.

On November 19 2014 03:06 Serejai wrote:


See, here's the thing...

Sleeping is the town thing to do. If we lynch today we have a 25% chance of winning and a 75% chance of losing as town.

If we sleep and lynch tomorrow, there will be a 33% chance to win and a 66% chance to lose as town.

For someone who makes a living playing poker and apparently is a math expert as well, I find it hard to believe they could be so oblivious to how this stuff works.

On the other hand, the remaining scum player would benefit greatly from us lynching today.

Out of the four of us, the only person who is hellbent on not sleeping is SL. It's in the best interest of town to sleep, and the best interest of mafia to lynch. Nothing he says makes any sense or adds up in any way, and it's all coming straight from a scum viewpoint - regardless of how many times he self-confirms himself as town.

On November 19 2014 13:31 sicklucker wrote:
Also if he thinks im the scum sleeping is actually good from his pov.

On November 20 2014 00:34 sicklucker wrote:
Like super if your not going to be here dont sleep. Give me the hammer by keeping your vote on obi. If I decide its serejai me and obi vote him. If I decide its obi hes voted out by tie break.

On November 21 2014 01:01 Superbia wrote:


I thought you were reading SL as scum?

Also, Obi, I would like some clarification. I was starting to read you town partially because I was starting to think you were genuinely questioning SL's read on me rather than passively throw scum on me. What the fuck is your agenda here?


I would like everyone to put down their final thoughts on the other 3 in the game before we get the NK flip.

On November 21 2014 01:54 Superbia wrote:
How are you expecting to townread me off of SL's response?

On November 21 2014 02:14 Superbia wrote:
Pretty much every (dead) confirmed has hard read me as town. I have no idea what SL's read on me is or why he's reading me town, but I don't think that's particularly alignment indicative given the circumstances.

I think it's fine that you are evaluating me independent of what has been said so far, but I would have expected you to have reached a conclusion long ago. There's a reason why the entirety of town so far has read me town, and you should've either come to that conclusion as well, or have evidence as to think otherwise. The fact that you have done neither makes me believe that you have not been evaluating the game and have just been stalling and asking questions for the sake of asking questions. I.e. you're scum.

On November 21 2014 02:25 Superbia wrote:


SL's analysis on me? He has been sheeping Rayn's reads for most of the game iirc.

You've been asking questions about me being town for the past days. It fucking boggles my mind to think that any town would just continuously ask the same question over and over again and not reach any conclusion. I don't buy it.

On November 21 2014 02:42 Superbia wrote:


I echo the desire to see where Sere stands on me (or anyone for that matter) at this point in time. Which is why I asked people to put down their thoughts on everyone by the EoN before the flip.

I just don't see what you have accomplished with your questions. You say they were partially to get a read on me, but you did not reach any conclusion regarding my alignment. Did you reach any conclusion regarding Sere or SL based on this question?

Getting a read on me in real-time is fine, but I fail to see how this has anything to do with asking others questions about me.

On November 21 2014 02:46 Superbia wrote:


So what will your approach be for tomorrow?

On November 21 2014 02:53 sicklucker wrote:
Like super the only reason serejai started to play again because things started to go my way. I thought that was completely obvious everyone of her posts were anti me.She didnt even mention either of you..

On November 21 2014 02:57 sicklucker wrote:
No obi you should know i lose everything by sleeping as a town. Thats what a dont understand about you and why I tunneled.

I dont think giving two potential mafia the hammer is ever a good town play.

On November 21 2014 03:06 sicklucker wrote:
Like super thinks obis scum and obi thinks supers scum. If you sleep and your right you know you lose right. Because serejai votes me everytime and we just gave the other mafia the hammer

On November 23 2014 12:44 sicklucker wrote:


Rly? I told you final 3 of me and serejai= mafia win thats why I didnt want to sleep

On November 23 2014 15:42 Blazinghand wrote:
I feel bad whenever I mislynch someone OR get mislynched. As a player, I might mislynch a guy who's acting silly or something, and claim it was "optimal" to lynch him, but in reality it's optimal to only lynch scum. It's all our responsibilities to do our best when we're town, and remember, with great shared responsibility comes great shared blame.