Carnival Cruise Mafia - Page 10

On May 17 2013 09:25 kushm4sta wrote:
I will vote VE.

But in regards to WoS, people need to realize he spams as scum. So spamming doesn't make him town.

##vote VE

On May 17 2013 10:33 ObviousOne wrote:
Please hide more information while you refuse to vote for scum. Please. It's helping me decide which of you or BH is scum. Stop being so helpful. Stop it. Stop. Oh wait.

On May 13 2013 05:35 Promethelax wrote:
WoS, that is dumb and you know it. Past statistics have nothing to do with this game. Why respond to that accusation which has no content or reasoning?

Kita: why WoS?

On May 15 2013 00:30 Promethelax wrote:
Yeah WoS was made out of town in that game. I think though that the dissonance we're seeing comes from no longer being a newbie. When you think of yourself as bad and offer yourself up to die its one thing but WoS has been around long enough to get an ego about mafia. We all do eventually. That ego explains a lot...

I don't see WoS being scum based on that. Actually its a point more towards the town side of things as I can understand his play if I assume he has gained the ego of bh in the last few months. If WoS is being an egotistical maniac his angry play makes a lot of sense. Look at recent Yamato rage or something similar. This is starting to read as the reaction of someone who thinks they are better than those accusing them simply because those people are accusing them.

WoS you hostile little fuck, I think you might be town. Work with me if you are so that I can be sure of that. Stop fighting for the sake of fighting and look for scum. If you think Oats is scum convince me. Or if its someone else convince me.

On May 17 2013 23:04 Promethelax wrote:


Your assessment matches mine.

## unvote

I'm liking the Play from VE today and hiro scum slipped. Points to the first person to find it.

##vote: hiropro

On May 15 2013 09:43 HiroPro wrote:
I don't see a lynch happening today and I won't be voting for either wave or vayne. might be around later to see if something changes.

On May 17 2013 09:00 HiroPro wrote:
to be honest, this game is kind of silly. i still haven't gone through viscera's posts but we literally cannot win (since we won't be able to get lynches) unless one of chaoser/bill/sinani is mafia.

On May 17 2013 09:31 HiroPro wrote:
w/e, i'll just hope for some luck in that regard.

Voting for Viscera because:

- the early WaveOfShadow vote looks artificial ("Abnormally high ratio of gif/pics"), this has nothing to do with alignment
- he constantly emphasizes early on that Obvious is lurky and lacks skill as mafia and then somehow reaches the conclusion that it's entirely possible for obvious to be a good mafia player.
- The assertion that the townie thing for obvious to do was to self-vote and suicide is complete nonsense and seems made up.

##Vote VisceraEyes

On May 18 2013 05:32 HiroPro wrote:
I think BH is mafia for 2 reasons: the first being that he has avoided any discussion of the major lynches of today and the second being that he seems very willing to overblow minor issues.

If you look at day 2, what have been the major lynches of the day? The first is the push onto VisceraEyes and the second is the lynch attempt on me. Almost every player has either made a vote onto one of these lynches or voiced their opinions about the two of us. Blazinghand though has been active during this time period, has been asked numerous times to comment on what he thinks of me, yet hasn't made a single comment on whether VisceraEyes or myself are mafia/town. I can't think of a single town reason to avoid this issue, yet I can think of several reasons that a mafia player might do this: he doesn't want to offer up opinions because he's afraid of being wrong or defending a teammate, he would rather see another no-lynch as people are unable to consolidate, he's waiting to see which person will be lynched and then jump on at the last second.

My next problem with Blazinghand is that he seems willing to ignore the major events that occur around him and instead focuses on relatively minor things. Discarding the "10/10" WaveOfShadow lynch for ObviousOne because he martyred and then later indicated that he was willing to live is a small example. The bigger one though is what has happened today between himself and prplhz. Depending on what the KP formula is, we're looking at a MYLO/LYLO situation here. Every town player should be trying to find the best possible lynch. Yet Blazinghand has seemingly decided to go after prplhz on psuedo-policy reasons. This comment in particular seems completely off: "Show me where he does this as scum OR tell me you have a red check on him OR tell me this is a policy lynch." Why on earth would prplhz saying that he's policy lynching kushm4sta make it an acceptable push when BH apparently feels that no case on kushm4sta is acceptable without showing that he does that behavior as mafia? This isn't day 1, we're not in a situation where policy lynches are feasible or good, so why would Blazinghand be ok with that as town? The simple answer is that Blazinghand has an easy reason to vote for someone as mafia. This isn't even considering the fact that declaring that someone can only be lynched if you can prove that they've done this exact same thing as mafia before is a completely ludicrous statement.

I think BH has the best chance of flipping mafia today, so everyone should vote for him.

##Unvote
##Vote Blazinghand

On May 18 2013 05:54 Blazinghand wrote:
for the record hiropro is a hideously bad lynch. he's not scum just a bad player. prplhz' is making this shit case against kush and opting out of the discussion and yall are just letting it slide for some reason. vote prplhz

On May 19 2013 05:49 kushm4sta wrote:
quadruple post for mafia justice.
read his filter its only 2 pages there are myriad reasons why the man is scum..

1 robotic overuse of misapplied meta in his arguments

2 constantly talking about past games instead of this game

3 vayne tunneling him, sure he's scum. then vayne dies

4 his top scumread is hiro d1. Nothing he says ever indicates that that changes. Yet on d2 he makes this random ass out of the blue case on me to distance himself from the hiro mislynch. If you are town and your top scumread has a huge bandwagon, why wouldn't you help push that wagon instead of introducing some lynch that's never going to happen.

5 his longest post in the game is about me. If you think I'm scummy, fine, but my content was so paltry at that time that a wall of text to analyze it is going way overboard.