RED Team's Prize - Page 15

On April 03 2013 07:58 Keirathi wrote:

You're missing the point.

If prplhz is scum and has been telling the truth about his role, he's probably going to use it tonight regardless. We have me+cora+hapa+you with "blue" claims. It really doesn't matter if he kills one of us, or you. But telling him who to kill means he has something to be accountable for. Killing anyone besides you proves that he's mafia, and killing you but you flip town ALSO proves that he's mafia. (*isclaimer: at least within a relative certainty. I still don't think any of Hapa/S&B/marv are scum).

Literally the only scenario that prplhz isn't proven to be mafia is if he shoots you and you flip scum.

On April 03 2013 07:59 Keirathi wrote:

If you're town, then this is the fucking dumbest thing you've said all game.

If you waste your shot on marv and we end up losing because of it, I will rage at you so fucking hard when the game is over.

On April 03 2013 08:33 strongandbig wrote:


so i thought that but then i remembered how hard oats "claimed mafia" during the day phase with his own similar paranoid dont kill me stuff. so now i'm not so sure it's alignment indicative as opposed to paranoia indicative.

that said, ryan i don't think your stuff makes sense. the only reason prp giving the gun to smurf instead of sinani would have been "claiming scum" is if sinani had been non-vanilla mafia. however, your path to town losing relies on prp giving a gun to sinani tonight and sinani using it - ie, sinani being vanilla mafia. those two are incompatible.

- D4 we lynch Oats (who has claimed vanilla)

2) sinani doesn't flip:
- sinani is either vanilla town or vanilla mafia
- D4 we lynch Oats (who has claimed vanilla)
- N4 prplhz kills me, game ends or sinani is the other mafia, doesn't matter because you lynch him the next phase, prplhz proves his role at the same time.