Mad Men Mafia - Page 67

On August 10 2012 09:18 Toadesstern wrote:


well if the red check is against the #1 or at least #2 scumread in the game I don't really see how the name makes much of a difference.

On August 10 2012 09:18 talismania wrote:


wtf is this lol?

how do you expect to tell another mason who the DT is in private? How would you know that that mason wasn't scum?

On August 10 2012 09:20 Toadesstern wrote:

idk, via PM's perhaps?
I just said, even if the next Mason is a mafia he has to tell the truth or he is busted because both the DT and I can confirm wether he's telling the truth or not.

On August 05 2012 21:00 XsebT wrote:
I agree that countdropula's voting pattern and reasoning during d1 is pointing towards scum. He is all over the place with his accusations. Lazermonkey's analysis points this out quite well.
Talismania, I was too inactive during d1, so a "default scum" accusation is probably in its place. If you keep having concerns, just ask me more direct questions. I'm not quite able to keep up with you guys when it comes to posting. I will be brief and to the point when posting.
That said, I don't know why you would throw out so many scum accusations so early on, while already in the spotlight with wbg from d1. You should fear for your own survival in this game. If you're town, I consider the accusations a bad move.

On August 09 2012 21:58 talismania wrote:
Medics: LISTEN TO ME DEAR GOD lol.

That said, the NKs are fairly illuminating. Especially solstice - he was killed primarily because he's a good townie and he was correct about VE. Solstice and I were interchangeable for those purposes, but I am spared because VE is committed to getting me mislynched (a reasonable play given that he thinks he can rely on xsebt and synystyr's votes if they're town). His push on zephirdd is there because he knows there's support for it from dropula at least I guess.

Who the mafia are:

VE
hassybaby
BKE
other two are somewhere in hier, glasse, dropula, synystyr I think. My bet is hier glasse at the moment.

_________________

In response to VE:

He set a trap by not talking about zephirdd? Ok... I'm just following up on anything and everything you say because I think you're scum. You said you were going to look at him again, therefore I wanted to know if you followed through on that as scum tend not to. I don't know zeph's alignment for sure but I do lean town.

_________________

VisceraEyes is scum.

(A) He makes lazy cases that are unresearched. Not just against me, but also against erandorr and against zephirdd. Read what I wrote about his case on me yesterday.

(B) He REFUSED TO KEEP IN CONTACT VIA PMs WITH SOMEONE (1) AND HE THOUGHT THAT THAT PERSON WAS SCUM (2).

Let me expand on that further - so you're a townie in VE's shoes. You think maybe I'm scum and that I'm connected with zephirdd. Therefore you set a trap... by refusing to talk to me about zephirdd???? Why, if I'm scum, do I keep haranguing a townie to find out what his read is on my scumbuddy??????????? Why the fuck would I care about that if I were scum? Especially because in that scenario, I'm trying to lynch the guy I'm haranguing. So why would I give a shit about how good his reads are on other people in my scum team? Why would I call attention to that?

No.

If you're townie, and you're a mason, and you suspect that the guy you're masoned with is scum you PRESS him. You don't set traps by NOT talking about a potential scumbuddy of your target. You re-engage. Ask questions. To hammer this point home: WHY STOP TALKING TO SOMEONE YOU THINK IS SCUM? How can that possibly help? VE isn't afraid of being manipulated, I know that. So why, after he switches back to thinking I'm scum, does he show no interest in talking anymore?

(C) I just realized that VE accidentally might have just trapped himself with this zephirdd thing.

To explain: he is claiming that he ignored my questions about zephirdd because he thought I was scum, and wanted to see what happened.

Let's look at the first assertion he makes:



+ Show Spoiler +

Our whole conversation was about zephirdd? Please. Firstly:



If by this you mean "after some negligible small talk about irc and skype", the course of our conversation was this:

You: what do you think about erandorr
Me: I'm looking into him but think he's town for the most part.
You: yeah here's why I think eran is scum. also here are my other scumreads, which I'm giving to you completely UNPROMPTED.
Me: Oh, I'd like to hear more about that zephirdd guy since you mentioned him earlier in the thread as well.

How the hell do you go from that to getting that the entire conversation was building up to me asking about zephirdd? It wasn't. VE brought zephirdd's name up, unprompted. Not me.

It gets better though.

My follow-up question about zephirdd was sent on August 7, 8:29. His reply about giving him some time to get home came August 7, 12:47. Then my follow up question since he didn't say anything in that reply about zeph, then he goes cold in PMs. Despite this, he makes the following post in the thread:



He's also posted that he's done in PMs. So he thinks I'm wrong town - yet when I ask him to just follow up on his read about zephirdd (after this post) he does nothing as a trap? How does that make sense? Like imagine you're a townie, and you think a wrong townie is on your case, possibly putting you in danger of being lynched. You ignore their questions?

By the way, AFTER all those quotes of me asking about zephirdd he makes the following post addressed to me:



Indicating that, at the very least, he still leans town on me. So during that entire period of ignoring my follow-up question to something he brought up he did not actually have a scumread on me. This "trap" was made up after the fact. It wasn't until after the lynch that he PMs me, saying that I "fooled" him and he was onto me and all that.

(D) VE has very few doubts. In general, townies are unsure about their scumreads. Read through all of VE's scumreads. He's never uncertain. I don't know his meta on this point but at the very least I consider this a weak scumtell.

##Vote: VisceraEyes