Movie Star Mini Mafia! - Page 4

On June 27 2012 12:56 Mattchew wrote:

I'm trying to win by avoiding a mis lynch

I'm appealing to the same logic you've used to push my lynch Aka none

On June 27 2012 12:43 rastaban wrote:
Until we get a verbal confirmation that we have enough people to kill xsksc please no one switch your vote. Mafia would love nothing more than have us do a no lynch. If someone switches and makes us have a mislynch I will do my best to get you policy lynched tomorrow.

On June 17 2012 19:53 marvellosity wrote:
Mafia heuristic: if an outrageous play is retarded from both a scum and a town viewpoint, it is usually from mafia

On June 28 2012 06:54 VisceraEyes wrote:
I also prefer a Matthchew lynch - or a prplhz lynch, or a risk.nuke lynch.

On June 28 2012 08:41 marvellosity wrote:
ok but no-one else claimed rb. ok scratch that sorry

On June 27 2012 03:42 Shraft wrote:
Snarfs meta

Here's a short list that describes Snarfs' posting in EMM (where he was mafia) quite accurately:

1. Comments on everything, but he has few (if any) scum reads of his own.
   
2. Has a few lenghty posts, but none of them contain much own thoughts, it's mostly just short stuff about everything going on.
   
3. Always has an opinion that corresponds well with what others have already said.
   
4. Applies light pressure often, but rarely follows through. Doesn't push his reads hard.
   
5. Tends to ask other people for their opinion rather than voicing his own thoughts.
   
6. As the number of players dwindles, he starts providing more content and more own thought. Probably because it's harder to just blend in.
   

Here are Snarfs' post game thoughts:


I compared Snarfs' play in EMM (where he was scum) to his play in WoF MM (where he was a vigilante), and I found some differences:

1. He seems to be willing to post more as town. He had a 2,5 page filter in EMM (excluding post game stuff) despite surviving until N5. In WoF he had a 4 page filter even though he got killed during N3.
   
2. His posting seems more condensed as mafia. He posts about a couple of subjects at once and only makes short remarks, whereas as town, he seems to be more focused in his posting.
   
3. Less interrogative questions as town than as mafia. (Although he still poses a fair amount of questions.)
   
4. Way stronger scum reads as town. Look at this post that he submitted before getting shot to death. He didn't post anything that even remotely resembles this post during EMM.
   

I think that it's too early to guess his alignment based on meta in this game, but his play looks more like his town meta to me. The way he presents his case on Zephirdd doesn't seem like his conservative scum play in EMM. However, it could just be him adapting his scum play according to his post game thoughts in EMM, which makes me quite uncertain.

Conclusion: Snarfs is still a null tell to me. I spent one hour researching his meta, but it didn't make me any more certain on his alignment. ._.

On June 28 2012 22:54 Mattchew wrote:
Marv

To simplify your process I will give you a step by step of how you should approach everything.

We are in Lynch Scum or Lose. Mis-lynching town or the SK will result in a scum victory

The first and MOST IMPORTANT thing you need to do is come up with a final read on Risk.
The reason for this, is that he is pretty much the only player 100% guaranteed not to be the SK.
Personally I believe him to be town. I don't think there is any logical reason for scum to hold their RB when I believe the SK has been hunting them all game (Zeph then Xsksc were scummy targets that I doubt scum would shoot at and I believe SK shot at them to kill mafia). It would be extremely bold of them to hold their RB and increase the chances of one of them being hit by SK.

If you disagree, I feel that you must vote and lynch Risk because if you are correct, he will flip scum 100%. There is no one else you can say this for.

---

If you agree with my assessment that Risk is town, then you have 5 players left, 4 of which are not town. I think the first step you must take is trying to remove the remaining townie from the pool of 5. This way (and this is so weird to actually say out loud) you can start to play connect-the-scum, something that normally can demolish town. However in this scenario, it is actually the best way to try and lynch a scum team member over the SK or townie.

Any route you choose I will support, other than voting me for lynch. I also will help you think out your reads if you would like my opinions. Basically Marv, the game comes down to your reads, no one else's, if you read the situation as Risk being town then his reads also matter, but until that point, the game is on your shoulders.

On June 28 2012 23:13 Mattchew wrote:

I mean I dont think you are the SK and I think town is me/marv/risk so I dont really care much for your opinions no offense

On June 29 2012 00:13 marvellosity wrote:
The only player at the moment where my read on risk/matt others at the moment doesn't matter is prplhz.

##unvote
##vote: prplhz

On June 29 2012 00:42 Shraft wrote:
prplhz your case is fucking shit. You didn't even bother responding to me when I pointed out that some stuff is your case is factually wrong.

@rastaban
Well, you are my #1 scum read at the moment, and you are comfortable lynching prplhz, and that makes me kind of wary...

On June 29 2012 00:48 marvellosity wrote:


so you believe risk is scum?