Because if he is town, as seems likely, we are lynching town? Not being shot by mafia is fine as presumably he will be posting more and make himself look towny to everyone else. Further, the roleblocker will eventually die.

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 17:43 GMT

#555

prplhz looks pretty awful. He doesn't really have many opinions of his own, asks a lot of questions and his posts are constructed in a way that makes it look like he is just filling space. He appears certain that redff isn't mafia, but also thinks he has to be lynched at some point. Just look at this post

Okay I don't think that redFF is scum because he's been pretty out there. The scummiest he has done in my opinion is his claim which was oddly timed. Right now he's a terribly easy lynch, because we'll have to lynch him at some point. I'd like to see wherebugsgo explain how everything redFF has done can be explained by scum motivation and can not be explained by town motivation. The worst thing about this whole redFF thing is that the lynch is so easy that everybody can just pile onto him and then the day is kinda ruined, we aren't going to find anybody else. I don't think that redFF is scum because he's just been putting himself too much in the line of fire.

A lot of things are suspicious about this post, but just to name one he asserts that redff is an easy lynch and thus we "aren't going to find anybody else". That is complete nonsense and just seems filler. Him randomly assigning blame on wbg seems off too. He thinks redff is not scum, but hasn't even tried to find anyone else. The only thing he has going for him is his attack on bc, but considering he is just sheeping me and not pushing at all, that doesn't mean much. He hasn't bothered to post today and he has definitely been around but doesn't seem to care.

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 17:48 GMT

#556

Since apparently the votes for BC aren't going to be there, how about we lynch prplhz instead

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 18:06 GMT

#567

RoL, but you are voting for redff still. Do you think it's likely that he will flip scum?

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 18:07 GMT

#568

Prplhz that seems awfully convenient timing

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 18:09 GMT

#569

By the way, it's page 28 and 15 minutes ago so you not being "totally up to date" means you are only missing the last 15 minutes

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 18:11 GMT

#572

Lynch prplhz please. You would be very dissatisfied with getting lynched day 1? Does that mean you would be satisfied with being lynched later? Isn't that worse? How does saying that make sense at all

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 18:17 GMT

#577

A lot of people have stated that they aren't willing to lynch BC on day 1 and I'll be around for 2+ hours in case we can actually make that happen. Also I think prplhz might look worse, especially after showing up like that immediately after I started pushing for him and then basically lying about not being up to date.

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 18:18 GMT

#579

Would you be open to posting your notes then? Right now?

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 18:24 GMT

#585

RoL so I take it that means you think redff has the highest chance of flipping scum then? Out of all the people in the game?

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 18:33 GMT

#592

On February 23 2012 03:29 prplhz wrote:

Show nested quote +

Because I didn't want to post as long as I wasn't in danger of getting lynched and as long as I wasn't fully up date with my notes and with reading filters.

That sounds almost too bad to be scum. You say you are trying your best, try to be active when "i need you (????)" and you've been making tons of notes. Yet despite all this, you have made no effort at all to stop a lynch of someone you consider town from happening. You never really even said who you would like to be lynched instead.

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 18:42 GMT

#597

Never ever not post because "you are not up to date" with the thread or because you haven't reread all the filters. Townie should never be afraid of posting their opinion. If you are fine making a note, you should be fine with making a post. Just reading a single post can be sufficient as your post can focus on commenting what is being said in that specific post.

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 18:49 GMT

#603

No we have not dropped the lynch, BC lynch is still a possibility

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 19:00 GMT

#613

Sigh prplhz why didn't you post those reads earlier. I'm switching back to BC for now but don't disappear anywhere

##vote bloodycobbler

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 20:11 GMT

#622

I don't know why you are rating BC's town play so high. You should rate players based on how you have seen them perform, not based on how long they have played. I doubt anyone would double stack BC in this game and probably won't even bother shooting him n1 especially with his current activity.

Anyway, I'll be on for another 30 minutes and as I'm relatively certain that redff is our tracker, I will be voting BC over him. The lynch is in less than two hours.

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 20:19 GMT

#624

There's no one arguing against the BC lynch, which I guess is bad. Getting the votes hasn't been particularly easy, but still now would be the time for there to start being some resistance in terms of thread activity. I suppose some people may not be around yet and I still think the lynch is better than redff one.

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 20:29 GMT

#633

The only one who seems like could attract votes is BH and I don't find him a particularly good lynch right now. I'm off now so someone else has to be pushing for a different lynch if it for some reason starts to look like BC isn't mafia. Given the time left and the complete lack of interest from most players, I doubt anything can be made to happen.

Kita I know you have been around and yet do not care enough to even post. This is the second game in a row you have been completely worthless in thread and at least in arkham you were town. Is this your new standard of play?

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 20:30 GMT

#634

I should just playing in these newbie mafia games as they are more interested in playing and probably also better than the vast majority of "vets" on TL.

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 22 2012 20:31 GMT

#635

EBWOP start playing*

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

February 23 2012 06:03 GMT

#812

Well I'm just not going to bother posting anymore and just silently vote