You have that many PMs huh? Since what you mostly do is play Mafia, I think you pretty much just admitted to being scum in one of the games you currently have going.

Also...... I have no idea which way to vote today. Not sure it matters since you only need a majority of 3 I believe.

I'm very dissatisfied with how you are actively inferring things about my alignment, publicly, for a game that you are not in.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 16 2012 03:04 GMT

#750

BUMP

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 16 2012 03:05 GMT

#753

well that sucked more

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 16 2012 03:08 GMT

#754

I'm fresh out of ideas, I hope you guys have something.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 17 2012 04:29 GMT

#782

Wow nice well played EchelonTee.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 17 2012 04:37 GMT

#784

:D

I really wanted to win this game.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 17 2012 05:22 GMT

#788

There are people on this forum, like Foolishness, who should be lynched day2 if they don't get killed night1.

Then there are other people on this forum, like sinani206, who should be killed night1 if they don't get lynched day1.

+ Show Spoiler +

JUST KIDDING, RELAX

... what I'm saying is that sinani206 usually plays in a way that gets him lynched early on because he's hyper-vocal and he doesn't take shit from anybody and maybe some would say that he's kinda difficult to work with. Makes him a very easy to lynch but he doesn't give a shit because AMERICA. Also, he's way too smart to think my joke-vote was for real and he used it to fish for empathy when I think he'd usually be all "WHAT THE FUCK YOU ARE TERRIBLE AT THIS GAME JOKE VOTES ARE FOR MORONS ##VOTE PRPLHZ". He was waaay too meek and he was fine being out of the spot light and that's something that townies shouldn't be (and something that I've never seen sinani206 be). I think you had a good day1 but after that it went down hill. You acted so confused and pressured for the rest of the game (especially day3) but there were better targets around I felt. I was really totally convinced that Nisani201 was the last scum.

I think this town overall has a lot to learn, myself included. We were in a great position after night1 but we didn't manage to take advantage of that situation too well. I played like I had set out to from the beginning of the game but it didn't work as well as I had hoped for and I'll see if I can adjust that for my future games

GG everybody.

And yes, day3 was fucking horrible. That was the worst day of mafia I have ever played.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 19 2012 03:11 GMT

#806

TheToast clearly played a decent game, he successfully convinced everybody on day1 that he was town and he kept up his activity throughout the entire game. That said, his reads were all over the place. So he accused EchelonTee of being scum at some point, who didn't he accuse at any point? If I hadn't been vigilante this game would likely have been essentially lost on day1 because of his mindless tunneling of seemingly random people. He accused like everybody and refused to discuss anything and that's big part of the reason nobody listened to him.

This game isn't just about having a correct list of scum on day1, it's about winning. If you want to win you can't just be good at finding scum, you also need to be good at getting them lynched, and TheToast had a hard time getting anybody lynched primarily because he was annoying, spammy, and chaotic.

I think TheToast was second best townie in this game (after me, yea) but how he was incessantly on my back was also part of the reason EchelonTee was so successful in buddying with me. There simply wasn't an alternative supporter in this town because TheToast spent the entire game yelling at me and nobody else seemed to care too much about the game. I'm not blaming TheToast for anything, I should have been able to win this game from the position I was able to put myself in, but going around saying "lol, i knew scum team, the other guys just didn't listen" isn't going to make anybody any better at this game and that would be sad. Ultimately, I enjoyed playing with TheToast because he was the only townie besides me who I think really cared about this game. Even though he got on my nerves so fucking bad I wanted to replace out more than a few times.

I wrote my opinion on EchelonTee right after the BaronFel lynch, he looked town but mostly because everybody else made that very easy. Some other townies didn't really care about this game, some were just dicking around, some intentionally spent a big portion of the game trying to get on my bad side. In hindsight, I see that EchelonTee was the last scum and hopefully I learned from it and will not be making a similar mistake again in a future game.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 19 2012 03:55 GMT

#809

I totally disagree that my random vote was bad for town. I nailed sinani206 in big part because of his reaction to my random vote and the only guy who thought I was scummy because of it was TheToast. I mean, he really thought I was pushing a sinani206 lynch based on how he killed my command center. The third time TheToast brought this up I facepalmed so hard that I almost put my hand through my skull. Also, your reaction to my day3 Nisani201 vote sheeping was really scummy to me, I was really pissed that my second biggest town read was acting so confused but I decided that it wasn't too important. If I had been able to use it a little better I think it would have been a game winning move, in the end it just allowed me to kill a scum and it didn't do any harm at all.

I don't think the town environment was all too bad, there was some inactivity and there were people with null/town lists, there were people who didn't care about the game, there were people who spent the entire game fighting against me instead of trying to debate with me, there was how I just took charge of everything after night1 which made people feel less encouraged to do original work, but overall it was alright. Look at the other minis, this game was decent in activity and analysis so it absolutely wasn't bad.

I think the mafia shots were absolutely alright although you should have picked up on the "final defense" thing (so should I). I really wanted to speak up for [UoN]Sentinel on day3 (as this post shows) but I couldn't make myself do it when he had straight up admitted to being "dicking around". Meh, don't ever do that again. Dick around or admit to it. There's nothing people who are taking this game seriously hates more than people not taking it seriously at all. Anyway, your shots were good in my opinion since you were planning on buddying with me and there could have been a medic prevent them. Shooting lurkers and buddying with active townies and shooting active townies while hiding among lurkers are both decent I think. Maybe you should have shot Bluelightz and [UoN]Sentinel first because first gamers can be really hard to read for town.

prplhz

Denmark8045 Posts

February 19 2012 15:35 GMT

#811

I don't really see it that way. Every single person I pushed in this game got lynched over people other people wanted to get lynched (excluding day3 but that was a weird day). I'm not really concerned that nobody WANTED to listen to me, as long as they ultimately did listen to me.