BC's Arkham City - Page 2

On February 10 2012 01:45 layabout wrote:

can you cut this out or explain yourself?

On February 10 2012 01:57 Jayjay54 wrote:


You forgot Doc's hit.

Might it occur to you that you check has been false due to your role? e.g. insane cop?

Your play doesn't make sense from a scum point of view either...but Doc is town. Deal with it.

On February 10 2012 07:42 VisceraEyes wrote:
VisceraEyes Lynch List of Correctitude v2.0

Opz - A lurker - and a site-veteran lurker. He's on Jackal's list of phone-network buddies, but I haven't seen much in the way of finding scum from Opz. Every passing hour that he hasn't done shit in the thread is another reason we should hang this guy.

On February 10 2012 09:02 Radfield wrote:


This is the vote total 1.5 hours before the lynch. Between this time and the lynch 5 more people vote for CC.

Liquid`sheth
jackal
opz
evantrees
billmurray

Sheth obviously doesn't count, and Jackal is dead. Bill Murray votes with a 1/2 hour to go, and actually switches onto CC from Kurumi. The CC lynch was already assured at that point, and mafia would want to distance themselves from the CC lynch at that point. That probably makes BM less likely to be scum, but BM loves his WIFOM.

Opz and evantrees were the 2 votes that cemented the CC lynch.

Evantrees only mention of CC prior to voting him:


next post:


Evantrees has done nothing redeeming this game. He is still talking about mechanics, speculating on night hits, and in general doing very little. Evantrees is very likely scum.

---

Opz's switches votes onto CC. He also hedges by stating that he DOES actually want Sheth dead, just not yet.


Opz is also actively cutting players down and somehow siding with Schworz out of that mess:
+ Show Spoiler +

Opz is clearly not following along very closely, though it's certainly possible that that is due to IRL reasons. Very possibly scum, though less likely than evantrees in my mind. Both are good targets.

Other than that it's kinda hard to get a good quick reconstruction on the voting pattern. In fact, up till that point the voting counts were pretty obscured, unless someone took the time go through them. Here is the breakdown in votes for each Sheth and CC:

+ Show Spoiler +

Tyrran, Bugs and Chaoser all rally when Sheth is leading by 3 votes. And frankly, all three look decently scummy. I haven't actually reread Day 1 yet, but I'm looking forward to it once Sheth flips. Obviously all 5 players are not likely to be mafia, but unless scum bussed Sheth hard Day 1, at least 2-3 probably are.

On February 07 2012 04:53 jaybrundage wrote:



Yay a vote of my very own :D

Alright lets get down to business.

It's Business, It's Business time.
You know when i get down to my socks its Business time.
Thats why there called Busness socks.

First off Kenpachi's claim so to speak is irrelevant and should be ignored.

Batman will be doing DT checks. Getting the Joker to roleclaim is dumb and very anti town.

I find VE's OMGUS really odd. Cracking under pressure maybe?

On February 07 2012 07:55 jaybrundage wrote:

You misunderstand me. Kenpachi's claim has no connection with whether hes mafia or town. Because he does regardless of what role or alignment he is. It's fine if it generates discussion. But I would not consider it a scum tell or a townie trait.

On February 09 2012 16:47 jaybrundage wrote:
Imma try to write as i go pretty far behind 30 pages about half way thru. First time trying this lets see how it goes :D

Tunkeg are you seriously doing your tunneling to the death again. It was bad in student mafia and its bad now. You have to stop getting so emotinally invested. If someone offends you it does not mean they are mafia. You need to stop this bad play now its anti town. Put a case but dont do this emotional bullshit.

Toad claims Two-face and says hes immortal. Just a bad play regardless. I think he has some "plan" and it probably involves a fake claim.

Wait Palmar is twoface too thats wierd. Nvm why would Palmar make that thing up with toad i dont get it.

Maybe a counter to cat women. (Perhaps hes Poison Ivy trying to get Catwomen to DT, take a hit at her and then Idk maybe a tracker/watcher involved (forgot which does which) to out the third party) Its wierd to say the least. I kind of dont like it because information is gold in a mafia game. And if you really are Twoface you just gave away information for free : /

Jackal Claims Santa Claus
Scare Crow? maybe Nvm hes zasza (he died)


Crazy QT buziness going on. Apparently a fake Palmar in the QT?

BM claims Hush the medic. I still have no idea why everyone is claiming this game. Is it because of the unique names. Its very wierd.

Wow this is a crazy fucken game. Toad tried to draw a bullet for RGthetwoface but Rg Counterclaims and totally loses the chance of not dying rofl so we have a dead blue tonight god this game is crazy

Offtopic But pics of Opz in creased pants and a button up or it didnt happen

And Jackal died looks like he was blue crazy he got to kill people in his own QT :o

And two townies as well

Both inmates were insane (miller) correct its not a typo.

It seems wierd that two insane townies got killed i would almost say the work of some wierd role. And it looks like one mafia/vig shot got blocked. A claim of a hit from RGtheshouldbedead. Well i caught up. Im really tired atm so no analazy from me i will try to be a bit more active tho D:

On February 10 2012 08:53 jaybrundage wrote:

Lol WBG really, you're nitpicking at literally nothing.

Radfield DTs Sheth comes red so he can be a miller, or mafia or Radfield is lying. I dont think Radfield is lying cause thats dumb as fuck.

So miller or mafia. And at this point what would you do WBG your the best scum player I know. So would you bus Sheth?

Oh wait of course you would because your not mentally retarded. And yes information if fucken great this game is all about information. If we can determine if Radfield alignment and nail scum why wouldn't we lynch Sheth.

On February 10 2012 13:08 jaybrundage wrote:
@OpZ

Am i a great contributer no. I find it really hard to find a read on people this game (maybe partly of the spam). And im usually playing in minis so its quite different im trying to post more and post my thoughts.

OpZ what are you other scum reads besides my self.

On February 10 2012 16:37 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
OpZ all you did was repeat the same case I made twice. So far it seems like that's your only contribution to this thread as it is. why are you so fucking this game you were way better than this in that TF2 mafia

On February 11 2012 07:23 rgTheSchworz wrote:
Ok, medic that protected me, make a claim if you wish.
It would be damn time.
Lynch this scum: Jaybrundage.
No, town is not gonna lynch an ally.

On February 11 2012 09:06 ~OpZ~ wrote:

Excuse me, Which game is this?

On February 11 2012 11:33 DoctorHelvetica wrote:

Arkham City in which all you've done was roleplay uselessly for a day then parrot everything I said to make a case on a lurker

What's the problem exactly? Haven't you called for vig's to shoot me multiple times now too?

On February 11 2012 14:33 DoctorHelvetica wrote:

I don't remember the number. Was it not the TF2 mafia game where we banded together in irc and you were useful or do I have you confused with someone else?



You were just saying I'm scum, I remembered wrong. Someone else said I should be shot or on a shoot list, maybe it was Palmar?

Regardless you've never called me out for spamming before as far as I can remember. this isn't the first game we've played together and it isn't the first time I'm the most prolific poster. I always am. All you did was flip out about all the claims all throughout Day 2 then push a case I made, probably because it was easy and didn't require you to make your own analysis. You haven't really done anything. In the first day you were just distracting with your worthless roleplaying shit. If you want to criticize other players for ruining the thread, look at yourself. You didn't do shit day 1, criticized Chaoser for a "worthless" post despite posting even less substance than he had.

Then you say "I knew DocH was scum all along." really? Why didn't you say anything? rG's fake DT check was the perfect opportunity for scum to do this bullshit but they had nowhere to go with it when rG couldn't back himself up and Radfield made the more convincing claim.

Chaoser was pretty worthless on Day 1 but you were worse. Roleplaying, being selective, not even pushing the player who according to you "reeked of scum Day 1", why was it that you didn't want to say anything? It's not like I wouldn't respond seeing as I post more often than anyone else, how do you justify criticizing other players for not contributing then contribute zero and not only that you don't even bother to make the case? All you've done for your "scumhunting" is agree/disagree with people or with jaybrundage repeat the exact same shit I said. That's not good enough. I make a lot of mistakes, I mix peoples names up and I post too much, I'm sloppy, but I'm not stupid enough to not make a case on a player I think is scum when there is a contested lynch. You had nothing on me Day 1 to call me scum, which is why you didn't. Getting to say you thought so all along when there is doubt (that is quickly stamped out) about it isn't convincing. You're also coming off like you're disappointed that my roleclaim checks out, disappointed that you can't push me for a bad lynch.

You didn't call for vig shots repeatedly. That post of yours I quoted about adding me and toad, I remembered as something like "remember to shoot toad/doch", the part earlier were you talk about killing me could have been about lynches. If I'm confusing you with a different player who I communicated with in that TL Mafia game (TF2 theme, kurumi was host I think) then correct me because my memory is horrible and I might be wrong. Even if I'm wrong about that all these points still stand. So put up or shut up.

On February 11 2012 18:58 rgTheSchworz wrote:
Voting for me is a waste at this point in time JayJay.
Even if you think i m scum because I lied,then you should shoot Palmar because he lied too.
Can t say that I agree with chaoser defending me.
Trusting what you think on first impulse is bad.
On the other hand, how can you explain my actions, in a way that I end up scum?
Reasonably, I should ve been scumcoached by now.would they allow me to endanger their team?

On February 11 2012 23:12 Kurumi wrote:
Opz, have You found Penguin yet?

On February 11 2012 19:08 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Whatever. I hope you got modkilled and replaced, I'm pretty sure you're town but your behavior is just so awful that I came pretty close to ragequitting this game.

On February 12 2012 13:00 kitaman27 wrote:
Layabout, I'll respond to some of your posts if I survive the night. I'm afraid I'd run out of time getting this in before the deadline if I wasted time responding to you. It should also be noted that I haven't had a great chance to read through the thread after the Sheth flip. Most of these reads have been just filter searching without the context of the entire thread in mind.

The badguys:
ico/rayzorflash
chaoser or bugs (possibly both)
evantrees
jaybrundage
Palmar
Radfield


chaoser
When the lynch was between Sheth and Cyber, he never mentions Sheth's name once. For a lynch that seems evenly split, it is certainly strange that he doesn't have an opinion. He have been going after all the wrong people. He has a theme of picking apart poorly constructed ideas or posts, but none of his posts add much value to the thread. It feels to me that he is more interested in complaining about the state of the thread or defending himself than finding scum. I think he would be a good lynch tomorrow.

ico/rayzorflash:
I made a case earlier and his replacement hasn't really changed my mind. Look at the way he talks about Sheth:



Willing to call him scum (because he knows he is), but unwilling to vote for him. I think he is a good secondary lynch candidate tomorrow.

wherebugsgo:
I'm running out of time to get this in before the deadline so I won't develop an entire case just yet, but he has been off his game thus far. He starts off with a forced case on schworz, which reminds me of the LSB case in Responsibility Mafia. He hard defends the sheth lynch against CC. As a mafia player, I don't think he has any problem sticking up for a scumbuddy if need be. The don't lynch sheth nonsense on day two reminds me of how he tried to dispute the role cop claim in couples mafia. He's willing to push a scum objective when most people would think "scum would never do that". I'll have to reevaluate him in the near future.

jaybrundage

He doesn't really have many posts to go by. His biggest post is essentially just a summary of what is going on. I found it funny that he posted this a few hours before the deadline when its like 20 votes for sheth and 2 votes for random other people. Who exactly were you trying to convice?



evantrees:
Nothing in his filter really shows that he cares about town. His vote on CC is really spontaneous and he doesn't seem to give an adequate reason.

Radfield:

I don't see town motivation for his dt claim. A detective's biggest fear is the roleblock. Why claim after one check if you're going to be useless for the rest of the game? A town detective would push the lynch without claiming, which doesn't totally shut down discussion for the day, gives the town more information since the lynch isn't set in stone and protects his identity from rb. To me, the claim seems like an attempt at gaining town cred. Claiming the hit likely makes him third party, but with the scum medic/scum vet possibility, I'd reevaluate the possibility that he could be scum down the road.

Palmar:
Lying, trolling, and spamming. He is destroying the thread with nonsense. I still don't see him as town. His claimed shot on radfield makes third party a strong possibility. I just wish that he could go about his business without posting.

Possible Others:
kurumi: fake vig claim
Adam: not quite sure I have a good reason.
BM: Similarities in playstyle to L
opz: I've enjoyed the roleplaying, but have no idea what his alignment is
There are several players whose filters I haven't read in a good 72 hours.

On February 11 2012 20:53 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
He could be lying about the shot. Radfield actually didn't specify if it was by medic or not.

They could both be third party.

On February 11 2012 20:43 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
No, I don't believe OpZ claimed Penguin. Did someone claim Penguin? If that happened I didn't read it. OpZ has been worthless in this game but he's probably got a similar role to me. I'm not good at picking up on other players breadcrumbs.

I can't die to Batman naturally. I can die to scum/vig which is why I need the medic.

On February 11 2012 22:39 Toadesstern wrote:
my list still stands:
Chaoser
Sheth <--- dead
forumite
risk.nuke
opz
layabout
hiro
Lynch these people unless you got a good damn reason not to.