Mr. Wiggles Mini Mafia I - Page 19

On December 28 2011 23:32 Shraft wrote:
Why'd you go all inactive on us yesterday? If you'd posted this only a few hours earlier, we might have had the power to lynch GiygaS. [...]

On December 29 2011 00:27 Dirkzor wrote:
Problem with hyshes is that he is a null read. I would like to send him of to the devil or whatever he believes in, but where does it leaves us if he flips town?

On December 29 2011 00:21 Dirkzor wrote:


Why?

Oh lets see. They were both quite active when we discussed policy lynched in the beginning. 2-4 post for each of them with nothing in it. They both did not jump the wagon for seph but tried to push another townie. Cyber FoS' me and Misder voted Jay with very little. They were both ended up voting jay day 1 (not scummy in itself). They both went through day 2 with minimim effort.

We'll start with misder:

On day1 he was decently active. He was pushing and saying it was obvious that Seph was noobtelling. He did try to push the lynch towards Jay and his vote was on Jay. Seems okay? Not jumping the wagon, trying to find another scummy player.

But remember how easy the wagon for seph was going. Both because of us, the town, and seph's own play. Why meddle in that? Why not just push another townie so you can call it a gut read on day 2 with minimum of effort.

His last post bothers me:


What bandwagon? The wandwagon, if it was there, came a few hours before lynch. If you think he wasn't scum if it was this 'easy' why didn't you vote giygas or even hyshes. You said you thought giygas was town - okay. But there was lots of time when you voted. Why not push for hyshes then? Or come back to see if the bandwagon went as easy as you thought?

Cyber_Cheese:

Day 1 activity: Discussing policy lynches. FoS' me with a small case. A handfull of fluff posts so he appears to be active: 1 2 3 4 5

After I picked up Misders Jay push he joins in. His case is short and practicly the same as misder wrote. He later shot down some of jays defence.

Day 2 he comes out with a post attacking myself, Shraft, Jay and Hyshes. Jay is confirmed town. Hyshes is the easiest target in the book and Shraft and myself har the most towniest around - imo. This post isn't really a case but it just appears to add to the discussion again. His logic about that i should be scum if jay was scum i can't follow at all. He say that my vote switching saved jay on day 1... I changed TO jay and came back half a day later and knew it was last time to change my vote. Changed to seph to get a lynch. But by his logic I'm town now?! He voted for me after his case on me.

Then changed to Hyshes - the easy target for scum (assuming hyshes is town)

and in the end changed to Jay. Oh and softdefending giygas here: Soft defending giygaS

So all in all i find them scummy.



Edit before posting: when reading this before posting the case didn't turn out as solid as it was in my head... Posting anyway...

On December 28 2011 21:24 Dirkzor wrote:
Where was that post yesterday ET? O_o

As much as I want to hang GiygaS I would rather hang a lurker this time around. Wouldn't be surprised that atleast 2 mafia are hiding out there chilling.

On December 29 2011 11:11 GiygaS wrote:
Also, why has Cyber_Cheese, a veteran, not been a target for the mafia? My problem right now guys is that we're at LyLo, after tonight we will have 7, if we lynch a town, that's GG right there. If we don't lynch, that's GG right there. We need to broaden our horizons. I urge people to think about the big picture.

On December 28 2011 10:49 Adam4167 wrote:
I'm here now, I overslept.

My vote on hyshes was a pressure vote, hoping to provoke some kind of reaction or well... anything. I am still suspicious of him. However, I am open to switching to either giygas or jay after skim reading the thread quickly, both are preferable to a no-lynch.

For the record I find giygas more scummy then jay.

On December 28 2011 11:26 Adam4167 wrote:
If I could kill someone right now, it would be hyshes.

Hes given us the least of the 3 current candidates. I think it was giygas that mentioned he pulled out of another game because he was busy, but when I checked that post Here, it sounds as though he pulled out so he could focus more on this game, rather than because of a time constraint.

Jay became a bit more scummy now that hes come back, not one hour after cheese called him out saying he was going to be modkilled soon. That feels to me like hes been reading the thread all along and just lurking among the afkers. And what does he produce? a jump onto the only other wagon going that isnt his -giygas. I cant find too much in jays words that are scummy, but his actions aren't flattering.

Still, id rather hang hyshes because hes at best a null read, at worst a lurking scum. Maybe our fairy godmother vigi can visit jaybrundage tonight (if we have one).

On December 28 2011 11:54 Shraft wrote:
I'm not sure on jay, but I'd rather have a lynch than a no lynch for sure. If we have a vig, he shouldn't shoot tonight. (It's basically trading your shot for another lynch the next day unless we get a successful medic protection. DO NOT SHOOT.)

On December 29 2011 11:11 GiygaS wrote:
Also, why has Cyber_Cheese, a veteran, not been a target for the mafia? My problem right now guys is that we're at LyLo, after tonight we will have 7, if we lynch a town, that's GG right there. If we don't lynch, that's GG right there. We need to broaden our horizons. I urge people to think about the big picture.