On December 18 2011 06:47 DEUS-ex-MAFIA wrote: you don't need protection, since it doesn't matter if your dead or alive. That sounds hard but it's true. You won't be able to lead this town later in the game. In fact, I am not 100% sure that you're town and Arctocod obviously isn't either. Now better contribute something and commentate about the other players that are in the spotlight right now:
On December 18 2011 06:47 DEUS-ex-MAFIA wrote: you don't need protection, since it doesn't matter if your dead or alive. That sounds hard but it's true. You won't be able to lead this town later in the game. In fact, I am not 100% sure that you're town and Arctocod obviously isn't either. Now better contribute something and commentate about the other players that are in the spotlight right now:
sheth, bumatlarge, evantress, cascades
Sheth is likely scum, I would put him at the top of the lynch list for tomorrow.
Bumatlarge is more of a lurker and should only be killed if we have nobody else.
Evantress and Cascades are a bit suspicious, and I'm sure the cases on them will grow.
On December 18 2011 06:47 DEUS-ex-MAFIA wrote: you don't need protection, since it doesn't matter if your dead or alive. That sounds hard but it's true. You won't be able to lead this town later in the game. In fact, I am not 100% sure that you're town and Arctocod obviously isn't either. Now better contribute something and commentate about the other players that are in the spotlight right now:
On December 18 2011 06:52 DEUS-ex-MAFIA wrote: but you aren't confirmed :-[
Using a role that helps the town for all to see isn't confirmed?
You're town. Lets not argue about this more, it's a pro town abillity. The host cant be so crual as to give that to mafia, it would be unfairly crual. You've done things like you not use your abillity when arctocod was withdrawn and town was in panic. Since I don't think even the slightest that you are scum your behavior isn't scummy but just newbie play. And even though you're town you're also confirmed green throw in that a medic just might choose to protect you because you are confirmed town. This combined equals you're not an as attractive target as you belive.
Yeah, part 2 isn't coming guys, sorry. I'll just skip to the end.
Liquid`Sheth Verdict: Leaning town.
Everyone look long and hard at evantrees. I've thrice asked someone other than Bum to comment. Arctocod can't be bothered, that bothers me. Rad also is way too busy.
Of the vets, I'm the most suspicious of Radfield. He's good at looking pro-town, and I don't really have much of a problem with his posts. What I have a problem with is the fact that he's still not really willing to discuss scumhunting with anyone...like, he's all about telling people why they might be wrong, but hasn't really agreed much that anyone looks scummy aside from inactive players who can be counted on to not read and not notice. *shrug* It's not much, but right now it's all I got.
On December 18 2011 06:13 GiygaS wrote: I'm giving the temp medics job is to save me and Arc tonight, so that the other medics can focus on Radfield/Zentor? Any objections?
This isn't going to work, the 2-shot medic is only allowed to use one protection tonight
You are the Surgeon General! Upon election, you have the ability to secretly grant target player the role of 2 shot-medic. You may not grant yourself this ability. The medic may not protect themselves. Only one protection may be used per night. If the bodyguard lives, the Mayor/Pardoner may not be targeted by this action. The medic's role will not be included in their role description upon death.
Just curious Arc, you want medic protection on Radfield despite your suspicion of him and his recent inactivity? Or is this still keeping with our 'protecting the best scum hunters' policy?
On December 18 2011 06:52 DEUS-ex-MAFIA wrote: but you aren't confirmed :-[
Using a role that helps the town for all to see isn't confirmed?
You're town. Lets not argue about this more, it's a pro town abillity. The host cant be so crual as to give that to mafia, it would be unfairly crual. You've done things like you not use your abillity when arctocod was withdrawn and town was in panic. Since I don't think even the slightest that you are scum your behavior isn't scummy but just newbie play. And even though you're town you're also confirmed green throw in that a medic just might choose to protect you because you are confirmed town. This combined equals you're not an as attractive target as you belive.
Explain how his power is pro town
Sure extended day = more time for town to think over their lynches thus it may seem its a pro town ability
But the power I think is somewhat similar to a pardon given that a scum was on the chopping block, the user can possibly give that scum more time to clear himself
MrZentor had no choice but to use his power to prove he wasn't lying per Arctocods request
I'm not suspicious of Radfield. Only a few things in his play have so far given me slight cause for concern, but on the whole this still appears to be town Radfield play. He informed us of his inactivity so I'm treating that as a null indicator for now.
On December 18 2011 06:52 DEUS-ex-MAFIA wrote: but you aren't confirmed :-[
Using a role that helps the town for all to see isn't confirmed?
You're town. Lets not argue about this more, it's a pro town abillity. The host cant be so crual as to give that to mafia, it would be unfairly crual. You've done things like you not use your abillity when arctocod was withdrawn and town was in panic. Since I don't think even the slightest that you are scum your behavior isn't scummy but just newbie play. And even though you're town you're also confirmed green throw in that a medic just might choose to protect you because you are confirmed town. This combined equals you're not an as attractive target as you belive.
Explain how his power is pro town
Sure extended day = more time for town to think over their lynches thus it may seem its a pro town ability
But the power I think is somewhat similar to a pardon given that a scum was on the chopping block, the user can possibly give that scum more time to clear himself
MrZentor had no choice but to use his power to prove he wasn't lying per Arctocods request
MrZentor is not confirmed period
Even in that situation, if the person were mafia, the more time the people had to look at him, the more guilty he would seem. The town has the power during the day, and the mafia has power during the night. Extending the amount of time that the town has power and therefore increasing the likelihood of them using it correctly is pro town. Period.
Glad to see I'm not seen as auto-scum given my activity levels this game. I'm working right now, and am working again tomorrow. Thank goodness for the bonus 24 hours.
Gigyas has two options tonight for a medic. A) someone who is very much town, or B) someone unlikely to die tonight. Both options have their risks, and right now I would lean towards option A, as that guarantees us at least one potential save. The medic landing in scum hands would leave players wide open to KP.
In the interest of full-disclosure I DO NOT have the ability to double-lynch. I simply said that to get discussion rolling again as I was worried we would just cruise control the rest of the day on ProfBA. I was also roleblocked again, so scum knew very well that I was bullshitting, since even if I had the ability to double lynch I would not be able to. I want to go over the reactions again, but I think dues-ex was fairly genuine.
VisceraEyes the anarchist has gone out with a bang. bumatlarge the mafia Godfather suddenly has a lot more time for Responsibility Mafia.
Welcome to Election Mafia! You are the anarchist! You wish to bring chaos to the world. Once per game, during the day, you may suicide yourself on target player. Both yourself and your target will explode. This action will bypass medic protection, however it will not bypass bodyguard protection. You win with town.
Welcome to Election Mafia! You are the mafia Godfather! All investigative results will return the role and alignment of your choice. Please submit your cover role by the end of day one. You win with mafia.
EPT
. Anyway, I'm gonna be looking at Evantrees and Risk again before the end of the night.
