|
we need to go through this list of five.
ciryandor kenpachi serejai vaderseven sprungjeezy
of these, top 2 have conceded redness. bottom 3 are likely due to last minute voting. i am reluctant to make it 100% because risen did the same shit and he was a green. but yeah.
if ciryandor and kenpachi are bane targets they need to go by way of bane, tonight. i wonder if it is smart to get two banes to claim (if two banes exist) to coordinate shots.
also, of these people, we need to comb their profiles to see if they match any clues.
|
if a town vig/bane hits a mafia member who the mafia (or the RNG) has chosen to perform a night kill, is the night kill prevented?
|
United Kingdom10823 Posts
EBWOP: Bah, missed that last name
On November 30 2011 23:23 Hassybaby wrote:Annul, I'm gonna rephrase the list, so that people can agree/disagree and we can at least start the discussions KenpachiCiryandorShow nested quote +On November 30 2011 12:17 Ciryandor wrote:
FUCK YOU, WE GOT BOTH PALMAR AND BC. SAY GOODBYE TO TOWN. SerejaiVadersevenSprungjeezyKeep em coming I'll just keep adding to the quote. Like I said, not sure about Serajai any more, but I'll throw him on there. He's worth a check at least.
Btw, others please contribute. We need some direction so any help is appreciated. This list isn't set in stone so hopefully some decent discussions will come out of this
|
On November 30 2011 23:30 annul wrote: if a town vig/bane hits a mafia member who the mafia (or the RNG) has chosen to perform a night kill, is the night kill prevented?
I'm betting that there would be some epic story about the mafia member chasing, killing and getting killed right after the chase; or even some epic duel or something like that
|
right but its important to know how this gets resolved for game purposes. the flavor of the day post aside
|
(since usually individual mafia members arent "doing" the killing in non-clue games so hitting one red at night isnt gonna stop the whole of mafia KP. but here, when its individuals who do the killing, it may be relevant. since generally speaking mafia KP on a shooting night vig = night vig shoots before he dies...)
|
By the way, newbie DTs: you might want to consider checking players such as ciryandor and kenpachi for checking tonight. They are both very likely to be mafia and likely to die soon one way or another (lynch, vigilanties, etc). If you've been smart enough to check veteran townies such as kitaman, syllogism, jackal and the like - who all flipped green on night 1 - you would be able to confirm your sanity after you see the flip.
|
United Kingdom10823 Posts
Zephirdd, you may well have a really good point there. Which means its even more important that we nail our shots tonight.
Anyone have a good read on Hier? His sudden disappearance made me super suspicious, but he was right about Kenpachi...
|
On November 30 2011 23:33 annul wrote: (since usually individual mafia members arent "doing" the killing in non-clue games so hitting one red at night isnt gonna stop the whole of mafia KP. but here, when its individuals who do the killing, it may be relevant. since generally speaking mafia KP on a shooting night vig = night vig shoots before he dies...)
I'm pretty sure they have to individually kill in non-clue games too. Just if there's nothing to actually block a night action or if there's no clues there's no need to assign a killer obviously.
|
United Kingdom10823 Posts
Oh, there's lemonwalrus as well, unless anyone objects
|
On November 30 2011 23:26 annul wrote: serejai and vaderseven as well.
I want you guys to remember this post when I flip town, considering I've been saying all game that annul is mafia and also because I'm the one who originally pointed out that vaderseven is mafia.
When I flip town, take out annul. He's scum.
|
To clarify, I feel annul is bussing vaderseven since he scumslipped and is going to die anyway. Kenpachi and Ciryandor also scumslipped and would die regardless. It's extremely easy for annul to simply buss these three other mafia (and even Lemonwalrus/coag, who will likely be modkilled or lurker bane killed) because
a) They're going to die anyway, and b) By bussing them he gets town cred without any negative consequences to his scum team (see a)
Please, please don't let annul sheep you guys into thinking he's town because of these flips.
|
On November 30 2011 23:45 Serejai wrote:I want you guys to remember this post when I flip town, considering I've been saying all game that annul is mafia and also because I'm the one who originally pointed out that vaderseven is mafia. When I flip town, take out annul. He's scum. Why did Annul push for Zeks lynch so hard then :S?
|
Good morning tl Mafia.
I have looking at the votes and trying to piece some things together and noticed a key point.
If everyone was changing votes as a gambit to get the two elected roles and save Zeks, why did Zeks not even bother to cast his 2nd vote?
If he had done so he would have had the option to save himself and kill the sheriff. The only reason not to is if he wanted to protect the sheriff.
What I assumed was happening last night was alot of people were aware of the deadline and where doing last minute reads of some filters like Palmer's and saw his emo quit. As I saw those votes pile in I saw the opening to kill the two most dangerous players in my eye.
I don't know what to say beyond kill the two that claimed scum.
Question- Is the town really dead without double lynches? If so, that alone will prove or dissprove BCs alignment.
At the Guy who said me saying stop PMing me is scummy. Annul and 2 others I can't recall the names of, one of whom is dead and flipped town, sent me PMs that were kinda about the game but kinda not (all were about opinions on rules and mod kills) and I passed those on to the GM. Dunno why you think that's a scum tell but there you go.
|
The other two were xtfftc and syllogism.
|
On November 30 2011 23:49 Benjef wrote:Show nested quote +On November 30 2011 23:45 Serejai wrote:On November 30 2011 23:26 annul wrote: serejai and vaderseven as well. I want you guys to remember this post when I flip town, considering I've been saying all game that annul is mafia and also because I'm the one who originally pointed out that vaderseven is mafia. When I flip town, take out annul. He's scum. Why did Annul push for Zeks lynch so hard then :S?
Zeks was going to die, also. He scumslipped and was probably intended to be a bus anyway.
The only evidence annul had was a vague day 1 clue when he started accusing Zeks. Nobody but him was willing to convict based on a clue, but he kept pushing it over and over. I would personally look at the list of people who switched from Zeks to Palmar, as they were likely mafia voting to bus Zeks and get the sheep to follow, then jumped ship to their real target later. Anyone who switched from Zeks to Palmar, at any point in the voting, should be looked at.
|
On November 30 2011 23:40 Hassybaby wrote: Zephirdd, you may well have a really good point there. Which means its even more important that we nail our shots tonight.
Anyone have a good read on Hier? His sudden disappearance made me super suspicious, but he was right about Kenpachi... When I analysed his posts yesterday I couldn't make up my mind - but his subsequent disappearance reminds a lot of how zeks acted. Both attempted to defend themselves and didn't do a terrible job but stopped contributing right after.
|
On November 30 2011 23:51 vaderseven wrote: Good morning tl Mafia.
I have looking at the votes and trying to piece some things together and noticed a key point.
If everyone was changing votes as a gambit to get the two elected roles and save Zeks, why did Zeks not even bother to cast his 2nd vote?
If he had done so he would have had the option to save himself and kill the sheriff. The only reason not to is if he wanted to protect the sheriff.
What I assumed was happening last night was alot of people were aware of the deadline and where doing last minute reads of some filters like Palmer's and saw his emo quit. As I saw those votes pile in I saw the opening to kill the two most dangerous players in my eye.
I don't know what to say beyond kill the two that claimed scum.
Question- Is the town really dead without double lynches? If so, that alone will prove or dissprove BCs alignment.
At the Guy who said me saying stop PMing me is scummy. Annul and 2 others I can't recall the names of, one of whom is dead and flipped town, sent me PMs that were kinda about the game but kinda not (all were about opinions on rules and mod kills) and I passed those on to the GM. Dunno why you think that's a scum tell but there you go.
Zeks last post before dying: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/viewmessage.php?topic_id=285690¤tpage=178#3548
Just over 2 hours before the deadline. I assume he wasn't around when mafia came up with the kill Palmar plan so they couldn't get him to switch his vote.
|
there is an IRC channel right now, #tlmafia, that has tons of people in game in there right now. they play dethy, they have general chats, etc. clearly the ban is not on communication at all but on game-related communication.
what i PMed vader was the following:
"Original Message From annul: this shit has happened in the past
the veterans in tl mafia have a blatant disregard for the rules and its fucking stupid
i quit mafia a year ago for similar blatant cheats and the game i come back to play has more cheating
its really fucking sad. i dont care if you win or lose if you do so cheating theres no point"
of course, vader responded to me too, with:
"I am very tempted to quit this game if he isn't mod killed. Clauses like that BREAK the game. I wont reply to more pm's till after game."
fair enough. i was likely to quit as well. it wouldnt be the first time i quit in the middle of the game in the face of blatant cheating that breaks the game.
|
by the way
"vague day 1 clue"
no, it was not vague. it was blatant as fuck. this is why i pushed him and now, you all, newbies or whatever, can see that when i tell you clues CAN be used for ez pz red finding, im being serious. not every clue is as obvious as zeks' was, but some are. be not afraid to use this very, VERY powerful tool. its no different than giving us DTs
|
|
|
|