igrok you are obviously not getting the ring as even if we believed your claim and your pledge to assist us, the OP suggests there are roles that can steal the ring from you regardless of you being bulletproof

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 05:09 GMT

#1002

Also I've a hard time believing that there is a survivor with an unblockable night kill or are you saying it only works on gandalf?

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 05:09 GMT

#1003

Oh it's one shot, nevermind

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 05:14 GMT

#1005

A "survivor" role whose only goal is to kill the most powerful townie and can then still win with mafia seems rather unfair unless this is reflected in mafia numbers

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 05:18 GMT

#1006

What is your kill flavor

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 05:28 GMT

#1010

Hey igrok i just realized that my win con is to kill all Evil. Would you characterize Balrog evil?

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 05:37 GMT

#1014

Sandroba are you ignoring my observation above regarding our win con? Would there really be a survivor role in the game that is clearly Evil when our win con is to defeat all Evil

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 05:39 GMT

#1015

igrok it sure is taking long to post that pm, you are dangerously close to being dead

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 05:46 GMT

#1019

well iGrok I don't think I can allow Evil to exist in Middle Earth

##cleave iGrok

I'm going to be extremely displeased with the setup if a clearly evil creature flips neutral when our win con says to purge all evil

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 06:26 GMT

#1024

Unless you can survive a hit, yes

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 06:32 GMT

#1026

Either he is lying scum or a "neutral" third party whose win con involves killing a townie. Our win con is to purge all evil and it doesn't get more much more evil than a balrog

Either way if he doesn't flip mafia, curu really messed up

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 06:35 GMT

#1029

On September 21 2011 15:33 iGrok wrote:
Apparently I can.

So, your medic is fucking dumb.

Though after the game ends I'm going to chew you out for playing dumb, this is actually hilarious

Calling bullshit on the medic, so you are still lying scum or a bulletproof SK and if you don't see how my above logic makes perfect sense, that just makes you even scummier

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 06:36 GMT

#1030

##vote igrok

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 06:49 GMT

#1032

Survivors aren't always vets and your claim made no sense at all in the context of a survivor. Why would survivor's win con involve killing a townie? Why is your role clearly evil and our win con is to kill evil? Why are you specifically told what happens if you obtain the ring considering it has nothing to do with your win con? If you can already survive a shot, why does it make you bullet proof?

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 06:52 GMT

#1033

Plus now you are even lying about the medic, instead of just saying that you are a survivor who can survive a bullet. You clearly know how you survived

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 07:26 GMT

#1036

Recap:

After I had vigged you:
"This had better be a fucking joke."
"was that supposed to do something syllogism?"

And now later:
"I was told I took a hit right after you used cleave."

I suppose you are more likely to be SK by this point, which is unfortunate because I'd rather lynch mafia.

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 08:05 GMT

#1037

Also I'm changing my mind about Sandroba. I don't know why he assumed that a survivor would have a safe claim and he isn't really pushing his lynches and his posting seems blander than usual. He has also made some weird leaps of logic, for instance:

Since jeejee is acusing jackal, but haven't said shit I'll keep him there. I have a funny feeling that if jackal is town jeejee is mafia planting the seed so someone else can make a full blown case and get the blame

People had been pushing Jackal since day 1, but sandroba interprets Jeejee's day 2 vote as scum wanting to subtly get a wagon started and thus "avoiding blame". This doesn't particularly sound like townie sandroba logic. The language is a bit awkward too, specifically the usage of "funny feeling"

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 08:29 GMT

#1039

On September 21 2011 17:22 Palmar wrote:
rofl, die scum die

Are you going to do anything useful all game?

syllogism

Finland5948 Posts

September 21 2011 11:17 GMT

#1049

But does Balrog the SK make sense to you? Balrog the mafia seems more realistic and I don't know why he would voluntarily claim balrog instead of his real role (that is, he would then be SK with a more fitting character). He was going to get lynched unless his claim was very good and if this claim buys him that one day, it's a success. He could have a vital scum role that he can use tonight, though I'm not sure how I could reconcile that with him surviving a shot.