Personality Mafia!

On August 14 2011 00:25 Jackal58 wrote:
Kurumi/Bill Murray must die. He is 3rd party or scum. There is absolutely no way we can allow a troll playing a troll remain in the game. Lynch him now!!!!!

On August 14 2011 00:27 Jackal58 wrote:

Nope. Ace.

On August 14 2011 03:14 Jackal58 wrote:

From my role PM

I'm not trying to parody or role play my personality. I'm compelled to get him lynched. Sorry.

On August 14 2011 03:26 kitaman27 wrote:


So its just a coincidence that you mentioned the BM/L rivalry and jackal has it in his role pm?

On August 14 2011 03:53 Jackal58 wrote:

I already posted my PM line regarding BM and what I am compelled to do. I have no list of things I can't do. Simply that if BM is revealed I must put all my efforts into getting him killed. So kill him already.
And my personality is already painfully obvious.

On August 14 2011 03:55 Kenpachi wrote:
Oh and i checked Jackal. hes red

On August 14 2011 04:03 Jackal58 wrote:

Your pokemon names scream BM. Your adversary is L. You were obviously informed in your role PM wtf was going down. Coincidence doesn't happen. After that post I strongly believe you to not be town. Maybe not scum but definitely not town.

On August 14 2011 04:05 Jackal58 wrote:

Kenpachi and Kurumi are scum together?

On August 14 2011 04:28 Curu wrote:


So you think it's more likely Jackal is Mafia and Kurumi is Town but you want Kurumi lynched instead?

Hi there scum logic.

On August 14 2011 04:17 Curu wrote:
Both of you shut up about this.

LSB where'd you go?

Do not shoot Jackal. If Kenpachi is Village Idiot, he just randomly picked someone to die. If he's a legit DT he can get off a lot more checks and when something confirms him we'll know that he's legit.

On August 14 2011 04:25 Curu wrote:


Then Jackal dies the day after. Easy enough.

Either way if Kenpachi is a DT both of them die. Not jumping the gun and shooting Jackal is the best way to go about this because the possibilities:

1) Kenpachi is Village Idiot and Jackal is Town. We don't lose a Townie to the Village Idiot.

2) Kenpachi is Village Idiot and Jackal is Mafia.
or 3) Kenpachi is DT and Jackal is Mafia.

Mafia has no way of knowing which one is true. They have to decide to gamble and let Kenpachi live assuming he's VI and picked Jackal at random because if they kill him and he does indeed flip DT instead of VI then Jackal's dead for sure. But there's also the chance he's a real DT and leaving him alive lets him get off more and more checks.

On August 14 2011 05:53 Curu wrote:
So if Kurumi is scum what alignment is Jackal?

On August 14 2011 05:55 Palmar wrote:


I have no idea. I don't think roles determine alignment, as in, I think the worst possible thing we could do is to mass-claim and lynch whoever claims someone who is famous for being scum.

On August 14 2011 06:00 Palmar wrote:


two things, according to jackal he just has to push for the lynch, it's not a part of his win condition, so again, I don't think it's something we need to worry about.

the weird bit is that jackal is technically enforcing the restriction on himself, Kurumi still argues he's not BM, and there has been presented evidence he might be someone else. Jackal could choose to believe that and stop the bullshit. the fact that he has not done so and instead chooses to hide behind the restriction is kind of... iffy.

On August 14 2011 06:28 Jackal58 wrote:

Kurumi could have spammed his entire way through the game and I would have just assumed it was Kurumi being Kurumi. He had no compelling reason to post his personality name and mine in his first post of the game. If he is indeed scum that's his fault for outing himself with his first post. I could have ignored it but if you go and read the L and BM sections of the Mafia Quiz like I did you may also get the impression that Kurumi can kill me tonight. I am mentioned in his role PM apparently. So ya I have a compelling reason to want him dead.
Coupled with Kenpachi's timing of his DT claim and who he claimed to have checked I am strongly beginning to believe that they are both scum.

On August 15 2011 04:18 Node wrote:
First, hai guys. Busy weekend, family's in town, yadda yadda yadda.

Second, what. The. Fuck. This is beyond bad. There's a reason a lot of people aren't contributing: it's almost impossible to contribute to this mess without making it worse. I propose that everyone simply stops posting so damn much, and tries to consolidate what would normally be 3 posts down to 1, so that there's a lot less fluff for everybody to digest whenever they want to figure something out or make a point.

I kinda-sorta agree with Pandain's actions so far, and I'm really disappointed that he seems to have been shot. I think Kurumi's been detrimental to the town, and I think he knows this. He's done a huge part in establishing the terrible atmosphere we've currently got, and his actions have made it impossible to just ignore the spam he's throwing around. He's gone straight to the chainsaw defense when people call him out, and claimed one of the few roles that would be worth playing risky to keep around. Pandain just made one crucial mistake: even if he's not roleplaying Bill Murray, kurumi is still kurumi. He's still gonna spew nonsensical BS. Personally, I would've rather he just be shot, as it still covers the VI possibility and saves us from any future thread-destroying shenanigans from that particular source.

I also find it hard to buy that the Qatol personality would be mafia-aligned, no matter how much everyone says personality != alignment. And since nobody's counter-claimed him, I'm inclined to believe Pandain is both Qatol and town-aligned.



This is an interesting way to interpret kav's actions. I'm not sure I agree with it, though. You say that he's trying to divert our actions. I ask, what exactly is he trying to divert us from? Considering how aimless this game has been, Kav might be one of the few trying to put us on a worthwhile track. I don't think he's necessarily town, but I'm willing to wait and see in this case.

On August 15 2011 05:27 Kavdragon wrote:


I would like to point out that I am the only person thus far who has done any "scumhunting" thus far. (As most "analysis" have been poor and not anything that would set a lynch.) I set the trap for inactive people, and Aidnai jumped in it. Silly VE doens't want to give me the benefit of the doubt. A better question: Why not Aidnai? He's only come in to defend himself, and then dissapeared. Do you dissagree with my analysis of his reaction to my pressure?

You will notice that I almost never posted something about Walton by itself. I always gave advice to the town, tried to get people to stop spaming, or commented on some situation, and then, as an addendum, added the Walton stuff on. I did this because I knew that nobody would understand Walton, and that it could NOT be the only thing I contributed.

Deconduo: + Show Spoiler +

To those of you who think that I'm a cultist: "Recruiting" Kurumi was an attempt to get him to stop spammign, and make him uesful for the town. You will notice that every public action has the hashtag form, and I have never used that. This means that if I have a recruiting power, it would have to be private, in which case why would I make it public that I was recruiting Kurumi? It makes no sense. I am not a cultist, I amd town. (Oh, and there. I deny being anything other than town. Not so sure what's magical about those words, but if you want them, there they are.)

On August 15 2011 12:21 Incognito wrote:

Night 1

The rowdy townspeople dragged aidnai to a dark room underneath the city hall, hoping to test their new execution device before using it to execute the 3 inactives. The room filled with chanting and jeering, followed by a sudden silence. Aidnai winced as he saw the executioner motion toward the switch. A moment later, blue sparks flew everywhere, and the town began to cheer. But their cheers turned into confusion, as a still alive aidnai began to walk straight toward the executioners chamber. Before too much chaos could ensue, an arrow zoomed past the crowd and shot straight through aidnai's chest, killing him instantly.

Disappointed at the failure of the device, the town pardoned the three inactives...for now.

aidnai, Chezinu's evil twin has been lynched!
Chezinu has regained his sanity!

Nobody is modkilled today. We are looking for 4 replacements, however.

---

Night ends tomorrow at 03:00 GMT (+00:00). Please send me your night actions before then.

On August 17 2011 03:55 Curu wrote:
I know there is a Vig left. scumatlarge purposely did this to go out with a bang and take out another Townie who likely had a DT role (Chezinu went sane). I propose we lynch someone else today and let the Vig take care of scumatlarge.

Oh and

M y hero for all ages, the wondrous Mig,
I love that your name is so short and not big.
G o Mig and lead the Town to victory?

On August 18 2011 02:37 Jackal58 wrote:
I'd be down with lynching LSB instead.

Role PM descriptions will not be given out until after the game is over. Only alignment and personality will be given.

On August 24 2011 09:34 Mig wrote:
Qatol I don't think you guys took into account how badly PRs damage the town and how much they help the mafia when really balancing. Like YM can't accuse anyone who hasn't accused him. How is he supposed to do any analysis? Sandroba can only post 5 times a cycle. So one of the best town players is nearly removed from the game. How is the town supposed to be able to get any read on things like that? Especially day 1. So much time has to be devoted into personality hunting and PR hunting just to have any clue about whats going on instead of actually looking for scum.